ZBO ZB R O NIK RNIK FILOZO FI FS LOZO K FS I M K AR I M A AR TO A N TO 2020 FILOZOFIJA IN TELO / FILOZOFIJA MED DUHOM IN NARAVO 1 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 1 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 =%251,.),/2=2)6.,0$5$721 ),/2=2),-$,17(/2),/2=2),-$0(''8+20,11$5$92 Urednica: Tara Peternell Recenzenta: Nina Petek, Franci Zore 6ORYHQVNDOHNWXUD0DUNR0LRÍLÉ/DUD.UDMQF $QJOHďNDOHNWXUD3HWUD3RODQLÍ.D\D6ODN 6OLNDQDQDVORYQLFL7LPRWHM6WHSLďQLN 7HKQLÍQDXUHGQLFD7DUD3HWHUQHOO 8UHGQLďWYR0DWHM.DSXV$QGUDĤ'ROLQďHN1HMF.UDOM-HUQHM0HGHQ1HVD9UHÍHU6DUD6YDWL6KDUDQ$UQH.XďHM =DORĤLOD=DORĤED8QLYHU]HY/MXEOMDQL =D]DORĤER*UHJRU0DMGLÍUHNWRU8QLYHU]HY/MXEOMDQL ,]GDOD=QDQVWYHQD]DORĤED)LOR]RIVNHIDNXOWHWH8QLYHU]HY/MXEOMDQL =DL]GDMDWHOMD0RMFD6FKODPEHUJHU%UH]DUGHNDQMD)LOR]RIVNHIDNXOWHWH 2EOLNRYDQMHLQSUHORP7LPRWHM6WHSLďQLN 7LVN%LURJUDʳND%RULGRR /MXEOMDQD 3UYDL]GDMD Naklada: 100 izvodov 3XEOLNDFLMDMHEUH]SODÍQD 7RGHORMHSRQXMHQRSRGOLFHQFR&UHDWLYH&RPPRQV3UL]QDQMHDYWRUVWYD'HOMHQMHSRG HQDNLPLSRJRML0HGQDURGQDOLFHQFDL]MHPDVRIRWRJUDʳMH7KLVZRUNLVOLFHQVHG XQGHUD&UHDWLYH&RPPRQV$WWULEXWLRQ6KDUH$OLNH,QWHUQDWLRQDO/LFHQVHH[FHSW SKRWRJUDSKLHV 3UYDHL]GDMD3XEOLNDFLMDMHYGLJLWDOQLREOLNLSURVWRGRVWRSQDQDKWWSVHNQMLJHIIXQLOMVL '2, .DWDORĤQD]DSLVDRSXEOLNDFLML&,3SULSUDYLOLY1DURGQLLQXQLYHU]LWHWQLNQMLĤQLFLY/MXEOMDQL 7LVNDQDNQMLJD &2%,666,,' ,6%1 (NQMLJD &2%,666,,' ,6%13') =QDQVWYHQD]DORĤED)LOR]RIVNHIDNXOWHWH8QLYHU]HY/MXEOMDQL$ďNHUÍHYD6,/MXEOMDQD t/ Ie/]QDQVWYHQD]DOR]ED#IIXQLOMVL ZZZIIXQLOMVL 2 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 2 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 SPREMNA BESEDA &HQMHQHEUDONHFHQMHQLEUDOFL9YDďLKURNDKVHQDKDMD]ERUQLNNLVHVWRMLL]SUH YLGQRL]EUDQLKSULVSHYNRYNLVPRMLPLPHOLNRWVOXďDWHOMLSULORĤQRVWSULVOXKQLWLYVNORSX )LOR]RIVNHJDPDUDWRQDSUHWHNOLKGYHKOHWVHGDMSDVRRYHNRYHÍHQLQDSDSLUMX7UDGLFLR QDOQLGRJRGHNĤHYUVWROHWSULUHMDMRPDUOMLYHďWXGHQWNHLQďWXGHQWL2GGHOND]DʳOR]RʳMR NLVHXGHMVWYXMHMRYĎWXGHQWVNHPʳOR]RIVNHPGUXďWYXRPHQLWLYHOMDGDEUH]QMLKRYHJD WUXGDLQSUL]DGHYQRVWLWDSLVQLL]GHOHNQHELXJOHGDOOXÍL 2SD]LWLMHGDVRQHNDWHUDL]PHGEHVHGLOYSUYHPUD]GHONXSLVDQDYDQJOHďNHP MH]LNXYďWXGLMVNHPOHWXVPRLPHOLQDPUHÍQD2GGHONX]DʳOR]RʳMRSULORĤQRVW JRVWLWLWXGLWXMHSUHGDYDWHOMLFHLQSUHGDYDWHOMH/HWRNLMHVOHGLORSDQDP]DUDGLWUDJLÍQLK UD]PHUVYHWRYQHJDUD]SRQDWRYUVWQHL]PHQMDYHUD]QRYUVWQLKSRJOHGRYĤDOQLGRSXVWLOR 7RNUDWQL]ERUQLNSRNULYDďLURNLQVLFHUGYROHWQLWHPDWVNLVNORS]DWRMHWHPX SULPHUQRUD]GHOMHQQDGYHORÍHQLHQRWL=QRWUDMYVDNHJDL]PHGGYHKVNORSRYȡ)LOR]RʳMD LQWHORLQ)LOR]RʳMDPHGGXKRPLQQDUDYRVRSULVSHYNLXUHMHQLSRNURQRORďNLR]LURPD WHPDWVNLXVWUH]QRVWLSRWHKWQLL]ELULLQSUHVRMLXUHGQLďNHJDRGERUD 7HPLQDSUYLSRJOHGGHOXMHWDQHNROLNRRGGDOMHQLHQDRGGUXJHDNOMXEWHPXRE EUDQMXNDMKLWURSRVWDQHUD]YLGQRGDQDSRVOHGNDUVHGDXVSHďQRSUHÍLWDYU]HOPHGVHERM LQVHSUHYHVLWDGUXJDYGUXJR)LOR]RʳMRNRWVDPRVYRMRLQVYRMHJODYRGLVFLSOLQRQDPUHÍ ĤH YHGQR VSUHPOMD QHND SRVHEQD RGOLND GD LPD Y VHEL ]PRĤQRVW YVDNR L]PHG WHP NL VHMLKORWLQDSUDYLWL]DLQWHUGLVFLSOLQDUQR]YH]QRLQSUHGVYRMLPÍDVRPÍHWXGLVHNGDM ]D]GLGDVRQHNDWHUHWHPHUD]SUDYHWDNďQHNRWGDELMLKL]NRSDOLQDUDYQRVWL]JURERY QDďLKRÍDNRY1HJOHGHQDSUREOHPNLJDREUDYQDYDJDYQRYLÍLQ]QRYDXVSHSUHNRVYRMH JRYRULFHYUHÍLYDNWXDOQRVWYSULVRWQRVWVHGDMDNLGRSXďÍDUD]NULYDQMHYVDNRNUDWQHJD QRYHJD =DSLVDQRVHSRVHEHMOHSRRGUDĤDYSULÍXMRÍHPL]GHONXNLYSLVDQLEHVHGLYVYR MHPXNYDUMDQMXVNRQFHSWRPĤLYHJDWHOHVDWHURGQRVRPPHGGXKRPLQQDUDYRSRNULYD PQRďWYR]JRGRYLQVNLKLGHMYVHRGDQWLNHGRVRGREQHJD7HPLVWDY]ERUQLNXRYUHGQRWHQL ]YLGLNDWHGDQMHJDSRJOHGDSLďRÍLKNLVRSUREOHPHREUDYQDYDOLYVNORSXYVHKPRĤQLK GLVFLSOLQYNDWHULKVHWHʳOR]RIVNHLGHMHSRUDMDMR2PHQMHQRNDUYQDMYHÍMLPHULVRYSDGD ]YL]LMRWDNRRUJDQL]DWRUMHYGRJRGNDNRWWXGLXUHGQLďNHJDRGERUDNLMHRKUDQMDWLʳOR]R ʳMRĤLYRQDSODQRYHVWQRSULQDďDWLYVHPRJRÍHSUREOHPHQHJOHGHQDQMLKRYRGRPQHYQR ÍDVRYQRSRJRMHQRVWWHUSUHSXVWLWLEHVHGRPODMďLPJHQHUDFLMDPNLVLVYRMRSRWYSURVWRU ʳOR]RʳMHďHOHXWLUDMR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 3 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 4 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 KAZALO ),/,3'5$ģ(129,È 0HWDIRUHWHOHVDLQEROH]QLYVUHGQMHPLQ]JRGQMHPQRYHPYHNX 7 1(-&.5$/- 3RPHQPDWHULMHY(QJHOVRYL Dialektiki narave 23 ,=,'25%$5Ď, 7KH/LPLWVRI9LROHQFH Conceptualising the contemporary liberal paradigm of violence with the help of Walter Benjamin 34 0$5,1$6$.$Ì %RG\0RGLʳFDWLRQDVDQ,QGLYLGXDO6XEYHUVLYH3UDFWLFH 52 58(/$/(;$1'(50$11(77( )LWQHVVLQJRI6RFLHW\ 62 7,1$720Ď,Ì 6OLNDUVWYR7LQH'REUDMFȡVOLNDWLSROLWLÍQDWHOHVD 77 $1'5$ģ'2/,1Ď(. 7HĤDYQRVWLQWHUSUHWDFLMHDUKDLÍQHJUďNHPLVOLȡ (ne)razumevanje in apropriacija Heraklita 91 6$5$69$7,6+$5$1 3DUDGRNV+HJORYHIDVFLQDFLMHQDG$QWLJRQR 103 7$5$3(7(51(// :DWVXMLLQ+HLGHJJHUȡSURVWRUVNRVWLQÍDVRYQRVWNRWRE]RUMLNXOWXUH 114 0$5.20$5.,Ì 3UREOHPGDQRVWLVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWDY+XVVHUORYLIHQRPHQRORJLML 123 ',120$1=21, 2WHOHVXPHG0HUOHDX3RQW\MHPLQ%RXUGLHXMHP 140 32-02912.$=$/2 156 329=(7.,$%675$&76 160 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 5 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 FILOZOFSKI MARATON 2019 filozofija in telo Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 6 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 METAFORE TELESA IN BOLEZNI V SREDNJEM IN ZGODNJEM NOVEM VEKU Filip Draženović UVOD ĎSDQVNL LQWHOHNWXDOHF LQ GLSORPDW 'LHJR GH 6DDYHGUD )DMDUGR MH Y VYRMHP NQHĤMHP]UFDOX,GHDGHXQSU¯QFLSHSRO¯WLFRFULVWLDQRL]UD]LO]DKWHYRQDMERSRJODYLWQD ODVWQRVWXVSHďQHJDSULQFD}PRÍQRLQHQRWQRWHORm)DMDUGR=JROMWDNRWHOR YODGDUMX]DJRWDYOMDHQRWQRVWFRQFRUGLRQXMQR]DJRWRYLORNLJDSRWUHEXMHSULYODGDQMX ÌHYVDNRUJDQÍODQGHOXMHSRVYRMHQLQLNDNUďQHJDXSDQMD]DEROMďRSULKRGQRVW3RGRE QRPLVHOMHL]UD]LOWXGL0DUWLQ/XWKHU}0DUQLQHQDUDYQRďHVSORKSDQHNUďÍDQVNRGD QDMELHQRUJDQQHSRPDJDOGUXJHPXJDQHEUDQLOSUHGSURSDGRPm/XWKHU 9VHNDUQDPYWUHQXWNXNRMHRJURĤHQQDUDYQLUHGRVWDQHMHÍDNDQMHQDERĤMRND]HQ,Q SRVOHGQMRVRGER 1DPHQÍODQNDMHSRND]DWLQDSRPHQPHWDIRULQDQDORJLMWHOHVDWHU]QMLPSR YH]DQLKVWDQMSUHGYVHPYSUDďDQMDEROH]QLYVUHGQMHYHďNLLQQRYRYHďNLSROLWLÍQLPLVOL %HVHGLORVHERRVUHGRWRÍDORQDUD]OLÍQHPHWDIRUHNLMLKODKNRYJUREHPUD]GHOLPRYWUL SRGURÍMDNLREVHJDMRSROLWLÍQRDQDWRPLMRSDWRORJLMRLQWHUDSHYWLNRNLVRPHGVHERMSR JRVWRSUHSOHWHQHWDNRGDQLYHQRPHUMDVQRYNDWHURNDWHJRULMRVHDYWRUMLXPHďÍDMRÌH MHVUHGQMHYHďNDSROLWLÍQDPLVHOPRÍQRSRVYHÍDODDQDWRPLMLNRWRVUHGQMLWHPDWLNLWHOHVD VH MH ] QDVWRSRP QRYHJD YHND SRYHÍDO SRXGDUHN QD SRPHQX EROH]QL NL QDV RJURĤDMR 7DSRMPRYQLSUHPLNERRVUHGQMHYRGLOREHVHGLODSRND]DWLSDJDERPSRVNXďDOWDNRQD R]DGMXVSUHPHQMHQLKSROLWLÍQLKNRQFHSWRYNRWWXGLSUHPHQYPHGLFLQVNLPLVOLNL VRQDVWRSLOHYVWROHWMX.HUMHWHPDWLNDPHWDIRUHWHOHVDYSROLWLÍQLPLVOLL]MHPQR UD]ďLUMHQDSULQDďDSULÍXMRÍHEHVHGLOR]JROMR]HNL]ERU0DUVLNDWHURGHORNLELELORODKNR XSRUDEOMHQRMHL]SXďÍHQR6SHWGUXJDVRL]SXďÍHQDQDPHQRPD2+REEHVXLQ.DQWR URZLF]XMHELORSRYHGDQHJDĤHYHOLNRNDNRYRVWQHJD]DWRWXQHERVWDSUHGVWDYOMHQD Med WHPDWVNLPLSROMLNLVRL]SXďÍHQDYHOMDRSR]RULWLQDWHPRSHUVRQLʳNDFLMHGUĤDYHNLMH ELODSRJRVWDSUHGYVHPYUHQHVDQVL1 2VQRYQRL]KRGLďÍHEHVHGLODMHYSUDďDQMHNDMVHQDKDMD]DQDYLGH]VDPRXPHY QLPL L]UD]L DQDORJLMDPL LQ PHWDIRUDPL NL REUDYQDYDMR WHOR 3RYHGDQR QD NUDWNR NDM VRĤHOHOLDYWRUMLSRYHGDWLVVNOLFHYDQMHPQDGRORÍHQHSULPHUHLQ]DNDMVRMLKXSRUDELOL 1 2WHMWHPLJOHM6NLQQHU Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 7 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 8SRUDED EHVHG QLNROL QL EUH] GRORÍHQLK SRVOHGLF 7HPHOMQD SUHPLVD EHVHGLOD MHGDMHQDďMH]LNĤHRG]DÍHWNDPHWDIRULÍHQ0HWDIRUHQLVR]JROMQDGRPHVWHN]DGREH VHGQLL]UD]ROHSďDYDEHVHGLODDOLPDďLORDPSDNVRNRQFHSWLVOLNHNLQDGRORÍHQQDÍLQ VWUXNWXULUDMRQDďVYHW0LďOMHQMH]PHWDIRUDPLMHQHNDMNDU]D]QDPXMHFHORWQR]JRGR YLQRÍORYHďNHJDPLďOMHQMD9WHPSULVSHYNXERGRPHWDIRUHSUYHQVWYHQRUD]XPOMHQHNRW PHQWDOQHSRGREHVNR]LNDWHUHVHNDĤHLPDJLQDULMÍDVD]DWRYEHVHGLOXQHERPXSRďWHYDO VWURJH ORÍQLFH PHG PHWDIRUDPL DQDORJLMDPL LQ SULPHUL2 ÌHWXGL VR PHG VHERM VHYHGD UD]OLÍQHSDLPDMRYVHQHNRHQDNRRVQRYRVDM}]DKWHYDMRPHQWDOQRDJLOQRVWDVRFLDFLM SULSUDYOMHQRVWSUHVNDNRYDWLPHGUD]OLÍQLPLVWRSQMDPLSRPHQDWHU]DYHGDQMHGDODKNR SUHGVWDYOMDMRQHNDMGUXJHJDm'DO\$QDORJLMHLQPHWDIRUHQLVRQLNROLSRSROQHD VRLQGLFLPLVHOQLKVYHWRY=DWRVHYHOMDVWULQMDWL]UD]PLVOHNRP3KLOOLSD6DUDVLQD}Ȥ&HOR WHVPLVODȤLQPQRJRWHULKSRPHQVNLKXÍLQNRYNDNHPHWDIRUHQHQDG]RUXMHQLKÍHLQQLKÍH ĤHYQDSUHMQHSR]QDUHVQLFHQDNDWHURELODKNRVWRPHWDIRURFLOMDOLm6DUDVLQ 0HWDIRUHVRQDPUHÍNRJQLWLYQLʳOWULNLʳOWULUDMRUD]OLÍQHNRďÍNHUHVQLFHQHNDMSRNDĤHMR VSHWGUXJRVNULMHMRVWHPSDJHQHULUDMRUD]YRMQRYLKSRPHQRY 3UDYWDP6DUDVL QRYLPLVOLYHOMDGRGDWLPLVHO5REHUWD'DUQWRQDGD}VYHWXUHMDPRJOHGHQDNDWHJRULMH NLVHQDP]GLMRVDPRXPHYQHVDPR]DWRNHUVRQDPQDYROMR=DVHGDMRHSLVWHPRORďNL SURVWRUNLMHSUHGPLVOLMRLQLPDMR]DWRQHQDYDGQRPRÍY]GUĤOMLYRVWLm'DUQWRQ 1DPHQSULVSHYNDSDQLRPHMLWLVH]JROMQDNULWLÍQRDQDOL]RPHWDIRUSDÍSDWXGLSR VWDYLWLL]EUDQHSULPHUHY]JRGRYLQVNLNRQWHNVWWDNUDWQHSROLWLÍQHPLVOLLQUD]XPHYDQMD SRVDPH]QLNDLQVYHWD2ESUHMRPHQMHQLKUD]PLVOHNLKRPHWDIRULERHQRL]PHGL]KRGLďÍ EHVHGLODWXGLPLVHODPHULďNHJDOLQJYLVWD%HQMDPLQD:KRUIDGDVHPLďOMHQMHRGYLMDYHG QRYVSHFLʳÍQHPMH]LNXLQGDMH]DWRMH]LNHGHQL]PHGNOMXÍQLKJUDGQLNRYQDďHJDUD]X PHYDQMDVYHWD3RYHPRODKNRQDPUHÍ]JROMWLVWRNDUQDPXVSHXEHVHGLWLYMH]LNXNLQDP MHGDQ:KRUI 7HPHOMQRGHORNLREUDYQDYDPHWDIRUHYSROLWLÍQLPLVOLMHNQMLJD'LHWPDUMD3HL ODYNDWHUHPL]SRVWDYLďHVWWHPHOMQLKPHWDIRUNLSUHÍLMRSROLWLÍQRPLVHORGDQWLNHGR GDQHVSDVWLULQÍUHGDNUPDUÍHEHOHR]ÍHEHOMDGUĤDYDWHORGUĤDYDNRWVWURMGUĤDYD NRW]JUDGED3RJRVWRSULGHWXGLGRSUHSOHWDUD]OLÍQLKPHWDIRU7RYLGLPRY*DOHQRYHP SULPHUXY]GUDYQLNXYLGLNUPDUMDNLÍORYHNDYRGLNR]GUDYLWYL7RPHWDIRURMHQDMYHU MHWQHMHSUHY]HOL]$ULVWRWHORYH1LNRPDKRYHHWLNHYNDWHUL$ULVWRWHONUPDUMDUD]XPHNRW XVPHUMHYDOFDGREUHJDĤLYOMHQMD6ROO2PHďDQMXPHWDIRUSULÍDWXGLQDYHGH NDQJOHďNHJDNUDOMD-DNRED,}-D]VHPĤHQLQLQWDFHORWQLRWRNMHPRMD]DNRQLWDĤHQDMD] 2 9PDUVLÍHPVHRSLUDPRWXGLQDUD]PLVOHN0D[D%ODFNDGDQLWDNRSRPHPEQRGDEUDOHFSR]QD VWDQGDUGQLSRPHQQHNHEHVHGHYQDďHPSULPHUX}WHOHVDmYDĤQHMHMHGDSR]QDWLVWRNDULPHQXMHVLVWHP DVRFLLUDQLKVSORďQLKPHVW*UH]DPQRĤLFRWUGLWHYNLMLKMHQDÍHORPDYVDNGR]PRĤHQL]UHÍL.RW]DSLďH%ODFN XÍLQNRYLWRVWPHWDIRUHQLYWHPGDQDMELELODVSORďQDPHVWDUHVQLÍQDWHPYHÍGDMLKMHPRJRÍH]ODKNDLQVYRERG QRSULNOLFDWL=DUDGLWHJDVHODKNRPHWDIRUDNLYHQLGUXĤELGHOXMH]GLYGUXJLQHVPLVHOQD%ODFN *UH]DGHOR8QWHUVXFKXQJHQ]XU6WDDWVȡXQG+HUUVFKDIWVPHWDSKRULNLQOLWHUDULVFKHQ=HXJQLVVHQ YRQGHU$QWLNHELV]XU*HJHQZDUW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 8 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 VHPJODYDLQWDMHPRMHWHORMD]VHPSDVWLUWDSDMHPRMDÍUHGDm-DNRYDFRS 7XYLGLPRWURMQLSUHSOHWPHWDIRUGUXĤLQDȡWHORȡSDVWLU-DNREMHVNXďDOQDJRYRULWL REÍLQVWYR]HQDNRPLVOLMRQDWULUD]OLÍQHQDÍLQHLQVLVWHP]DJRWRYLWLVSORďQRUD]XPOML YRVW2SD]QRMHSRJRVWRPHďDQMHPHWDIRUHGUXĤLQHLQWHOHVD7DNRNRWPRUDRÍHVNUEHWL ]DVYRMHSRWRPFHPRUDWXGLJODYDVNUEHWLGDXGLGHOXMHMRXVNODMHQRVDM}ÍHVHXGMHQH PRUHMR PHG VHERM SRJRYDUMDWL NDU EL ELOR ]D REVWRM FHORWQHJD WHOHVD VHYHGD NRULVWQR JUR]L WHOHVX KXGD RNXĤEDm 6WURKPH\HU 7DNR NRW MH RÍH JODYD GUXĤLQH MH JODYDYODGDUWHOHVD 'UXJRL]KRGLďÍHEHVHGLODMHSRPHQNLJDMHLPHODUHWRULNDYQRYRYHďNHPPLVHO QHPVYHWX2VQRYQRVSRURÍLOR$ULVWRWHORYH5HWRULNHNLMHREGUXJLKGHOLKRUHWRULNLVYRM SRPHQRKUDQLODWXGLYQRYHPYHNXQLWRNDNRERPRNDMSRYHGDOLQSUUHWRULÍQHʳJXUH DPSDNSUHGYVHPQDÍLQWYRUMHQMDDUJXPHQWRYLQUD]YUďÍDQMD]QDQMDVNDWHULPJRYRUHF REOLNXMHJRYRULQYSOLYDQDSRVOXďDOVWYR1DORJDJRYRUFDMHSRLVNDWLNDMERUHNHOKHXUH VLVLQYHQWLRXUHGLWLWRNDUMHRGNULOWDNVLVWHUQDNRQFXYVHGRSROQLWLYVPLVHOQRFHOR WROHNVLV9WHPNRQWHNVWXVHMHSRWUHEQRXVWDYLWLSULRGQRVXRGNULYDQMDLQL]QDMGHYDQMD DUJXPHQWRY.RWGYDPRĤQDYLUDDUJXPHQWRY$ULVWRWHOQDYDMD]JRGRYLQVNHGRJRGNHLQ EDVQL*RYRUHFVLWRUHMQHVPHSUHSURVWRL]PLVOLWLGRORÍHQLKDUJXPHQWRYDPSDNPRUD SRVHÍLSRSULPHULKNLVRSRVOXďDOFHPĤH]QDQL=DWRMHNOMXÍYWHPGDJRYRUHFRGNULMH R]LURPDSR]QDWDNHSULPHUHNLERGRLPHOLQDSRVOXďDOFHYHOLNRSUHSULÍHYDOQRPRÍNDU MHSR$ULVWRWHOXWXGLRVQRYQLFLOMJRYRUQLďWYD 9WHPNRQWHNVWXMHSRWUHEQRREUDYQDYDWLSRPHQWRSLNHLQWRSRVDNUDMD=D $ULVWRWHODMHWRSLNDQDÍLQRGNULYDQMDDUJXPHQWRYWRSRVSDSURVWRUNDPRUVHVWHNDYHÍ UD]OLÍQLKJRYRUQLďNLKVNOHSDQM3RJRVWRĤHOLJRYRUHFJRYRUSULSHOMDWLGRQHNHJDRE ÍHJDPHVWDQDNDWHUHPVHUD]OLÍQLDUJXPHQWLVWHÍHMRVNXSDMYFHORWR7RSRVELODKNR UD]XPHOLWXGLNRWREÍDPHVWDVHGHVOHFWLRQLVR]LURPDNRWQHNDNďQHLGHDOQHNUDMHRG NRGHUYVWRSDPRYPLVHOQLSURFHVLQRGNRGHUVRY]HWLWHPHOMQLDUJXPHQWL7HORVHMHYSL VRYDORPHGNOMXÍQHWRSRVHSUHGPRGHUQH1DORJDJRYRUFDMHQDPUHÍSRVOXďDOVWYXÍLP MDVQHMHSUHGVWDYLWLDUJXPHQWDFLMRVSRPRÍMRWDNVLVPHWRGHUD]YUďÍDQMD]DWRMHUDYQR XUHMDQMH WR NL }QDUHGLm JRYRU SUL ÍHPHU VR PX UHWRULÍQH ʳJXUH LQ VORJ QXMQD SRPRÍ 3RGREQRPLVHOL]UD]LWXGL(UD]HPYVYRMHP 3ULURÍQLNX]DY]JRMRNUďÍDQVNHJDYODGDUMD}NDUMHERJY YHVROMXNDUMHVRQFHQD]HPOMLNDUMHRNRYWHOHVXWRQDMERYODGDUYGUĤDYLm'HVLGHULXV 1DWRRSR]RULQSUWXGLDQJOHďNLNUDOM-DNRE,}>@WDNRNRWJODYDVNUEL]DWHORVNUELNUDOM]DVYRMH OMXGVWYRm3HLORS 6 0HWDIRUDWHOHVDVLFHUQLELODSRYVHPRELÍDMQDY]QDQRVWL9 Enciklopediji VRWDNRďWLULNOMXÍQHSRGREH VNDWHULPLMHSUHGVWDYOMHQD]QDQRVWGUHYRODELULQWYHULJDLQ]HPOMHYLG.URXSD-HELODSD]QDQRVW UD]XPOMHQDNRWHQDRUJDQVNDFHORWDVDMMHELORYVH]QDQMH]GUXĤHQRY corpus YWHOR7DNRMHQSUQHPďNLHQFLNOR SHGLN-RKDQQ+HLQULFK$OVWHGVYRMR Enciklopedijo EUDOFHPSRQXGLNRWRJURGMHRNRVWMH sceleton]QDQMDEUDOFX WRUHMRVWDQHGDVDP]JUDGLFHORYLWRWHOR corpus succiplenum GDQDNRVWLREHVLPHVRLQXVWYDULĤLYRFHORWR =HGHOPDLHU2QSUPHWDIRULNQMLJHNRWWHOHVDJOHM&KDUWLHU]DVUHGQMHYHďNHSULPHUHSD &XUWLXVȡ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 9 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 TELO IN VELIKA VERIGA BIVAJOČEGA 1D]DÍHWNXMHVPLVHOQRSRGDWLQHNDMRGJRYRURYQDYSUDďDQMH]DNDMMHELORWHOR SULOMXEOMHQDPHWDIRUD]DRSLVSROLWLÍQHJDVWDQMD1DMSUHMMHSRWUHEQRR]DYHVWLWLGHMVWYR GDLPDYVDNGRL]NXďQMRWHOHVD]DWRMHELODȡLQďHYHGQRMHȡWDL]NXďQMDXQLYHU]DOQD2 WHPSULÍDMRWXGLďWHYLOQLVRGREQLSULPHULRÍHPHUEREHVHGDWHNODY]DNOMXÍNX3RGUXJL SODWLVHMHWHORYSUHGPRGHUQLPLVOLYSLVRYDORYďLUďLNRQWHNVWYHOLNHYHULJHELYDMRÍHJD LQMHELORSRVOHGLÍQRUD]XPOMHQRNRWERĤMDVWYDULWHY2VQRYQRL]KRGLďÍHWHLGHMHMHSR YH]DQRVW YVHJD Y VWUQMHQR YHULJR RG ERJD GR QDMPDQMďHJD ]UQD ÌH YDQMR SRVWDYLPR WHOR YLGLPR GD MH SUHY]HOR R]QDÍER PLNURNR]PRVD NL MH Y VRRGQRVX ] PDNURNR]PR VRPYHVROMHPVYHWRP6RRGYLVQRVWPHGGHOLMHSRJRMWYRUMHQMDFHORWH6WRNRQFHSFLMR VRSRYH]DQHGRORÍHQHDQDORJLMHSUHGYVHPSUHY]HPJUDGXDOL]PDNL]D]QDPXMHSRPLN RGREÍHJDNSRVHEQHPXLQRGUDĤDDULVWRWHOMDQVNRSWROHPDMVNRNRQFHSFLMRVNOHQMHQHJD XQLYHU]XPD 2VQRYD PHWDIRUH R]LURPD DQDORJLMH MH WRUHM YH] PHGWHOHVRP NRW PLNUR NR]PRVRP LQ QDUDYQLP R]LURPD ERĤMLP UHGRP WHU GUĤDYRȡ SUL ÍHPHU MH FLOM XVWYDULWL LGHDOQRXUHGLWHY 9HOLNDYHULJDELYDMRÍHJDMHLPHODVYRMHNYLYDOHQWWXGLYSROLWLNLNDUMHERJY QHEHVLKMHNUDOMQD]HPOML'UXĤLQDMHELOD]DWRSRJRVWRR]QDÍHQD]DPDNURNR]PRVNDU SRVOHGLÍQRYRGLNUD]XPHYDQMXÍORYHďNHJDWHOHVDNRWPLNURNR]PRVDVSRGREQRVWUXN WXUR LQ ]PRĤQRVWPL GHORYDQMD 'DO\ ȡ9HVROMH LQ WHOR VWD RED ERĤML NUHDFLML ]DWRVHYREHKNDĤHSULSDGQRVWLVWHPXUHGX2EDVWDQDUDYQLLQSRVOHGLÍQRWXGLPRUDOQL WYRUEL9VUHGQMHPYHNXMHELODWDSULPHUMDYDSRJRVWRXSRUDEOMHQDYĤHOMLSRHQRWQRVWLLQ DYWRULWHWLWHUVRRGYLVQRVWLYVHKÍODQRYSROLWLÍQHVWUXNWXUH.D]DODMHQDPUHÍQDQHVSUH PHQOMLYRVWWHOHVDVWHPSDMRMHELORPRĤQRREOLNRYDWLNRWPDNVLPRGDMHSRWUHEQRRKUD QLWLWHORWDNďQRNRWMH NDUMHELOSRPHPEHQDUJXPHQW]DRKUDQLWHYREVWRMHÍHJDVLVWHPD =DWRWXGLQHSUHVHQHÍDGDMHDQJOHďNLPLVOHF)UDQFLV*UD\WHORR]QDÍLO]DPLNUDUKLMR GREURYRGHQRPDORNUDOMHVWYR3UDYWDP7DNRNRWMHWHORNR]PRVYPDOHPMHWHOR WXGLVRFLDOQLUHGYPDOHP2EHPDMHQDPUHÍVNXSHQRUJDQVNL]QDÍDM]DWRPRUDELWLPHG QMLPDWXGLQDUDYQDSRYH]DQRVW7HOHVDQLEUH]UHGDYVDNUD]UHGVWDQSDXVWUH]DGRORÍH QHPXRUJDQXNLL]YDMDVYRMHQDORJHLQVHQDKDMDQDWRÍQRGRORÍHQHPPHVWX6WHOHVRP MHELORWDNRPRĤQRL]UD]LWL]DKWHYRSRVNUEL]DVSORďQREODJLQMRHQHPL]PHGWHPHOMQLK SRVWXODWRYSUHGPRGHUQHSROLWLÍQHPLVOL.RWMHSRWUHEQRVSRďWRYDWLKLHUDUKLMRYWHOHVX MRMHSRWUHEQRVSRďWRYDWLWXGLYGUXĤEL7DNRNRWMHWHORQDUDYQDGDQRVWMHWXGLGUXĤED LQ]QMRSROLWLNDGDQDSRQDUDYL6UHGQMLYHNWHPHOMLQDLGHMLGDMHYVDNVWDQRGYLVHQRG GUXJHJD]DWRWHORSRQXMDGREURPHWDIRUR]DXVSHďQREODĤHQMHUD]OLÍQRVWLYGUXĤELNLQL SUREOHPDPSDNQXMQLSUHGSRJRM]DGUXĤER9VHVNXSDMVHYHGDYĤHOMLSRPDQMďHPďWHYLOX XSRURY)XQNFLRQDOQHSRYH]DYHPHGRUJDQLVRELOHWHPHOM]D]DJRYDUMDQMHSUHSULÍDQMD $YWRUNRQFHSWDYHOLNHYHULJHELYDMRÍHJDMH$UWKXU2/RYHMR\ 10 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 10 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 GDMHYVDNGRRGJRYRUHQ]DGREURSRÍXWMHFHORWQHJDRUJDQL]PDNDUMHSULSHOMDORNWYRUEL KDUPRQLÍQHYHULJH9R]DGMXWHJDVHMHL]REOLNRYDODWHOHRORďNDUD]ODJDNRQFHSWDNLVHMH QDSDMDODL]VWUDKXSUHGNR]PLÍQRDQDUKLMR 1HPRUHPRSDWUGLWLGDMHÍORYHďNRWHOR]JROMPHWDIRUD]DDEVROXWQRPRQDUKLMR .UDOMSDQDMERYLGHQNRWJODYDDOLVUFHQLQLÍEUH]RUJDQRYÌHMHELORSUHMR]DYHďÍHQRGD LPDYVDNGRL]NXďQMRWHOHVDVLQLWHĤNRSUHGVWDYOMDWLNDNRELWHORGHORYDORLQL]JOHGDOREUH] URNDOLQRJ5DYQRYWHPMHSORGQRVWPHWDIRUHWHOHVDGDMRMHPRÍSULODJRGLWLUD]OLÍQLP VLWXDFLMDPRÍHPHUERGRSULÍDOLWXGLSULPHULNLERGRSUHGVWDYOMHQLYQDGDOMHYDQMX 8VWDYLPRVHďHSULVWDQMXNLVSUHPOMDPDUVLNDWHURWHORȡEROH]QL.GRMHWDNLWHOR ODKNRSR]GUDYLEROH]QL"=GUDYQLN,QNGRODKNRSR]GUDYLSROLWLÍQHEROH]QL"9ODGDU Zato ne SUHVHQHÍDSULND]RYDQMHYODGDUMDNRW]GUDYQLNDNLGUĤDYRYRGLNR]GUDYLWYL9ODGDUMHNRQ VWUXLUDQNRWWHUDSHYWNLGHOXMHNRWYRGQLNYGUXJDÍQRUHVQLÍQRVW.GRGUXJNRWRQMH]PR ĤHQSRGDWLGLDJQR]RSROLWLÍQHJDGRJDMDQMDLQWREROH]HQWXGLSR]GUDYLWL"=PRĤHQMHWDNR SURJQRVWLNHNRWWXGLGLDJQRVWLNH103ULWHPQLQHSRPHPEQDVLPEROQDPRÍEROH]QLVDMMH ĤHRGDQWLNHQDSUHMEROH]HQWLVWR'UXJR7DNďQHPXUD]PLVOHNXODKNRVOHGLPRRG3ODWRQRYH R]QDÍEHWLUDQLMHNRWKXGHEROH]QLNLRJURĤDGUXĤER11%ROH]HQLPDJOREOMHSRVOHGLFHNGRU MHVSUHMHOEROH]HQVNRYORJRQHPRUHLJUDWLVYRMHQRUPDOQHYORJHVDMEROH]HQVXVSHQGLUD QRUPDOQRVWDQMHLQXYHGHL]UHGQRVWDQMH6WDQMH]GUDYOMHQMDMHHNVSHULPHQWDOQLUHĤLPY NDWHUHPMHGRYROMHQRYVHOHGDVHQDNRQFXSR]GUDYLEROH]HQ12%RMPHGEROH]QLMRLQR]GUD YLWYLMRVHVSUHYUĤHYPDQLKHMVNLERMPHGGREULPLQ]OLPNLVHODKNRNRQÍDOHVWRWDOQLP VSRSDGRP7DNRNRWMHYRMQDRÍLďÍHQMHMHWXGLEROH]HQRÍLďÍHQMHWHOHVYVHJDVODEHJDNDU VHMHYQMHPQDEUDOR7XQDVWRSLSRYH]DYDPHGJUHKRPLQEROH]QLMRNDWHUHQDMEROMďLSULPHU VRJREDYFLYVUHGQMHPYHNX.HUMHYVNXSQRVWLĤHYHGQRYSHWRSUHVRMDQMHLQSUHSULÍHYDQ MHMHNUKNRÍORYHďNRWHORSROLWLÍQLSUHL]NXVQLNDPHQEROH]HQSDSUHSURVWRLQKLWURRSUD YLÍLOR]DL]NOMXÍLWHYGRORÍHQLKVNXSLQSDQDMERGRWRYHUVNHVSROQHDOLVRFLDOQHVNXSLQH 3UREOHPDWLND EROH]QL MH QD SRPHQX SULGRELOD SUHGYVHP Y ]JRGQMHP QR YHP YHNX NR MH HQD L]PHG UHIHUHQF SRVWDO 3DUDFHO]LM 3RXGDUMDO MH NHPLÍQH SURFHVH NL VH GRJDMDMR Y WHOHVX V ÍLPHU MH SRXGDULO XSRUDER LQ RGPHUMDQMH ]GUDYLO 9]URN EROH]QL VHSR QMHJRYHP PQHQMX QDKDMD ]XQDM WHOHVD NDU MH SULSHOMDOR GR WHJD GD VR }WXMD WHOH VDm Y SROLWLÍQL PLVOL GRELYDOD YHGQR YHÍML SRPHQ NRW SRY]URÍLWHOML SROLWLÍQLK EROH]QL =DGREHUSUHJOHGVUHGQMHYHďNHSROLWLÍQHPLVOLJOHM%ODFN 3UREOHPDWLNHSULND]RYDQMDNUDOMDNRW]GUDYQLNDVHERWDSULVSHYHNGRWDNQLOOHEHĤQRNHUELVWHP SUHVHJOLRGPHUMHQLSURVWRU9VHNDNRUSDJUH]DWHPDWLNRNLVHMLYHOMDSRVYHWLWLVDMMHNDUQHNDMSULPHUMDYPHG REHPD 10'DSDLPDYODGDUODKNRWXGLQHSRVUHGQH]GUDYLOQHXÍLQNHMHSRND]DO0DUF%ORFKVďWXGLMR RERĤMHPGRWLNXNL]GUDYLďNURIXOR]RÌHSUDYJUHYRVQRYL]DVUHGQMHYHďNLRELÍDMVHMHWDNRY)UDQFLMLNRWWXGL $QJOLMLRKUDQLOGRVWROHWMD 11&LFHURMHWLUDQLFLGSULPHUMDO]DPSXWDFLMR6KRJLPHQȡ 12 'DQHVVRQDPWDNLSULPHULQDMEROMSR]QDQLNRWďRNWHUDSLMHL]QRYHMďHHNRQRPVNRSROLWLÍQH]JRGRYLQH *REDYHFQLPRJHOSRVWDWLNUDOM(GLQDL]MHPDMHELO%DOGZLQ,9NLMHSRVWDONUDOMQDHQHPL]PHG NULĤDUVNLKSRKRGRYLQWRUHM de facto QLELONUDOMY(YURSL=DQLPLYRVWWHJDMHWXGLYWHPNDNRQHNDSRVHEQDVWDQ MDNULĤDUVNLSRKRGLQSRVHEQLNUDMLL]YHQ(YURSHVOHGLMRQHNLVYRMLORJLNLLQQLVR]DYH]DQLHQDNLPGRORÍLORP. 11 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 11 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 3UREOHPDWLND EROH]QL MH QD SRPHQX SULGRELOD SUHGYVHP Y ]JRGQMHP QR YHP YHNX NR MH HQD L]PHG UHIHUHQF SRVWDO 3DUDFHO]LM 3RXGDUMDO MH NHPLÍQH SURFH VH NL VH GRJDMDMR Y WHOHVX V ÍLPHU MH SRXGDULO XSRUDER LQ RGPHUMDQMH ]GUDYLO 9]URN EROH]QL VHSR QMHJRYHP PQHQMX QDKDMD ]XQDM WHOHVD NDU MH SULSHOMDOR GR WHJD GD VR }WXMD WHOHVDm Y SROLWLÍQL PLVOL GRELYDOD YHGQR YHÍML SRPHQ NRW SRY]URÍLWHOML SR OLWLÍQLK EROH]QL 1DVWRSLO MH VWUDK SUHG ELRWVNLP 'UXJLP NL QDV RJURĤD ] RNXĤER NDU MH YSOLYDOR WXGL QD SROLWLÍQL GLVNXU] 6WUDK SUHG GUXJDÍQLP WXMLP QHYLGQLP MH UD]ORJ ]DNDM MH PHGLFLQVNL GLVNXU] SRVWDO LQWHJUDOQL GHO JUDGQMH QDFLRQDOQLK LGHQ WLWHW Y VWROHWMX ȡ QDUDYQR LQ PRUDOQR WHOR MH WLVWR NL SRGDMD VOLNR R GROR ÍHQL QDFLML 7R VH NDĤH Y ORÍQLFL 0L LQ 'UXJL NL MR ODKNR EHUHPR NRW =GUDYL LQ %ROQL ANTIKA IN SVETO PISMO 'DELODĤMHUD]XPHOLUDERPHWDIRUWHOHVDYSUHGPRGHUQLVHMHSRWUHEQRVH]QD QLWL]DQWLÍQLPLSULPHUL3UYDRPHPEDPHWDIRUHWHOHVDMH(]RSRYDEDVHQRĤHORGFX2V QRYQDSUHPLVDEDVQLMHGDVRVHYVLRUJDQLXSUOLĤHORGFXVDMQDMELWDĤLYHOL]NOMXÍQRRG QMLKRYHJDGHODÍHďGDMHOHMHGHOLQOHQDULODVRRUJDQLKLWURXJRWRYLOLGDEUH]WUHEXKDQH PRUHMRVDMMLPSULQDďDQXMQRSRWUHEQRHQHUJLMR(]RSRYREDVHQODKNRYLGLPRNRWSUYR ]DYHGDQMHGDYWHOHVXYODGDGRORÍHQDKDUPRQLMDKNDWHULSULSRPRUHMRYVLRUJDQLNDUMH ELORSR]QHMHSUHQHVHQRQDSROLWLNR(]RSNRWRVQRYQLRUJDQSUHGSRVWDYLĤHORGHFNDUMH UD]OLNDJOHGHQDVUHGQMHYHďNRLQQRYRYHďNRSHUVSHNWLYRNLYJODYQHPWHPHOMLQDSUHPLVL GDVWDJODYDLQVUFHNOMXÍQD]DRUJDQL]DFLMRWHOHVD(]RSRYDSUHPLVDVHMHNDVQHMHY ]JRGRYLQLSRMDYLODYHÍNUDWEDVHQMHQDSULPHUYVSRUXPHGSDWULFLMLLQSOHEHMFLXSRUDELO WXGL 0HQHQLM $JULSD LQ ]DJRYDUMDO GD WDNR NRW WHOR QH PRUH ĤLYHWL EUH] ĤHORGFD WXGL SOHEHMFLQHPRUHMRĤLYHWLEUH]YODGHSDWULFLMHY'DSRPHQ(]SRYHEDVQLQLELOSR]DEOMHQ QLWLYVWROHWMXSULÍDIDUVD%LWNDGHORYWHOHVDNLMRMHOHWDL]GDO$GULDHQ6WLNNH 6WLNNHMHYDSULSRYHGJUDGLQDLURQLÍQRVWLVDMDYWRUSRXYRGQLSUHGVWDYLXYHGH }ďHHQHJDÍODQDWHOHVDmNLJDSRLPHQXMH]D}YODGDUMDNUDOMHYLQERJRYmVÍLPHUQDNDĤH GDPXMHXVSHORQHNDMQHPRJRÍHJD3RPRQRORJXWHJDDQRQLPQHJDRUJDQDL]VSRGQ MH SRORYLFH WHOHVD }GXKm L]EUXKQH QD SODQ NR ]DGQMLFD QHXÍDNDQR RSR]RUL QDVH .R ML GUXJLRUJDQLRPHMLMRSUDYLFRJRYRUDVHWHPXXSUHLQ}]DSUHYUDWDm7HORMHNPDOX]D SDFNDQR V SRVOHGLFDPL WHJD XSRUD ĤHORGHF VH ]DÍQH NUÍLWL ÍUHYHVMH SRVWDQH WUGR YVH WRSDSRY]URÍLQHUHGYWHOHVX3ULWHPQHPRUHSRPDJDWLQREHQDPHGLFLQDVDM}YUDWD RVWDMDMR]DSUWDmNRWSRVOHGLFDYVHJDSDQDVWRSLÍXGQDPHďDQLFDKODSRYNLYPRĤJDQLK SRY]URÍL KODGHQ SRW LQ GYLJDMRÍH ODVH 7XGL RVWDOL GHOL WHOHVD VH QH SRÍXWLMR QLÍ EROMH YVL VR VH ĤH QD SRO PUWYL ]DUDGL ÍHVDU SR]DELMR QD VYRMR QHNGDQMR ÍDVW LQ SRVWRSRPD .WUHEXKXNRWRVUHGQMHPXRUJDQXVHMHYUQLOQL]R]HPVNLNUDOM9LOMHP2UDQVNLNLMHSR]YDOVWDQRYH QDM]DďÍLWLMROHSRWHORGUĤDYHNLJDMHNUDOMĤHOHOSRKDELWL 3ULWHPRSLVXYLGLPRNDNRĤLYRMHELODWHRULMDKXPRUMHYďHYHGQRSULVRWQDYVWROHWMX 12 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 12 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 SRWUGLMRYVHĤHOMHLQ]DKWHYH]DGQMLFH'HORVH]DNOMXÍLVVOHGHÍRPLVOLMR}9VDNGRELPR UDO YHGHWL GD VH PRÍ SRVDPH]QLND SRYHÍD WDNUDW NR MH ]DQLÍHYDQm .R MH EHVHGLOR SR GHVHWLKOHWLKSRQRYQRL]ďORJDMHL]GDMDWHOMSULND]DONRW]DKWHYRSRGHPRNUDFLMLVDMSR OLWLÍQRWHORSRWUHEXMHYVHVYRMHÍODQHÍHĤHOLELWLDNWLYQR7XGLWLVWHNLVHMLKVUDPXMH 9 PDUVLÍHP VWD ]DÍUWDOD XSRUDER PHWDIRUH WHOHVD Y DQWLNL WXGL 3ODWRQ NL VH MH V WHOHVQLPL PHWDIRUDPL XNYDUMDO SUHGYVHP Y 'UĤDYL LQ =DNRQLK SRVUHGQR SD WXGL Y 7LPDMX WHU $ULVWRWHO NL MH ]DJRYDUMDO GD MH SR QDUDYL SROLV SUHG YVHPL SUHGKRGQL PLREOLNDPLVDMMHFHORWDYHQRPHUSUHGGHOL$ULVWRWHOD 9QDGDOMHYDQMX DUJXPHQWLUD GD NR XQLÍLPR WHOR XQLÍLPR WXGL QMHJRYH GHOH NL EUH] FHORWH QH PRUH MR GHORYDWL $ULVWRWHOD LPDPR ODKNR WXGL ]D SRVUHGQHJD ]DÍHWQLND XYDMDQMD PHWDIRUH GDMHPHVWRSROLVWHORNDUVHMHNDVQHMHVSURSDGRPSROLVSUHWYRULORYLGHMRNR]PR VDNRWPHVWDĤHSUHGWHPMHELODSRJRVWDSULPHUMDYDNR]PRVDLQWHOHVD=DYDGLO 7RMHSUHY]HODVWRDNLMHPRÍQRYSOLYDODQD6YHWRSLVPRWHUNDVQHMHQDSROLWLÍQR PLVHO LQ VWROHWMD 3RPHPEHQ MH ELO SUHGYVHP &LFHUR LQ QMHJRYD PLVHO GD GXďD YODGD WHOHVX WDNR NRW NUDOM YODGD VYRMLP SRGORĤQLNRP 3HLO $ YHQGDU VH MH WXGL &LFHUR ]DYHGDO GD WDNR NRW WHOR QH PRUH REVWDMDWL EUH] YVHK RUJDQRY WXGL GUĤD YD QH PRUH REVWDMDWL EUH] VYRMLK GHORY =DYDGLO ģH WD SULPHU QDP NDĤH NDNR MH PRĤQR ] PHWDIRUR WHOHVD SR HQL VWUDQL XWHPHOMLWL VXYHUHQRVW YODGDUMD LQ JD KNUDWL RSR]RULWL GD PRUD SUL YODGDQMX PLVOLWL QD GUXJH VDM QL NUDOMD EUH] SRGUHMHQLK 96YHWHPSLVPXLQSUHGYVHPQRYRYHďNLSRERĤQRVWLMHSRPHPEQRYORJRLJUDOD LGHMDFRUSXV&KULVWLRÍHPHUODKNREHUHPRY3DYORYHPSLVPX(IHĤDQRPNMHUMH]DSL VDO}XQXPFRUSXVHWXQXVVSLULWXVm7HEHVHGHVRYQRYHPYHNXSRJRVWRSRQDYOMDOLNRW DUJXPHQWSURWLYHUVNLVYRERGL(QRMHSRPHPEQHMďHRGPQRďWYDȡLQWDPLVHOVHSRQDYO MDWXGLSULREUDYQDYLWHOHVD.DMGUXJHJDMHUHIRUPDFLMDNRWWUJDQMHWHOHVDQDGYDGHOD &HUNHYVHEHUD]XPHNRWWHORNRWFRUSXVP\VWLFXPNLMHQDGÍDVRYQRLQQDGSURVWRUVNR DďHYHGQRQDUDYQDSRYH]DQDHQRWD=DMDVQRVWSULND]DODKNRQDYHGHPRPLVHOVYHWHJD 3DYODL]SLVPD.RULQÍDQRP .DNRUMHQDPUHþWHORHQRLQLPDYHOLNRGHORYYVLWHOHVQLGHOLSDVRHQRWHORþHSUDYMLKMH YHOLNRWDNRMHWXGL.ULVWXV9HQHP'XKXVPRELOLQDPUHþPLYVLNUãþHQLYHQRWHORQDM ERPR-XGMHDOL*UNLVXåQMLDOLVYRERGQLLQYVLVPRSLOLHQHJD'XKD7XGLWHORQDPUHþQL VHVWDYOMHQRL]HQHJDWHOHVQHJDGHODDPSDNL]YHþGHORYýHELQRJDUHNODµ.HUQLVHPURND QHVSDGDPNWHOHVX¶YHQGDUOHVSDGDNWHOHVXýHELXKRUHNORµ.HUQLVHPRNRQHVSDGDP NWHOHVX¶YHQGDUOHVSDGDNWHOHVX.MHELELOVOXKNRELELORYVHWHORRNR".MHELELOYRQM NRELELORYVHWHORVOXK"7DNRSDMH%RJYVHSRVDPH]QHWHOHVQHGHOHUD]SRVWDYLOSRWHOHVX 1DVSORďQRODKNRPHGLFLQVNLPPHWDIRUDPVOHGLPRYVNRUDMYVHK$ULVWRWHORYLKGHOLK 7XYHOMDRSR]RULWLQDYSOLY&LFHUDQDUD]YRMKXPDQLVWLÍQLKWRNRY7XFN]DJRYDUMDWH]RGD ODKNRSROLWLÍQRPLVHOYLQVWROHWMXUD]GHOLPRPHG&LFHUDNLSRNULYDÍDVVWROHWMDLQ7DFLWDÌHSUDYJUH ]DJURERÍUWSDVHOHWDNDĤHNRWPRĤHQQDVWDYHN]DNRQFHSWXDOL]DFLMRSROLWLNHYWHPREGREMX 96YHWHPSLVPXMHYHÍSRGREQLKSULPHUMDYWDNRVHQDSULPHUJRYRULRL]JUDMHYDQMX.ULVWXVRYHJD WHOHVDVÍLPHUMHPLďOMHQDL]JUDGQMDFHUNYHQHRUJDQL]DFLMH(I.ULVWXVVHRPHQMDNRWJODYDFHUNYH(I . Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 13 27. 10. 2022 11:16:16 NDNRUMHKRWHO.RELELORYVHVNXSDMHQVDPWHOHVQLGHONMHELELORWHOR"7DNRSDMHYHOLNR GHORYWHORSDMHHQR1HPRUHRNRUHþLURNLµ1HSRWUHEXMHPWH¶WXGLQHJODYDQRJDPµ1H SRWUHEXMHPYDV¶âHYHþWHOHVQLGHOLNLVH]GLMRVODERWQHMãLVRãHEROMSRWUHEQLLQWLVWLP NLVHQDP]GLMRPDQMYUHGQLþDVWLL]ND]XMHPRãHYHþMHVSRãWRYDQMHLQ]PDQMXJOHGQLPL ãHOHSãHUDYQDPRPHGWHPNRXJOHGQLWHJDQHSRWUHEXMHMR'D%RJMHVHVWDYLOWHORLQ VNURPQHPX QDPHQLO YHþ þDVWL GD Y WHOHVX QH EL ELOR UD]SUWLMH PDUYHþ EL WHOHVQL GHOL HQDNRVNUEHOLGUXJ]DGUXJHJDýHHQGHOWUSLWUSLMR]QMLPYVLGHOLþHMHHQGHOYþDVWL VH]QMLPYHVHOLMRYVL9LSDVWH.ULVWXVRYRWHORLQYVDN]DVHGHOWHOHVD.RU± SREDNJEVEŠKA POLITIČNA MISEL .RW MH ELOR RPHQMHQR Y XYRGX MH PHWDIRUD WHOHVD LJUDOD SRPHPEQR YORJR Y VUHGQMHYHďNLSROLWLÍQLPLVOL9WHPREGREMXVRVHL]REOLNRYDOHWULWHPHOMQHPHWDIRUHWHOH VDNR]PLÍQDNLMRSRQD]DUMDSUHGVWDYDWHOHVDNRWPLNURNR]PRVDFHUNYHQDLQSROLWLÍQD 6FKPLWW (GHQ L]PHG QDMEROM ]QDQLK SULPHURY MH -DQH] 6DOLVEXU\MVNL NL MH YVYRMHPGHOX3ROLFUDWXVQDMEROMMDVQRL]UD]LOLGHMRRRUJDQVNLSRYH]DQRVWLSROLWLÍQHJD WHOHVD9UD]PLVOHNXVHMHRSUOSUHGYVHPQD&LFHUDLQ3OXWDUKDVÍLPHUMHĤHOHOGRVHÍL UHQRYDWLRVYRMHGREH2G&LFHUDMHSUHY]HOSUHGVWDYRRNUDOMXNRWPHGLFXVUHLSXEOLFDH 6KRJLPHQNDUVHQDYH]XMHQDSUHGVWDYRRNUDOMXNLSRWUHEXMHGRORÍHQR]QDQ MHRWHOHVXÍHĤHOLYODGDWL-DQH]MHWDNROHSUHGVWDYLONUDOMHVWYRWHOR}QMHJRYYODGDUMH JODYDVHQDWVUFHVRGQLNLVRRÍLXďHVDLQMH]LNYLWH]LURNHYODGDUMHYLSRPRÍQLNLVWUDQVNL GHOLWHOHVDNYHVWRUMLLQSLVDUMLWUHEXKLQGURERYMHNPHWMHSDQRJHNLKRGLMRSR]HPOMLm 6FKPLWW*UH]DWHORPRQDUKLMHNMHUQLYVHYURNDKNUDOMD+NUDWLMHYSHOMDO delitev duše, ki ne more grešitiLQWHOHVDNDUMHLPHOR]DSRVOHGLFRQDVWDQHNGYHKWHOHV NUDOMD LQ GXKRYďÍLQH ,] DQDORJLMH ODKNR UD]EHUHPR VRGHORYDQMH LQ NRPSOHPHQWDUQRVW YVHKVWDQRYVDMQHVORJDPHGQMLPLRJURĤDUHG2UJDQLVWLÍQDGHOLWHYGUXĤEHMHELODWHPHOM L]SHOMDYLGUXĤEHQHKLHUDUKLMHLQQDÍHODVRFLDOQHQHHQDNRVWL20'DMHELODQDORJDVUHGQ MHYHďNHJDYODGDUMD]DďÍLWDWHOHVDEROMNRWQMHJRYR]GUDYOMHQMHQDPNDĤHVOHGHÍDPLVHO 1LNRODMD.X]DQVNHJD}9ODGDUMHYDVNUEELPRUDORELWLGREURSRÍXWMHWHOHVDVDMELVWHP RPRJRÍLOGDVHGXKĤLYOMHQMDSUDYLOQRUD]ďLULSRFHORWQHPWHOHVXm6KRJLPHQ .X]DQVNLWXVOHGL*DOHQRYLPLVOLGDMHSUHYHQFLMDYHOLNREROMďDNRW]GUDYOMHQMHÌHSUDY MHELOD*DOHQRYDWHRULMDKXPRUMHYNOMXÍQDUHIHUHQFDQDSRGURÍMXPHGLFLQHVDMMHL]UD ĤDODWLVWRNÍHPXUMHWHĤLODVUHGQMHYHďNDGUXĤEDȡKDUPRQLMRMHELORQHSRVUHGQRVNOLFH YDQMHQD*DOHQDLQWHRULMRKXPRUMHYYSROLWLÍQLPLVOLUHGNR'RORÍHQUD]ORJWHPXYHOMD SULSLVDWLGHMVWYXGDKXPRUDOQD]DVQRYDNRWRVQRYQLRUJDQSULY]HPDMHWUDLQQHJODYHali VUFDNRWMHELORRELÍDMQRYSROLWLÍQLWHRULML21 M }'RNOHUJODYDSULPHUQRYODGDWHOHVXQDG]LUDUD]OLÍQHRUJDQHLQMLKSULVLOMXMHNSUDYLÍQRVWLGRNOHU MHSUL]DQHVOMLYDGRQDMEROMUDQOMLYLKLQMLKREGDUMD]OMXEH]QLMRLQȣREXYDQRJDPÍHYOMHȤQLQLÍNULYDm'XE\ 20 'D-DQH]6DOLVEXU\MVNLQLELOHGLQLNLMHVOHGLOWHMPLVOLSULÍDWXGLVOHGHÍLFLWDW+XPEHUWDGH6LOYH &DQGLGDL]OHWDNLLGHMRWHOHVDYSLVXMHYFHUNYHQRUD]XPHYDQMHGDQHJDSRORĤDMD}5HGNOHULNRYMHSUYLYWH OHVXWDNRNRWVRRÍLSUYHYJODYL&HUNHYMHELODWLVWDRNDWHULMHJRYRULOJRVSRGNRMHGHMDOȣ.GRUVHYDVGRWDNQH VHGRWDNQHSXQÍLFHPRMHJDRÍHVDȤm=DK3RVYHWQDREODVWMHNRWSUVLLQURNDNDWHUHPRÍMHQDYDMHQDGD XERJD&HUNHYLQMREUDQL9LJQMHYLÉȡ9VHVNXSDMODKNRSRVSUHPLPR]$YJXďWLQRYRPLVOLMR}5HGMH GLVSR]LFLMDNLHQDNLPLQUD]OLÍQLPVWYDUHPGRGHOLQMLKRYRPHVWRm3UDYWDP Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 14 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 ZGODNJENOVOVEŠKI PRIMERI .RWVPRYLGHOLL]SUHGKRGQLKSULPHURYMHWHORL]UDĤDORVDPRXPHYQRVW QDUDYQRVWUHGLQXUHMHQRVW7DNRNRWYVUHGQMHPYHNXMHELORWXGLYQRYHPSRJODYLWQR YRGLORGDPRUDWHORLPHWLJODYR%DWLSDVHYHOMDWHOHVDNLQLYUD]PHUMXVDMJUH]DEROQR DOLUDQMHQRWHOR*DUDQWQDUDYQHJDWHOHVDMHVHYHGD%RJ'UXĤEHVLEUH]YHUHQHGDSUHG VWDYOMDWLVDMMHYHUDGXďDSROLWLÍQHJDWHOHVD6SUHPHPEDYHUHSRPHQLWXGLVSUHPHPER FRQGLWLRKXPDQDȡNDMVH]JRGLVWHOHVRPNR]EROLYHUDVHMHVSUDďHYDONUDQMVNLSROLWLÍQL WHRUHWLN)$3HO]KRIIHU%ROH]QLGXďHODKNRSR]GUDYLVDPRKLPPOLVFKH$U]WQHEHďND PHGLFLQDYHUVNHEROH]QLNRWVWDUDNDOLVXďLFDSDL]VXďLMRWHORLQJDQDUHGLMRQH]PRĤ QHJD]DĤLYOMHQMH.DUSDMHQDMKXMHQLVUHGVWYDVNDWHULPELWRODKNRSUHVHJOLNLQHELELOR WUGDYHUD3HO]KRIIHU$WXGLWDQLYHÍQR]DJRWRYLOR 7XGL-XVW/LSVLMVHMHSULWRĤHYDOGDVRGUXJRYHUFLRNXĤHQLÍODQLGUXĤEH LQMH]DKWHYDOQMLKRYRRGVWUDQLWHYRGĤLJVDMMHEROMHL]JXELWLQHNDWHUHGHOHNRWSD FHORWQRWHOR21 2 SUHGQMHYHďND WHOHVQD DQDWRPLMD MH RVWDOD ĤLYD SUL VWDQRYLK VDM VH SR QMLK RYHP PQHQMX SUL SRNORQLWYL GHĤHOQL NQH] LQ VWDQRYL PHG VHERM SRYHĤHMR LQ VH V WHP JODYD]GUXĤLVFHORWQLPWHOHVRPVÍLPHUVRSRQDYOMDOLSUHSULÍDQMHGDMHSRWUHEQRQD UHGLWL PRÍQR LQ HQRWQR WHOR 6WURKPH\HU 7DNďQD SRYH]DYD MH }PHG JRV SRGRPLQSRGORĤQLNRPUHVQLÍQDWDNUDWNDGDUSRGORĤQLNLNRWXGMHVHELQDGUHMHQHJOD YH LQ REODVWL L]SROQMXMHMR VYRMH QDORJH LQ GROĤQRVWL GR WH REODVWL REODVW SD SULWRĤEH SRGORĤQLNRY REUDYQDYD NRW VSORďQH WDNR NRW QHORÍOMLY &RUSXV ]YHVWR GUĤLMR VNXSDM LQ L] WH Y]DMHPQRVWL L]KDMD XÍLQNRYLWD EODJLQMDm 3UDY WDP 9VDNR WHOR SD QL QDUDYQR LQ ERJX SRYďHÍL 3XIHQGRUI MH R]QDÍLO 6YHWR ULPVNR FHVDUVWYR ]D SRďDVW22 Stav ek mo UDPR UD]XPHWL Y VPLVOX GD MH XVWDYQD XUHGLWHY FHVDUVWYD QHPRJRÍD QHQDUDYQD ]DWR JDYHOMDUD]XPHWLNRWQHVWYRUQHNDMNDUSRQDUDYLQHPRUHREVWDMDWLLQMHSURWLQMHM (GHQL]PHGWHKNLVR*DOHQRYRWHRULMRSRJRVWRXSRUDEOMDOLMHELO1LNRODM.X]DQVNL9VYRMHPUD]PLV OHNXMHWDNR.X]DQVNLSULSLVDOMHWURPRVUHGQMHPHVWRYNDQRQXVDML]QMLKL]KDMDMRĤLOHNLVHďLULMRSRFHORWQHP WHOHVXĎHHQWDNSULPHUMHIUDQFRVNLWHRORJL]VWROHWMD3LHUUH&KDUURQNLMHGHMDO}6WUDVWLLQKXPRUMLYSOLYDMR QDWHOR]DWRPRUDGUĤDYDVSR]QDWLÍORYHNRYRWHORGDELODKNRRKUDQLODSROLWLÍQLLQQDUDYQLUHGm6ROO 1LFROH2UHVPHMHWLUDQLMRRSLVDONRWSUHWLUDQYSOLYKXPRUMHYYJODYR6KRJLPHQ%DFRQSDMH SULPHUMDOQH]DGRYROMVWYRYSROLWLÍQHPWHOHVX]QH]GUDYLPLWHOHVQLPLVRNRYLSULÍORYHNX%DFRQ 22 3RGREHQEHVHGQMDNXSRUDEOMDDQRQLPQLSDPʴHWNLVHMHOHWDYSRMDYLOY)UDQFLMLWMYOHWX NRMHXELWNUDOM+HQULN,,,WHU]DKWHYDOR]GUDYLWHYGUĤDYH%ROH]HQMHELODSRVOHGLFDYHUVNLKVSRURYDYWRUSDMH SRQDYOMDOGDMH)UDQFLMDWHORNLPXMHSRWUHEQRSXďÍDWLNULR]NLPRUDL]NUYDYHWL]DUDGLVPUWLNUDOMDNLMHELOSRG YSOLYRPVODELKKXPRUMHYSURWHVWDQWRY%UDOHFMHSRYDEOMHQQDMVHYĤLYLYYORJR]GUDYQLND)UDQFLMHYORJRNLMH ELOD]DJRWRYOMHQDNUDOMX } Irregolare aliquod corpus et monstro simile mȡL]MDYRMH3XIHQGRUISRGDOSRGSVHYGRQLPRP 9HÍJODYRWHORMHSRďDVWNLVLMHQLPRĤQR]DPLďOMDWL9SRGREQHPNRQWHNVWXPRUDPREUDWLWXGL %HVROGRYRL]MDYRGDMHĎSDQLMDQHVWYRU]HQRJODYRLQUD]OLÍQLPLWHOHVL6WURKPH\HU $QJOHďNLSUDYQLN L]VWROHWMD:LOOLDP)XOEHFNHMHQDSULPHUL]MDYLO}3HWDVHQHPRUHQDKDMDWLQDPHVWXJODYHHGLQRÍHMHWHOR XQLÍHQRLQMHQDGHOXSRďDVWQDDQDWRPLMDm3HLO7XQDĤDORVWQLPRĤQDQDWDQÍQHMďDUD]ODJDRGQRVD ERJDLQQDUDYHYQRYRYHďNLPLVOL3ULYHÍLQLPLVOHFHYVWDRKUDQLODGRORÍHQRSRYH]DQRVWERJNRWVWYDULWHOMQDUD YH]DWRPRUDPRYWHPGDMHQHNDMQHQDUDYQRYLGHWLWXGLGDMHQDVSURWQRERĤMHPX Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 15 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 9SUDďDQMH SRPHQD JODYH MH QDÍHO WXGL EULWDQVNL ]JRGRYLQDU 'DYLG &UHVV\ 9 VYRMHP SULVSHYNX VH MH RVUHGRWRÍLO QD GYH DQJOHďNL SXEOLNDFLML L] OHW VWR OHWMD NL VWD VH XNYDUMDOL ] URMVWYRP EUH]JODYLK RWURN *UR]R WDNHJD URMVWYD VR SUL SLVRYDOL ďWHYLOQLP YHUVNLP LQ SROLWLÍQLP GHOLWYDP NL VR SUHWUHVDOH $QJOLMR WHU MLK UD]ODJDOL SRG YSOLYRP ďWHYLOQLK PHWDIRU RG PQRJRJODYLK SRďDVWL LQ KL GHU GR EUH]JODYHJD NUDOMD 7DNR WHOR NRW JODYD LPDWD VYRMR PLWRORďNR YUHGQRVW 1DYHGLPRGYDSRPHQOMLYDSULPHUDIUDQFRVNDUHYROXFLMD]JLOMRWLQRORÍLJODYRLQ WHORVÍLPHUUHDOQRLQVLPEROQRXPRULWHORNDWHUHJDYRGLWHOMLFDMHJODYD,QREUDWQRQR YRYHďNLSULPHUUD]ÍHWYHUMHQMDVNDWHULPVRREND]QRYDQMXSRVDPH]QLNDKNUDWLSRND]DOL GDRUJDQLVDPL]DVHEHQHPRUHMRREVWDMDWLDPSDNMLPVPLVHOGDMHďHOHYSHWRVWYFHORWR 7DNR NRW SROLWLÍQR WHOR ODKNR UDVWH VH UD]YLMD DOL ]EROL ODKNR WXGL XPUH }1LÍ QD VYHWX QL YHÍQHJDm VSRURÍD ďSDQVNL WDFLWLVW (XJHQLR GH 1DUERQD NUDOMX )LOL SX ,9 LQ QDGDOMXMH }UHSXEOLNH XPUHMR LQ QD NRQFX MLK RGQHVH WRN ÍDVD LQ VSUHPHPE NRWYVHQDUDYQHVWYDULm0DUDYDOO 'DMHELOWDNUD]PLVOHNYEDURÍQLĎSD QLML L]MHPQR SULOMXEOMHQ SULÍD WXGL PLVHO /RSH]D %UDYD }GD VH LPSHULML LQ ]DNRQL SR VWDUDMRWDNRNRWYVHGUXJHVWYDULÍHSUDYMH3ODWRQVDQMDOGUXJDÍHQDUDYDMHGRORÍLOD GDVHQLÍQHY]GUĤXMHLQWUDMDYHÍQRYVHVWYDULVHVÍDVRPVSUHPLQMDMRm3UDYWDP Na WDN QDÍLQ UD]PLVOHND MH YSOLYDO 7DFLW V VYRMLP ]DYHGDQMHP R PLQOMLYRVWL ]HPHOMVNHJD (GZDUG)RUVHWYGHOX&RPSDUDWLYH'LVFRXUVHRIWKH%RGLHV1DWXUDODQG3ROL WLTXHNLMHL]ďOROHWDRGORÍLWHY]DWHOHVQHPHWDIRUHXWHPHOMXMHVWHPGDMHFRP PRQZHDOWKPRĤQRSULND]DWL]PHWDIRURYHVROMDDOLWHOHVDDGDMHVOHGQMDEROMUD]XPOMLYD ģHYQDVORYX)RUVHWUD]GHOLWHORQDQDUDYQRLQSROLWLÍQRȡLQREHVLODVWLYOD GDU 9 VYRMHP UD]PLVOHNX QH SRGD MDVQH R]QDÍEH NGR YODGD WHOHVX 9ÍDVLK YLGL VX YHUHQD Y VUFX VSHW GUXJLÍ Y JODYL LQ VUFX YÍDVLK WXGL Y GXďL YVH WR NDĤH QD WR NDNR ]DKWHYQR MH L]EUDWL SRJODYLWQL RUJDQ EUH] NDWHUHJD WHOR QH PRUH YHÍ REVWDMDWL$ YVH HQRNUDOMLPDREODVWQDGYVHPLWUHPLR]LURPD]DVHGDYVHWUL)RUVHWMHELOPQHQMDGD 7DNDURMVWYDNRWWXGLUD]YRMGRORÍHQLKEROH]QLVRELODSRJRVWRSULSLVDQDUD]OLÍQLPY]URNRPERJX KXGLÍXDVWURORďNLPIHQRPHQRPSDWXGLVODERVWLLQJUHďQRVWLOMXGL 2EGREMHDQJOHďNHGUĤDYOMDQVNHYRMQHMHSUHSROQRVNOLFHYDQMQDEROQRWHORR]LURPDQDWHORNLVHY XUHMHQLUHGQHPRUHYSLVDWLĎWHYLOQLSLVQLGRNXPHQWLSDWXGLYL]XDOQHXSRGRELWYHVRVHVNOLFHYDOLQDSRďDVWQL LPDJLQDULMNLVHMHQDKDMDOY6YHWHPSLVPXJUHSUHGYVHP]D'DQLMHORYRNQMLJRLQ$SRNDOLSVRNDUVWD L]NRULďÍDODREDWDERUD3UH]ELWHULMDQVNLPLQLVWHU(GZDUG:LOODQMHOHWD]DSLVDOGDVRQRYLGUĤDYQL]GUDYQLNL JUH]DUHSXEOLNDQFHSRY]URÍLOLďWHYLOQHEROH]QLVWHPNRVRRGVWUDQLOLNUDOMDSRJODYLWQLYLU]GUDYMD7XGL RGVWDYLWHY&URPZHOODLQUHVWDYUDFLMDPRQDUKLMHMHELODGRMHWDYNRQWHNVWXPHGLFLQH7LVWLNLVRSRGSLUDOLYUQLWHY PRQDUKLMHVRXVSHďQRVWWHJDSRGYLJDYLGHOLNRWGRND]VSORďQHJD]GUDYMDGUĤDYOMDQRYLQQMLKRYHJDGREUHJD SRÍXWMDNOMXEWHPXGDVR}GUĤDYQL]GUDYQLNLmXELOL.DUOD,(OPHUȡ =DGRSROQLWHY]JRUQMHJDUD]PLVOHND6XDUH]GH)LJXHURDMH]DSLVDOGDQLYHÍQHJDSROLWLÍQHJDWHOHVD VDMYVDNRSDQDMERďHWDNRGREURRUJDQL]LUDQRÍDNDSURSDGSRGRORÍHQHPÍDVX0DUDYDOO 2VQRYDWHJDSRJODYMDER6ÅOÅYÅVWUX9DQJOHďNHPNRQWHNVWXMHSRWUHEQRRSR]RULWLWXGLQD delo On the Laws and Governance NLJDMHQDSLVDO-RKQ)RUWHVFXHYNDWHUHPVRďWHYLOQHPHWDIRUHWHOHVDLQL] NDWHUHJDVWDYHUMHWQRÍUSDODREDDYWRUMD)RUVHWRYUD]PLVOHNWHPHOMLQD*DOHQXYSUHGJRYRUXSDNRWUHIHUHQFR QDYHGH3LVPR.RULQÍDQRP0HQHQLMD$JULSRLQ3URWDJRUR+NUDWLQDP)RUVHWRYSULPHUOHSRSRNDĤHWRGDVRGR ORÍHQHPHWDIRUHUD]XPOMHQHNRWHQDNRYUHGQHWHORYHVROMHPLNURLQPDNURNR]PRVLQGDMHRGYLVQRRGDYWRUMD LQSXEOLNHNLMLSLďHNDWHURERL]EUDO Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 16 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 MH RGQRV PHG RUJDQL SURSRUFLRQDOHQ YVL VR VLFHU QXMQL D QLVR HQDNR SRPHPEQL SUR SRUFL 'DO\ 2E WHOHVQL PHWDIRUL )RUVHW SULNDĤH NUDOMD NRW }SROLWLFDO SK\V icianm NDU VH QDQDďD SUHGYVHP QD LQWHUSUHWDFLMR ]DNRQRY 3D YHQGDU MH ODKNR WXGL NUDOMR]LURPD]GUDYQLNSRY]URÍLWHOMEROH]QL"-HWRUHMEROQLNODKNRKNUDWLWXGL]GUDYQLN" )RUVHWVLFHUSUHGYLGL]DNRQHNRW]GUDYLOREROH]QLDWLVRSRGQDG]RURPSROLWLÍQHJD ]GUDYQLND6DPMHVLFHUPQHQMDGDVR}EROH]QLJODYHSRVOHGLFDEROH]HQVNLKVWDQMWHOHVDm 6ÅOÅYÅVWUX D YHQGDU VH ]GL GD PX QH XVSH GRVOHGQR PLVOLWL SUREOHPRY YODGDUVNLKSUHJUHK3UL)RUVHWRYHPGHOXJUH]DOHJLWLPDFLMRDEVROXWQHJDYODGDUMD%HVHGLOR SDNDĤHQDQHNSUHPLNYDQJOHďNLSROLWLÍQLPLVOLRGNRQFHSWDSULNDWHUHPMHELORSUDYR RGYLVQRRGSULYROLWYHSRGUHMHQLKNUDOMXNDU]D]QDPXMHSRMHP.LQJLQ3DUOLDPHQWNEROM DEVROXWLVWLÍQHPXNRQFHSWXSULNDWHUHPNUDOMODKNR]DNRQHVSUHPLQMDSRVYRMLODVWQLYROML .UDOMPRUDWRUHMSRVWDWLSROLWLÍQL]GUDYQLNNRWMHWR]DÍUWDOWXGL)RUVHWR]LUR PDNRWVHMHYSUDďDO(UD]HP5RWWHUGDPVNL}.DMMHYODGDUGUXJHJDNRW]GUDYQLNGUĤDYH"m (UDVPXV1DWHPPHVWXYHOMDSUHGVWDYLWLWH]RGDMHSUHPLNRGWHOHVQLKPHWD IRUNPHWDIRUDPEROH]QLUH]XOWDWGHEDWHRWHPNDNďQDQDMELELODYORJDNUDOMD3RWUHEQR MHQDPUHÍL]QDMWLGREHU}UHJLPHQRIKHDOWKmNDUSRJRMXMHGRORÍHQQDÍLQĤLYOMHQMDGUĤDYH .UDOMPRUDELWL]PRĤHQGLDJQRVWLFLUDWLSRORĤDMWHUVSRPRÍMRPHWRGSROLWLÍQHSURJQRVWL NHQDSRYHGDWL}]GUDYMHmGUĤDYH-HDQ%RGLQMHSRVNXďDOXWHPHOMLWLDSOLNDWLYQRSROLWLÍQR ]QDQRVWNLMRMH]D]QDPRYDOREUDWNWUDGLFLMLQDUDYQH]JRGRYLQHLQPHGLFLQH3RQMHJR YHPPQHQMXPRUDNUDOMWDNRNRW]GUDYQLNQDWDQÍQRRSD]RYDWLVWDQMHSR]QDWL]JRGRYLQR LQEHOHĤLWLL]NXďQMHÍHĤHOLXVSHďQRYODGDWLȡPRGURVWQLGHGQDDPSDNVHMHMHSRWUHEQR SULXÍLWL3ULWHPSDMHSRWUHEQRELWLSR]RUHQVDM}WDNRNRWVRPD]DÍLY]GUDYVWYXVRWXGL PD]DÍLYGUĤDYQLďWYXWRVROMXGMHNLVHORWHYDMRYHOLNLKSRVHJRYLQVRLPHOLPRUGDVUHÍ QRURNRYGYHKDOLWUHKSRVNXVLK.HUSDMLPPDQMND]QDQVWYHQHJDWHPHOMDQHPRUHMR Y]WUDMDWLm%DFRQȡ HARVEY :LOOLDP+DUYH\MHELOHGHQL]PHGQDMSRPHPEQHMďLKQRYRYHďNLKUHIRUPDWRUMHY PHGLFLQHVDMMHOHWDYGHOX'HPRWXFRUGLVNLJDMHSRVYHWLO.DUOX, SUHGVWDYLO RGNULWMHNUYQHJDREWRND9SUHGJRYRUXGHODMH]DSLVDOGDMHVUFHRVQRYDĤLYOMHQMDELWMD SUYLPHGYVHPLVRQFHPLNURNR]PRVDRGNDWHUHJDMHRGYLVQDYVDYHJHWDFLMDL]NDWHUHJD L]YLUDYVD]DJQDQRVWLQPRÍ.RWMHNUDOMXWHPHOMLWHOMNUDOMHVWYDLQVRQFHVYRMHJDPLNUR %RGLQMHWDNRSULSLVDQMXVYRMLKSROLWLÍQLKGHOXSRďWHYDO+LSRNUDWRYDLQ*DOHQRYDGHODVYRMSURMHNW SDMHUD]XPHONRWWHUDSLMRGUXĤEHQHJDR]LURPDSROLWLÍQHJDWHOHVD3RGREHQSURMHNWMHQDÍUWRYDO/D)UDPERLVLHUH z delom Tempelj medicineȡSRQMHJRYHPPQHQMXPRUDNUDOMSR]QDWLDQDWRPLMRVRFLDOQHJDWHOHVDNLMHPHďDQLFD QDUDYQHʳOR]RʳMHPHGLFLQHVYRERGQLKXPHWQRVWLLQSROLWLNH6ROO 2SR]RULWLYHOMDWXGLGD+DUYH\MHYRRGNULWMHNURĤHQMDNUYLQLELORWDNRMVSUHMHWRSDULďNDXQLYHU]DJD MHWDNRSRWUGLODďHOHYHÍNRWSROVWROHWMDSRRGNULWMX+LOO Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 17 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 NR]PRVDMHVUFHVUHGLďÍHVYRMHJDNUDOMHVWYDFRPPRQZHDOWKL]NDWHUHJDL]KDMDWDYVD QMHJRYDPLORVWLQPRÍ+DUYH\YODGDUMXVYHWXMHďWXGLMVUFDVDMMHLPDWRYVHELERĤDQVNR SRGREQRVW]QMHJRYLPLNUDOMHYLPLGHMDQMLVUFHSDMH}RVQRYQLSULQFLSÍORYHNRYHJDWHOH VDLQSRGREDNUDOMHYHPRÍLm+LOOÌHYWHPEHVHGLOXďHODKNR]D]QDPRKLHUDUKL MRGRORÍHQHJDGHODWHOHVDVUFHNL]DVHGDSUHVWROSRGREQRNRWWRSRÍQHVRQFHYNRSHUQL NDQVNL]DVQRYLNR]PRVDSD+DUYH\SR]QHMHWRKLHUDUKLMRRSXVWLYSULGLGHMLGDNULSRUDMD YVH1HJUHWRUHMYHÍ]DVXYHUHQRVWVUFDDPSDN]D}SUDYLFRLQVWDURVWNUYLmNLSRVWDQH SRJODYLWHQHOHPHQWYFHORWQHPVLVWHPX9HÍQRVWNUYLQLNROLQHL]JLQH}VDMNUYLQLNROLQH ]PDQMNDm3UDYWDP3RVOHGLÍQRSULGHWXGLGRSUHPHQHSROLWLÍQHJDUD]XPHYDQMD NUYLQLPRĤQRXPHVWLWLYNRQFHSWDEVROXWLVWLÍQHPRQDUKLMHVUFHSDVHVSUHPHQLY]JROM ÍUSDONRNLSRWLVNDNULSRWHOHVX6YRMHPQHQMHMHVSUHPHQLOPHGOHWRPDLQ WDNUDWL]LGHWDGHOL'HFLUFXODWLRQHVDQJXLQLVLQ'HJHQHUDWLRQHDQLPDOLXPL]GDMDREHK GHOSDMHVRYSDGOD]DQJOHďNRGUĤDYOMDQVNRYRMQRSRGYSOLYRPNDWHUHMHPRJRÍHSULODJR GLOVYRMHUD]XPHYDQMH2ESULPHUMDYL,VDDFD1HZWRQDLQ+DUYH\MDDQJOHďNL]JRGRYLQDU &KULVWRSKHU+LOOWUGLGDODKNRʳ]LNRSUYHJDSULPHUMDPR]PRQDUKLMRNLMRRPHMXMH]DNRQ PHGWHPNRSRWHJQHDQDORJLMRPHG+DUYH\MHYRDQDWRPLMRLQSDUODPHQWDUQRPRQDUKLMR METAFORE TELESA IZVEN EVROPE 'DSDVHSULÍXMRÍLÍODQHNQHELRPHMLOL]NOMXÍQRQDSURVWRU(YURSHLQGDQHEL YHUMHOL SUHGVWDYL GD VR WHOHVQH PHWDIRUH SURL]YRG ]JROM HYURSVNHJD SURVWRUD ERPR Y REUDYQDYRSULWHJQLOLWXGLMDSRQVNHSULPHUH 1 7DPMHďOR]DVSHFLʳÍQRPHďDQMHHYURSVNH PHGLFLQHVSUHGKRGQLPLNRQFHSWLWUDGLFLRQDOQHNLWDMVNHNRQIXFLMDQVNHPHGLFLQH.RQ IXFLMDQVNLʳOR]RILQ]GUDYQLN.DLEDUD(NLNHQȡMHL]HQDÍLOPRĤJDQH]YODGDU MHPPHGWHPNRMHWHORUD]XPHONRWYODGDUMHYHSRGORĤQLNH-DSRQVNLPLVOHFLVRRVWDOLSUL VSORďQHMďLKWHOHVQLKPHWDIRUDKJODYDURNHVDMSUHGVUHGLQRVWROHWMHVHFLUDQMHWHOHV ďHQLELORL]YDMDQR]DWRWXGLQLPHWDIRUNLELYNOMXÍHYDOHQRWUDQMHRUJDQH3RJRVWHMďH VRELOHQSUPHWDIRUHR]GUDYOMHQMX7VXQHWRPRMHSRXGDUMDOSUHGYVHPSRPHQSUHYHQ WLYHVDMQLYHUMHOGDODKNRPHGLFLQDXVSHďQRSR]GUDYLEROH]QLVÍLPHUMHEOL]X*DOHQR YHPXUD]XPHYDQMXYORJH]GUDYQLND3RQMHJRYHPPQHQMXPHGLFLQHQHELSRWUHERYDOL ]DGRVWRYDODQDMELĤHGQHYQDVNUE]DRKUDQMDQMHGREUHJDSRÍXWMD6KRJLPHQ 2 1DWHPPHVWXVHďHHQNUDWYUQLPRNSUHMRPHQMHQHPX.DLEDUX(NLNHQX}9OD GDUMHYD]DYUQLWHYGDSRVOXďDSRGORĤQLNRYRVYDULORMHSULPHUOMLYD]EROQLNRYRY]WUDMQR 7DRGVWDYHNWHPHOMLQDGHOX6KRJLPHQ2EVWDMDMRďWHYLOQLQHHYURSVNLSULPHULDUDEVNLʳOR]RI $OIDUDELMHSULPHUMDO]GUDYQLNDLQNUDOMDPHGWHPNRMHLQGLMVNLʳOR]RI6XNXUDSULPHUMDOGHOHGUĤDYH] GHOLWHOHVD93HVPLR3XUXďLYLQGLMVNL Rgvedi MHXWHPHOMHQDGHOLWHYQDNDVWHSUHNRGHORYWHOHVD.LWDMVNLPHGL FLQVNLSULURÍQLN Huangdi Neijing SDMHNUDOMDSULPHUMDOVVUFHP3UDYWDP2SD]QRMHGDMHPRÍWHMPHWDIRUL VOHGLWLYVNRUDMYVHKNXOWXUDK 'YRPDOLODKNR]GUDYQLNYVHQDG]RUXMHLQDOLREVWDMDMR]GUDYLODWXGL]DGROJRWUDMQHEROH]QLMHL]UD ]LOďHHQ]GUDYQLN6RUDLNLMHSULPHUMDORPHMHQRVW]GUDYQLNRY]RPHMHQRVWMRSROLWLNHSULUHďHYDQMXNRQʴLNWRY 3UDYWDP Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 18 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 ]DYUQLWYLMR]GUDYLONLELYRGLODYVPUWm3UDYWDP9REGREMX7RNXJDZDVRVHPH WDIRUH]GUDYOMHQMDEROMUD]YLOHNDUJUHPRJRÍHSULSLVDWLSUHSOHWXHYURSVNHPHGLFLQVNH YHGQRVWLVVWDUHMďLPLSUDNVDPLYWHPREGREMX ZAKLJUČEK 9UQLPRVHNYSUDďDQMXNLMHELORL]WRÍQLFDWHJDEHVHGLODNGDMVHWRUHMDYWRUML ]DWHNDMRNXSRUDELWHPHWDIRUH"3RHQLVWUDQLELODKNRGHMDOLGDSUHGYVHPYNUL]QLKVWDQ MLKVDMMHELORWHORSRJRVWRSRVOHGQMLEUDQLN}VWDUHJDmXYHOMDYOMHQHJDUHGD3DYHQGDU JUH]DHQRL]PHGQDMEROMREÍLKPHVWNLMLKMHELORPRJRÍHXSRUDELWLYYVHVPHUL.WHPX MH]DJRWRYRSULSRPRJODL]NXďQMDWHOHVDNLMRLPDSRVDPH]QLNSDWXGLPRĤQDYNOMXÍLWHY Y YHOLNR YHULJR ELYDMRÍHJD VWROHWMH SULQHVH SUHPLN RG PHWDIRUH WHOHVD Y SROLWLNL N PHWDIRULVWURMDXUHNDUVOHGLďLUďHPXREUDWXNPHKDQLFLVWLÍQLUD]ODJLVYHWDNL]DPHQMD RUJDQLVWLÍQRUD]XPHYDQMHJOHM6WROOEHUJ5LOLQJHUÌHSUDYMHYEHVHGLOXSULND]DQ RPHMHQ L]ERU SULPHURY ODKNR L] Y]RUFD SRWHJQHPR QHNDWHUH ]DNOMXÍNH ,GHRORďND DOL YHUVND SULSDGQRVW SUL XSRUDEL PHWDIRUH WHOHVD DOL EROH]QL QLVWD LJUDOL SUHWLUDQH YORJH SUHGYVHP ]DUDGL XQLYHU]DOQRVWL WHOHVD =DWR MR ODKNR QDMGHPR PHG ]DJRYRUQLNL WDNR GHPRNUDFLMHNRWWXGLDEVROXWLVWLÍQHXUHGLWYHWDNRPHGSURWHVWDQWLNRWNDWROLNLWDNR Y(YURSLNRW]XQDMQMH0DUVLNGRVHMH]RVQRYDPLWHOHVDVUHÍDOYVDMSUL$ULVWRWHOXÍHĤH QHYNDWHULL]PHGďWHYLOQLKPHGLFLQVNLKNQMLJLQUD]OLÍQLKSULURÍQLNRYNLVRVHUD]ďLULOL V SRMDYRP WLVND 7R ]QDQMH SD YHÍLQRPD QL SUHVHJDOR RVQRY NDU QDP ODKNR XSUDYLÍL ]DNDM MH PHWDIRU WHOHVD YHOLNR LQ WXGL ]DNDM VR XSRUDEOMHQH UD]PHURPD VWHUHRWLSQR 5HGNHVRQDPUHÍORÍLWYHQDĤHQVNRLQPRďNRWHORSUDYWDNRMHUHGNR]D]QDWLORÍLWHYPHG ]GUDYQLNRPLQNLUXUJRPUHGNLVRWXGLSUHQRVLVRGREQHMďLKPHGLFLQVNLKGRJQDQMQSU NUYQHJDREWRND .RWVPRSRND]DOLYXYRGXLQVSULPHULMH]GUDYRHQDNRWLVWHPXNDUMHQDUDYQR PRUDOQRLQWRUHMERJXYďHÍQREROH]HQSDMHSUHNRUDÍLWHY]GUDYHPHUHLQ]DQHPDUMDQMH WHOHVDÌHSUDYMHWHORQDUDYQDGDQRVWWRQHSRPHQLGDJDQLPRJRÍHVSUHPHQLWLR]LURPD SRSUDYLWL$YVHHQRVHMHWHĤNRVSULMD]QLWLVSURWHWLÍQLPNRQVWUXLUDQLPWHOHVRP9HÍNUDW Y PHWDIRUDK ODKNR UD]EHUHPR ]DJRYDUMDQMH SUDYLOQLK QRUPDOQLK WHOHV NL MH SUHSURVWR RGYLVQRRGQDďHVNUEL]DWHORLQSULSUDYOMHQRVWLSUHSR]QDWLEROH]QLWHUERULWLVH]QML PL7HOHVQHPHWDIRUHVHSRMDYOMDMRWXGLYGDQDďQMLSROLWLÍQLDWXGLďLUďLPLVOLÌHODKNR PHWDIRUHRWHOHVXLQWHOHVQLKRUJDQLKR]QDÍLPRNRWPUWYHPHWDIRUH WXPLVOLPQSUQD URNRSUDYLFHGUĤDYQLRUJDQL SDVRPHWDIRUHNLVHXNYDUMDMR]EROH]QLPLďHNDNRĤLYH 0UWYHPHWDIRUHVRWLVWHNLVR]DUDGLREVHĤQHSRQDYOMDMRÍHVHXSRUDEHL]JXELOHVYRMRPRÍ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 19 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 7DWUDGLFLMDPHWDIRUHNLMLODKNRVOHGLPRSUHGYVHPRG]JRGQMHJDQRYHJDYHND QDSUHMVHMHRNUHSLODYLQVWROHWMXWXGL]XYDMDQMHPSROLWLÍQLKLQYRMDďNLKPHWDIRU YELRORJLMLLQQMHMVRURGQLKYHGDKWHUSUHGYVHP]QDVWDQNRPPLNURELRORJLMH6ďLULWYLMR PHGLFLQVNHYHGQRVWLVRWXGLPHWDIRUHSRVWDOHYHGQREROMVRʳVWLFLUDQH.DMEROMVLPEROL ]LUDGDQDďQMLÍDVNRWVWUDKSUHGLQYD]LMDPLRNXĤEDPLQHYLGQLKPLNURERY"3RYVRGRNROL QDVVRYLUXVLNLSRY]URÍDMRVSUHPHPEHLQPXWDFLMHNLRJURĤDMRQDďL]YLUQLLPXQVNLVLV WHP0HGLFLQVNHPHWDIRUHVRďHSRVHEHMYVWRSLOHYHNRQRPVNRPLVHOVDMWXGLSRMHPNUL]H YRVQRYLL]KDMDL]PHGLFLQVNHJDEHVHGLďÍD1%ROH]HQ MHďHYHGQRUD]XPOMHQDNRWSUHKRG YQHNRGUXJRVWDQMHLGHQWLWHWRQSUDLGVďHYHGQRMHSULVRWHQJRYRUREROQLKLGHMDK LQ]GUDYLSDPHWLNXJDSDMHHQDL]PHGEROH]QLNLďHYHGQRRJURĤDQDďHWHOR7RYUVWHQ GLVNXU]L]EUXKQHQDSODQREYVHKVLWXDFLMDKSDQDMERJRYRUDRHSLGHPLMDKPLJUDQWLK SROLWLÍQLKPUWYHFLKDOLEROH]QLKGUXĤEH9ÍDVLKVH]GLGDLPDPRVVUHGQMLPLQQRYLP YHNRPYHÍVNXSQHJDNRWVLĤHOLPRSUL]QDWL 1DERUMHďWHYLOHQJRVSRGDUVWYRMHEROQLNNLPXODKNRSRPDJD]JROMďRNWHUDSLMDSRGMHWMHMHNRW ÍORYHďNRWHORNLVHUD]YLMDSULODJDMD]DWRMHSRWUHEQRXJRWRYLWLXWULSSRGMHWMD9DQJOHďÍLQLVHXSRUDEOMDWXGL izraz spin-doctor. 20 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 20 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 BIBLIOGRAFIJA $ULVWRWHO3ROLWLND/MXEOMDQD*9=DORĤED $ULVWRWHO5HWRULND/MXEOMDQDĎRODUHWRULNH=XSDQÍLÍ =XSDQÍLÍ %DFRQ)UDQFLV(VHMLDOL3ROLWLÍQLLQPRUDOQLQDVYHWL/MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD %ODFN$QWRQ\3ROLWLFDOWKRXJKWLQ(XURSH&DPEULGJH&83 %ODFN0D[0HWDIRUDY.DMMHPHWDIRUD"ȡ/MXEOMDQD.UWLQD %ORFK0DUF5R\DO7RXFK6DFUHG0RQDUFK\DQG6FURIXODLQ(QJODQGDQG)UDQFH /RQGRQ5RXWOHGJH .HJDQ3DXO &KDUWLHU5RJHU3LVDQMHLQEULVDQMHSLVQDNXOWXUDLQOLWHUDWXUDRGGR VWROHWMD/MXEOMDQD6WXGLDKXPDQLWDWLV &KDUWLHU5RJHU5HGNQMLJEUDOFLDYWRUMLLQNQMLĤQLFHY(YURSLPHGLQ 6WROHWMHP/MXEOMDQD6RSKLD &XUWLXV(UQVW5REHUW(YURSVNDOLWHUDWXUDLQODWLQVNLVUHGQMLYHN/MXEOMDQD/8' /LWHUDWXUD 'DO\-DPHV&RVPLF+DUPRQ\DQG3ROLWLFDO7KLQNLQJLQ(DUO\6WXDUW(QJODQGY 7UDQVDFWLRQVRIWKH$PHULFDQ3KLORVRSKLFDO6RFLHW\YROȡ 'DUQWRQ5REHUW9HOLNLSRNROPDÍNLQGUXJHHSL]RGHIUDQFRVNHNXOWXUQH ]JRGRYLQH/MXEOMDQD6WXGLDKXPDQLWDWLV 'XE\*HRUJHV7ULMHUHGLDOLLPDJLQDULMIHYGDOL]PD/MXEOMDQD6WXGLD KXPDQLWDWLV (OPHU3HWHU7KH0LUDFXORXV&RQIRUPLVW9DOHQWLQH*UHDWUDNHVWKH%RG\3ROLWLF DQGWKH3ROLWLFVRI+HDOLQJLQ5HVWRUDWLRQ%ULWDLQ2[IRUG283 (UDVPXV'HVLGHULXV(UDVPXV7KH(GXFDWLRQRID&KULVWLDQ3ULQFHZLWKWKH 3DQHJ\ULFIRU$UFKGXNH3KLOLSRI$XVWULD&DPEULGJH&83 )DMDUGR'LHJRGH6DDYHGUD$EULVV(LQHV&KULVWOLFKSROLWLVFKHQ3ULQW]HQV,Q&, $QPXWKLJHQ6LQQELOGHUQ.¸OQ1DEX3UHVV +HOPHUV+HOPHU,OOQHVVDV0HWDSKRU7KH6LFN%RG\3ROLWLFDQG,WV&XUHVY ,OOQHVVDQG/LWHUDWXUHLQWKH/RZ&RXQWULHVIURPWKH0LGGOH$JHVXQWLOWKHVWFHQWX U\ȡ*¸WWLQJHQ 9 58QLSUHVV +LOO&KULVWRSKHU:LOOLDP+DUYH\DQGWKH,GHDRI0RQDUFK\Y3DVW 3UHVHQW YROȡ -DNRYDF*DďSHU.DU%RJ]DKWHYDWRQDMNUDOMXNUHQHLGHRORJLMDDEVROXWL]PDY 6KDNHVSHDURYLWULORJLML+HQULN9,/MXEOMDQD/8'/LWHUDWXUD .URXSD*UHJRU3RGREQRYQHSRGREQHPRPHWDIRULYQRYRYHďNLʳOR]RʳML /MXEOMDQD6WXGLDKXPDQLWDWLV 21 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 21 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 /XWKHU0.UďÍDQVNHPXSOHPVWYXQHPďNHJDURGXRL]EROMďDQMXNUďÍDQVNLK UD]PHUY,VWL7XVWRMLPȡ/MXEOMDQD.UWLQD 0DUDYDOO-RVH$QWRQLR&XOWXUHRIWKH%DURTXH$QDO\VLVRID+LVWRULFDO 6WUXFWXUH0LQQHDSROLV8QLYHUVLW\RI0LQQHVRWD3UHVV 3HLO'LHWPDU8QWHUVXFKXQJHQ]XU6WDDWVXQG+HUUVFKDIWVPHWDSKRULNLQOLWHUD ULVFKHQ=HXJQLVVHQYRQGHU$QWLNHELV]XU*HJHQZDUW0¾QFKHQ:LOKHOP)LQN9HUODJ 3HO]KRIIHU)UDQ]$OEHUW1HXHQWGHFNWH6WDDWV.OXJKHLWLQ+XQGHUWSROLWLVFKHQ 5HGHQRGHU'LVFXUVHQ)UDQFNIXUW$GROSK 6ÅOÅYÅVWUX$QGUHL&RQVWDQWLQ7KHERG\SROLWLFDQGȦSROLWLFDOPHGLFLQHȧLQWKH -DFREHDQSHULRG(GZDUG)RUVHWȤV$&RPSDUDWLYH'LVFRXUVHRIWKH%RGLHV1DWXUDODQG 3ROLWLTXHY,QWHOOHFWXDO+LVWRU\5HYLHZYRO 6DUDVLQ3KLOLSS,Qʳ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ȡ 6WROOEHUJ5LOLQJHU%DUEDUD'HU6WDDWDOV0DVFKLQH]XUSROLWLVFKHQ0HWDSKRULN GHVDEVROXWHQ)¾UVWHQVWDDWHV%HUOLQ'XQFNHU +XPEORW 6WURKPD\HU$UQR6YRERGDSROLWLNHLQPRÍYHUHďWXGLMHRSROLWLÍQLNXOWXULGHĤHO QLKVWDQRYKDEVEXUďNHPRQDUKLMHYÍDVXYHUVNLKYRMQRNȡRN/MXEOMDQD FI 6YHWRSLVPR/MXEOMDQD'UXďWYR6YHWRSLVHPVNDGUXĤED6ORYHQLMH 7XFN5LFKDUG3KLORVRSK\DQGJRYHUQPHQWȡ&DPEULGJH&83 9LJQMHYLÉ7RPLVODY7ULMHUHGRYLVYHWD/MXEOMDQD.UWLQD :KRUI%HQMDPLQ/HH/DQJXDJHWKRXJKWDQGUHDOLW\VHOHFWHGZULWLQJVRI %HQMDPLQ/HH:KRUI%RVWRQ0,73UHVV =DYDGLO-HIIHU\%RGLHV3ROLWLFDQG%RGLHV&RVPLF7KH5RPDQ6WRLF 7KHRU\RIWKHȣ7ZR&LWLHVȤY0HWDSKRUDQG'LVFRXUVH%DVLQJVWRNH3DOJUDYH 0DFPLOODQ =HGHOPDLHU+HOPXW:HUNVW¦WWHQGHV:LVVHQV]ZLVFKHQ5HQDLVVDQFHXQG $XINO¦UXQJ7¾ELQJHQ0RKU6LHEHFN 22 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 22 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 POMEN MATERIJE V ENGELSOVI DIALEKTIKI NARAVE Nejc Kralj UVOD 'LDOHNWLÍQLPDWHULDOL]HPMHVLQWDJPDQDELWD]UD]QRYUVWQLPLSRPHQL3RHQL VWUDQLODKNRSUHGVWDYOMDRVUHGQMRPDUNVLVWLÍQRGRNWULQRNLMHVWDURLGHDOLVWLÍQRPHWDʳ ]LNRREUQLOD]JODYHQDQRJHPDUNVL]PXGDODXVWUH]QR]QDQVWYHQRLQʳOR]RIVNRSRGODJR ter konstruirala enoten Weltanschauung ]DSRWUHEHVRFLDOLVWLÍQHWHRULMH3RGUXJLVWUDQL SDODKNRSRPHQLQDWXUDOL]DFLMRGLDOHNWLNHVNUXQLWHYL]YRUQH0DU[RYHPLVOLLQSULÍHWHN GRJPDWL]PDNLQDMELSUHSUHGDOXUDGQRVRYMHWVNRʳOR]RʳMRRG/HQLQDGDOMH )ULHGULFK(QJHOVVHY]JRGRYLQL]DKRGQHJDPDUNVL]PDSRJRVWRSULND]XMHNRW SUHFHM SUREOHPDWLÍQD ʳJXUD NL QDM EL VNYDULOD DYWHQWLÍQR PLVHO YHOLNHJD .DUOD 0DU[D (QJHOVMHYREUDYQDYDKNLPXQLVRQDNORQMHQHSULND]DQQDUD]OLÍQHSRJRVWRQHNRPSD WLELOQHDOLFHORSURWLVORYQHQDÍLQHMHYXOJDUQLSR]LWLYLVWDOLQDLYHQKHJORYHFWLVWLNLQL UD]XPHO+HJORYHGLDOHNWLNHDOL0DU[RYHJDNDSLWDODȡVOHGQMHMHPHGGUXJLPSRY]URÍLOR GDVHMHGREHUPDUNVL]HPVSUHOHYLOYVODEHQJHOVL]HPRGNDWHUHJDPDQMNDOHďHVWRSQLÍND do Stalinovega diamata.DQJDOȡ*UHVHYHGD]DREWRĤEHNLVRSRYHÍLQLĤH VDPHNRQWUDGLNWRUQHNDUSDQHSRPHQLGDYÍDVLKQLVRUHVQLÍQH(QJHOVRYLQ0DU[RY RSXVMHREVHĤHQLQVDP(QJHOVMHWHNRPVYRMHJDĤLYOMHQMDYHÍNUDWVSUHPHQLOVYRMDVWD OLďÍD *ODYQDREWRĤEDSURWL(QJHOVXVHVLFHUJODVLGDMHSRWYRULODYWHQWLÍQRPLVHOYH OLNHJD.DUOD0DU[DLQYPDUNVL]HPYVLOLOHOHPHQWHNLVRELOLVOHGQMHPXWXML*ODYQLWXMHN QDMELELOUDYQRGLDOHNWLNDQDUDYHNLQDMELSRPHQLODUHLʳNDFLMRPDUNVLVWLÍQHWHRULMHNRW ʳOR]RʳMHSUDNVH.DQJDO'RND]RYGD0DU[QHELRGREUDYDO(QJHOVRYHJDGHOD SUDY]DSUDYQLNDUGRND]XMHWXGLRVHEQDNRUHVSRQGHQFDREHKDYWRUMHY.DQJDOȡ 0DU[MHQDYVH]DGQMHVSLVDOWXGLHQRSRJODYMH Anti-Dühringa YNDWHUHP(QJHOVVLFHU REďLUQRREUDYQDYDUDYQRWLVWRGLDOHNWLNRNLQDMQHELELODVNODGQD]0DU[RYRPLVOLMR6SRU RVWDWXVX(QJHOVRYHʳOR]RʳMHQDMELVLFHUYYHOLNLPHUL]DNULYLO*HRUJ/¼NDFVY Zgodovini in razredni zavesti NR(QJHOVRYSRVNXVDSOLNDFLMHGLDOHNWLNHQDQDUDYRPLPRJUHGHR]QDÍL ]DQDSDNR 1 1 }.OMXÍQRMHUD]XPHWLGDMHWXXSRUDEOMHQDPHWRGDRPHMHQDQDREPRÍML]JRGRYLQHLQGUXĤEH1H VSRUD]XPRPNLL]YLUDMRL](QJHOVRYHJDRSLVDGLDOHNWLNHODKNRSRYHÍLQL]YHGHPRQDGHMVWYRGD(QJHOVȡVOHGHÍ +HJORYL]PRWLȡPHWRGRUD]ďLULWXGLQDYHGQRVWRQDUDYL7RGDJODYQDGRORÍLODGLDOHNWLNHȡLQWHUDNFLMDPHG VXEMHNWRPLQREMHNWRPHQRWQRVWWHRULMHLQSUDNVHUHDOQH]JRGRYLQVNHVSUHPHPEHNRWJODYQLY]URNLVSUHPHPE YPLVOLLWGȡVRRGVRWQHL]QDďHYHGQRVWRQDUDYLm/¼NDFVRS Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 23 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 .ULWLND(QJHOVRYHGLDOHNWLNHYQDUDYLVHQDWRQDGDOMXMHYWUDGLFLML}]DKRGQHJD PDUNVL]PDmNLVYRMRNULWLNR(QJHOVDUD]XPHNRWNULWLNRVRYMHWVNHJDPDUNVL]PD0HUOH DX3RQW\YGHOXNLVNXMHNRQFHSW}]DKRGQHJDPDUNVL]PDmWDNRWUGLGDVH}PDUNVLVWLÍQD RUWRGRNVLMDȬ]DGRYROMLVWHPGDSRVWDYOMDUHÍLLQUD]PHUMDPHGOMXGPLQDLVWRUDYHQ WHUYGLDOHNWLNRGRGDQHNDMQDWXUDOL]PDNLÍHSUDYJUH]D]PHUQRNROLÍLQRGLDOHNWLNRSUL SULÍLUD]ELMHLQMRSRVWDYLQDPHVWRNMHUMHďHQDMPDQMGRPDÍDQDPUHÍYREMHNWYELWm 0HUOHDX3RQW\ 2 ÌHSUDY VR QHNDWHUL ʳOR]RIVNL SRPLVOHNL SURWL GLDOHNWLNL QDUDYH XWHPHOMHQL MH YUHGQRSRXGDULWLGDLPDGHEDWDRÍLWQHSROLWLÍQHNRQRWDFLMH=DKRGQLPDUNVL]HPVHMH SULPDUQR GLVWDQFLUDO RG XUDGQLK GRNWULQ 6RYMHWVNH ]YH]H REHQHP SD MH ĤHOHO RKUDQLWL YORJRSUDYHJDGHGLÍD]DÍHWQLNRYPDUNVL]PD=DWRMHPRUDOVYRMHODVWQHSR]LFLMHSURML FLUDWLQD]DMY0DU[DLQ(QJHOVDSULÍHPHUMHQHVNODGMDL]YRUQLKEHVHGLO]}GHMDQVNRGRN WULQRmSDÍPRUDOSULVRGLWLQHNHPXNULYFX7DNRVWDQDVWDODDYWHQWLÍQL0DU[LQYXOJDUQL (QJHOV .DQJDO 7RGD WXGL }VRYMHWVNL PDUNVL]HPm NL ďH ]GDOHÍ QL ELO HQRWQD VWUXNWXUDVHMHVRUD]PHUQRKLWURRGPDNQLORG(QJHOVRYHʳOR]RʳMHQDUDYHģHVDP/HQLQ MH UD]YLO VYRMR ODVWQR YHU]LMR GLDOHNWLÍQHJD PDWHULDOL]PD NL SRJRVWR EROM VSRPLQMD QD PDWHULDOL]HPVWROHWMDHQDJODYQLK/HQLQRYLKUHIHUHQFMHSUDY]DSUDY'LGHURW kot QDWHRULMR0DU[DLQ(QJHOVD 3ULÍXMRÍLÍODQHNERSRVNXďDOUD]YR]ODWLQHNDMNOMXÍQLKYSUDďDQMJOHGHL]YRURY GLDOHNWLÍQHJDPDWHULDOL]PDSUHGYVHP]R]LURPQDYORJRPDWHULMHLQWHOHVDYRNYLUX(Q JHOVRYLKSRVNXVRYL]JUDGQMHQRYHPDUNVLVWLÍQHʳOR]RʳMHNLMLKQDMGHPRYQMHJRYLQHGR NRQÍDQL]ELUNLIUDJPHQWRY Dialektika narave MATERIALIZEM =DNDMYVSORďQHPJUHSULPDWHULDOLVWLÍQLGLDOHNWLNL"6DPDEHVHGQD]YH]D]D MHPDGYDSRMPDȡSRMHPPDWHULMHLQSRMHPGLDOHNWLNH1DMSUHMVLSRJOHMPR(QJHOVRYR SRMPRYDQMHPDWHULMHNLQDMELOHĤDORYWHPHOMXPDWHULDOL]PD 0DWHULMD QL QLÍ GUXJHJD NRW WRWDOLWHWD PDWHULDOQLK UHÍL RG NDWHULK MH SRMHP DEVWUDKLUDQ LQ JLEDQMH NRW WDNR QLÍ GUXJHJD NRW WRWDOLWHWD YVHK ÍXWQR ]D]QDYQLK REOLN JLEDQMD EHVHGH NRW PDWHULMD LQ JLEDQMH QLVR QLÍ drugega kot RNUDMďDYH V NDWHULPL SRMPXMHPR PQRJH UD]OLÍQH ÍXWQR ]D ]QDYQH UHÍL QD SRGODJL QMLKRYLK VNXSQLK ]QDÍLOQRVWL (QJHOV 2 0HUOHDX3RQW\]DWDRGNORQYJODYQHPVLFHUNULYL/HQLQDÍHSUDYJDRSDĤDĤHSUL0DU[XLQ(QJHOVX &I/HQLQ 9HÍLQDIUDJPHQWRY Dialektike narave MHELODSUYLÍREMDYOMHQDďHOHOHWD&I.DQJDQ /HQLQMHWDNRPRUDOÍUSDWLL]GUXJLKYLURYPHGNDWHULPLMHYUHGQRRPHQLWLSUHGYVHP Anti-Dühringa Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 24 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 1DSUYLSRJOHGJUHYGDQLGHʳQLFLML]DWDYWRORJLMRPDWHULMDVRPDWHULDOQHUHÍL 7RGDVWYDULQLVRWDNRSUHSURVWHWRWDOLWHWDPDWHULDOQLKVWYDULELODKNRSRPHQLODWXGLGD YQDUDYLQLQREHQLK]XQDQMLKGXKRYQLKHOHPHQWRYVVYRMLPLODVWQLPLNDY]DOQRVWPL$WR ďHQHSRYHSUDYYHOLNRRPDWHULMLVDPL %LVWYHQRMHGD(QJHOVJRYRULRWRWDOLWHWLPDWHULDOQLKUHÍL1DPDWHULMRQHPR UHPRJOHGDWLNRWQDVXEVWUDWR]LURPDVXEVWDQFRNLMHĤHYHGQRSULVRWQDVDMJUH]DQHNR FHORWRNLSUHVHJDYVRWRVYRMLKGHORYLQMHODKNRUD]XPOMHQDOHVNR]LQMLKRYRPHGVHERM QRSRYH]DQRVW7RGDWRMHSUDY]DSUDYďHOHWUHEDSRND]DWLVDMQLNDNRUQLMDVQR]DNDMEL PDWHULMR R]LURPD PDWHULDOQH UHÍL SRMPRYDOL Y RNYLUX QHNH WRWDOLWHWH LQ QH QD SRGODJL UD]QLKPHKDQVNLKSRYH]DYÌHPXQHELPDWHULDOQHJDVYHWDNRQFLSLUDOLNRWVNXSHNPHQL ]XQDQMLKUHÍLLQGHMVWHYNLWDPHQRVWDYQRVR" 3UREOHP]GHMVWYLNRWGHMVWYLMHGDVRUD]XPOMHQDNRWQHNDMGRQDVLQGLIHUHQW QHJDNDUQDVÍDNDWDP]XQDMLQ]DNDUSRWUHEXMHPROHSUDYDRURGMDGDMLKUD]XPHPR ĎLENRVWWDNHJDHPSLUL]PD(QJHOVSRNDĤHYHQHPL]PHGIUDJPHQWRYL]GLDOHNWLNHQDUDYH NRďDOMLYRQDSDGDXJOHGQH]QDQVWYHQLNHPHGNDWHUHVSDGDWXGLQSU'DUZLQRYVRGHODYHF $OIUHG5XVVHO:DOODFHNLVRVHYVWDURVWLREUQLOLNQDMEROMSOHKNHPXVSLULWXDOL]PXSDQDM JUH]DUHOLJLR]QDL]NXVWYDDOLSUHXÍHYDQMHSRMDYOMDQMDGXKRYLQSRGREQLKELWLM(QJHOVRYD SRDQWDMHGDODKNRYRGVRWQRVWLNDNUďQHNROLWHRULMHGHMVWYDQDMGHPRYÍHPHUNROLQH JOHGHQDDEVXUGQRVWSUHGPHWD(PSLUL]HPLQVSLULWXDOL]HPVH]QDMGHWDY]HORQHQDYDGQL HQRWQRVWLNRSUYLQHPRUHRYUHÍLGUXJHJD)DOVLʳNDFLMDQHNDWHULKÍXGHĤHYMHOHSRWUGLWHY YVHK RVWDOLK (PSLUL]HP SUDYL (QJHOV VH WDNR SR VYRML QDUDYL VSUHYUDÍD Y VYRMHQDVSURWMH(QJHOVVWHRULMRNLQDMELSUHVHJODVWDWLÍQRVWLQLQGLIHUHQWQRVWGHMVWYD FLOMDQDQHNRPRÍQRPRGLʳFLUDQRKHJORYVWYR+HJHOUD]YUďÍDVWRSQMHVDPRUD]YRMDSRM PDRGQDMEROMNRQÍQLKIRUPPHKDQL]PDLQNHPL]PDNMHUJUHYJODYQHP]DPHGVHERMQD GRORÍDQMDPHGVHERMLQGLIHUHQWQLKREMHNWRYGRVDPRGRORÍDQMDLGHMHQDMSUHMNRWĤLYOMHQ MDLQNRQÍQRNRWDEVROXWQHLGHMH9VDNDVWRSQMDUD]ODJDVYRMSUHGPHWQDWRSDVH]DUDGL VYRMLK LQWHUQLK SURWLVORYLM ]DXVWDYL LQ SRNDĤH RQNUDM VHEH QD VWRSQMR NL WD SURWLVORYMD UD]UHďLLQSUHGPHWUD]ORĤLEROMHGRNOHUYDEVROXWQLLGHMLQH]DMDPHPRFHORWHNRWPHWRGH 0HWRGD VH QDMSUHM ODKNR NDĤH NRW JROL QDÍLQ VSR]QDYDQMD LQ GHMDQVNR LPD QDUDYR WDNďQHJD QDÍLQD 9HQGDU NRW PHWRGD QL OH QHND QD LQ ]D VHEH GRORÍHQD PRGDOQRVW ELWL WHPYHÍ MH NRW PRGDOQRVW VSR]QDYDQMD SRVWDYOMHQ NRWGRORÍHQVNR]LSRMHPLQNRWIRUPDNROLNRUMHIRUPDGXďDYVHREMHNWLYQRVWL LQLPDYVDVLFHUGRORÍHQDYVHELQDVYRMRUHVQLFRHGLQRYQMHMÌHSURWLPHWRGL SULY]DPHPR YVHELQR NRW GDQR LQ V VYRMVNR QDUDYR VWD Y WDNďQHP GRORÍLOX WDNR PHWRGD NDNRU ORJLÍQR QDVSORK ]JROM YQDQMD IRUPD +HJHO 5D]YRMSUL+HJOXYVSORďQHPSRWHNDRG]JROMSRWHQFLDOQHJDNGHMDQVNHPXQDM Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 25 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 SUHMMHQDUDYQLQDVHEMDNRWMHQSUPDMKHQRWURNQDVHELĤHÍORYHNDYHQGDUďHQLSUDYR UD]XPQRELWMH'DELRWURNSRVWDOSUDYRUD]XPQRELWMHPRUDSRVWDWLUD]XPQRELWMHWXGL ]DVHEH(QDNRYHOMDWXGL]DGXKDNLJD+HJHOUD]XPHNRWÍORYHďNRVNXSQRVW7DMHQDVHEL ĤHYHGQRVYRERGHQDPRUDSRVWDWLWRWXGL]DVHEHPRUDVHYHGHWLNRWVYRERGQHJD1MH JRYDSRWMHNURĤQDMHSRWRGVHEHYGUXJRLQVSR]QDQMHGDMHWXGLYGUXJHPSULVHEL3RW GXKDVHSR+HJOXUD]YLMDY]JRGRYLQLʳOR]RʳMDSDMHGRMHPDQMHWHJDUD]YRMD)LOR]RIVNR SRMPRYDQMHQD]JRGQHMďLKVWRSQMDK]JRGRYLQHQHERSRSROQRVDM]JRGRYLQVNDFHORWD ďH QL UHDOL]LUDQD =DUDGL QHUHDOL]LUDQRVWL ]JRGRYLQVNH FHORWH VH Y ]JRGRYLQL SRMDYOMDMR ʳOR]RIVNLSULQFLSL]RPHMHQRXSRUDEQRVWMR (QJHOV+HJOXQHVOHGLWDNRGDOHÍ=DQMMHNOMXÍQDSUHGYVHPWUDQVIRUPDFLMDUL JLGQH}PHWDʳ]LNHmNDWHUHREMHNWLVRVLPHGVHERM]XQDQMLYGLQDPLÍQR}GLDOHNWLNRm VNDWHURODKNRYQDUDYLX]UHPRLPDQHQWHQSULQFLSUD]YRMD6KHHKDQȡ*UH WRUHMSUHGYVHP]DQRWUDQMLUD]YRMVWYDULVDPH]DQMHQRVDPRJLEDQMHNLQDGRPHďÍDUL JLGQRVWDELOQRVW}UHÍLQDVHELm 7DNRWXGLPDWHULMDQLQHNDUHÍDOLSUHSURVWDSR]LWLYQRVW0DWHULMDMHQHVNRQÍQD YHQGDUQHYVPLVOXQHVNRQÍQHJDďWHYLODGHOFHYWHPYHÍYVYRMLODVWQLLPDQHQWQLSURWL VORYQRVWL]DUDGLNDWHUHQDVWRSDNRWSURFHV0DWHULMDNRWWRWDOLWHWDPDWHULDOQLKUHÍLRE VWRMLUDYQRNRWSURFHVSRVWDMDQMDPDWHULDOQLK UHÍLLQYWHPVPLVOXQDVWRSDNRWGHMDQVND QHVNRQÍQRVWVDMVRYQMHMRKUDQMHQDLQSUHVHĤHQDSURWLVORYMDYNDNUďQDVH]DSOHWHPR SULYVDNHPSRVNXVX]DPHMLWYHPDWHULDOQHJDVYHWDDOLQMHJRYLKUHJLM0DWHULDOQDQDUDYD SRVWDMDVNR]LVYRMRODVWQRSURGXNFLMRLQUHSURGXNFLMR 3R]QHMďHPDUNVLVWLÍQHLQWHUSUHWDFLMHSRMPDPDWHULMHVRďOHYQHNROLNRGUXJDÍQH VPHUL/HQLQMH]DJRYDUMDOL]UD]LWRUHDOLVWLÍHQSRMHPPDWHULMHLQWDNRY]WUDMQR]DWUMHYDO GDPDWHULMDR]QDÍXMHRGQDVQHRGYLVQRREVWRMHÍREMHNWLYQLVYHW }0DWHULMDMHʳOR]RIVNL SRMHPNLR]QDÍXMHREMHNWLYQRUHDOQRVWNLVHÍORYHNXGDMHVNR]LQMHJRYHÍXWHLQNLMRÍXWL RGVOLNXMHMRLQRGVHYDMRRQDSDREVWDMDQHRGYLVQRRGQMLKm ,]UD]DPHWDʳ]LNDLQGLDOHNWLNDVWDWXVLFHUXSRUDEOMHQDQDVLODSUREOHPDWLÍHQQDÍLQ(QJHOV]DWUMXMH GDKHJORYVNDGLDOHNWLNDVSUHYUDÍDPHWDʳ]LNR+HJORYLKSUHGKRGQLNRYYHQGDUSDWHGLVWLQNFLMHSUL+HJOXQH QDMGHPRSUDYWDNRODKNRQMHJRYSURMHNWYYHOLNLPHULUD]XPHPRUDYQRNRWPHWDʳ]LÍHQ(QJHOVRYL]UD]}PHWD ʳ]LÍHQmELďHQDMEROMHXVWUH]DOSUHGNDQWRYVNLPHWDʳ]LNL2EHQHPVDP+HJHOL]UD]DGLDOHNWLNDQHXSRUDEOMDWDNR REďLUQRNRWELWRODKNRPLVOLOLQDSRGODJLPDUNVLVWLÍQLKLQWHUSUHWDFLM.DQJDOSUHGODJDGDJUHSUL (QJHOVRYLWHUPLQRORJLMLYYHOLNLPHUL]DSROLWLÍQRRGORÍLWHYVDMVWDULWHUPLQLȡPHWDʳ]LNDVSHNXODFLMDLWGȡQLVR YHÍSULPHUQL]DRNYLUHUHYROXFLRQDUQHWHRULMH &I(QJHOV}1HVNRQÍQRVW je SURWLVORYMHLQMHSROQDSURWLVORYLMģHWRMHSURWLVORYMHGDELELOD QHVNRQÍQRVWVHVWDYOMHQDL]VDPLKNRQÍQRVWLLQYHQGDUMHWDNR2PHMHQRVWPDWHULDOQHJDVYHWDQDVQLÍPDQMQH YRGLYSURWLVORYMDNDNRUQMHJRYDQHRPHMHQRVWLQYVDNSRVNXVGDELRGSUDYLOLWDSURWLVORYMDQDVYRGLNDNRUVPR YLGHOLYďHKXMďDSURWLVORYMD5DYQR zato, ker je SURWLVORYMHMHQHVNRQÍQRVWQHVNRQÍHQYÍDVXLQSURVWRUXEUH] NRQFDUD]YLMDMRÍVHSURFHVÌHELRGSUDYLOLSURWLVORYMHELWRSRPHQLORNRQHFQHVNRQÍQRVWLm (QDNRVWDOLďÍHVHY Materializmu in empiriokiticizmu QHSUHVWDQRSRQDYOMD}(GLQLLQQHL]RJLEQL ]DNOMXÍHNNLJDL]WHJDODKNRSRYOHÍHPRȡGHGXNFLMDNLMRYVLL]YDMDPRQDYVDNGDQMLUDYQLLQNLMRPDWHULDOL]HP QDÍUWQRSRODJDYWHPHOMHVYRMHHSLVWHPRORJLMHȡMHGD]XQDMQDVLQQHRGYLVQRRGQDVREVWDMDMRREMHNWLVWYDUL WHOHVDLQGDVRQDďHSHUFHSFLMHVOLNH]XQDQMHJDVYHWDm/HQLQ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 26 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 /HQLQMHVHYHGDGHORYDOYQHNROLNRGUXJDÍQLKRNROLďÍLQDKNDNRU(QJHOVYÍDVX NLVRJD]D]QDPRYDOLYHOLNLQDSUHGNLLQNUL]DYʳ]LNLYRNYLUXNDWHUHVRVHSROHJ]QDQVWYH QLKRGNULWLMY]SRUHGQRUD]YLMDOHWXGLʳOR]RIVNHLQWHUSUHWDFLMHQDUDYRVORYMD0HGVOHGQ MLPLVRQDVWDMDOHWXGLQDLYQRLGHDOLVWLÍQHSUHGYVHPRNROL0DFKDLQ/HQLQMHSULPDU QRSRVNXďDOREUDQLWLPDWHULDOL]HPSUHGWRYUVWQLPLSRVHJLUD]QLKLGHDOLVWLÍQLKʳOR]RʳM 6KHHKDQ$OWKXVVHUSUDYWDNREUDQL/HQLQDÍHďGDMHSULSUDYLOSUYHRVQRYH]D SUDYRPDUNVLVWLÍQRʳOR]RʳMRLQ/HQLQRYUHDOL]HPKLSRVWD]LUDYʳOR]RIVNRGUĤRSRNDWHUL ʳOR]RʳMDQLPDREMHNWDSRVOHGLÍQRSDWXGLQH]JRGRYLQH$OWKXVVHU)LOR]RʳMD YHGQR]QRYDLQ]QRYDSRQDYOMDLVWHʳOR]RIVNHWH]HNLVRY]DGQMLLQVWDQFL]DWUMHYDQMH PDWHULDOL]PDSURWLLGHDOL]PX.OMXEWHPX RVWDMDGHMVWYRGD/HQLQWXSRVWDYOMDGUXJDÍ QRNRQFHSFLMRPDWHULMHNDNRU(QJHOV1MHQQDMEROMGRJPDWLÍQLL]UD]QDMGHPRSUL6WDOLQX 9 QDVSURWMX ] LGHDOL]PRP NL WUGL GD REVWRML UHDOQR VDPR QDďD ]DYHVW ELW SULURGD OH Y QDďL ]DYHVWL Y QDďLK REÍXWNLK SUHGVWDYDK SRMPLK L]KDMD PDUNVLVWLÍQL ʳOR]RIVNL PDWHULDOL]HP L] WHJD GD MH PDWHULMD SULURGD ELW REMHNWLYQDUHDOQRVWNLREVWRMLL]YHQ]DYHVWLLQQHRGYLVQRGRQMHGDMHPDWHULMD SUYRWQD]DNDMWDMHYLUREÍXWNRPSUHGVWDYDP]DYHVWL]DYHVWSDMHGUXJRWQD L]YHGHQD]DNDMWDMHRGUD]PDWHULMHRGUD]ELWLGDMHPLďOMHQMHSURGXNWPDWHULMH NL MH GRVHJOD Y VYRMHP UD]YRMX YLVRNR VWRSQMR GRYUďHQRVWL LQ VLFHU SURGXNW PRĤJDQRYPRĤJDQLSDVRRUJDQPLďOMHQMDGDWRUHMQLPRJRÍHORÍLWLPLďOMHQMD RG PDWHULMH ÍH QRÍHPR QDSUDYLWL JUREH QDSDNH 6WDOLQ 6WDOLQ/HQLQRYRUHʴHNVLMVNRHSLVWHPRORJLMRSRWHQFLUDGRWRÍNHNRVHGLDOHNWLÍ QLPDWHULDOL]HPSUHOHYLYPHKDQLFLVWLÍQRWHRULMRNMHUPDWHULMDQHSRVUHGQRGHWHUPLQLUD QDďHPLďOMHQMH3UL(QJHOVXVWDPLVHOLQPDWHULMDVLFHUVWUXNWXUQRLGHQWLÍQLYHQGDUPLďO MHQMHYVHOHMYVHEXMHWXGLPRPHQWGUXĤEHQHJDSRVUHGRYDQMD'DELUD]MDVQLOLWRUD]OLNRVL PRUDPRRJOHGDWLPDUNVLVWLÍQRSRMPRYDQMHGLDOHNWLNH DIALEKTIKA .RWVPRYLGHOLMHELVWYRPDWHULMHYQMHQHPVDPRSRUDMDQMXNLJD(QJHOVSRJRVWR ]DMHPDVSRMPRPJLEDQMD 9 QDMVSORďQHMďHP SRPHQX JLEDQMH PLďOMHQR NRW QDÍLQ REVWRMD LQKHUHQWQD ODVWQRVW PDWHULMH ]DMHPD YVH VSUHPHPEH LQ SURFHVH NL VH GRJDMDMR Y YHVROMX RG ]JROM VSUHPHPEH PHVWD QDUDYQRVW GR PLďOMHQMD (QJHOV *LEDQMHWRUHMQLOHVSUHPHPEDPHVWDYSURVWRUXȡNDUELELORJLEDQMHYRĤMHP SRPHQX EHVHGH ȡ DPSDN R]QDÍXMH SUHGYVHP QHNR ÍDVRYQR UHODFLMR 7D MH NOMXÍQD ]D 9NROLNďQLPHULMHWDLQWHUSUHWDFLMDVSORK]YHVWD/HQLQXMHVHYHGDYSUDďOMLYR&IQSU6KHHKDQ 7UGLWHYGDWXĤHVWRSDRQNUDM/HQLQD$OWKXVVHUVLFHUEUH]WHĤDYVSUHMHPD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 27 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 (QJHOVRYRUD]XPHYDQMHGLDOHNWLNH1DUDYDLPDMRVYRMRODVWQR]JRGRYLQRLQVHQHSUHVWD QRVSUHPLQMDWHUWUDQVIRUPLUD7RGDWXQHJUH]DQHRSLVOMLYHDOLNDRWLÍQHSURFHVHWHPYHÍ ]DSURFHVHNLMLKQDMELXUHMDOLGLDOHNWLÍQL]DNRQL(QJHOVMLKYUD]OLÍQLKREGREMLKVLFHU QDďWHYDYHÍDJODYQLVRWULMH ]DNRQVSUHPHPEHNYDQWLWHWHYNYDOLWHWRLQREUDWQR ]DNRQHQRWQRVWLLQSURWLVORYQRVWLQDVSURWLM ]DNRQQHJDFLMHQHJDFLMH (QJHOV 7L]DNRQLLPDMRQDÍHORPDXQLYHU]DOQRYHOMDYQRVWLQVRYELVWYXPHWDʳ]LÍQL]D NRQL ÍHSUDY VH (QJHOV WHJD L]UD]D QD YVDN QDÍLQ RWHSD ÌHSUDY VH ]DVWDYL YSUDďDQMH GHGXNFLMHWHK]DNRQRYMHSUL(QJHOVXQHQDMGHPR9VSORďQHPYVLȡYQHNROLNRSULODJR MHQLKREOLNDKȡL]YLUDMRL]+HJORYH=QDQRVWLORJLNHYHQGDUSD(QJHOVQLNROLQHSRMDVQL ]DNDMUDYQRWL]DNRQLLQQHPRUGDNDWHULGUXJL .DNRUNROL ĤH WL ]DNRQL YVHNDNRU SRGSLUDMR (QJHOVRYR NRQFHSFLMR GLDOHNWLNH Y naravi 3UYL ]DNRQ ]DNRQ WUDQVIRUPDFLMH NYDQWLWHWH Y NYDOLWHWR Y WHPHOMX SRPHQL GD ] GRYROM VSUHPHPEDPL Y NROLÍLQL ODKNR GRVHĤHPR NYDOLWDWLYQL SUHVNRN 7DNR ]YLďDQMH WHPSHUDWXUH YRGH GR VWRSLQM &HO]LMD VSURĤL VSUHPHPER YRGH Y SDUR 7RGD ]DNRQ QLRPHMHQQDWRYUVWQHIRUPXOH]QMLPODKNRRSLďHPRWXGLSRYVHPEDQDOQDGRJDMDQMD NRWQSURSLMDQMH]DONRKRORPNMHUGRYROMďQDNROLÍLQDSRSLWHJDDONRKRODVSURĤLNULWLÍQR PDVRQDVWDQNDďNRGOMLYLKVQRYLYWHOHVXNLSRY]URÍDMR]PDÍNDQRVW3ROHJWDNďQLKEDQDO QRVWL SD ]DNRQ VSUHPHPEH NYDQWLWHWH Y NYDOLWHWR UD]ODJD WXGL NRPSOHNVQH IHQRPHQH NRWMHQSUJHQH]DNDSLWDOD 'UXJL]DNRQJRYRULRSUHKDMDQMXQDVSURWLML]HQHJDYGUXJHJD6WYDUVDPDQDMEL ELODL]YRUQRLGHQWLWHWDVWYDUMHVWYDUWRGDREHQHPWXGLQLWDVWYDUVDPDLQVHWRUHMUD]OL NXMHRGVDPHVHEH.RQÍQRMHYWUHWMHPNRUDNXVWYDUHQRWQRVWREHKPRPHQWRYHQRWQRVW LGHQWLWHWHLQUD]OLNH7DDEVWUDNWQDIRUPXODFLMDSUDY]DSUDYL]UDĤDELVWYRVSUHPLQMDQMD 6WYDUMHLGHQWLÍQDVDPDVVHERMGRNOHUVHQHVSUHPHQLYQHNDMGUXJHJDWRGDREHQHP RKUDQLVYRMRLGHQWLWHWRUDYQRNRWVSUHPLQMDMRÍDVHVWYDU5HÍLVRGRORÍHQHVNR]LQD VSURWMDLQSURWLVORYMD 10 NDUMHELOR]DWUDGLFLRQDOQRPHWDʳ]LNRQDÍHORPDQHVSUHMHPOMLYR 9 Kapitalu ODKNRQDMGHPRQHSRVUHGQRUHIHUHQFRQDRPHQMHQL]DNRQ}3RVHVWQLNGHQDUMDDOLEODJDVH YNDSLWDOLVWDGHMDQVNRSUHREUD]LďHOHWHGDMNRMHPLQLPDOQDYVRWD]DORĤHQD]DSURGXNFLMRGDOHÍQDGVUHGQ MHYHďNLPPDNVLPXPRP7DNRNDNRUYQDUDYRVORYMXVHWXSRWUMXMHSUDYLOQRVW]DNRQDNLJDMH+HJHORGNULOY ȥ/RJLNLȣWM GDSUHSURVWRNYDQWLWDWLYQHVSUHPHPEHQDQHNLWRÍNLSUHLGHMRYNYDOLWDWLYQHUD]OLNH>SRXGDUHN1.@m0DU[ 10 }9HUMHWQRQDMVODYQHMďLSULPHUQDMGHPRY Kapitalu}9LGHOLVPRGDSURFHVPHQMDYHEODJYNOMXÍXMH SURWLVORYQHLQPHGVHERMQRL]NOMXÍXMRÍHVHRGQRVH5D]YRMEODJDWHKSURWLVORYLMQHRGSUDYLXVWYDULSDIRUPRY NDWHULVHODKNRJLEOMHMR7RMHQDVSORKPHWRGDSRNDWHULVHUD]UHďXMHMRGHMDQVNDSURWLVORYMD3URWLVORYMHMHQD SULPHUGDNDNRWHORVWDOQRSDGDYGUXJRLQSUDYWDNRVWDOQREHĤLRGQMHJD(OLSVDMHHQDRGIRUPJLEDQMDYNDWH ULKVHSURWLVORYMHSUDYWDNRXGHMDQMDNRWUD]UHďXMHm0DU[ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 28 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 =D(QJHOVDMHFHORJLEDQMHQDWDQDÍLQSURWLVORYQRVDMMHJLEDMRÍDVHUHÍREHQHP QDHQHPPHVWXLQGUXJHPPHVWX(QJHOVȡ5HÍSDYHQGDUOHQLQHQDHQHP QHQDGUXJHPPHVWXDPSDNYJLEDQMXPHGQMLPD3RVNXVʳNVDFLMHREMHNWDQDQDÍLQDE VWUDNWQHLGHQWLWHWHȡ$ $REMHNWVHQDKDMDQDGRORÍHQHPPHVWXȡMHYVWURJHPVPLVOXQH PRJRÍR]LURPDMHNYHÍMHPXXSRUDEHQYYVDNGDQMHPQHSDWXGL]QDQVWYHQHPSRVWRSDQMX 7UHWML]DNRQQHJDFLMHQHJDFLMHRSLVXMHFLNHOSRVWDMDQMDNMHUVHSUYDVWYDUVSUH PHQLYQHNDMGUXJHJDVNR]LVYRMHXQLÍHQMHUH]XOWDWWHJDXQLÍHQMDSDMHSRQRYQRXQL ÍHQ D WDNR GD MH YUQMHQ Y L]YRUQR REOLNR =DNRQ QHJDFLMH QHJDFLMH ODKNR SRQD]RULPR QDSULPHUXVSUHPHPEHVHPHQDYUDVWOLQR6HPHVVSUHPHPERYUDVWOLQRSUHQHKDELWL VHPHWRGDWXGLUDVWOLQDGDOMHSURSDGHREHQHPSDSURL]YHGHSORGNLJDODKNRSRQRYQR SRVHMHPR(QJHOV.OMXÍQRMHGDMHVDPRL]YRUQRVHPHYQD]DMGRORÍHQRVNR]L UDVWOLQRR]LURPDGDJUHSULQMHP]DQHNRVDPRJLEDMRÍRHQRWQRVW .DMSUDY]DSUDYORÍXMH(QJHOVRYRGLDOHNWLNRRG+HJORYHVSHNXODWLYQHʳOR]RʳMH" 2PHQLPRODKNRSUHGYVHPGYDPRPHQWD]DYUDÍDQMHLGHDOL]PDȡWM]DWUMHYDQMD}GXKDm NRWJODYQHJDJRQLOD]JRGRYLQHȡLQDʳUPDFLMDGLDOHNWLNH]QRWUDMQDUDYHVDPH'LDOHNWLÍQL ]DNRQLGHOXMHMRYYVHKWUHKVIHUDKNLMLK(QJHOVRPHQMDYQDUDYLY]JRGRYLQLLQYPLďO MHQMX=D+HJODQDUDYDQLGLDOHNWLÍQDYQMHM 11 QHSULKDMDGRGHMDQVNHJDUD]YRMDDPSDN NYHÍMHPXGRQHVPLVHOQHJDPQRĤHQMDQSUYUVWĤLYLKELWLM=D(QJHOVDSDMHQDUDYDELV WYHQR]JRGRYLQVNLSURFHV.RQVWDQWQRQDVWDMDQMHQRYLKELWQRVWL]QRYLPLODVWQRVWPL REHQHPSDY]SRUHGQRRGPLUDQMHVWDULKELWQRVWLSULÍDUDYQRRQDÍLQXELWLQDUDYHNRW VDPRSRUDMDMRÍHWRWDOLWHWH.DQJDO=DQDYHGHQRVWDOLďÍHMHLPHO(QJHOVGREUH UD]ORJH 9 QMHJRYHP ÍDVX MH ]QDQRVW SULďOD GR ďWHYLOQLK RGNULWLM NL VR UD]ORĤLOD dolo ÍHQHȥPDQMNDMRÍHÍOHQHȣGRWHGDQMHYHGQRVWLREHQHPSDRKUDQLODGLVNRQWLQXLWHWRPHG SRVDPH]QLPLSRGURÍMLVÍLPHUMHQDďLURNRRGSUODYUDWD]DEROMHPHUJHQWLVWLÍQHSRJOHGH QDQDUDYRPHGNDWHUHODKNRXYUVWLPRWXGL(QJHOVRYHJD0HGQDMSRPHPEQHMďDWRYUVW QDRGNULWMDODKNRďWHMHPRRGNULWMHFHOLFHNRWRVQRYQHJDJUDGQLNDĤLYLKELWLM'DUZLQRYR WHRULMRQDVWDQNDYUVWNLMHSRMDVQLODUD]YRMĤLYLKELWLMYVHGRÍORYHNDter zakon o ohranitvi LQ WUDQVIRUPDFLML HQHUJLMH NL MH RGSLUDO QRYH SRJOHGH QD ʳ]LNDOQD YSUDďDQMD 6KHHKDQ 6DPD REÍRVW GLDOHNWLÍQLK ]DNRQRY SD LPD ODKNR ]DVNUEOMXMRÍH SRVOHGLFH ]D ÍORYHďNR ]DYHVW LQ PLďOMHQMH ÍH VR WL LVWL ]DNRQL REHQHP WXGL ]DNRQL QDUDYH 3UHKL WHU VNOHS L] ĤH SRYHGDQHJD EL ELO GD MH PLďOMHQMH ]JROM SURGXNW PRĤJDQRY LQ SUDY]D SUDY ]JROM RGVHYD QHNR ]XQDQMR UHDOQRVW (QJHOV WDNR UD]OLNXMH PHG REMHNWLYQR QD UDYQRLQVXEMHNWLYQR]DYHVWQRGLDOHNWLNRSULÍHPHUSDMHVOHGQMDL]UD]UHʴHNVSUYH 11 7RGUĤLYVDM]DPDUNVLVWLÍQLSRPHQL]UD]DGLDOHNWLÍQR.DQJDOSUHGODJDGDELYKHJORYVNL WHUPLQRORJLML(QJHOVRYLUDELSUHMXVWUH]DOWHUPLQVSHNXODWLYQR(QJHOVVHMHYHUMHWQRĤHOHOL]RJQLWLSUHGYVHP NRQRWDFLMLUDFLRQDOQRVWLNLVHGUĤLWHEHVHGHLQNLQHXVWUH]D(QJHOVRYLPFLOMHP Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 29 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 3RVDPH]QLNRYD]DYHVWYVHNDNRUQLQHRGYLVQDRGQMHJRYHJDWHOHVDLQRNROMDYHQ GDUSDLPD(QJHOVWXQHNROLNRNRPSOHNVQHMďLRGJRYRUVDMQDMELELODPLVHOSRVUHGRYDQD WXGLVÍORYHNRYRGHMDYQRVWMRYVYHWXVVDPLPDNWRPVSUHPLQMDQMDVYRMHJDRNROMD 12 .HUSD MHÍORYHNRYDGHMDYQRVWYHGQRGUXĤEHQDGHMDYQRVWMHWXGLPLďOMHQMHGUXĤEHQRSRVUHGRYD no7UGLWHYGDSRPHQLGLDOHNWLNDQDUDYHREHQHPUHGXNFLMRPLďOMHQMDQDHSLIHQRPHQPD WHULMHMHWRUHMQHNROLNRSUHWLUDQD.OMXÍQRMHWRUHMGDMH]D(QJHOVDQDUDYDVDPDGLDOHNWLÍ QD+HJHO]DQLNDUD]YRMYQDUDYLVOHGQMDQLPD]JRGRYLQH(QJHOVRYDQDUDYDMHQDVSURWQR YVDPRJLEDQMXVNR]LNDWHUHJDVHQHSUHVWDQRWUDQVIRUPLUDLQXVWYDUMDYHGQRQRYHREOLNH LQODVWQRVWL6HGDMVLSRJOHMPRďH(QJHOVRYRJHQH]RQDUDYQHJDVYHWDLQGUXĤEHQHJDVYHWD APLIKACIJA MATERIALISTIČNE DIALEKTIKE ÌHSUDY MH QDUDYD QDÍHORPD YHÍQD LPD SR (QJHOVX QHNDNďQR ]DÍHWQR VWDQMH 1DMSUHMMH]JROMEUH]REOLÍQDPHJOD(QJHOVȡYQHSUHWUJDQHPJLEDQMXL]ND WHUHVHSUDY]DUDGLWHJDJLEDQMDSULÍQHMRREOLNRYDWL]YH]GHLQSODQHWL1DVOHGQMLKVHSRG GRORÍHQLPLNHPLMVNLPLSRJRMLLQQDSRGODJLSULPHUQHNRQʳJXUDFLMHPROHNXOWDNďQHNL XVWUH]D]DGRVWQLNYDQWLWHWLUD]YLMHMRRUJDQVNHFHOLFHWHU]QMLPLĤLYOMHQMH&HOLFHVHQDWR UD]YLMDMRSRQDÍHOXQDNOMXÍQLKPXWDFLMLQQDUDYQHVHOHNFLMHYVNODGXVWHRULMRNLMRMH RULVDO&KDUOHV'DUZLQLQNLVWDMR0DU[LQ(QJHOVPRÍQRREÍXGRYDOD6NR]LWHQDNOMXÍQH PXWDFLMHSDVHQDGRORÍHQLWRÍNLUD]YLMHRUJDQL]HPNLMHSUHWLUDQRSURGXNWLYHQVDMMH ]PRĤHQSULGRELWLYHÍKUDQHNDNRUMHWHORSRWUHEXMH]DVYRMHSUHĤLYHWMH7RÍNRRGNORQD WHJDRUJDQL]PDRGGUXJLKVRURGQLKYUVWRSLFODKNRGRORÍLPRYWUHQXWNXNRVYRMHSUHGQ MHRNRQÍLQHSUHQHKDXSRUDEOMDWLQDHQDNQDÍLQNRWVYRMH]DGQMHRNRQÍLQHLQSULGRELSR NRQÍQRGUĤRNDUVSURVWLSUHGQMHRNRQÍLQH]DL]YDMDQMHGUXJLKNRPSOHNVQHMďLKRSHUDFLM 6WHPÍORYHNRYSUHGQLNQLYHÍVSRVREHQ]JROMVYRMHODVWQHUHSURGXNFLMHDPSDNSULÍQH DNWLYQRWUDQVIRUPLUDWLVYRMRRNROLFR1RYHLQWHUDNFLMH]RNROMHPNLMLKRPRJRÍLSURVWD URND YRGLMR N QRYLP SULODJRGLWYDP ÍORYHďNHJD WHOHVD WH SD RPRJRÍLMR L]GHORYDQMH LQ UDERRURGLM 6SHFLDOL]DFLMD URNH ȡ WR LPSOLFLUD RURGMH RURGMH LPSOLFLUD VSHFLʳÍQR ÍORYHďNR DNWLYQRVW WUDQVIRUPLUDMRÍL RG]LY ÍORYHND QD RNROMH SURGXNFLMR ģLYDOL Y RĤMHP SRPHQXSUDY WDNR LPDMR RURGMH DPSDN OH NRW RNRQÍLQH VYRMLK WHOHV PUDYOMD ÍHEHOD EREHU ĤLYDOL SUDY WDNR SURGXFLUDMR YHQGDU MH QMLKRY SURGXNWLYQL XÍLQHN QD RNROLFR QLÍHQ (QJHOV =JRGRYLQDVH]DÍQHNRVHURNDL]WHJQHYQDUDYRMRWUDQVIRUPLUDLQXSRUDEL]D 12 &I(QJHOV}1DMEROMHWLRYUĤHWHNDNRUYVHGUXJHʳOR]RIVNHPXKHSUDNVDQDPUHÍSRVNXV LQLQGXVWULMDÌHPRUHPRGRND]DWLGDMHSUDYLOQRQDďHSRMPRYDQMHQHNHJDQDUDYQHJDSRMDYDQDWDQDÍLQGD JDVDPLQDSUDYLPRGDJDXVWYDULPRL]QMHJRYLKSRJRMHYLQJDYUKWHJDďHSULSUDYLPRGDVOXĤLQDďLPQDPHQ WHGDMMHNRQHF.DQWRYLQHGRXPOMLYLȥUHÍLQDVHELȣ.HPLÍQHVQRYLNLQDVWDMDMRYUDVWOLQVNLKLQĤLYDOVNLKWHOHVLKVR RVWDOHWDNHȥUHÍLQDVHELȣYVHGRWOHMGRNOHUMLKQL]DÍHODRUJDQVNDNHPLMDL]GHORYDWLGUXJR]DGUXJRVWHPMHSR VWDODȥUHÍQDVHELȣUHÍ]DQDVNDNRUQSUDOL]DULQEDUYLOREURďÍDNLQDPJDQLYUÍWUHEDJRMLWLQDSROMXYEURďÍHYLK NRUHQLQDKPDUYHÍJDPQRJRFHQHMHLQHQRVWDYQHMHL]GHOXMHPRL]SUHPRJRYHJDNDWUDQDm Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 30 27. 10. 2022 11:16:17 VYRMHODVWQHFLOMHNRRURGMDSUHQHKDMRELWLRNRQÍLQHLQSRVWDQHMRSURGXNFLMVNDVUHGVWYD 3UYDRURGMDVRVOXĤLODSUHGYVHP]DQDELUDQMHKUDQH]DORYQDĤLYDOLLQULERORYVÍLPHU MHSUYLÍORYHNODKNRSULďHOGREROMďHSUHKUDQH6WHPVRWXGLVNUDMďDODÍDVNLJDMHÍORYHN SRWUHERYDO]DVYRMRUHSURGXNFLMR7DNďQHVSUHPHPEHPHGQMLPLSUHGYVHPL]XPRJQMD ÍORYHNRYHJDWHOHVDQLVRSXVWLODQH]D]QDPRYDQHJD7HORQLOHY]URNGHODDPSDNWXGLQMH JRYDSRVOHGLFD=URNRVRVH]DÍHOLSUHREOLNRYDWLGUXJLRUJDQLPHGQMLPLSUHGYVHPPRĤ JDQL7LSR(QJHOVXVOXĤLMRSUHGYVHPRGNULYDQMXQXMQLKQDUDYQLK]DNRQRY6WHPÍORYHN SRVWDQHVYRERGHQVDMVYRERGDYPHWDʳ]LÍQHPVPLVOX]D(QJHOVDSRPHQL]PRĤQRVWRE YODGRYDQMDVYRMHRNROLFHNDU]DKWHYDSR]QDYDQMHSUDYLOSRNDWHULKVHVOHGQMDREQDďD 9HYROXFLMLÍORYHďNHYUVWHSDQDMGHPRďHWUHWMLIDNWRU5D]YRMRURGLMLQQMLKRYD VSHFLDOL]DFLMDLPSOLFLUDWDWXGLGHOLWHYGHODVWHPSDVHSRMDYLSRWUHEDSRNRPXQLNDFLML VDM HQ SURGXFHQW SURL]YDMD HQ SURGXNW GUXJL VSHW GUXJHJD 7DNR VR OMXGMH L] SRWUHEH L]XPLOLMH]LNVWHPSDVRL]SROQMHQLYVLSRJRMH]DQDVWDQHNGUXĤEHYSROQHPSRPHQX 6SHFLDOL]DFLMDRURGMDSRPHQLGHOLWHYGHODPRĤJDQLLQJRYRUSDQDPGDMRPRĤQRVWVRʳV WLFLUDQHNRPXQLNDFLMHPHGSRVDPH]QLPLSULSDGQLNLÍORYHďNHYUVWH3UHKRGPHGQDUDYR LQGUXĤERVHWXNRQÍD.OMXEHQRWQLGLDOHNWLÍQLVKHPL]JRGRYLQDVOHGLODVWQLPLPDQHQW QLP]DNRQRP(QJHOVWDNRSUDYL 3R PDWHULDOLVWLÍQHP SRMPRYDQMX MH UD]ORJ NL Y ]JRGRYLQL Y SRVOHGQML VWRSQML RGORÍD SURGXNFLMD LQ UHSURGXNFLMD QHSRVUHGQHJD ĤLYOMHQMD 7D SD MH VSHW GYRMQD 1D HQL VWUDQL ȡ SURL]YRGQMD ĤLYOMHQMVNLK VUHGVWHY ĤLYHĤD REOHNH VWDQRYDQMD LQ ]D WR SRWUHEQHJD RURGMD QD GUXJL VWUDQL ȡ SURL]YRGQMD OMXGL VDPLK UD]SORMHYDQMH YUVWH 'UXĤEHQLP XVWDQRYDP Y NDWHULK ĤLYH OMXGMH GRORÍHQH]JRGRYLQVNHGREHLQGRORÍHQHGHĤHOHVWDSRJRMREHYUVWLSURGXNFLMH UD]YRMQDVWRSQMDGHODQDWHMGUXĤLQHQDGUXJLVWUDQL(QJHOV 1DWHMSRGODJL(QJHOVDQDOL]LUDWXGLQDGDOMQMLUD]YRMGUXĤEHRGGUXĤLQHLQSUL YDWQH ODVWQLQH LQ NRQÍQR GR GUĤDYH 2VQRYQR SRMPRYDQMH RVWDMD Y GLDOHNWLÍQHP UD] PHUMXPHGVWRSQMRUD]YRMDSURGXNFLMVNLKVLOLQGUXĤEHQRIRUPDFLMRNLVHSUHSOHWDWDY PHGVHERMQHPXÍLQNRYDQMX9YVDNHPGUXĤEHQHPVLVWHPXVHREOLNXMHMRGRORÍHQLDQWD JRQL]PLNLNRQVWLWXLUDMRGHMDQVNRSURWLVORYMHYGUXĤELLQXVWYDULMRWHQGHQFRNLODKNRQD NRQFXUD]WUJDREVWRMHÍLUHGWHU]JUDGLQRYHJD ZAKLJUČEK 6HGDM VH ODKNR YUQHPR N ]DÍHWQLP RSDĤDQMHP LQ RGJRYRULPR QD YSUDďDQMH ]DNDM (QJHOVRY SURMHNW GLDOHNWLNH QDUDYH Y QHNDWHULK PDUNVLVWLÍQLK NURJLK QL ELO QDM EROMHVSUHMHW1HNDWHULPDUNVLVWLVRPDWHULDOLVWLÍQRGLDOHNWLNRUD]XPHOLNRWQHPRĤQRVW LQ VNUXQLWHY 0DU[RYH GLDOHNWLNH VDM GLDOHNWLND QLPD PHVWD Y QDUDYL GUXJL SD VR MR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 31 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 UD]XPHOLQDSUHWLUDQRUHDOLVWLÍHQQDÍLQ3URWLRERMLPVPRSRVNXďDOLSRND]DWLGD(QJOH VRYD GLDOHNWLND QDUDYH SRPHQL SRPHPEHQ LQ L]YLUHQ SULVSHYHN N PDUNVLVWLÍQL WHRULML NLQLQLWLSUHWLUDQRLGHDOLVWLÍHQQLWLQHPHKDQLFLVWLÍHQ9LGHOLVPRGD]D(QJHOVDPD WHULDOL]HP QH OHĤL Y PDWHULML NRW VXEVWDQFL DPSDN SRPHQL UDYQR VDPRJLEDMRÍR LQ VD PRUD]YLMDMRÍRFHORWR9 WHPVPLVOXMHPDWHULMDWRWDOLWHWDLQWXGLYKHJORYVNHPVPLVOX UHVQLÍQDQHVNRQÍQRVWVDMREVWDMDUDYQRYVYRMHPQHQHKQHPVDPRSUHVHJDQMXLQÍDVRY QHPUD]YRMX(QJHOVQHSDGDYSDVWL/HQLQRYHWHRULMHVSR]QDQMDNRWRGVHYDQMD]XQDQMH REMHNWLYQHUHDOQRVWLLQ]DYUDÍDPHKDQLFLVWLÍQRWHRULMRNDY]DOQRVWLNLMHGR6WDOLQDNRQ WDPLQLUDODYVRPDUNVLVWLÍQRWHRULMRRGQDUDYRVORYMDGRNRQFHSFLMHUHYROXFLRQDUQHSUDN VH (QJHOVRYPDWHULDOL]HPMH+HJORYLGHDOL]HPSRVWDYOMHQQDQRJH>DOLREUQMHQQDJOD YR@NROLNRUMHYQMHPSUHVHĤHQSULPDWGXKDGLDOHNWLNDSDUD]ďLUMHQDL]RPHMHQHJDVYHWD PLďOMHQMDYSURVWUDQLVYHWQDUDYH0DUNVL]HPVWHPGRELVYRMRODVWQRʳOR]RIVNRWHRULMR NL QL SULPHUQD ]JROM ]D REUDYQDYR HNRQRPLMH LQ ]JRGRYLQH DPSDN WXGL QDUDYRVORYMD &IQSU6WDOLQ}7RVHSUDYLGDQHVPHMRSDUWLMHSUROHWDULDWDYRGLWLYQMHQLSUDNWLÍQLGHMDY QRVWLNDNUďQLNROLVOXÍDMQLPRWLYLWHPYHÍ]DNRQLGUXĤEHQHJDUD]YRMDSUDNWLÍQLVNOHSLL]WHK]DNRQRYm7HRUHWVNL PHKDQLFL]HPSRPHQLSUDNWLÍQRWHKQRNUDFLMR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 32 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 BIBLIOGRAFIJA $OWKXVVHU /RXLV /HQLQ LQ ʳOR]RʳMD Y ,GHRORJLMD LQ LGHRORďNL DSDUDWL GUĤDYH LQGUXJLVSLVL/MXEOMDQD=DORĤEDFI (QJHOV)ULHGULFK'LDOHFWLFVRI1DWXUHY0DU[(QJHOV&ROOHFWHG:RUNV9RO 1HZ@7KHVWDWHKRZHYHUIHDUVWKLVYLR OHQFHVLPSO\IRULWVODZPDNLQJFKDUDFWHUEHLQJREOLJHGWRDFNQRZOHGJHLWDVODZPDNLQJ ZKHQHYHUH[WHUQDOSRZHUVIRUFHLWWRFRQFHGHWKHPWKHULJKWWRFRQGXFWZDUIDUHDQG FODVVHVIRUFHLWWRFRQFHGHWKHPWKHULJKWWRVWULNHȤ%DOLEDU,QKLVPHWLFXORXV GHFRQVWUXFWLYHUHDGLQJRIWKHWH[W-DFTXHV'HUULGDUHFRJQLVHV%HQMDPLQȣVDPELWLRQWR DUULYHDWWKHSRLQWRIKRPRJHQHLW\RIODZDQGYLROHQFHȣ6XFKDVLWXDWLRQ>FDUU\LQJWKH ULJKWWRVWULNHWRLWVOLPLWȡWKHJHQHUDOVWULNH@LVLQIDFWWKHRQO\RQHWKDWDOORZVXVWR FRQFHLYHWKHKRPRJHQHLW\RIODZRUULJKWDQGYLROHQFHYLROHQFHDVWKHH[HUFLVHRIGURLW DQGGURLWDVWKHH[HUFLVHRIYLROHQFH9LROHQFHLVQRWH[WHULRUWRWKHRUGHURIGURLW,WWKUH DWHQVLWIURPZLWKLQȤ'HUULGD7KHYLROHQFHRIWKHJHQHUDOVWULNHLVDYLROHQFH WKHSRWHQWLDORIZKLFKRULJLQDWHVLQWKHRUGHURIODZEXWWKDWDWWKHVDPHWLPHWKUHDWHQV it as a ȣIXQGDPHQWDOIRXQGLQJYLROHQFHȤ WKDWFRXOGIRXQGDQRWKHUODZ:HFDQVHHWKDW FRQFHSWXDOO\LWDOOGHSHQGVRQWKHH[FHVVʳUVWLWLVWKHH[FHVVWKDWGHʳQHVWKHȣQRQH[ FHVVLYHȤWKHH[FHVVRISRZHULVDQHFHVVDU\FRQGLWLRQRISRZHUDVVXFKand second, it is WKHH[FHVVWKDWFRQQHFWVWKHVXSSRVHGO\QHLJKERXULQJGLPHQVLRQVRISRZHUDQGYLROHQ 12 6HH%HQMDPLQ:DOWHUȨ&ULWLTXHRI9LROHQFHȦ,Q Selected writings, Vol. 1, 1913-1926&DPEULGJH 0DVVDFKXVHWWVS%HQMDPLQ:DOWHUȨ+NULWLNLQDVLOMDȦ ProblemiďWȡSDQG%DOL EDU(WLHQQH Politics and the Other Scene/RQGRQ9HUVRS Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 39 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 FHȡWKHH[FHVVRISRZHUEULQJVXVWRWKHH[FHVVRIYLROHQFHZHFRXOGHYHQDGGȣDQH[FHVV RIODZȤZLWKWKHKHOSRI&DUO6FKPLWWDVZHZLOOVHHODWHURQ:HFDQDOVRDOUHDG\VHQVH DQDPELYDOHQFHDWZRUNEHWZHHQKRPRJHQHLW\DQGKHWHURJHQHLW\RIODZDQGYLROHQFH YLROHQFHWKUHDWHQVODZKHWHURJHQHLW\EXWLWWKUHDWHQVLWIURPWKHLQVLGHKRPRJHQHL W\'HUULGDGRHVQRWPDNHH[SOLFLWRUGRHVQRWQRWLFHWKHLPEDODQFHDWZRUNKHUHLQWKH VHFRQGSDUWRI%HQMDPLQȣVWH[WZKLFKZHDUHDSSURDFKLQJDQGZKHUH%HQMDPLQLVWKH PRVWFUHDWLYHLWLVHYHQPRUHH[SOLFLWO\QRWKRPRJHQHLW\LQTXHVWLRQDQ\PRUHEXWWKH SULPDF\RIYLROHQFHRYHUODZ:HDUHJRLQJWRWDNHVPDOOVWHSVLQRUGHUWRDUULYHDWWKLV SRLQW)RUQRZLWLVHQRXJKWRVWUHVVWKDWWKHODZPDNLQJGLPHQVLRQRIYLROHQFHJRHV EH\RQGWKHJHQHUDOVWULNHDQGZDUIRU%HQMDPLQ7KHDGPLUDWLRQRIDȣJUHDWFULPLQDOȤLQ WKHH\HVRIWKHSXEOLFLVDQDGPLUDWLRQRIDQDQFLHQWRUP\WKLFDOʳJXUHRIDODZPDNHURU SURSKHWDQDGPLUDWLRQRIWKHSRZHUDQGFRXUDJHRIWKHRQHZKRHVWDEOLVKHVQHZODZ /DZPDNLQJYLROHQFHWKXVVWDQGVDWWKHRULJLQRIODZ%HQMDPLQ 7KHUHLVDQRWKHUIXQFWLRQWKDW%HQMDPLQH[SOLFDWHVIURPWKHH[DPSOHRIWKHPL OLWDU\WKHODZSUHVHUYLQJYLROHQFHWKDWFRHUFHVFLWL]HQVWRDFWDFFRUGLQJWRODZDQGLWV OHJDOHQGVVXFKDVREOLJDWRU\FRQVFULSWLRQ%XWWKLVH[DPSOHLVQRWDVSHFLDOFDVHRI ODZSUHVHUYLQJYLROHQFH7KHFULWLTXHRIWKHODWWHUFRLQFLGHVZLWKDFULWLTXHRIDOOOHJDO YLROHQFHLPSO\LQJWKDWODZSUHVHUYLQJYLROHQFHLVHIIHFWLYHLQWKHRUGHURIODZDVVXFK %HQMDPLQ 7KLVLVZKHUH%HQMDPLQLQWURGXFHVWKHQRWLRQVRIWKUHDWDQGIDWH7KHLQWHUHVW RI ODZSUHVHUYLQJ YLROHQFH LV WKH JHQHUDO LQWHUHVW RI SRVLWLYH ODZ LQ DV PXFK DV LW LV ȣFRQVFLRXVRILWVURRWVȤWKHODWWHUFODLPVWRȣDFNQRZOHGJHDQGSURPRWHWKHLQWHUHVWRI PDQNLQGLQWKHSHUVRQRIHDFKLQGLYLGXDO,WVHHVWKLVLQWHUHVWLQWKHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQDQG SUHVHUYDWLRQRIDQRUGHULPSRVHGE\IDWHȤ7KHSRZHURIODZGRHVQRWUHVLGHLQSDUWLFXODU GHFUHHVDQGODZVEXWȣLQWKHIDFWWKDWWKHUHLVRQO\RQHIDWHDQGWKDWZKDWH[LVWVDQG LQSDUWLFXODUZKDWWKUHDWHQVEHORQJVLQYLRODEO\WRLWVRUGHUȤ%HQMDPLQP\ HPSKDVLV /DZSUHVHUYLQJYLROHQFHLVQRWWKUHDWHQLQJEHFDXVHLWZRXOGLQWLPLGDWHZLWK DSURVSHFWRISXQLVKPHQWIRUDYLRODWLRQRIDSDUWLFXODUODZEXWEHFDXVHLWUHSUHVHQWVWKH JHQHUDORUGHURIWKLQJVGDV%HVWHKHQGHDVLQȣZKDWH[LVWVȤȣWKDWZKLFKLVDFWXDOȤLWLV WKUHDWHQLQJLQLWVXQFHUWDLQW\ZKLFKLVZKDWOLQNVODZDQGIDWHȣ7KHGHHSHVWSXUSRVHRI WKHXQFHUWDLQW\RIWKHOHJDOWKUHDWZLOOHPHUJHIURPWKHODWHUFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHVSKHUH RI IDWH LQ ZKLFK LW RULJLQDWHVȤ ,ELG /DZSUHVHUYLQJ YLROHQFH IXQFWLRQV DV IDWH GRHV ȣ7KHVSKHUHRIIDWHȣLVWKXVRINH\LPSRUWDQFHVLQFHWKHUHLVQRIXQFWLRQLQJODZZLWKRXW LW'HUULGDDOVRDFFHQWXDWHVWKLVSRLQWȣ7KLVRUGHU>RUGHURIODZ@LVVXFKWKDWWKHUHH[LVWV RQHXQLTXHIDWHRUKLVWRU\7KDWLVRQHRIWKHNH\FRQFHSWVRIWKHWH[WEXWDOVRRQHRI WKH PRVW REVFXUH ZKHWKHU LWȣV D TXHVWLRQ RI IDWH LWVHOI RU RI LWV DEVROXWH XQLTXHQHVV 7KDWZKLFKH[LVWVZKLFKKDVFRQVLVWHQF\DQGWKDWZKLFKDWWKHVDPHWLPHWKUHDWHQV ZKDWH[LVWVEHORQJLQYLRODEO\WRWKHVDPHRUGHUDQGWKLVRUGHULVLQYLRODEOHEHFDXVHLWLV Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 40 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 XQLTXH,WFDQRQO\EHYLRODWHGLQLWVHOIȤ'HUULGD7KLVȣIDWHȤLQDOOLWVREVFXULW\ LVFUXFLDO:HDUHJRLQJWRDGGUHVVWKHIDFWRIREVFXULW\ODWHURQEXWʳUVWOHWXVIROORZ %HQMDPLQLQKLVHODERUDWLRQ THE POLICE, CONCEPTUALLY ,Q RUGHU WR GHYHORS WKH WKHPH RI IDWH DQG WKH XQFHUWDLQW\ RI WKH OHJDO WKUH DW%HQMDPLQH[DPLQHVWKUHHH[DPSOHVWKHVSKHUHRISXQLVKPHQWVVSHFLʳFDOO\FDSLWDO SXQLVKPHQWWKHLQVWLWXWLRQRISROLFHDQGWKHSDUOLDPHQW&RPPRQWRDOOWKUHHLVWKH IDFWWKDWWKH\DOOWHVWLI\DERXWWKHQHFHVVLW\RIYLROHQFHIRUDQHIIHFWLYHRUGHURIODZ7KH FULWLTXHRIFDSLWDOSXQLVKPHQWLVDFWXDOO\DOZD\VDFULWLTXHRIWKHRUGHURIODZLWVHOILQ WKDWFDSLWDOSXQLVKPHQWLVWKHSULYLOHJHGDFWRIODZDQGLWVKLJKHVWYLROHQFHRYHUOLIH DQGGHDWKLQZKLFKȣWKHODZUHDIʳUPVLWVHOIȤ7KHSDUOLDPHQWVRIPRGHUQGHPRFUDWLF VWDWHVWHVWLI\DERXWWKHQHFHVVDU\OLQNEHWZHHQYLROHQFHDQGODZLQDQLQYHUVHZD\7KHLU LQHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQGODFNRISRZHUDUHDGLUHFWUHVXOWRIWKHLUGHPRFUDWLFSULQFLSOHVRIFRQ VHQVXVDQGQRQYLROHQFHWKDWDUHDGLUHFWFRQVHTXHQFHRIDQDEVHQFHRIFRQVFLRXVQHVV ȣRIWKHUHYROXWLRQDU\IRUFHVWRZKLFKWKH\RZHWKHLUH[LVWHQFHȤ%HQMDPLQLVFOHDURQWKLV ȣ:KHQWKHFRQVFLRXVQHVVRIWKHODWHQWSUHVHQFHRIYLROHQFHLQDOHJDOLQVWLWXWLRQGLVDSSH DUVWKHLQVWLWXWLRQIDOOVLQWRGHFD\Ȥ%HQMDPLQ$VVRFLDWLQJWKLVGLPLQLVKLQJ FRQVFLRXVQHVVZLWK%DOLEDUȣVREVHUYDWLRQUHJDUGLQJSROLFHPDNLQJODZDQGRUGHUȣLQFL ties and in souls,ȤZHFDQVHHWKH\ʳWWRJHWKHULQWRWKHOLEHUDOSDUDGLJPRIQRQYLROHQFH %RWKRIWKHVHDUHPRUHWKDQMXVWH[DPSOHVEXWWKHFDVHRIWKHSROLFHLVHYHQ PRUHWKHRUHWLFDOO\SRLJQDQWIRU%HQMDPLQ7KHSROLFHUHSUHVHQWVDVLQJXODULQVWLWXWLRQ RIWKHPRGHUQVWDWHLQZKLFKWKHWZRIRUPVRIYLROHQFHODZPDNLQJDQGODZSUHVHUYLQJ DUH PL[HG WR WKH GHJUHH RI LQGLVWLQFWLRQ ZKLFK LV LQ KLV ZRUGV DQ DEVROXWHO\ȣLJQR PLQLRXVȣ IRUP RI DXWKRULW\ 7KH SROLFH VXSSRVHGO\ DFWV RQ EHKDOI RI WKH VWDWH DQG LWV OHJDOHQGVEXWLQWKHFRQGLWLRQVRIWKHPRGHUQGLVWLQFWLRQRIOHJLVODWLYHDQGH[HFXWLYH SRZHULWʳQGVLWVJURXQGZKHUHWKHVWDWHLVXQDEOHWRUHDFKLWVHPSLULFDOHQGVE\ZD\RI ODZZKLFKPHDQVWKDWWKHSROLFHSRVVHVVHVWKHODZPDNLQJDQGWKHODZSUHVHUYLQJIXQ FWLRQDWWKHVDPHWLPHZKLOHHPDQFLSDWLQJLWVHOIIURPDFWXDOODZVRIWKHVSHFLʳFVWDWH ȣ7KHUHIRUHWKHSROLFHLQWHUYHQHȣIRUVHFXULW\UHDVRQVȤLQFRXQWOHVVFDVHVZKHUHQRFOHDU OHJDOVLWXDWLRQH[LVWVZKHQWKH\DUHQRWPHUHO\ZLWKRXWWKHVOLJKWHVWUHODWLRQWROHJDO HQGV DFFRPSDQ\LQJ WKH FLWL]HQ DV D EUXWDO HQFXPEUDQFH WKURXJK D OLIH UHJXODWHG E\ RUGLQDQFHVRUVLPSO\VXSHUYLVLQJKLP8QOLNHODZZKLFKDFNQRZOHGJHVLQWKHȣGHFLVLRQȤ GHWHUPLQHGE\SODFHDQGWLPHDPHWDSK\VLFDOFDWHJRU\WKDWJLYHVLWDFODLPWRFULWLFDO HYDOXDWLRQDFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKHSROLFHLQVWLWXWLRQHQFRXQWHUVQRWKLQJHVVHQWLDODWDOO ,WVSRZHULVIRUPOHVVOLNHLWVQRZKHUHWDQJLEOHDOOSHUYDVLYHJKRVWO\SUHVHQFH Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 41 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 LQWKHOLIHRIFLYLOLVHGVWDWHVȤ%HQMDPLQP\HPSKDVLV7KHLJQRPLQ\RISR OLFHOLHVH[DFWO\LQWKHFRPELQDWLRQRILWVDOOSHUYDVLYHQHVVDQGWKHODFNRISRVVLELOLW\RI LWVFULWLTXHZKLFKLQWKHHQGDUHRQHDQGWKHVDPHWKLQJ $WWKLVSRLQWZHZLOOEHPDNLQJDVWHSWKDWLVFRQFHSWXDOO\ERWKDQWHULRUDQGSR VWHULRULQUHODWLRQWR%HQMDPLQȣVIRUPXODWLRQV:HDUHPDNLQJLWLQRUGHUWRERWKEHWWHU H[SOLFDWH%HQMDPLQȣVSRVLWLRQDQGWRGHYHORSDIXUWKHUFRQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQRIYLROHQFHLQ PRGHUQGHPRFUDWLFUHJLPHVRQLWVJURXQG,QWKHHQGRXUDQDO\VLVRI%HQMDPLQȣVWH[W ZLOOEULQJXVEDFNWRWKLVSRLQW7KHFXUUHQWVWHSFRQVLVWVLQFRQVLGHULQJWKHUHODWLRQVKLS EHWZHHQYLROHQFHDQGODZRQWKHH[DPSOHRIKLVDQDO\VLVRIWKHLQVWLWXWLRQRISROLFH ,QWKLVUHVSHFWLWFDQEHVDLGWKDWWKHSROLFHȣUHSUHVHQWVȤODZLQDSHFXOLDUZD\ ,W GRHV QRW UHSUHVHQW D VSHFLʳF ODZ RI D VSHFLʳF VWDWH EXW LW FRXOG EH VHHQ DV D SD UDGR[LFDOUHSUHVHQWDWLYHRI/DZDVVXFKXQGHUWKHFRQGLWLRQVRIWKHPRGHUQ6WDWH $VDPL[WXUHRIERWKW\SHVRIYLROHQFHODZPDNLQJDQGODZSUHVHUYLQJLWSURYLGHVDQ ȣDQVZHUȤWRWKHXQFHUWDLQW\RIWKHOHJDOWKUHDWODZLWVHOI7KLVDQVZHULVQHLWKHUDJH QHUDORQHQRULVLWDQRSHQFROOHFWLRQRISDUWLFXODUDQGȣFRUUHFWȤDQVZHUVLQWKHVHQVH WKDW WKH SROLFH ZRXOG EHȣIROORZLQJ WKH ODZȤ LGHQWLI\LQJ EUHDFKHV RI LW DQG UHDOLVLQJ LWV MXVWLʳDEOH DQG QHFHVVDU\ DSSOLFDWLRQV 7KLV DQVZHU ZRXOG UDWKHU EH SDUDGR[LFDO DQG LQYHUWHG LW FRQVLVWV LQ GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ D SDUWLFXODU DFW RU D SDUWLFXODU ERG\ RXW RI DQ RWKHUZLVH XQGLIIHUHQWLDWHG PDVV RI DFWLRQV DQG OLYLQJ ERGLHV DQG RIIHULQJ LW WR WKHODZDVDVDFULʳFH7KHSROLFHWKXVSHUIRUPVWKHIXQFWLRQRISURYLGLQJDYLFWLPIRU WKH ODZ ,W UHSURGXFHV WKH XQFHUWDLQW\ RI WKH WKUHDW WR WKH H[WHQW WKDW WKH YLFWLP LV FRLQFLGHQWDO 7KH ODWWHU LV FRLQFLGHQWDO EHFDXVH WKH ODZ FRQVWLWXWHV LWV RZQ XQGLIIH UHQWLDWHG RXWVLGH IURP ZKLFK LW LV LPSRVVLEOH WR LGHQWLI\ DQG H[WUDFW DQ\ SDUWLFXODU ERG\RQWKHJURXQGRIDQ\IRUPRISXUHO\UDWLRQDOUHDVRQLQJ7KLVLVZK\WKHQRWLRQV RIȣIDWHȤȣVDFULʳFHȤDQGȣYLFWLPȤFDQEHLQWURGXFHGKHUHZKLFKZHZLOOGHYHORSIXUWKHU ODWHU RQ )URP D VWULFW SHUVSHFWLYH RI ODZ SROLFH SURYLGHV LW ZLWK WKH HPSLULFDO RE MHFWVXSRQZKLFKLWFDQWKHQSHUIRUPLWVRSHUDWLRQVUHVXOWLQJLQDʳ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ȣVRZQH[DPSOHLQRUGHUWRVKRZWKHFRQFHSWXDOFRPSOH[LW\WKDWFDQEHGHYHORSHGIURP WKHSDUDGR[KHGHPRQVWUDWHGDQGWKDWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\JRDJDLQVWKLVEDVLFSUHPLVHVEXWLVUDWKHUDEOHWR GHIHQGDQGGHP\VWLI\KLVSRVLWLRQ$WOHDVWWKLVLVZKDWZHDUHDLPLQJDW ȣ/DZDVVXFKȤLVKHUHDQGIRUQRZXQGHUVWRRGQHLWKHUDVDWUDQVFHQGHQWQRUDVDWUDQVFHQGHQWDO HQWLW\EXWUDWKHUDVDQLGHDDQGDIDQWDV\VXSSRUWHGERWKE\WKHOHJDOV\VWHPDQGWKHUHSUHVVLYHDFWLYLWLHVRIWKH ȣDSSDUDWXVHVRIWKHVWDWHȤ,Q%HQMDPLQȣVFRQFHSWXDOLW\LWFRLQFLGHVZLWKWKHSRZHURIODZZKLFKUHVLGHVLQWKH VSKHUHRIIDWH7KHIDFWWKDWZHXQGHUVWDQGLWDVIDQWDV\GRHVQRWPHDQWKDWLWVHIIHFWXSRQUHDOLW\LVQXOOLʳHG QRWDWDOO%XWDWWKHVDPHWLPHWKLVLVQRWWKHSULPDU\SRLQWZHDUHPDNLQJKHUH:HZLOOWRXFKXSRQWKLVWKHPH DJDLQODWHURQZKHQZHZLOOEHDQDO\VLQJWKHLQʴXHQFHRI+DQV.HOVHQRQ)UHXGȣVFRQFHSWRIWKH6XSHUHJR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 42 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 2QWKHRQHKDQGWKHODZQHHGVWREHDSSOLHGLQRUGHUWREHDFWXDOEXWLWLVXQDEOH WRGRVRE\LWVHOI :KDWLVPRUHWKHODZLVXQDEOHWRDSULRULLGHQWLI\WKHHPSLULFDOREMHFWV ERGLHVWKDWFRUUHVSRQGWRLWVFDWHJRULHVDQGFDQQRWVLPSO\ʳOOWKHSRVLWLRQVGHʳQHGE\LW DVLWVREMHFWOHJDOVXEMHFWV$SUHVXSSRVLWLRQRIXQVSHFLʳ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ȣVJHQHUDOPRGHRIWKRXJKWWKDWLWLVH[DFWO\WKLVQHHGDQGDFW RIUHIHUUDOE\WKHSROLFHZKLFKSURYLGHVODZZLWKLWVSRZHUDFWXDOLVHVLWPHDQLQJWKDW LWQROHVVWKDQSURGXFHVLWLQLWVPDWHULDOUHDOLW\7KHH[WUHPLW\RIWKLVWKHVLVZKLFKXOWL PDWHO\GHQLHVODZLWVH[LVWHQFHEH\RQGLWVDFWXDOLVDWLRQE\WKHSROLFHEH\RQGLWVWKUHDW PHGLDWHGE\WKHSROLFHLVFRQFHSWXDOO\YLROHQWEXWVHUYHVRXUSXUSRVHRIJUDGXDOO\RXW OLQLQJDʳHOGRIWKRXJKWZHEHOLHYH%HQMDPLQKDVLQDXJXUDWHGZLWKKLVWH[W 7RDGYDQFHVWHSE\VWHSZHFDQʳUVWVWUHVVWKDWWKHDFWLYLW\RIWKHSROLFHLVQRW LGHQWLFDOZLWKWKHRUGHURIODZ$WʳUVWJODQFHWKLVJRHVDJDLQVW%HQMDPLQȣVHPSKDVLVEXW LWLVDFODLPWKDWIROORZVIURP%HQMDPLQȣVDQDO\VLVRIWKHLQVWLWXWLRQRISROLFH,QWKHLPD JLQDULXPRIWKHGHPRFUDWLFRUGHUWKHSUD[LVRIWKHSROLFHFDQLQGHHGVHHPWREHLGHQWL FDOZLWKWKHODZLHDGLUHFWPHDQVQRWKLQJEXWPHDQVWRDODZHVSHFLDOO\LQLQVWDQFHV ZKHUHWKHSROLFHVHHPVWRIROORZLWVWULFWO\%XW%HQMDPLQHPSKDVLVHVWKDWWKHSULYLOHJHG GRPDLQRIRSHUDWLRQRISROLFHLHZKHUHLWȣOLYHVXSWRLWVQDPHȤLVDVSDFHȣZKHUHQR FOHDUOHJDOVLWXDWLRQH[LVWVȤ,QVLWXDWLRQVZLWKQRFOHDUOHJDOLQGLFDWRUVRQKRZWRDFW WKHSROLFHKROGVWKHSRZHUWRLQYHQWDQGHQIRUFHGLUHFWLYHVDQGUHJXODWLRQVDQGLWLVWKLV ȣFUHDWLYHPRPHQWȤRIWKHSROLFHWKDWE\GHʳQLWLRQGRHVQRWIROORZODZEXWSUHFHGHVLW 7KLVSUHPLVHLVH[SOLFLWLQ&DUO6FKPLWWȣVZRUNZKLFKLVFORVHWR%HQMDPLQȣVZKRLQIDFWDGPLUHGLW LQRSSRVLWLRQWRDEVROXWHSROLWLFDOGLYLGHEHWZHHQWKHPȣ%HFDXVHWKHOHJDOLGHDFDQQRWrealiseLWVHOILWQHHGVD SDUWLFXODUorganisationDQGIRUPEHIRUHLWFDQEHWUDQVODWHGLQWRUHDOLW\Ȥ6FKPLWW 7KHIDPRXVȣEDUHOLIHȤPHQWLRQHGE\%HQMDPLQRIZKLFKEORRGLVWKHV\PERO%HQMDPLQ /DWHUGHYHORSHGE\*LRUJLR$JDPEHQVHH Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life 0HULGLDQ&URVVLQJ $HVWKHWLFV6WDQIRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV. 7KLVODFNRIFODULW\GRHVQRWRQO\FRUUHVSRQGWRWKHJHQHUDOXQFHUWDLQW\RIWKHOHJDOWKUHDWEXWLV DFWXDOO\SRVLWLYHO\VDQFWLRQHGE\VSHFLʳFODZVWKDWSXUSRVHIXOO\RSHQXSDQLQGHWHUPLQDWHʳHOGRIDFWLRQIRUWKH SROLFH$QH[DPSOHRIVXFKDODZLQ6ORYHQLDQOHJLVODWLRQLVWKH Act on the Protection of Public Peace and Order Zakon o javnem redu in miru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ilozofski_maraton_1.indd 43 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 ,WSUHFHGHVLWMXVWOLNHSURGXFWLRQSUHFHGHVWKHSURGXFW2QWKLVJURXQGLWFDQEHVDLG WKDW WKH DFWLYLW\ RI WKH SROLFH LV HVVHQWLDOO\ KHWHURJHQHRXV WR ODZ +RZ GRHV WKLV LQ FRKHUHQFH HPHUJH" %HQMDPLQȣV FRQFHSWXDO DPELWLRQ LV WR GHPRQVWUDWH WKH LQHYL WDELOLW\ RI YLROHQFH SUHVHQW LQ HVWDEOLVKHG LQVWLWXWLRQV DQG LQ SROLWLFDO FRQʴLFWV DQG WR GHPRQVWUDWH WKLV HVSHFLDOO\ LQ RSSRVLWLRQ WR WKH LGHDOLVWLF DQG OHJDOLVW OL EHUDO FRQFHSWLRQV RI ODZ VWDWH DQG LQVWLWXWLRQ EDVHG RQ WKH QRWLRQ RI FRQWUDFW 7KLVLVWKHUHDVRQKLVDQDO\VLVSURJUHVVHVIURPODZWRWKHSROLFHZKHUHWKHODWWHU IXQFWLRQVLQWKHWH[WDVWKHPRVWFRPSUHKHQVLYHFDVHRIYLROHQFHFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIODZ,W VHUYHV%HQMDPLQȤVWKHRUHWLFDOJRDORIPHUJLQJODZZLWKYLROHQFHZKLFKLVH[SOLFLWO\KRV WLOHWRSDFLʳVWDQGOLEHUDOLGHDVRIFRQVHQVXV:HDUHQRWRSSRVLQJWKLVDWDOOEXWLQVWHDG WU\LQJWRGHYHORSLWIXUWKHULQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIUHFRJQLVLQJGLIIHUHQWFRQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQV WKHPVHOYHVDVQRWRQO\ULJKWO\RUZURQJO\GHVFULELQJRUUHʴHFWLQJWKHȣDFWXDOȤZRUNLQJV RIODZDQGYLROHQFHEXWEHLQJDVFRQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQVSDUWRIWKLVVDPHUHDOLW\DQGKDYLQJ HIIHFWVZLWKLQWKHPHFKDQLVPVWKH\DUHVXSSRVHGO\RQO\UHIHUHQFLQJ7KLVLVZK\ WKHKLVWRULFDOPRPHQWRIHQXQFLDWLRQDSSHDUVWRWDNHHIIHFWLQGLVFRXUVHWKHTXHVWLRQ LVQRWZKHWKHUODZLVYLROHQWRUQRWEXWIURPZKHUHIURPZKLFKSHUVSHFWLYHLWLVLQKH UHQWO\YLROHQW"2ULQYHUVHO\IURPZKLFKSHUVSHFWLYHLWLVIXQGDPHQWDOO\QRQYLROHQW" ,I%HQMDPLQFRQFHSWXDOO\PHUJHGODZDQGYLROHQFHKHZDVDEOHWRGRVRRQO\ RQDVSHFLʳFFRQGLWLRQ+HʳUVWRIDOOKDGWRQRWWDNHWKHSRVLWLRQRIFODVVLFDOOLEHUDO SROLWLFDO SKLORVRSK\ LQ ZKLFK ODZ LV VHOIVXIʳFLHQW DQG DFWXDOLVHV IXOO\ LQ UHODWLRQ WR LWVHOI7KHSDWKOHDGLQJWRWKHFRQFHSWXDOLVDWLRQRIYLROHQFHIURPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIODZ ZRXOGKDYHEURXJKWKLPQRIXUWKHUWKDQWRWKHSDUDGLJPFDXJKWEHWZHHQWKHOLPLWVZH KDYHEHHQGHVFULELQJ+HUHWKHZRUGȣYLROHQFHȤHYHQVHHPVUHGXQGDQWVLQFHYLROHQFHLV WRWKHJUHDWHVWH[WHQWGLVVROYHGZLWKLQOHJDOLVWFDWHJRULHVRIHQGVDQGPHDQVDVZHKDYH VHHQ ZLWK +DQQDK$UHQGWȣV HVVD\ ,W LV WKXV RI QR FRLQFLGHQFH WKDW LQ OHJDO GLVFRXUVH ȣYLROHQFHȤEHFRPHVȣIRUFHȤȣOHJLWLPDWHIRUFHȤȣH[FHVVLYHIRUFHȤHWF7KHWHUPVȣOHJLWLPDWH YLROHQFHȤRUȣH[FHVVLYHYLROHQFHȤDUHDEVHQW VLQFHIROORZLQJRXUWKHVLVLIYLROHQFHLV OHJLWLPDWHLWORVHVLWVFKDUDFWHUDVYLROHQFHZKLOHLWLVH[FHVVLYHE\QDWXUHZKLFKLVZK\ WKHDGMHFWLYHȣH[FHVVLYHȤLVQRWQHHGHGȣH[FHVVLYHIRUFHȤLVZKDWGHVLJQDWHVYLROHQFHLQ WHUPVRIODZ7KHIDUWKHVWWKLVSDWKOHDGVLVWKHUHIRUHWKHFRQFHSWXDOOLPLWRIYLROHQFH DVDQH[FHVVVSHFLʳFDOO\DQH[FHVVRISRZHU%XWPRUHLPSRUWDQWO\WKDQVROHO\GLUHF WLQJFULWLTXHDWWKLVFRQFHSWXDOLQDELOLW\ZHDUHLQZKDWZHEHOLHYHWREHWKHȣVSLULWȤRI ȣ>/@LNHWKHRXWFRPHWKHRULJLQRIHYHU\FRQWUDFWDOVRSRLQWVWRZDUGYLROHQFH,WQHHGQRWEHGLUHFWO\ SUHVHQWLQLWDVODZPDNLQJYLROHQFHEXWLVUHSUHVHQWHGLQLWLQVRIDUDVWKHSRZHUWKDWJXDUDQWHHVDOHJDOFRQtract LVLQWXUQRIYLROHQWRULJLQHYHQLIYLROHQFHLVQRWLQWURGXFHGLQWRWKHFRQWUDFWLWVHOIȤ%HQMDPLQ 7KHH[SUHVVLRQȣOHJLWLPDWHYLROHQFHȤLVQRWDEVROXWHO\DEVHQWEXWZHEHOLHYHLWLVWREHIRXQGSUH GRPLQDQWO\LQWKHPRVWWKHRUHWLFDOSDUWRIOHJDOGLVFRXUVHZKLFKERUGHUVRQRWKHUʳHOGVRIVRFLDOVFLHQFHVDQG KXPDQLWLHV Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 44 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 %HQMDPLQDWWHPSWLQJWRUHFRQQHFWWKLVLQDELOLW\ZLWKLWVEDVHZKHUHLWFRPPHQFHVRQ WKHRQHKDQGZLWKDGLOXWLRQRIYLROHQFHE\MXGLFLDOSRZHULQWRȣOHJLWLPDWHXVHRIIRUFHȤ YLROHQFH DV PHDQV DQG RQ WKH RWKHU ZLWK D SDUWLFXODULVDWLRQ RI YLROHQFH RXWVLGH RI WKHODZWUDQVIRUPLQJLWLQWRFULPLQDOEUHDFKHVE\LQGLYLGXDOVȡDQXQOLPLWHGVHULHVRI SDUWLFXODUFUXPEVRIYLROHQFH,QWKHSDUDGLJPZHDUHDWWHPSWLQJWRGHʳ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ȣFRQGLWLRQVRISRVVLELOLW\ȤZKLFK FDQXQGRXEWHGO\EHWUDFHGWRKLVWKHRUHWLFDOUHIHUHQFHVDWWKDWWLPH*HRUJHV6RUHOKLV LQWHOOHFWXDOEDFNJURXQG-XGDLVPDQGHQYLURQPHQW*HUVKRP6FKROHP+RZHYHUWKH H[SOLFDWLRQRIDOORIWKHVHZRXOGGHPDQGPRUHWKDQZHFDQDIIRUGKHUHZKLOHLWLVDOVR DOUHDG\LWVRZQYDVWʳHOGRIUHVHDUFK7KLVLVZK\ZHDUHJRLQJWRIROORZZLWKWKHPRVW JHQHUDOREVHUYDWLRQZKLFKZHEHOLHYHLVFRQFHSWXDOO\GHFLVLYH %HQMDPLQEHJLQVKLV.ULWLNE\H[DPLQLQJWKHȣFUDFNVȤLQWKHRUGHURIODZZKLFK KDYH WKH IRUP RI FRQWUDGLFWLRQV DQG SDUDGR[HV VSHFLʳFDOO\ HPSKDVLVLQJ WKH FDVHV RI ZDUDQGZRUNHUVȣVWULNHDVZHKDYHVHHQ6HHPLQJO\LIZHIROORZWKHOLQHDURUGHURIWKH WH[WLWLVWKHVHLQFRQVLVWHQFLHVWKDWOHDGKLPWRYLROHQFHLPPDQHQWWRODZDQGPRGHUQ LQVWLWXWLRQV%XWKHGRHVQRWDFWXDOO\PRYHIURPODZWRYLROHQFHRQWKHFRQWUDU\KLV .ULWLNSUHVXSSRVHVYLROHQFHLQDZD\WKDWLWLVYLROHQFHZKLFKHVVHQWLDOO\FKDUDFWHULVHV WKHSRVLWLRQRUSHUVSHFWLYHIURPZKLFKKHGLUHFWVKLVFULWLTXHWRWKHYLROHQFHRIODZ,Q RUGHUWRELQGODZDQGYLROHQFHKHKDGWRWDNHWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIYLROHQFHIURPWKHVWDUW KH KDG WR SRVLWLRQ KLPVHOI RQ WKH JURXQG GHʳQHG E\ YLROHQFH DQG WDNH D ORRN DW ODZ IURPWKHUH,WLVRQO\IURPVXFKDSRVLWLRQWKDWODZLVHYLGHQWO\YLROHQWLQLWVHVVHQFH (YHQPRUHLQWKLVSHUVSHFWLYHLWLVQRWYLROHQFHWKDWLVWKHH[FHVVRIODZEXWLWLVODZ 20 ȣ:LWKLQWKHLQVWLWXWLRQDOIRUPVRISRZHUWKHLQWHUQDODPELJXLW\RIWKHZRUG Gewalt LVWHQGHQWLDOO\ GLVJXLVHGVRWKDWODZPDNLQJYLROHQFHWRZKLFKWKHOHJDOLQVWLWXWLRQRZHVLWVH[LVWHQFHGLVDSSHDUVEHKLQG ODZSUHVHUYLQJDGPLQLVWUDWLYHYLROHQFH)URPWKHSHUVSHFWLYHRIWKHVWDWHWKDWFODLPVDOHJDOO\VDQFWLRQHG PRQRSRO\RQYLROHQFHYLROHQFHLWVHOIDSSHDUVRQO\DVDQH[WHUQDOGLVWXUEDQFHUHYROXWLRQLQVXUUHFWLRQFULPH XQODZIXOEHKDYLRXUȤ.KDWLE,IZHFRQQHFWWKLVWRRXULQLWLDOSUREOHPRIWKHȣIRUPRIH[SXOVLRQȤZH FDQVD\WKDWLWKDVWZREUDQFKHVSDUWLFXODULVDWLRQZKLFKPHDQVWKHUHODWLRQEHWZHHQWKHODZDQGLWVREMHFW DQGȣSURMHFWLRQȤZKHUHDVSHFLʳFRUGHURIODZLVWKUHDWHQHGE\DQRWKHUDWOHDVWSRWHQWLDORUGHURIODZ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 45 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 ZKLFKLVQRWKLQJEXWDSDUWLFXODUIRUPDWLRQDȣVROLGLʳFDWLRQȤ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ȣGLYLQHYLROHQFHȤ %HIRUHGLVFXVVLQJWKHVHZHZLOOʳUVWHODERUDWHRQWKHWKLUGUHDVRQWKDWZHKDYHDOUHDG\ WRXFKHGXSRQȡ%HQMDPLQȣVXVHRIȣH[DPSOHVȤVSHFLʳFDOO\WKHSROLFHLQKLVDUJXPHQW $VZHKDYHVHHQLWFDQEHDUJXHGWKDWWKHSROLFHLVLQLWVSUDFWLFHKHWHURJHQHRXV WRODZEXWWKDWDWWKHVDPHWLPHLWQHHGVWRUHIHUWRODZLQRUGHUWRVHFXUHLWVRZQVWDWXV RIOHJDOLW\DQGRUOHJLWLPDF\$QGLWLVLQWKLVDFWRIUHIHUUDOWKDWLWVXPPRQVWKHSRZHU RIWKH/DZEH\RQGVSHFLʳFODZV 21 RIDVSHFLʳFVWDWH7KLVLVEHFDXVHWKHQHHGIRUUHIHUUDOLV SULPDU\WRSDUWLFXODUODZVDPRQJZKLFKWKHVHDUFKIRUWKHDSSURSULDWHRQHXQIROGVEXW RQO\DVDVHFRQGDU\DFWLRQ6WUXFWXUDOO\WKLVQHHGSUHVXSSRVHVWKH/DZEHIRUHLWDSSUH KHQGVDQ\RIWKHDFWXDOODZVZKLFKLVDPHFKDQLVPWLHGZLWK%HQMDPLQȣVVSKHUHRIIDLWK $VWKHIXQGDPHQWDOFRQFHSWRI%HQMDPLQȣVSROLWLFDOWKHRORJ\WKHODWWHUWKXV GHVLJQDWHVWKHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQDODZDQGWKH/DZWKH/DZEHLQJDQHFHVVDU\SUH VXSSRVLWLRQDFRQGLWLRQRISRVVLELOLW\RIDODZ,QWKLVVHQVHWKHDFWRIUHIHUUDOSRVLWL YHO\SURGXFHV/DZRUDWOHDVWSDUWLFLSDWHVLQLWVSURGXFWLRQ 22 LIWKHUHDUHRWKHULQVWDQFHV RI SURGXFWLRQ LQYROYHGȡ DQG ZH ZRXOG QRW EH ZURQJ WR VD\ WKHUH DUH 7KH SDUDGR[ LVWKDWODZDQGWKHSROLFHDUHLQWHUGHSHQGHQWDQGSURYLGHHDFKRWKHUZLWKQHFHVVDU\ HYHQHVVHQWLDOIXQFWLRQVEXWWKH\GRVRZLWKRXWWKHLUUHVSHFWLYHSURFHGXUHVIRUPLQJD XQLʳ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ʳUPWKDWLWLVQRWRQO\DQH[WHQVLRQRIWKHODZEXWDQLQGHSHQGHQWLQVWLWXWLRQWR ZKLFKWKHODZLVRQO\VHFRQGDULO\DSSOLHGZKHQWKHUHLVHQRXJKSXEOLFRURWKHUSUHVVXUH$OVRLQWKHFRQWH[WRI ODZDQGYLROHQFHDVPHDQVZHDUHPDNLQJQRUHDOGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQOHJLWLPDF\DQGOHJDOLW\HYHQWKRXJKLW FDQRUVKRXOGEHDUJXHGLQRWKHUFRQWH[WV 22 ȣ/DZȤGHVLJQDWHVQRWKLQJEXWWKHRSHUDWLRQRIODZ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 46 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 HDFKRWKHUDVSURGXFWLRQV7KLVLVKRZWKH\DUHVWUDQJHO\WLHGWRHDFKRWKHUE\WKHDFWRI UHIHUUDOPHGLDWHGWKURXJKWKHVSKHUHRIIDLWKZKHUH/DZLVSURGXFHGDVDVKDUHGHQWLW\ EHWZHHQERWK:HDUHQRZDEOHWREHWWHUXQGHUVWDQGWKHSDUDGR[LFDOFKDUDFWHURIWKHLU UHODWLRQVKLS ZKLFK LV ERWK KRPRJHQHRXV DQG KHWHURJHQHRXV DW WKH VDPH WLPH LW LV KRPRJHQHRXVRQWKHOHYHORIȣH[FKDQJHȤZKHUHDFRPPRQDQGQHFHVVDU\LPDJRRIODZ LVSURGXFHGZKDWZHDUHFDOOLQJWKH/DZDQGLWLVKHWHURJHQHRXVRQWKHOHYHORISUR GXFWLRQZKHUHWKHSURGXFWLRQRISROLFHFDQQRWEHVXEVXPHGXQGHUODZRUYLFHYHUVD (YHQ WKRXJK ZH DUH D VWHS RXWVLGH RI %HQMDPLQȣ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ʳQHG E\ODZ7KLVKROGVLPSRUWDQWORJLFDOFRQVHTXHQFHVIRUZKDWZHDUHVHDUFKLQJIRULH ZKDWZHFDOOHG%HQMDPLQȣVȥSRVLWLRQȣRUȥSHUVSHFWLYHȤKHWHURJHQHLW\RUZKDWDPRXQWV WRWKHVDPHDXWRQRP\RIYLROHQFHFDQQRWEHVHHQIURPDQ\ZKHUHVSHFLʳFDOO\LWFDQ QRWEHVHHQIURPLQVLGHRIWKHGLVFRXUVHRIODZ:KDWWKHQLVWKHSRVLWLRQIURPZKLFK WKLVGLVWLQFWLRQLVREYLRXV"3URYLVLRQDOO\ZHFDQQDPHWKLVWKHSRVLWLRQRIYLROHQFHD SHUVSHFWLYHIURPZKLFKHYHU\WKLQJLVUHJDUGHGLQWHUPVRIYLROHQFHMXVWDVHYHU\WKLQJ ȣ7KHDVVHUWLRQWKDWWKHHQGVRISROLFHYLROHQFHDUHDOZD\VLGHQWLFDORUHYHQFRQQHFWHGWRWKRVHRI JHQHUDOODZLVHQWLUHO\XQWUXH5DWKHUWKHȣODZȤRIWKHSROLFHUHDOO\PDUNVWKHSRLQWDWZKLFKWKHVWDWHZKHWKHU IURPLPSRWHQFHRUEHFDXVHRIWKHLPPDQHQWFRQQHFWLRQVZLWKLQDQ\OHJDOV\VWHPFDQQRORQJHUJXDUDQWHH WKURXJKWKHOHJDOV\VWHPWKHHPSLULFDOHQGVWKDWLWGHVLUHVDWDQ\SULFHWRDWWDLQȤ%HQMDPLQ 7RJRHYHQIXUWKHUZHFRXOGSRVHWKDWODZLVGURZQHGLQYLROHQFHSUHFLVHO\DVDVXSSRVHGHQGWKDW OHJLWLPLVHVYLROHQFHLQWKHFRQVFLRXVQHVVHVRIWKHLQYROYHGDFWRUVPHDQLQJWKDWODZLVGURZQHGLQYLROHQFH LQRQHDQGWKHVDPHDFWDVYLROHQFHLVGLVVROYHGE\ODZZKLFKZRXOGPDNHWKHVHWZRSURFHGXUHVMXVWWKHWZR GLUHFWLRQVRIRQHDQGWKHVDPHPRYHPHQW7KH\ZRXOGEHDEVROXWHO\FRPPHQVXUDEOHDQGZHZRXOGEHDEOH WRH[SUHVVRQHLQWHUPVRIWKHRWKHULQERWKGLUHFWLRQV%XWWKHUHLVDQLPSRUWDQWGLIIHUHQFHDGLVV\PPHWU\DW ZRUNKHUHVLQFHRQHWDNHVSODFHLQWKHVRFLDOʳHOGDQGWKHRWKHULQWKHVWDJHRIFRQVFLRXVQHVV,QWKHFDVHRIWKH ODWWHUWKHUHLVQRWKLQJQHFHVVDU\DERXWLWVSKHQRPHQDOLW\ODZHQIRUFHUVDFWLQJDVWKHSHUSHWUDWRUVRIYLROHQFH QHHGQRWVXEMHFWLYHO\LPDJLQHWKHLUDFWLRQVDVPHDQVWRDODZIXOHQGHYHQLIWKLVLVSUHVXPDEO\WKHXVXDOFDVH 7KH\FDQDOVRLPDJLQHLWDVȣRQO\GRLQJWKHLUMREȤRUDQ\RWKHUZD\:KDWHYHQPRUHFOHDUO\EHWUD\VWKLVODFN RIQHFHVVLW\EHWZHHQFRQVFLRXVQHVVDQGWKHFRQWHQWRIODZDVDQHQGLVWKHF\QLFLVPLQUHODWLRQWRODZWKDW UHJXODUO\DFFRPSDQLHVWKHHQIRUFLQJRILWE\WKHFRQFUHWHHQIRUFHUV)LQDOO\DQGPRVWFUXFLDOO\WKHLQFRPPHQ VXUDELOLW\DQGGLVWLQFWLRQRIWKHWZRSURFHGXUHVFRPHVH[SOLFLWO\WROLJKWZKHQZHDFWXDOO\WDNHLQWRDFFRXQW all WKHLQYROYHGDFWRUVPHDQLQJDOVRWKHRQHVZKRDUHRQWKHUHFHLYLQJHQGRISROLFHYLROHQFH)RUWKRVHYLROHQFH LVQRWKLQJEXWYLROHQFHVLQFHWKHUHLVQRVHQVHLQMXVWLI\LQJWKHLURZQSDLQVDQGZRXQGVZLWKODZ2QWKHRWKHU KDQGWKHLQYHUVHIRUPXODȣODZDVDPHDQVRIYLROHQFHȤGRHVPDNHVHQVHLIZHDFNQRZOHGJHWKHSULPDF\RI YLROHQFHRYHUODZODZDVDQDGGLWLRQDOVWURNHRIYLROHQFH Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 47 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 LVUHJDUGHGLQOHJDOWHUPVIURPWKHSRVLWLRQRIODZ+RZHYHUWKLVGRHVQRWPHDQWKDW WKHVH WZR SHUVSHFWLYHV DUH IRUPDOO\ KRPRORJRXV 7KLV GHVLJQDWLRQ LV UDWKHU QRPLQDO LWIXQFWLRQVDVDSURYLVLRQDOWKHVLVIRURSHQLQJDSRVVLELOLW\RIDWKHRUHWLFDOOHDS,IRXU UHDVRQLQJLVYDOLG%HQMDPLQȣVFULWLTXHRSHQVXSWKLVGLPHQVLRQRIWKRXJKW BENJAMIN AGAINST KANT .DQWȣVFDWHJRULFDOLPSHUDWLYHSURFODLPVWKDWRQHVKRXOGȣDFWRQO\DFFRUGLQJWR WKDWPD[LPZKHUHE\\RXFDQDWWKHVDPHWLPHZLOOWKDWLWVKRXOGEHFRPHDXQLYHUVDO ODZȤ.DQW)RU%HQMDPLQWKLVLVQRWSRVVLEOHDWDOOVLQFHLWLVQRWSRVVLEOHWRWLH KXPDQDFWLRQVWRHQGVQRULVLWSRVVLEOHWRWLHWKHPWRRWKHUDFWLRQVDVH[DPSOHVWKDW FRXOGEHFODVVLʳHGRUJHQHUDOLVHG,QWKHZRUGVRID%HQMDPLQVFKRODU6DPL.KDWLEȣThe UHDVRQIRUWKLVLVLQWKHDEVWUDFWLRQIURPWKHFRQFUHWHKLVWRULFDOVLWXDWLRQVWKDWDUHLI ZHFRQVLGHUWKHPJHQHUDOL]DEOHGHFODUHGDVDQDKLVWRULFDOSUHFHGHQWRQWKHJURXQGRI ZKLFKZHDUHDEOHWRMXGJHRWKHUXQLTXHVLWXDWLRQVZKLOHGLVUHJDUGLQJWKHLUKLVWRULFDO LQGH[%XWDFFRUGLQJWR%HQMDPLQDVSHFLʳFDFWLRQFDQRQO\EHWLHGWRWKHXQLYHUVDOPR UDOODZRUPD[LPLQWKHVHQVHRIRULHQWDWLRQDQGQRWLQYHUVHO\UHJDUGHGDVDQH[DPSOH RIXVHDQGDSRVWHULRUSUHFHGHQWRIDFHUWDLQJHQHUDOLW\Ȥ.KDWLE 6FKHPDWLFDOO\VSHDNLQJ%HQMDPLQRSSRVHVWKHKLVWRULFDOVLQJXODULW\RIDVLWXD WLRQDVLQJXODUFDVHWRWKHJHQHUDOL]DWLRQRIODZRUQRUPZLWKLWVSDUWLFXODUDSSOLFD WLRQVFRQVWLWXWLQJH[DPSOHVZKHUHLQWKHFDVHRIWKHIRUPHUWKHVHKLVWRULFDOO\VLQJXODU VLWXDWLRQVLQFDSDFLWDWHDOOSURVSHFWRIJHQHUDOLVDELOLW\ZKHUHDVLQWKHFDVHRIWKHODWWHU WKHJHQHUDOIRUPWKHOHJDOIRUPVXEVXPHVWKHFRQFUHWHKLVWRULFDOVLWXDWLRQVXQGHULWV UXOH,Q*URXQGZRUNRIWKH0HWDSK\VLFVRI0RUDOVZKHUHKHGHYHORSVKLVFDWHJRULFDOLP SHUDWLYH.DQWGLVWLQJXLVKHVEHWZHHQWKHȣXQLYHUVDOLW\>$OOJHPHLQKHLW@RIWKHSULQFLSOH XQLYHUVDOLWDVȤ and a ȣPHUH JHQHUDO YDOLGLW\ >*HPHLQJ¾OWLJNHLW@ JHQHUDOLWDVȤ .DQW ,QKLVH[SRVLWLRQRISUDFWLFDOUHDVRQWKH\DUHQRWFRPSDUDEOHLQDPRUDOsense, VLQFHRQO\WKHFDWHJRULFDOLPSHUDWLYHDVDIRUPDOUXOHHQVXUHVWKHDVFHQWIURPDPD[LPWR DXQLYHUVDOSUDFWLFDOODZZKLFKLVDEOHWRȣGHWHUPLQHWKHZLOODVZLOOȤ7KLVGHWHUPLQDWLRQ VKRXOGEHLQGHSHQGHQWRIȣFRQGLWLRQVWKDWDUHSDWKRORJLFDODQGWKHUHIRUHRQO\FRQWLQ JHQWO\FRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHZLOOȤ.DQW7KHZLOOVKRXOGEHGHWHUPLQHGWKURXJK IRUPDQGQRWPDWWHUVLQFHLWLVRQO\IRUPWKDWHQVXUHVWKHXQLYHUVDOLW\RIDODZȣ(PSLULFDO GHWHUPLQLQJJURXQGVDUHQRWʳWIRUDQ\XQLYHUVDOH[WHUQDOOHJLVODWLRQDQGDUHQRPRUHʳW IRULQWHUQDOODZJLYLQJȤ.DQW8QLYHUVDOLW\E\IRUPLVWKXVUHDFKHGE\ZD\RI DVHSDUDWLRQRIODZIURPHYHU\WKLQJPDWHULDOWKDWLVIURPHYHU\SRVVLEOHHPSLULFDORE MHFWRIZLOO)RU.DQWWKHHPSLULFDODQGWKHPDWHULDOKROGWKHWLWOHRISDWKRORJ\7KHPR UDOODZLVPRGHOOHGDIWHUWKHODZVRIQDWXUHDQGVSHFLʳFDOO\WKHLUXQLYHUVDOLW\ZKLFKLQ ȣ>7@KHXQLYHUVDOLPSHUDWLYHRIGXW\FRXOGDOVREHH[SUHVVHGDVIROORZVVRDFWDVLIWKHPD[LPRI Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 48 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 WKHFRQWH[WRIWKHHPHUJLQJQDWXUDOVFLHQFHVVLJQLʳHV WKHDEVHQFHRIDQH[FHSWLRQ.DQW DOORZVIRUȣH[FHSWLRQVȤDVSDUWLFXODUGHYLDWLRQVIURPWKHPRUDOODZLQDFWXDOFRQGXFWEXW WKHVHDUHXQGHUVWRRGDVHPSLULFDORFFXUUHQFHVWKDWGRQRWWDLQWWKHXQLYHUVDOLW\RIWKHFD WHJRULFDOLPSHUDWLYHVLQFHWKH\UHSUHVHQWȣDUHVLVWDQFHRILQFOLQDWLRQWRWKHSUHVFULSWLRQ RIUHDVRQȤ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ȡD SRVLWLRQKHOGE\WKHFDWHJRULFDOLPSHUDWLYHLWVHOI $VZHKDYHVHHQ%HQMDPLQRQWKHRWKHUKDQGLQWURGXFHVDQDEVROXWHFRQFHSWXDO VHSDUDWLRQRIMXVWLʳHGPHDQVDQGMXVWHQGVZKLFKLQWXUQLPSOLHVDVHSDUDWLRQRIHQGV DQGODZDVZHOODVDUHMHFWLRQRIWKHSUDFWLFDOLW\RISXUHUHDVRQ7KLVVHSDUDWLRQWKURZV light on ȣWKHXOWLPDWHLQVROXELOLW\>8QHQWVFKHLGEDUNHLW@RIDOOOHJDOSUREOHPVȤ%HQMDPLQ P\HPSKDVLVZKLFKZHFDQUHJDUGDVDNH\FKDUDFWHULVWLFRIODZIRU%HQMD PLQDQLGHDKHVKDUHVZLWK 6FKPLWW,IIRU.DQWSXUHUHDVRQLVSUDFWLFDODQGKHDWWHPSWV WRSURYHWKLVE\GHYHORSLQJWKHPRUDOODZLQLWVSXUHIRUPPRGHOOLQJLWDIWHUQDWXUDO ODZVWKHLUXQLYHUVDOLW\DQGWKHLUREMHFWLYLW\DQGWKXVVXUSDVVLQJPD[LPVDVVXEMHFWLYH SULQFLSOHVWKDWLQKXPDQDFWLRQXVXDOO\GHWHUPLQHWKHJURXQGRIWKHZLOO.DQW %HQMDPLQVHYHUVWKLVERQGEHWZHHQSXUHUHDVRQDQGLWVSUDFWLFDODELOLW\LP SOLFLWO\ VXJJHVWLQJ ZLWK KLV ȣXOWLPDWH LQVROXELOLW\ >8QHQWVFKHLGEDUNHLW@ RI DOO OHJDO SUREOHPVȤ WKDW ODZ LV DEVROXWHO\ GHWDFKHG IURP KXPDQ DFWLRQ DQG UDWKHU FORVHG LQ RQLWVHOILIZHFRQFHLYHRILWDVWKHKLJKHVWH[SUHVVLRQRIUHDVRQ,QRUGHUIRUWKLVVH SDUDWLRQWRH[LVWDQGIRUODZWRQHYHUWKHOHVVKROGDSULYLOHJHGSRVLWLRQLQUHODWLRQWR WKH VSKHUH RI KXPDQ DFWLRQȡ SULYLOHJHG WR WKH H[WHQW WKDW LW VHHPV DV LI LW GHWHUPL QHVLWRULVDWOHDVWDEOHWRGHWHUPLQHLWȡLWGHSHQGVRQDWKLUGHOHPHQWDQLQGHSHQ GHQWHOHPHQWQRWWKRXJKWE\.DQWȡYLROHQFHȡZKLFKUHSODFHVUHDVRQDVWKHXOWLPDWH SRLQWRIUHIHUHQFHȡWRUHLWHUDWH%HQMDPLQȣVFHQWUDOVWDWHPHQWȣ)RULWLVQHYHUUHDVRQ WKDW GHFLGHV RQ WKH MXVWLʳFDWLRQ RI PHDQV DQG WKH MXVWQHVV RI HQGV IDWHLPSRVHG YLROHQFH GHFLGHV RQ WKH IRUPHU DQG *RG RQ WKH ODWWHUȤ %HQMDPLQ P\ HP \RXUDFWLRQVZHUHWREHFRPHE\\RXUZLOOD81,9(56$//$:2)1$785(Į.DQWȣ ȣ8QHQWVFKHLGEDUNHLWĮFRXOGDOVREHWUDQVODWHGDVȣXQGHFLGDELOLW\ȤRUȣLQGHFLVLRQȤ. Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 49 27. 10. 2022 11:16:18 SKDVLV ,I %HQMDPLQ PDNHV .DQWLDQ UHDVRQ UHGXQGDQW LQ UHODWLRQ WR WKH VSKHUH RI KXPDQ DFWLRQ DQG WR WKH IXQFWLRQLQJ RI ODZ KH QHYHUWKHOHVV UHWDLQV WKH IXQFWLRQ RI GHFLVLRQ ,Q .DQWȣV YLHZ GHFLVLRQ ZRXOG IDOO LQWR WKH FDWHJRU\ RI WKH H[FHSWLRQ HYHQ WKHFDWHJRU\RIDWDLQWHGHPSLULFDOZKHUHDVZLWK%HQMDPLQLWLVH[DFWO\WKLVȣH[FHSWLRQȤ WKDW HYHU\WKLQJ GHSHQGV RQ 7KLV LV DOVR WKH SRLQW IURP ZKLFK LW ZRXOG EH HUURQHRXV WRFRQWLQXHZLWKRXW6FKPLWKLVSUR[LPLW\WR%HQMDPLQDQGPRUHVRWKHLUGLIIHUHQFHV Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 50 27. 10. 2022 11:16:19 BIBLIOGRAPHY $UHQGW+DQQDK2Q9LROHQFH6DQ'LHJR+DUFRXUW%UDFH-RYDQRYLFK3XEOLVKHUV %DOLEDU(WLHQQH6WUDK3UHG0QRĤLFDPL/MXEOMDQD6WXGLDKXPDQLWDWLV %DOLEDU(WLHQQH5HʴHFWLRQVRQ*HZDOWY+LVWRULFDO0DWHULDOLVPYROȡ /HLGHQ%ULOO3XEOLVKHUV %DOLEDU(WLHQQH9LROHQFHDQG&LYLOLW\1HZȬ@ÍHYʳOR]RʳMLQLELORQLNROLWHOHVDUD]HQRGGXďHSRGUXJLVWUDQLYOLWHUDWXUL QL QLÍHVDU GUXJHJD UD]HQ WHOHV NDU EL ODKNR GHMDOL ]D XPHWQRVW QDVSORK 9HQGDU QDP OLWHUDWXUDȡ DOL YVDM WLVWD LQWHUSUHWDFLMD OLWHUDWXUH LQ XPHWQRVWL NL MR MH ĤH GRMHOD NRW LQNDUQDFLMR ʳOR]RʳMH >Ȭ@ȡ SULND]XMH WUL VWYDUL REHQHP ERGLVLʳNFLMRLJURUHSUH]HQWDFLMNLVHWHGRWDNQHMR]DJRWRYRVWUDKLQĤDORVW VPHKLQPLPLNULMDWRGD]QHNLPGRWLNRPNLMHVDPGRMHWNRWʳNWLYHQXEUDQ MHQ RGPDNQMHQ ] HQR EHVHGRȥGXKRYHQȣ SUDYR YSUDďDQMH GRWLND LQ OLWHUDUQH WHU XPHWQLďNH VHQ]LELOQRVWL QDVSORK SUDYR YSUDďDQMH HVWHWLNH RVWDMD EROM DOL PDQM RGSUWR WROLNR NROLNRU VR WHOHVD SUHGYVHP R]QDÍHYDOFL >Ȭ@ ,ELG Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 83 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 1DVOLNDQDWHOHVDODKNRUD]XPHPRWXGLNRWSROLWLÍQD 3ROLWLÍQRWHORȯMHWDYWRORJLMDDOLQDMPDQMHYLGHQFD]DYVRWUDGLFLMRNDWHUHNROLĤH VRQMHQHUD]QHʳJXUH3ROLWLÍQDXWHPHOMLWHYSRÍLYDQDWHMDEVROXWQRR]QDÍHYDOQL NURĤQRVWL GD QDM LPD VNXSQRVW ]D VYRM VPLVHO WHOR LQ GD QDM LPD WHOR ]D VYRM VPLVHOVNXSQRVW'DQDMLPDWHORVNXSQRVWȡQMHQHLQVWLWXFLMHȡ]DVYRM]QDNLQGD QDMLPDVNXSQRVWWHORȡNUDOMDDOL]ERUȡ]DVYRM]QDN1HVNRQÍQDSUHGSRVWDYND MHWRUHMQHNRWHORVNXSQRVWNLQRVLVVHERMGYRMHLPSOLNDFLM3RHQLVWUDQLLPD WHOR QDVSORK ]D VYRM VPLVHO VYRMR ODVWQR RUJDQVNR LQWLPQRVW VYRM ÍXWLWLVH LQ GRWLNDWLVHVXEMHNWDUHVLQH[WHQVDGUXJDÍHUHÍHQRWHORLPD]DVYRMVPLVHODE VROXWQRLQYFHORWLVDPVPLVHO3RGUXJLVWUDQLNRUHODWLYQRLQGLYLGXDOX]XUDQD WHOHVDVLVRSULSDGDMR]QRWUDMQHNHJDVNXSQHJDWHOHVDNMHUVXEVWDQFDSRQRY QRUHVLQH[WHQVDSRQXMDWHPHOM]DUD]NULWMHSROLWLÍQHVNULYQRVWL,ELGȡ 1DVOLNDQD WHOHVD Y VOLNDK 'REUDMF ODKNR UD]XPHPR NRW RERMH SUDY ]DWR NHU VR QDVOLNDQD LQ GUXJRWQD RG ʳOR]RIVNHJD WHOHVD SUL NDWHUHP MH ORNXV UD]LVNRYDQMD GXďD XNYDUMDMR VH ] GRORÍHQR UHSUH]HQWDFLMR WHU VH V ʳNWLYQLP GRWLNRP GRWLNDMR JOH GDOFD NL RE JOHGDQMX YHÍLQH VOLN VNR]L GRWLN L]NXďD GRORÍHQR VWRSQMR JUR]OMLYRVWLȡ GDV 8QFKHLPOLFKH .OMXE WHPX SUHY]DPHMR WXGL L]MHPQR SROLWLÍQR VWDQFR VDM VR GREHVHG QRXWHOHďHQD VNXSQRVW ȡ SRVWDMDMR ]QDN VNXSQRVWL LQ REHQHP VL MLK SULSDGQLFH VNXS QRVWL ODKNR Y]DPHMR NRW VYRM VPLVHO UHSUH]HQWDFLMH 6OLNH VH QDV GRWDNQHMR V VYRMR VSRURÍLOQRVW WD GRWLN NL MH VPLVHO RUJDQVNH LQWLPQRVWL SRVWDQH VPLVHO GUXJHJD WHOHVD 7HOHVDNLWDNRSRQD]DUMDMRGRORÍHQRSROLWLÍQRWHORWXGLQDďHGUXĤEHSRVWDQHMR PHVWRGRWLND]JOHGDOFHPSRVDPH]QLNRP2EHQHPQDVWXGLVDPDSRVWDYLWHYXSRGREOMHQN YL]UD]LWRPRďNHSRORĤDMHPRÍLVSRPQLWXGLQDWRGDVRYQHNDWHULKSULPHULKXSRGREOMHQH NRW ]JRGRYLQVNL LPHWQLNL PRÍL 'HNOLFD NL QD VOLNL 0HODPHODPHODPHODQFKROLD 0RQ &KHUVHGLQDVWROXYHQDNLSR]LNRWVRYSUHWHNORVWLVHGHOLNUDOMLDOLSDSHĤLMHSULND]DQD NRWSROLWLÍQRWHORGUĤDYHVWHPSDďHEROMSRWUMXMHVYRMRSR]LFLRQLUDQRVWNRWSROLWLÍQRWHOR 8SRUDEDSROLWLÍQLKWHPMHYVOLNDUVWYX7LQH'REUDMFSULVRWQDWDPNMHUSUHNRVYRMHJDJOH GDQMDLQLQWHUSUHWLUDQMDGRORÍHQHJDGRJRGNDXSRGRELLQVWHPXWHOHVLSROLWLNRVNXSQRVW 9SUDďDQMHRGRWLNXXPHWQRVWLMHNRWMHSRXGDULOWXGL1DQF\YHVWHWLNLSHUHÍHRG SUWRYSUDďDQMHVDMVHQDVQDÍHORPDGRWLND]JROMQHNDMNDUUD]XPHPRNRWWHOHVQRʳ]LÍQR YHQGDUȡDOLODKNRJRYRULPRRGRWLNXQHÍHVDNDUMHWHOHVQRNRWVRWRQSUQDVOLNDQDWHOHVD YHQGDUQLʳ]LÍQRQLWHORYNUďÍDQVNHPVPLVOXQDYGDKQMHQR]GXKRP" 3R /DFDQX MH LPDJR SRGRED SRVUHGQLN PHG QRWUDQMLP VYHWRP LQ VYHWRP NL QDVRENURĤDQDWDQÍQHMH]UFDOQLVWDGLMYNDWHUHPVHRWURNSUHSR]QDNRWVXEMHNWYVYRML ]UFDOQL SRGREL SURL]YHGH UD]XPHYDQMH QRWUDQMHJD LQ ]XQDQMHJD VYHWD PHGVHERMQR SR YHĤHRUJDQL]HP]QMHJRYRUHDOQRVWMR/DFDQ6DPDSRGREDWDNRSRVWDQHSRYH zaYDPHGQDďLPLQ]XQDQMLPVYHWRPȡSRGREDMHWRUHMWLVWDNLQDVQDďRELWSRYHĤH] *UR]OMLYRVWVWRSQMXMHMRSUHGYVHPPDVNHNLVHQDPNDĤHMRNRWGHOQDVOLNDQHUHVQLÍQRVWLNLMHGUX JDÍQDRGQDďHVWHPNRL]NXďDPRVDPRJUR]OMLYRVWXSRGREOMHQHJDSDVHQDVVOLNDGRWDNQHÍHSUDYVHQDVODKNR GRWDNQHWXGLÍHRQMHMUD]PLďOMDPRNRWRUHSUH]HQWLUDQHPSUHPLVOHNXRSRORĤDMXĤHQVNYGDQDďQMLGUXĤEL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 84 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 ]XQDQMRVWMR UHDOQLP VYHWRP 3RGREH 7LQH 'REUDMF Y NDWHULK ODKNR SUHSR]QDPR QDP HQDNHJDVXEMHNWDVRWLVWHNLQDVSUHNRQDSHOMDYQDUHVQLÍQLVYHWWXGLSRYHĤHMR]QMLPLQ QDPVYHWNDNUďHQMHSULNDĤHMRVNR]LVYRMRODVWQR]UFDOQRSRGRERVYHWD6WHPNRQDP NDĤHMRQDďVYHWSUHNRVYRMHJDXQLYHU]XPDNRWGRPDÍHQLQQDPSR]QDQGRVHĤHMRGRWLN XSRGREOMHQLKWHOHVVSRURÍHYDOFHYLQQDďLKʳ]LÍQLKWHOHVNLSDVRSUDYWDNRR]QDÍHYDOFL ENEMY OF THE STATE I (2019): ŠTUDIJA PRIMERA Slika Enemy of the State I MH QDVWDOD SROHWL NRW RG]LY QD VSUHMHP LQWHU YHQWQHJD]DNRQDYNDWHUHPMHYODGD5HSXEOLNH6ORYHQLMHSUHGYLGHODRGVWUHOUMDYLK PHGYHGRYLQYRONRY1DVOLNLODKNRYLGLPRGHNOHNLQDPNDĤHKUEHWUDKORSULY]GLJXMH VYRMH NULOR LQ VH REUDÍD SURWL PHGYHGX NL MH SRVWDYOMHQ Y GUXJL SODQ REGDMDWD MX MDVD LQ JR]G DWPRVIHUD VOLNH L]ĤDUHYD VYRMHYUVWQR DSRNDOLSWLÍQRVW 3RYUďLQR SODWQD Y NYD ]LSUYHP SODQX SUHNULYDMR YHOLNH UGHÍH URĤH NL VSRPLQMDMR QD VWUHOQH UDQH UD]OLÍQH YH]HQLQHSODWQRMHWXGLQHNROLNRQDSUDVNDQR ,]VOLNH]HYDGRORÍHQDPHUDQDVLOMDSUHGQDVMHSRVWDYOMHQWLVRYUDĤQLNGUĤDYH SUHGNDWHUHJDVPRSRVWDYOMHQLPLJOHGDOFLPHGQDPLLQVRYUDĤQLNRPSDVWRMLGHNOLFD NLVHPHGYHGX]RSHUVWDYLWDNRGDUDKORSULY]GLJQHNULORLQSRNDĤHGHO]DGQMHSODWL9HQ GDUNULODQHY]GLJXMHSURWLPHGYHGXNDUMHSULVRWQRSUL]JRGEDKRĤHQVNDKNLVRSUHG SRďDVWMRSULY]GLJQLOHVYRMHNULORWDSDVHMHĤHQVNHJDJROHJDWHOHVDWDNRXVWUDďLODGDMH SUHNOLFDODVYRMRJURĤQMRLQSUL]QDODVYRMSRUD]WHPYHÍJDSULY]GLJXMHQDPJOHGDOFHP 6HYHGDQHPRUHPRYHGHWLDOLERNULORSULY]GLJQLODWXGLREUQMHQDNPHGYHGXYHQGDUVH ]GLGDWHJDQHQDPHUDYDVWRULWL7DNRVHPSULPRUDQDSUHY]HWLVWDOLďÍHGDGHNOLFDVYRMR ]DGQMRSODWNDĤH]JROMQDPVWHPSDMHQMHQRWHORSULND]DQRWDNRGDMHODKNRIHWLďL]LUDQR VDMYLGLPR]JROMGHOQMHQHJDWHOHVD 3RIUHXGRYVNLWHRULMLMHUD]YRMIHWLďDREUDPEQLVLVWHPSUHGVWUDKRPSUHGNDVWUD FLMR9IDOLÍQLID]LGHÍNLUD]YLMHMRVWUDKSUHGďNRGRNDVWUDFLMRNLQLVNRQFHQWULUDQ]JROM QDHQRUJDQWHPYHÍSUHMSUHGVWDYOMDJURĤQMRWHOHVQLQDUFLVLVWLÍQLĤHOMLSRXĤLWNX3ROORFN 6DPRUD]XPHYDQMHWHOHVDNRWFHORWHNLMLSULSDGDWXGLIDORVVHUD]YLMHVNR]L VSR]QDYDQMHVDPHJDVHEHSULPHUWHJDMHWXGLVSR]QDYDQMHVHEHSUHNR]UFDODWDNRSDVH ]JUDGLWXGLGHÍNRYDLGHQWLWHWD.RVHGHÍHN]DYHUD]OLNHPHGVHERMLQPHGVYRMRPDWHUMR SULNDWHULSULGHGRYL]XDOQHUD]OLNHXPDQMNDQMDIDORVDMH]DQMWRL]MHPQRWUDYPDWLÍQD L]NXďQMD]DWRY]SRVWDYLYHÍREUDPEQLKPHKDQL]PRYNLJDYDUXMHMRSUHGWHPVSR]QDQ VWYRPLQL]JXERHQRWQRVWLNLMRMHGHÍHNÍXWLOREVYRMLPDWHULVDMMH]DQMRSUHGYLGHYDO GD PX MH DQDWRPVNR HQDND NDU QHQDGRPD SD SRVWDQH SRSROQRPD GUXJDÍQDȡ QMHPX GUXJL,ELG 1HPRUHPRJRYRULWLRGHMDQVNHPSUYHPSODQXVDMMHWDWLVWLNLMHQDVOLNDQ=OHSOMHQMHPQDSODWQR VOLNDUNDXVWYDULNYD]LSUYLSODQSUHGSUYLSODQNLSRVHJDYSURVWRULQSUHVHJDSORVNRYLWRVWVOLNDUVNHJDPHGLMD =DUDGLYHOLNHJDIRUPDWDVOLNHLQQHNROLNRYHÍMHʳJXUHELODKNRUHNOLWXGLDMGRYVNDGHNOLFD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 85 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 (GHQRGREUDPEQLKPHKDQL]PRYSRVWDQHIHWLďNDWHUHJDNRQÍQLVWDGLMSRVWDQH SUHREOLNRYDQMHFHORWQHĤHQVNHSRGREHYIHWLďQDGRPHVWLOR]DWLVWRNDUQDPDWHULQHP WHOHVXPDQMNDȡ]DIDORV,ELG3ULIHWLďXVHWDNRY]DGQMLID]LVUHÍDPRVWHOHVRPNL SRVWDQHYFHORWLIHWLďȡSRVWDQHR]QDÍHYDOHF]DIHWLď3ULIHWLďXJRYRULPRSUHGYVHPRWHP GDMHJOHGDOÍHYSRJOHGRVUHGRWRÍHQQDIHWLďȡGHOIUDJPHQWWHOHVDȡNMHUFHORWDSRQD]DUMD RGVRWQRVWIDORVDQDSHOMXMHQDNDVWUDFLMRSULND]XMHĤHQVNRNRWQHPRďNHJDNRWUD]OLND WXGLQDUHNXMH,ELG8SRGREOMHQNDQDVOLNL Enemy of the state I MHWLVWDNLQDPNDĤH OHGHOWHOHVDNLSDJDODKNRUD]XPHPRWXGLNRWWLVWLGHOWHOHVDNLMHODKNRIHWLďL]LUDQVDP GHOWHOHVDSDSUHUDďÍDYFHORWQRWHORIHWLďVDMMHWHORYVOLNDUVWYX7LQH'REUDMFR]QDÍH YDOHF 6RYUDĤQLNGUĤDYHWDNRQHSRVWDQH]JROMPHGYHGNLVHQDPNDĤHNRWGUXĤEHQL VRYUDĤQLNYORJRVRYUDĤQLNDWDNRSUHY]DPHWXGLGHNOLFDNLVHGU]QHSRVWDYLWLPHGQDV LQ VRYUDĤQLND GUĤDYH ďWHYLOND HQD NL VL GU]QH PLVOLWL GD MH GRYROM NRPSHWHQWQD GD VH ]PHGYHGRPVRRÍLVDPD0HGGUXJLPMHWHĤDYDWXGLYWHPGDNRWJOHGDOFLQHPRUHPR YHGHWLDOLVHERGHNOLFD]DUHVORWLODPHGYHGDDOLSDVHMHSRVWDYLODQMHPXYEUDQLQQDVV VYRMRGUXJRWQRVWMRNDUĤHQVNDYSULPHUXPRďNHJDJOHGDOFDNLMHY]JRGRYLQLXPHWQRVWL SUHYODGRYDOLQELOHGLQLDNWLYQLJOHGDOHFXSRGREOMHQLKVXEMHNWRYVNXďDSRUD]LWL5D]X PHYDQMHĤHQVNHNRWVRYUDĤQLNDDOLQHÍHVDNDUMHSUDYWDNRGLYMHNRWMHPHGYHGODKNR L]YUVWQRSRQD]RULPRVNR]LLQWHUSUHWDFLMRFLWDWD/XF\%ODQGNLJDQDYHGHWXGL*ULVHOGD Pollock: 1DVSURWXMRÍD VL UHSUH]HQWDFLMD ĤHQVN NRW PRUDOQH LQ NUHSRVWQH QD HQL VWUDQL LQ ȮĤLYDOVNHȯ QD GUXJL MH ELOD PRĤQD ]DUDGL GHOLWYH ĤHQVNH QD WUL GHOH QDPHVWR NDUWH]LMDQVNH GYRMQRVWL XPD LQ WHOHVD ĤHQVNLQD GXKRYQRVW LQ QMHQD PRUDOQRVW MH ELOD ÍLVWD LQ HWHULÍQD YHQGDU ML MH YHGQR JUR]LO ĤLYDOVNL QDJRQ SR UHSURGXNFLML NL MH REYODGRYDO QMHQR WHOR LQ QMHQ XP ,ELG ģHQVNDMHELODYSUHWHNORVWLWRUHMYHGQRWLVWDNLMHYVHELQRVLODGRORÍHQR PHUR ĤLYDOVNRVWL LQ MH ELOD Y SDWULDUKDWX WXGL YHGQR NRW WDND UD]XPOMHQD .HU MH VOLNDUVWYR 7LQH 'REUDMF SRVWDYOMHQR Y VYRM XQLYHU]XP NL JD Y YHÍML PHUL VHVWDYOMDMR WXGL HOHPHQWL WUDGLFLRQDOL]PD NL QDV RSRPLQMDMR QD QMHJRYR SULVRWQRVW WXGL GDQHV VH ODKNR SRVOXĤLP WXGL LQWHUSUHWDFLMH GD ODKNR ĤHQVNR na sliki Enemy of the State I UD]XPHPRNRWWLVWRĤLYDOVNRWLVWRNLMHQHNMHPHG QDďLPLQĤLYDOVNLPVYHWRP =DQLPLYRMHWXGLGDODKNRXSRGREOMHQNRUD]XPHPRNRWVDPRWHORNLSDMH]UH GXFLUDQR QD HQ VDP GHO WHOHVD NL SRVWDQH LGHQWLʳNDFLMVND WRÍND ]D FHORWQR WHOR *UL VHOGD3ROORFNQDYHGH}6KHLVERG\VKHLVVH[XDOLW\VKHLVGDQJHUm ,ELGNDUSD ODKNRXSRUDELPRWXGLSULREUDYQDYDQLVOLNLȡXSRGREOMHQNDQLYHÍVXEMHNWNLJDUD]X PHPRNRWQDPHQDNSRVWDODMHWHORWRWHORSDSRQD]DUMDGRORÍHQRVHNVXDOQRVWNLMR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 86 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 ODKNRUD]XPHPR]DUDGLVNUDMQHPHUHIHWLďL]DFLMHNDUSDWRĤHQVNRWHORQDUHGLJOHGDOFX QHYDUQR*OHGDOHFVHWDNRWHOHVDXVWUDďLNHUWRWHORL]UDĤDPRÍĤHQVNHVSROQRVWLĤHQ VNHJDWHOHVDNLMHSUDYWDNRVSROQRNRWPRďNRWHUVNR]LVYRMRVSROQRVWHPDQFLSLUDQR ZAKLJUČEK 6OLNDUVWYR7LQH'REUDMFVVYRMLPHNOHNWLFL]PRPXVWYDULODVWHQXQLYHU]XPNLMH QDďHPXVORYHQVNHPXSURVWRUXEOL]XSDYHQGDUVH]GLNRWGDSRQD]DUMDQHNRGUXJDÍQRUHV QLÍQRVW9VLQDVOLNDQLHOHPHQWLVR]DQDVEOLĤQMLYHQGDUVH]DUDGLGUXJDÍQHJDSRVWDYOMDQMD PRWLYRYQDVOLNHNRWELWRSULÍDNRYDOLRGWXMLRGQDďHJDYVDNGDQMHJDVYHWDLQL]NXďQMHWHUV WHPXVWYDUMDGRORÍHQRVWRSQMRQHODJRGQRVWLNLMHXVWYDUMHQDQDPHQVNR9VYRMHPXVWYDU MDQMXXSRUDEOMDUD]OLÍQHHOHPHQWHNDUXVWYDULNRPSOHNVHQVLPEROQLVYHWNLQDPVSRURÍD YHÍVWYDULKNUDWL=DQMHQRVOLNDUVWYRQHPRUHPRUHÍLGDMH]JROMIHPLQLVWLÍQRDOL]JROMDNWL YLVWLÍQRVDM]]GUXĤHYDQMHPUD]OLÍQLKHOHPHQWRYWXGLVLPERORYVORYHQVWYDGRVHĤHHGLQ VWYHQSUHSOHWUD]OLÍQLKVSRURÍLONLVHPHGVHERMGRSROQMXMHMRQDGJUDMXMHMRLQVWRSQMXMH MR1HJOHGHQDUD]QRYUVWQRVSRURÍLOQRVWSDMHQMHQRVOLNDUVWYRYHGQRL]UD]LWRSROLWLÍQR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 87 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 BIBLIOGRAFIJA &ROQHU0LKD 7LQD'REUDMF9HOLNDGHNOHWDQHMRÍHMR.RVWDQMHYLFDQD.UNL*DOHULMD %RĤLGDU-DNDF *RGIUH\7RQ\ Conceptual Art 1HZQHQDYDGQR@ VRÍDVQRVW GXKRYQLK UHYROXFLM Y WHP ÍDVX >NR VH Y JUďNHP VYHWX SUHEXGL ʳOR]RʳMD@ Y ,QGLML QDVWDQHMR SRPHPEQH 8SDQLďDGH QDVWRSLWD XVWDQRYLWHOM GĤDLQL]PD 0DKDYLUD LQ EXGL]PD 6LGGKDUWKD *DYWDPD QD .LWDMVNHP Y]QLNQH NRQIXFLDQL]HP LQ SLďH /DR]L Y 3HU]LMLVHUD]YLMH]RURDVWUVWYRLQYHUMHWQRĤLYLWXGLVDP=DUDWXVWUDY,]UDHOXSDSUHURNL R]QDQMDMRYLVRNLHWLÍQLPRQR WHL]HPm ,ELG ,]YDMDQMDSUYLKPLVOHFHYSUYLKʳOR]RIRY SR]QHMHR]QDÍHQLK]LPHQRPSUHGVRNUDWLNLVRL]UD]LWRUD]QROLNDÍHWXGLMLK]D]QDPXMH VNXSQRNXOWXUQRRNROMH 9VRRGYLVQRVWLVSRYHGDQLPMHWUHEDXSRďWHYDWLLQSUHPLVOLWLQHNDWHUHSRGURE QRVWLWDNRWHUPLQRORďNHNRWYVHELQVNHQDUDYH1DMSUHMWHUPLQRORďNLSUHPLVOHN,]UD]L kot so predsokratiki, predsokratska misel ali SUHGVRNUDWVNDʳOR]RʳMDȡVDPMLKXSRUDEOMDP VNXSDM LQ L]PHQOMLYR ] L]UD]RPD DUKDLÍQD JUďND PLVHO ter DUKDLÍQL JUďNL PLVOHFL ȡ VR Y UHVQLFLSUHFHMRKODSQLXSDOELVLGHMDWLGDFHORQHWRÍQL3UHGVRNUDWLNLQDMELNDUVOHGL L]SRLPHQRYDQMDNRWJDMHGRNRQÍQRXYHOMDYLO+HUPDQQ'LHOV6RNUDWXSUHGKRGLOLWDNR YSUREOHPVNHPNRWYNURQRORďNHPSRJOHGXĎORQDMEL]DNRQWUDVWPHGUD]JODEOMDQMHPR GUXĤEHQLKYSUDďDQMLKLQWXGLRYSUDďDQMLKPRUDOHWDSUREOHPQDMELY]QLNQLOSUL6RNUDWX LQ VH NDVQHMH XWUGLO SUL 3ODWRQX WHU RPHMHYDQMHP QD YSUDďDQMD ʳ]LNH LQ NR]PRORJLMH 2 .RWSRPHQVNDR]QDNDLQWXGLNRWSRMPRYQDYVHELQDMHʳOR]RʳMD >YQHNHPVPLVOX@VYRMHYUVWQDVWYDUL WHY*UNRY5HDOHLQVWHPHYURSVNHJDPLďOMHQMD 1DM]DGRďÍDWDNUDWHNRSLVVDMVHQDWHPPHVWXQHERPSRGDMDOYSRGUREQRVWL]JRGRYLQVNLKRNR OLďÍLQWHGDQMHJDÍDVDYGUXJLKJHRJUDIVNLKLQNXOWXUQLKNRQWHNVWLKNLELWHUMDOHďLUďRREUDYQDYR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 92 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 $YHQGDUWRQHGUĤL1HNDWHULL]PHGSUHGVRNUDWLNRYVRELOLYUHVQLFL6RNUDWRYL FHOR3ODWRQRYLVRGREQLNLĎHYHÍQHNDWHULPHGQMLPLVRVHXNYDUMDOLWXGL]YSUDďDQMLSR OLWLNHLQGREUHJDĤLYOMHQMD&XUG .URQRORďNHPXSUHPLVOHNXQXMQRVOHGLďHYVHELQVNL9]DÍHWNXJUďNHJDPLďOMHQMD MHELORNRWQDYDMD.RFLMDQÍLÍ}VNXSDMWRNDUMHďORSR]QHMHQDUD]HQm.RFMDQÍLÍ .RWMHGHMDOĤH+HUDNOLW>PRUDMRQDPUHÍ@}PRĤMHNLOMXELMRPRGURVWGREURSR]QDWL PQRJH VWYDULm % 3UHGVRNUDWVNL PLVOHFL VR VWRSDOL SR QHVNRQÍQHP SROMX YSUD ďDQMQMLKRYDUDGRYHGQRVWQDUDYQDQRVWQDÍXGHQMHMHELODVNRUDMGDQHL]PHUQD . }1MLKRYR PLďOMHQMHVHMHNULVWDOL]LUDORYYHGQRVWLKNLMLKGDQHVRSUHGHOMXMHPRNRWUD]OLÍQD SRGURÍMD ʳOR]RʳMH]QDQRVWLLQGXKRYQRVWLm .RFLMDQÍLÍ }2EOLNRYDOLVRVWDOLďÍDRQDUDYL VYHWDȡQMLKRYLSRJOHGL]DMHPDMRYVHWLVWRNDUGDQHVLPHQXMHPRʳ]LNDNHPLMDJHRORJLMD PHWHRURORJLMD DVWURQRPLMD HPEULRORJLMD LQ SVLKRORJLMD ȡ R WHRORJLML PHWDʳ]LNL R YSUDďDQMLKHSLVWHPRORJLMHYSUDďDQMLKSROLWLNHLQYSUDďDQMLKRGREUHPĤLYOMHQMXm&XUG SULÍHPHUVRPHGQMLPLREVWDMDOHSUHF HMďQMHUD]OLNH 1DWHPPHVWXYHOMDSUYLÍSRXGDULWLGDMHSULVRRÍHQMX]]DÍHWNLPLďOMHQMDQXMQD GRORÍHQDPHUDSUHYLGQRVWLLQ]DYHGDQMDODVWQHJDSRORĤDMDYVYHWX.RWVHPQDND]DOĤH ]JRUDM VH MH WUHED ]DYHGDWL GD VH VOHKHUQL SRVNXV SULEOLĤHYDQMD DUKDLÍQL JUďNL PLVOL Y VRGREQRVWLRGYLMDQDR]DGMXPRGHUQH]DVWDYLWYHPLďOMHQMDNLY]SRVWDYOMDORÍHQRVWVIHU ]QDQRVWLUHOLJLR]QRVWLOLWHUDWXUHʳOR]RʳMHLWG3RYHGDQREROMSUHSURVWRÍHWXGLVRDU KDLÍQLPLVOHFLNRWVHPSULND]DOQHNDMYUVWLFYLďMHGHORYDOLQDďWHYLOQLKSRGURÍMLKQMLKR YDSUHGVWDYDRYHGQRVWLQLYNOMXÍHYDODVWURJLKGHOLWHY]QDÍLOQLK]DPRGHUQRPLďOMHQMHD KNUDWLQLNDNRUQLELODKRPRJHQD 8SRďWHYDWL MH WUHED WXGL GHMVWYR GD VH }PLVOHFL DUKDLÍQHJD JUďWYD VDPL QDMYHUMHWQHMH QH EL RSUHGHOLOL ]D ʳOR]RIHm ,ELG YVDM QH Y VPLVOX Y NDNUďQHP VH NRW ʳOR]RIDRSUHGHOMXMHWD3ODWRQDOL$ULVWRWHOSDWXGLQMXQLPRGHUQLQDVOHGQLNL9NROLNRU ĤHOLPRGRVSHWLGR]DYHGDQMDRWHPRGNRGL]KDMDʳOR]RʳMDLQ]DNDMMLJUHVHPRUDPRELWL YVDMGRQHNHPHUHVSRVREQLRGUHÍLVYRMLPODVWQLPSUHGVWDYDPRWHPNDMWDMH .RFLMDQÍLÍGHQLPRQDYDMDSULPHUYNDWHUHPSUDYLGDQDMEL$QDNVLPDQGHUNLMHELODYWRUSUYHJD IUDJPHQWDRKUDQMHQHJDY]DKRGQLPLVOLLQPHGGUXJLPWXGLDYWRUSUYHJD]HPOMHYLGDSRVHOMHQHJDVYHWDYRGLONR ORQLVWHNLVRVHL]0LOHWDRGSUDYLOLY$SRORQLMRRE3RQWX3LWDJRUDLQ3DUPHQLG>SD@VWDELODGHMDYQDYSROLWLÍQHP ĤLYOMHQMXNRORQLM.URWRQDLQ(OHMHVOHGQMLMH]D(OHMRPHQGDFHORQDSLVDO]DNRQH Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 93 27. 10. 2022 11:16:20 TEŽAVNOST PRISTOPANJA K ZAČETKOM - ZAGATE INTERPRETACIJ 9HOLNDYHÍLQDDQWLÍQLKʳOR]RIVNLKVSLVRYVHMHYWRNX]JRGRYLQHQHSRYUDWQRL] JXELOD3ULPLVOHFLKDUKDLÍQHJDJUďWYDMHWDL]JXEDďHSRVHEHML]UD]LWD}9HÍLQDPHGQMLPL MH]DÍDVDVYRMHJDĤLYOMHQMDQDSLVDODYVDMHQR knjigo ȡ>SRJRVWRMHďOR]DSUHFHMNUDWND SUR]QDEHVHGLOD]DWUDNWDWHSRQHNRGFHOR]DSRH]LMR@ȡDSUDYQREHQDL]PHGQMLKQLYFH ORWLRKUDQMHQDm,ELG6RRÍHQMH]PLVOHFLDUKDLÍQHJDJUďWYD]DKWHYDRYHGHQMHWHL]JXEH .HUVHQMLKRYDGHODQLVRRKUDQLODYFHORWLMLKQDPUHÍODKNRUHNRQVWUXLUDPRR]LURPDSR QRYQR]JUDGLPROHGHOQR3ULWHPSRÍHWMXVHRSLUDPRSUHGYVHPQDWURMHQDIUDJPHQWH L]YLUQLKEHVHGLOQDGRNVRJUDIVNDSRURÍLODLQQDELRJUDIVNHRSLVHPLVOHFHY 2KUDQMHQLIUDJPHQWLRELÍDMQRVHVWRMLMR]JROML]QHNDMEHVHGYÍDVLK]GUXĤHQLK YVWDYHNDOLGYDVSHWGUXJLÍSRYVHPQHSRYH]DQLKLQEUH]MDVQHJDVPLVOD9HÍNUDWJUH]D FLWDWHNLMLKMHPRJRÍHQDMWLYGHOLKGUXJLKDYWRUMHYLQ]DWRRELÍDMQRSRWUHEXMHMRGRSRO QLWHY7XYLJURYVWRSLGRNVRJUDʳMDYPDQMďLPHULSDWXGLELRJUDIVNLRSLVL Izraz dok VRJUDʳMDVLFHUQLL]YLUQRJUďNLWHPYHÍJDMHYVWROHWMXREOLNRYDO+HUPDQQ'LHOVNRW }R]QDNRVSHFLʳÍQHOLWHUDUQH]YUVWLNLMH]DSLVRYDODPQHQMDPLVOHFHYSUHGYVHPYSROMX XNYDUMDQMD]YSUDďDQMLRijȪıȚȢm0DQVIHOG*UHWRUHM]DVNXSNHSULÍHYDQM]DSLVNRY FLWDWRYSUHSLVRYSRURÍLOLQNRPHQWDUMHYNLVPLVHOQRGRSROQMXMHMRWHUPHVWRPDQDGJUD MXMHMRNRQWHNVWRKUDQMHQLKIUDJPHQWRY5HNRQVWUXNFLMDSUHGVRNUDWVNHPLVOLMHSUHWHĤQRY GRPHQLNODVLÍQLKʳORORJRY7LVRY]DGQMLKQHNDMVWROHWMLKQHGYRPQRRSUDYLOLSRPHPEQR GHOR2]LUDMRÍVHQDWHĤDYQRVWSULVWRSDQMDN]DÍHWNRPʳOR]RʳMHMHSUDYGDRSR]RULPQD GYDVNORSDWHĤDYNL]D]QDPXMHWDVOHKHUQLSRVNXVVRRÍHQMD]DUKDLÍQRPLVOLMR 3UYLVNORSWHĤDYL]KDMDL]VDPHJD QDÍLQD MDYOMDQMDSUHGVRNUDWVNHPLVOL=DÍHWNL ʳOR]RʳMHQDPUHÍY]QLNQHMRYREGREMXNRGUXĤEDďHOHSULÍHQMDVSRVWRSQLPSUHKDMDQMHP RGXVWQHNSLVQLWUDGLFLML7RYUVWHQSUHKRGMH]DPLďOMHQMHL]UHGQHJDSRPHQD=DSLVDQD EHVHGLODVR}VVYRMLPSUHKDMDQMHPL]NUDMDYNUDMLQVVYRMRUHODWLYQRWUDMQRVWMRRPRJRÍL ODDEVWUDNWQHMďRPLVHOLQSDUWLFLSDFLMRRGGDOMHQLKPLVOHFHYYVNXSQHPGLDORJXYQRYLK UD]ďLUMHQLK NRRUGLQDWDK ÍDVD LQ SURVWRUDm .RFLMDQÍLÍ 3UL WHP YHOMD SRQRYQR SRXGDULWLGDMHUDYQRREGREMHSUHGVRNUDWLNRYREHQHPWXGLREGREMHSRÍDVQHJDSUHKRGD RGXVWQHJDNSLVQHPX3LVDQDEHVHGDSRWHPWDNHPY]QLNQHďHOHNRWHQD L]PHGPRĤQRVWL , ]ODVWL Y REOLNL ]YLWNRY LQ NRGHNVRY ,] SRYHGDQHJD VOHGL GD VUĤ DUKDLÍQH PLVOL GRPXMH QHNMHYYPHVQRVWLPHGSRH]LMRLQSUR]R0LVOHFLVRWHGDMVYRMHʳOR]RIVNHGRPLVOHNHRE OLNRYDOLYMH]LNXNLďHQLELOMH]LNMDVQRL]GHODQHʳOR]RIVNHWHUPLQRORJLMH=DQDďDMRVHQD 'LHOVDQWLÍQHELRJUDIVNH]DSLVHR]LURPDSRVNXVHRSLVRYDQMDĤLYOMHQMDVLFHU]DYUDÍD5D]XPHMLKNRWQH]DQHVO MLYHLQDQHNGRWLÍQHFHORʳNWLYQHLQ]DWRPDQMSRPHPEQH.RFLMDQÍLÍ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 94 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 HOHJDQWQHSULVSRGREHPXÍQHLQQHURGQHDQDORJLMHMDVQHWHUQHSRVUHGQHDUJXPHQWHLQ ]DSOHWHQHSDUDGRNVH&XUG,]WHJDUD]ORJDMHLQWHUSUHWLUDQMHSUHGVRNUDWLNRYY QDMYHÍMLPHULWHĤDYQRLQYÍDVLKYVDMQDSUYLSRJOHGLQYNROLNRUGRLQWHUSUHWLUDQMDSULVWR SDPRVVHQ]LELOQRVWPLPRGHUQHʳOR]RʳMH]HORQHKYDOHĤQRSRÍHWMH 'UXJLVNORSWHĤDYL]KDMDL]UD]PLNDPHGWHPNDUSUHGVRNUDWLNL pravijo, in tem kar QDMELKRWHOLUHÍL.RIPDQ7DUD]PLNQL]JROMSRVOHGLFDÍDVRYQHRGGDOMHQRVWL QLWLGHMVWYDGDSUHGVRNUDWVNDPLVHO]DSROQMXMHELVWYHQRGUXJDÍHQSRMPRYQLRNYLUNRWJD ]DSROQMXMHPRVDPL9SUHFHMďQMLPHULJUH]DSRVOHGLFRGHMVWYDGDSULÍHYDOFLSUHGVRNUDW VNHPLVOLQMHQLSUHSLVRYDOFLLQWHUSUHWLLQNRPHQWDWRUMLSULVYRMHPGHOXQLNGDUQLVRQLWL SRYVHPREMHNWLYQLQLWLSRYVHPQHYWUDOQL 3UL UHNRQVWUXNFLML LQ VRRÍHQMX ] L]YLUQLPL IUDJPHQWL VHNXQGDUQD JUDGLYD QHGYRPQRSUHGVWDYOMDMRNOMXÍQRGRGDQRYUHGQRVWYHQGDUMHQMLKRYRQDUDYQDQRVWNOMXE WHPXWUHEDNULWLÍQRRYUHGQRWLWL*OHGHQDWRGDMHYHÍLQDGRNVRJUDIVNLKSRURÍLOQDVWDOD SRÍDVXL]YLUQLKIUDJPHQWRYMHSULQMLKRYLREUDYQDYLQXMQRXSRďWHYDWLNXOWXUQR]JRGR YLQVNHRNROLďÍLQHQDVWDQND /HS SULPHU REUDYQDYH DUKDMVNH PLVOL NL PX QHGYRPQR SULWLÍH SRGUREQHM ďL SUHPLVOHN MH $ULVWRWHO 1MHJRYR L]YDMDQMH Y SUYL NQMLJL 0HWDʳ]LNH }NL MH RGORÍLOQR ]D]QDPRYDOR YVR QDGDOMQMR UHFHSFLMR DUKDLÍQH PLVOL QD =DKRGX MH VDPR SR VHEL L]MHPQHJDSRPHQDLQQHSUHFHQOMLYR%UH]QMHJDELELORR]DÍHWNLKJUďNHʳOR]RʳMH>LQV WHP]DÍHWNLKʳOR]RʳMHQDVSORK@QDYROMRQHSULPHUQRPDQMJUDGLYD]DWRVHPXQHPRUH L]RJQLWLQREHQDVLQWH]DDUKDLÍQHPLVOLNLVLSUL]DGHYDELWLNDUVHGDFHORYLWDm&LJOHQHÍNL ,QYHQGDUPRUDPRRVWDWLSR]RUQLVDMMHNRWQDYDMD.RIPDQ}$ULVWRWHOHGHQ RG WHK GRNWRUMHY NL L]NRULďÍD UD]OLNR PHG WHP NDU SUDYLMR SUHGVRNUDWLNL LQ WHP NDU QDM EL KRWHOL UHÍL >WHU VH@ SRODďÍD QMLKRYH PLVOL SULVYDMD VL QMLKRY GLVNXU]m 1MHJRY SULND] SUYLK ʳOR]RIRY NL MLK RNOLÍH ]D tiste, ki se ukvarjajo z naravo, vodi logi NDQDSUHGRYDQMDNDWHUHGRYUďLWHYQDVWRSLSUDY]QMLP3UHGVRNUDWLNLQDMEL}VVYRMLPL GHOQLPL QHSRSROQLPL RGJRYRUL V VYRMLPL QDSDNDPL LQ ]DEORGDPL V VYRMLPL SUHWHĤQR SRYUďLQVNLPL LQ HQRVWUDQVNLPL WHRULMDPL SULSUDYOMDOL HGLQR ]DGRYROMLYR ʳOR]RʳMR >Ȭ@ ʳOR]RʳMR$ULVWRWHOD VDPHJDm .RFLMDQÍLÍ =DÍHWNL VR ]DQM ]DQLPLYL VDPR WR OLNRNROLNRUR]QDQMDMRLQSRWUMXMHMRDULVWRWHOVNRUHVQLFR . 3RYHGDQRGUXJDÍH }$ULVWRWHO QDVLOQRYVUNDQMLKRYRL]YLUQRVWYLVWRYHWQRVWVYRMHʳOR]RʳMH9]DPHMLPNDUMHPRJRÍH Y]HWL RE VWUDQL SXVWL SUHRVWDOR NDU WYRUL QMLKRYR L]YLUQRVWm .RIPDQ – vse tisto, NDUVDPSRMPXMHNRW]DQHPDUOMLYR 1MHJRYLQDVOHGQLNLYVYRMHP]DQDďDQMXQDDY toriteto 0HWDʳ]LNH, SDWXGLYVYRMLĤHOMLSRQDYH]RYDQMXQDWLVWRL]YRUQRRGDULVWRWHOL ND7HRIUDVWDGDOMHSRÍQHMRSRGREQR7XYHOMDQDYHVWL+HJOD7DYVYRMLK Predavanjih o ]JRGRYLQL ʳOR]RʳMH QH RYLQNDUL NR SUDYL GD }NDU ]DGHYD ďWXGLM JUďNH ʳOR]RʳMH QL PR JRÍHVWRULWLQLÍEROMďHJDNRWSUHXÍLWLSUYRNQMLJR>Ȭ@0HWDʳ]LNHm&LJOHQHÍNL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 95 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 'DELEROMHUD]XPHOLSUREOHPDWLÍQRVWDSURSULDFLMHL]YLUQHJDNLVHJDRG$ULVWR WHODSUHN]JRGQMHJDNUďÍDQVWYDLQKHOHQLVWLÍQHʳOR]RʳMHYVHGRYHOLNRNDVQHMďLK+HJOD 1LHW]VFKHMDLQ+HLGHJJHUMDMHSUDYGDVLRJOHGDPRYVDMHQQHNROLNRNRQNUHWQHMďLSULPHU RPHQMHQHJDSULVYDMDQMD3ULPHUNL]DGHYDQHUD]XPHYDQMHLQVHOHNWLYQRUHFHSFLMR+H UDNOLWRYHPLVOL HERAKLIT - OSNOVNE OPAZKE +HUDNOLWQDMELVHURGLOLQĤLYHOY(IH]XQHNDMNLORPHWURYRGPHVWD6HO©XNbQD]D KRGQLREDOLGDQDďQMH7XUÍLMH1DWDQÍQDÍDVRYQD]DPHMLWHYQMHJRYHJDĤLYOMHQMDQL]QDQD ĤLYHOQDMELQDSUHORPXLQVWROHWMDSUHGQDďLPďWHWMHP5HDOH6YRMUD]FYHW QDMELSRSRURÍDQMX'LRJHQD/DHUWVNHJDGRĤLYOMDOYÍDVXGHYHWLQďHVWGHVHWHROLPSLMDGH '.$WRMHPHGOHWRPDLQSUQďW9HÍLQDRKUDQMHQLK]JRGERSLVXMHQMH JRY]QDÍDMNDNRUVRRQMHPVNOHSDOLL]QMHJRYHJDQDXND*UDKDP2QDWDQÍQHMďHP SRWHNXQMHJRYHJDĤLYOMHQMDMHEROMPDOR]QDQHJD7HPXYHOMDGRGDWLGDVRQHNDWHULRSLVL QMHJRYHJD]QDÍDMDLQYHGHQMDSUHFHMJURELPHVWRPDYNOMXÍXMHMRSUHFHMQHQDYDGQHSRG UREQRVWL'LRJHQJDR]QDÍXMH]DSRQRVQHJD in RďDEQHJD'RGDMDDQHNGRWRRQMHJRYHP ]DYUDÍDQMXGUXJLKOMXGL3UDYLWDNROH}.RVRJD]DSURVLOLQDMMLPQDSLďH]DNRQHVH]D WRQL]PHQLO]DUDGLWHJDNHUMHSROLVĤHREYODGRYDODVODEDXUHGLWHY.RVHMHXPDNQLOY $UWHPLGLQRVYHWLďÍHMHNRFNDO]RWURNL.RVRJD(IHĤDQLREVWRSLOLMHUHNHO}.DMVHÍXGLWH QDMYHÍMLVODELÍL"$OLQLEROMHGDSRÍQHPWRNRWSDGDEL]YDPLXSUDYOMDOSROLV"m,QQD NRQFXNRMH]DVRYUDĤLOOMXGLLQRGďHOMHĤLYHOYJRUDKNMHUMHMHGHO]HOLďÍDLQWUDYHm $ +HUDNOLW QDM EL ]D ÍDVD ĤLYOMHQMD ]DSLVDO ]JROM HQR ODVWQR GHOR QDVORYOMHQR Ƚİȡ੿ijȪıİȦȢ ali O naravi 3RXGDULWLYHOMDGDMHQDVORYQDMYHUMHWQHMHDQDKURQL]HP}VDMVR ʳOR]RIVNHVSLVHQDYDGQRWDNRQDVODYOMDOLYNDVQHMďHPÍDVXm=RUH3UHGHQQD GDOMXMHP]REUDYQDYRVWUXNWXUH+HUDNOLWRYHPLVOLVHERPYUQLONYSUDďDQMXUD]OLNRYDQMD PHGPRGHUQLPSRMPRYDQMHPQDUDYHLQL]YLUQRJUďNLPDUKDMVNLPSRMPRYDQMHPijȪıȚȢ, QDNDWHUHJDVHPVHRSUOYSUHGDYDQMX Izraz ijȪıȚȢ WDNR QH R]QDÍXMH QDUDYH Y NDWHUHPNROL VRGREQHP SRPHQX WHJD SRMPD 1H JUH ]D QDUDYR Y VPLVOX RG ÍORYHND ORÍHQHJD SUHGPHWQHJD VYHWD ali za del ze-PHOMVNH SRYUďLQH NL JD ÍORYHN ďH QL ELVWYHQR VSUHPHQLO, niti ne gre za naravo kot skupek ÍORYHNRYLKODVWQRVWLL]NDWHULKL]KDMDQMHJRYRUDYQDQMH 11DVSURWQRijȪıȚȢ]DREVHJDďLUďL SRPHQVNLVNORS%LVWYHQR]D]QDPXMHYVH }NDUVHSULND]XMHQDVWDMDNDUSULKDMDQDGDQ DOLVHSRMDYOMDNDUUDVWHm =RUH1DVORYLWHY+HUDNOLWRYHJDGHODVȽİȡ੿ijȪıİȦȢ 6 *OHMJHVOR naráva Y 6ORYDUMXVORYHQVNHJDNQMLĤQHJDMH]LND'RVWRSQRQDVSOHWQHPQDVORYXKWWSV ZZZIUDQVLLVNDQMH"9LHZ 4XHU\ QDUDYD 96 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 96 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 ]JRUDMVHPMRRSUHGHOLONRWDQDKURQL]HPȡSDQDSRWXMHQDďHQHNROLNRGUXJDÍQRFHOR SRSDÍHQRUD]XPHYDQMHijȪıȚȢNLVHEROMNRWQDDUKDLÍQHPLVOHFHRSLUDQD$ULVWRWHOR YHLQWHUSUHWDFLMHLQMHYQHNDWHULKR]LULK]HOREOL]XPRGHUQL naravi$ULVWRWHOLQQMHJRYL nasledniki ijȪıȚȢ GRORÍDMR NRW }ELWQRVW WLVWLK VWYDUL NL LPDMR SRÍHOR JLEDQMD Y VDPHP VHELm$ULVWRWHO0HWDʳ]LNDDȡ3UHQDďDQMHWDNďQHJDUD]XPHYDQMDijȪıȚȢ QD]DM NSUYLPPLVOHFHP]DPHJOMXMHSUYRWQLSRPHQL]UD]D=RUHLQQDUDYQDQRVWSU YLKʳOR]RʳM+NUDWLPRÍQRRPHMLPDQHYUVNLSURVWRUNLQDMELJDWHLPHOHQDUD]SRODJR ,PHQXMHMLK]D ʳOR]RʳMHQDUDYH PLVOHFHSDYNOHQHYL]UD] naravoslovci, tudi ʳOR]RʳQDUDYH ali celo QDUDYRVORYQLʳOR]Rʳ&LJOHQHÍNL,]SRYHGDQHJDVOHGLGDSRYUďQRJH QHULÍQLQDVORYȽİȡ੿ijȪıİȦȢ QHVOXĤLDYWRUMHYLQDUDYQDQRVWLWHPYHÍSUHGVWDYOMDRURGMH LQWHUSUHWDFLMHWXGLNODVLʳNDFLMHNLQDVWRSLďHOH]DQD]DM 3RURÍLODRVWUXNWXUL+HUDNOLWRYHJDGHODďHMDVQHMHNDĤHMRNDNRSUREOHPDWLÍQH VRODKNRJHQHULÍQHNODVLʳNDFLMH]DQD]DM'LRJHQQDYDMDGHOLWHYQDWULGHOH}QDWLVWHJDR YHVROMXQDSROLWLÍQHJDLQQDERJRVORYQHJDm$1LNDNRUWRUHMQHJUH]DR]NRXVPH ULWHYYʳOR]RʳMRQDUDYH3RURÍLORMHVNODGQHMďH]EROMRGSUWRSUHGVWDYRWDNRRijȪıȚȢ kot o DUKDLÍQLPLVOLQDVSORK1DWDQÍQDVWUXNWXUD+HUDNOLWRYHJDVSLVDVLFHUQLSRWUMHQD/DKNR GDMHďOR]DQRWUDQMHÍOHQMHQDNRKHUHQWHQ]DSRYUVWQRL]SHOMDQDUJXPHQW1LÍPDQMYHU MHWQRSDQLGDMH+HUDNOLWRYRGHORL]SROQMHYDOD}PQRĤLFDNUDWNLKMHGUQDWLKWXGLMH]LNRY QRGRGHODQLK>LQPHGVHERMVNRSRSRYH]DQLK@L]UHNRYm=RUHȡQDWRQDSRWXMH SUHFHMRKUDQMHQLKIUDJPHQWRYNLQHQDND]XMHMRPRĤQRVWLHQHVDPH]DRNURĤHQHFHORWH FRAGMENTI IN TEMAČNOST HERAKLITA +HUDNOLWMHWLVWL]JRGQMLJUďNLPLVOHFNLVRPXĤHQMHJRYLDQWLÍQLVRGREQLNLQD GHOLL]UD]0UDÍQLDOL7HPDÍQL=RUH9SUDďDQMHWHWHPDÍQRVWLMHWLVWRNLQDV ERXYHGORYELVWYRSULÍXMRÍHJDEHVHGLODYSUREOHPDWLÍQRVWQHUD]XPHYDQMDLQDSURSULD FLMH]JRGQMHJUďNHPLVOL'HMVWYRGDVR WHPDÍQRVW SUL+HUDNOLWXQD]QDQLOLĤHQMHJRYLVR GREQLNL L]SRGELMD PRĤQRVW GD WD L]KDMD ERGLVL L] RGGDOMHQRVWL DYWRUMHYHJD L]UD]MD LQ NXOWXUQHJDNRQWHNVWDNLJDSRSROQMXMHERGLVLL]PDQNDVREHVHGLOQHJDNRQWHNVWDRKUDQ MHQLKIUDJPHQWRY2GNRGWRUHMWHPDÍQRVWLQNDMQDWDQNRLPDWRRSUDYLWLVSULVYDMDQMHP L]YLUQHJDYSUHGVRNUDWVNLPLVOL" =JRGRYLQDʳOR]RʳMHSRQXMDďWHYLOQHRGJRYRUH3UYLLQQDMHQRVWDYQHMďLRGJRYRU DOLUD]ODJDVHQDVODQMDQD]JRUDMRPHQMHQH]JRGEHR+HUDNOLWRYHP]QDÍDMXDOLĤLYOMHQ MXVNODGQRVNDWHULPLQDMELQMHJRYDPUDÍQRVWL]KDMDODL]}PHODQKROLÍQRVWLEROH]HQVNH SUHREÍXWOMLYRVWLLQ]DQLÍOMLYRVWL7HPDÍQRVWQDMELLVNDOQDÍUWQRGDJDQHYHGQDPQRĤLFD QHELUD]XPHODLQGDELVHSUHGQMR]DYDURYDOm.RIPDQ3RPLVOLWLJUHQDUD]GHOHN Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 97 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 L]SUHMRPHQMHQH'LRJHQRYHDQHNGRWHYNDWHUHPRSLVXMHGDQDMEL+HUDNOLWQDSRVOHG ĤLYHOYJRUDKNMHUMHMHGHO]HOLďÍDLQWUDYH7DQHQDYDGQRVWRVHEQRVWLQDMELGRORÍDODWXGL QMHJRYRPLVHOLQQMHQHNDVQHMďHLQWHUSUHWDFLMH 7DNďQRUD]XPHYDQMHMHSRPDQMNOMLYRFHOR]DYDMDMRÍH.R+HUDNOLWQDPUHÍĤHOL }PRUHELWLMDVQHMďLNRWNGRUNROLGUXJ9ÍDVLKVHYVYRMLNQMLJLL]UDĤDWDNRMDVQRLQUD]XPO MLYRGDJDPRUHUD]XPHWLFHORQDMPDQMSUHWDQMHQXPLQGDPRUHGRMHWLSRWHNQMHJRYH PLVOLm,ELG1MHJRYDPUDÍQRVWQLYEUH]XSXNLJDQDYGDMDRESRJOHGXQDPQRĤLFRVDM VH}SRUD]QRVWDQMHOMXGLNLJDRSLVXMHQHGRWLNDELVWYHQHJD>QMHJRYHʳOR]RʳMH@QDQHSR VUHGHQQDÍLQm=RUH 'UXJLRGJRYRUQDYSUDďDQMHWHPDÍQRVWLQMHQRSRMDYOMDQMHSRMDVQMXMH]}REOLNR +HUDNOLWRYHJDGLVNXU]DSHVQLďNRPLWVNRDOLPHWDIRULÍQR>FHOR@QHSRMPRYQRm.RIPDQ 7DNďQRSRMDVQMHYDQMHMHSUDYWDNRSRPDQMNOMLYRÍHWXGLQDYLGH]PDQMQDLY QRRGSUYHJD1HSULVOXKQHQDPUHÍPLďOMHQMXVDPHPXWHPYHÍVLGDMHRSUDYNDVNULWLNR REOLNHGLVNXU]DNLL]SDGHSUHSURVWR]DWRNHUQHXVWUH]DPRGHOXNRWJDSRVWDYOMDVDP NULWLN 7D QH XSRďWHYD UD]GDOMH NL VRGREQL GLVNXU] ORÍXMH RG DUKDLÍQHJD ,] WH QDSDÍ QR ]DVWDYOMHQH SRGODJH UD]XPHYDQMD DUKDLÍQH PLVOL UDVWHMR SUYH REWRĤEH R VHOHNWLYQL UHFHSFLMLLQDSURSULDFLML'HMDQVNDUHVQLÍQD+HUDNOLWRYDWHPDÍQRVWMHQDPUHÍVWULNWQR ʳOR]RIVNHQDUDYH SELEKTIVNOST RAZUMEVANJA IN PRILAŠČANJE 7LVWR NDU QDSRWXMH QD VHOHNWLYQRVW UD]XPHYDQMD FHOR QD SULODďÍDQMH NUDMR L]YLUQHJDY+HUDNOLWRYLPLVOLMHQDPUHÍSUDYQH]PRĤQRVWSULVOXKQLWLPLVOLVDPL3RÍHWMH PRGHUQLKPLVOHFHYȡYNRQWHNVWXYSUDďDQM+HUDNOLWDVHMDYOMDMRSUHGYVHP+HJHO1LHW] VFKHLQ+HLGHJJHUȡQLWXQLÍGUXJDÍQRRGWLVWHJDNDUVHP]JRUDMSULSLVDO$ULVWRWHOXDOL DULVWRWHOLNRP1LHW]VFKHGHQLPRYEHVHGLOX Ecce Homo +HUDNOLWDQDYDMDNRWWLVWHJDY EOLĤLQLNDWHUHJD}VHSRÍXWLEROMWRSORLQEROMHNRWNMHUNROLGUXJRGm+HJHOSRGREQRXJR WDYOMDGD}QLQREHQH+HUDNOLWRYHWUGLWYHNLMHQHELELO]PRĤHQSRY]HWLYVYRML Znanosti logike. m }+HUDNOLWSUHGVWDYOMDSUYLPRPHQWSRQRYQHSRODVWLWYHGXKDVVWUDQLGXKDVD PHJDLQSRWHPMHUHVQLÍHQ+HJORYSUHGQLNm,ELG3UL1LHW]VFKHMXNDUMHUD]YLGQR L]]JRUQMHL]MDYHYHOMDSRGREQR7XGLVDPQLÍGUXJDÍHRG+HJOD}SRVWDYOMD+HUDNOLWD]D VYRMHJDSUHGKRGQLNDLQSUHGQLNDm,ELG6RSRVWDYLWHYREHKSUHSULÍDQMVSURĤDPQRĤLFR YSUDďDQM R WHP NDNR VL MH PRJRÍH +HUDNOLWD KNUDWL ODVWLWL NRW SUHGQLND GYHK SRYVHP 7XGLWXJUH]DSRURÍLOR'LRJHQD/DHUWVNHJDNRWJDYVYRMHPGHOXSDUDIUD]LUD.RIPDQ 2EHL]MDYLQDYDMDPSRLQWHUYMXMX+DQVD*HRUJD*DGDPHUMDL]OHWDGRVWRSQHPQDVSOHWQHPQDVORYX KWWSVZZZ\RXWXEHFRPZDWFK"Y (OOS1R0 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 98 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 QDVSURWQLK ʳOR]RIVNLK SR]LFLM }SUHGQLND GLDOHNWLNH LQ SUHGQLND SRMPRYDQMD VYHWD NRW SROHPLÍQHLJUHQDVWDMDQMDNDWHUHJDQDVSURWXMRÍLKVLVLO>NDWHUHVR@YYHÍQHPPHGVHERM QHPQDVSURWMXLQVSRSDGXQHPRUHVSUDYLWLQREHQDGLDOHNWLNDm ,ELG .RIPDQ]DYUDÍDPRĤQRVWGDMHWDNďQDUD]QROLNRVWEUDQMODKNRQDVWDODEHQHYR OHQWQREUH]RÍLWQHVHOHNWLYQRVWLYL]ELUDQMXSRGODJH6WHPVHYVDMSRPRMHPPQHQMX YHOMDVWULQMDWL3ULVWRSDNEUDQMXLQN povzemanju NLVHMXSRVOXĤXMHSUHGYVHP+HJHO1 VWDYUHVQLFL]HORSRGREQDWLVWHPX gospodovanju NLJDYVYRMHPVHOHNWLYQHPEUDQMXLQ XUHMDQMXPDWHULDODVYRMLKSUHGKRGQLNRYSUDNWLFLUD$ULVWRWHO*RYRULFRJUďWYD+HJHOWDNR }SUHYDMDYJRYRULFRVSHNXODWLYQHJDXPDm ,ELGVHSUDYLYIRUPXOHNLXVWUH]DMRQMH JRYLODVWQLʳOR]RʳML1LHW]VFKHMX]DNDWHUHJD}L]NRSDYDWLSUYHʳOR]RIHQHSRPHQLRG VWUDQMHYDWLQMLKRYHRWURďNHWHPDÍQRVWLVSRMPRYQRMDVQLQR WHPYHÍSRPHQLYUQLWLMLP QMLKRYRSUDYRSRGRER>Ȭ@QMLKRYROHSRWR>Ȭ@QMLKRYRSROQRVWm ,ELG.RIPDQSUH FHMSUL]DQDďD7RYUHVQLFLQLQDMEROMSRďWHQRVDMWXGL1LHW]VFKHYVYRMLKSUHGKRGQLNLK LďÍHSUHGYVHPSRWUGLWHYYHOLÍLQHVYRMHJDODVWQHJDUD]XPHYDQMDPLďOMHQMD 3RVHEQRSRJODYMHYVRRÍHQMX]DUKDLÍQRPLVOLMRSUHGVWDYOMDWUHWML]JRUDMRPHQ MHQL PLVOHF 0DUWLQ +HLGHJJHU 1MHJRYR PLVHO ]D]QDPXMH WUXG SUHYLGQHJD SULVWRSDQMD QHSRVUHGQRNPLVOLVDPLNVPLVOXNLOHĤLYDUKDLÍQHPJUďWYXLQVHMDYOMDL]QMHJD2QMH WLVWLNLSRVNXďDRVWDWLNDUVHGDRGSUWGRWHĤDYNLREOHJDMRVRRÍHQMH]L]YLUQLP6DPL]SR VWDYLWHĤDYRSULVYDMDQMDNRSUDYLGDPLVHOQHSRWLNDVQHMďLKPLVOHFHYLQSLVFHYGRORÍDMR L]ERU LQ QDÍLQ QDYDMDQMD +HUDNOLWRYLK EHVHG 6 WHP MH SR QMHJRYR }]DNROLÍHQR WRULďÍH YVDNRNUDWQHUD]ODJHIUDJPHQWRY,Q]DWR]PRUHPRYVSLVLKNDVQHMďLKDYWRUMHY]QDWDQÍ QHMďLPPRWUHQMHPQDMGLďÍDQDYHGNDYHGQRSUHSR]QDYDWLOHVRYLVMHYNDWHURVRQDYHGHN YVWDYLOLQHSDWXGLWLVWHJDL]NDWHUHJDVRJDSUL+HUDNOLWXY]HOLm+HLGHJJHU +HLGHJJHU VNXďD RKUDQMDWL ]DYHGDQMH GD VPLVOD DUKDLÍQH PLVOL QL PRÍ GRNRQÍQR LQ Y FHORWL]DSRSDVWLQHGDEL]DďOLYSULVYDMDQMH3RXGDUMDGDWXGLVDPQLLPXQQDWDNďQR SRÍHWMHLQGDVHWHPXPRUGDQLPRÍL]RJQLWLGDMHEUDQMH]DQD]DMYVHOHMSRJRMHQRWXGL ]QDďRODVWQRPLVOLMR$OLEROMQHSRVUHGQRREUDÍDQMHYSUHWHNORVW}VHQDYH]XMHWDNRQD SUHWHNORNRWWXGLQDSULÍXMRÍHLQSULKRGQMHm+HLGHJJHU $YHQGDUVRQMHJRYDL]YDMDQMDȡWRVH]GLQXMQRL]SRVWDYLWLȡSUDYWDNRSRJRMHQD VVSHFLʳÍQRPLVHOQRSRWMRLQ]ĤHOMRXWHPHOMLWLʳOR]RʳMRYL]YRUQHP1DQHNDWHULKPHVWLK JDRGQHVHJORERNRYUD]JODEOMDQMDNLLPDMRYHÍVNXSQHJD]QMHJRYLPLODVWQLPL]DVWDYLW YDPLNRWVSUHGVRNUDWVNRPLVOLMRNDUJDQHUD]ORÍXMHELVWYHQRRGQMHJRYLKSUHGKRGQLNRY 1HPďNDʳOR]RʳMDMHQDPUHÍWDNRSUDYL*DGDPHU*DGDPHUYVHRGURPDQWLNH GDOMH]DYH]DQDVYRMHYUVWQL grekomaniji NLMRVLOLGDVHQHQHKQRYUDÍDN]DÍHWNRPLQY QMLKXWHPHOMXMHVYRMHODVWQHSRVWDYNH .RIPDQMHYVYRMHP]DYUDÍDQMX povzemanja SUHFHMNULWLÍQDSUHGYVHPGR+HJOD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 99 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 )HQRPHQDVHOHNWLYQHJDUD]XPHYDQMDLQSULODďÍDQMDVWDYUHVQLFLODKNRSRYVHPQH SUREOHPDWLÍQD1HNDWHUHʳOR]RIVNHďROHNRWMHQDSULPHUSUDJPDWL]HPELSRÍHWMHVNODGQR VNDWHULPRGSUHGKRGQLNRYY]DPHPRWLVWRNDUMHNRULVWQRQDPRVWDORSD]DYUĤHPRFHOR YSRSROQRVWLSRGSUOH+NUDWLQHVSRUQRYHOMDȡRGWRG]JRUDMRPHQMHQRKHLGHJJHUMDQVNR ]DYHGDQMHȡGDVHSRYUďQHPXSRY]HPDQMXLQSULODďÍDQMXQLNROLQLPRÍYFHORWLL]RJQLWL ,QYHQGDUMHWRYUVWQRL]YDMDQMHȡYVDMYNRQWHNVWXVRRÍDQMD]PLVOLMRNLMHRGQDV RGGDOMHQDWROLNRNROLNRUVRRGGDOMHQL]DÍHWNLʳOR]RʳMHȡSUHFHMďNRGOMLYRVDMSRQHSR WUHEQHP]DPHJOMXMHPRĤQRVWQHSRVUHGQHJDVRRÍHQMDVVDPLPLIUDJPHQWL3ULEOLĤHYDQMH DYWRUMHPNDWHULKPLVOLSR]QDPRLQSUL]QDPR]JROMNRWYULYNHNRWSRHWLÍQR]DVWDYOMHQH LQQDLYQRQHGRGHODQHWHPHOMHPRGHUQHMďLKEOLĤMLKLQMDVQHMďLKʳOR]RIVNLKVLVWHPRYMH ODKNRNDMKLWURVPDWUDQR]DQHSRWUHEQRDOLFHOR]DSRYVHPRGYHÍQR9NROLNRUMHQDďH ]DQLPDQMH]DPLVHODUKDLÍQHJDJUďWYDSRJRMHQREROMDOLPDQML]NOMXÍQR]ĤHOMRSRLVNDWL SULNODGQRSRGODJRDOLSRSROQLWLODVWHQʳOR]RIVNLVLVWHPMHĤLYRVWVDPHPLVOLQHREKRGQR REVRMHQDQDSURSDG 326.86,=+2'$,==$*$7(35,69$-$1-$ 1DPHQSULÍXMRÍHUD]SUDYHXYRGRPDLPHQRYDQH dopolnitev predavanja, ni v is NDQMXXQLYHU]DOQLKUHďLWHY*UH]JROM]DSRVNXVODMďDQMDWHĤDYNLMLKSULQDďDVRRÍDQMH] DUKDLÍQRJUďNRPLVOLMR9NROLNRUVLQHĤHOLPRGDWDRVWDQHLQSRVWDQHPUWYDÍUNDQDSD SLUMX]JROM]JRGRYLQVNLRNUDVDOLSRGODJDPRGHUQLPʳOR]RIVNLPVLVWHPRPMHSRWUHEHQ WUXG.RWYXYRGQLďWXGLMLNVORYHQVNHPXSUHYRGX Fragmentov predsokratikov SUDYL*R UD]G.RFLMDQÍLÍ.RFLMDQÍLÍ}3UHGVRNUDWLNLVRNRW]UDN2NURJQDVȡDSRWXMRÍLY QDV9SOHWHQLYQDďHPLVHOQRYGLKDYDQMHLQL]GLKDYDQMHm6RRÍHQMH]QMLPL]DKWHYDRGSU WRVWYSRJOHGRYDQMXQD]DM]PRĤQRVWGD]DWUHQXWHNRGORĤLPRODVWQRʳOR]RIVNRSUWOMDJR LQSULVOXKQHPRMDYOMDQMXSUHWHNOHJD 0QRĤLFDLQWHUSUHWDFLMNL EROMDOLPDQMEHQHYROHQWQRSRY]HPDMRLQVLSULODďÍDMR UD]OLÍQHHOHPHQWHSUHGVRNUDWVNHPLVOLWXQLYSRPRÍ7DNRMHNOMXEWLVRÍOHWQLWUDGLFLMLDOL SUDY]DUDGLQMHGDQHVHQDNRÍHQHďHEROMQHMDVQR}NDMMHVSRVDPH]QLPLL]UHNL>PLVOLO GHQLPR@ +HUDNOLWm =RUH $OL GUXJDÍH }9HÍ ďWXGLM NRW SUHEHUHPR >GHQLPR@ R+HUDNOLWXPDQMYHPRRQMHPDÍHQHSUHEHUHPRQREHQHWHGDMQHYHPRQLÍm ,ELG ȡ,]WHJDVOHGLGDMHSRWUHEQRRKUDQMDWLUDYQRYHVMH=DYHGDQMHSRPHQD+HUDNOL WRYHPLVOLNDNRUWXGLPLVOLGUXJLK]JRGQMLKPLVOHFHY]DKWHYDRERMH=DKWHYDUD]ODJRLQ ]PRĤQRVWSULVOXKQLWLL]UHNRPVDPLP7HĤDYDPRGHUQHPLVOLNLSDMLMHYUHVQLFLSRGOHJOD ĤHDQWLNDV3ODWRQRPLQ$ULVWRWHORPQDÍHOXQLYSUHNRPHUQHPYGDMDQMXLQWHUSUHWDFLMDP WHPYHÍYVDPHPSULVWRSXNLQWHUSUHWLUDQMX}1DPHVWRGDELSULVOXKQLOLL]UHNRPÍHVPR 100 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 100 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 MLK VSORK VSRVREQL VOLďDWL VNR]QMH UD]ODJDPR SUHGYVHP VHEHm ,ELG %UDQMH +HUDNOL WD ]DKWHYD VSUHMHWMH GYRMHJD ÍHWXGL QDP QDďD PRGHUQD LQWXLFLMD WR VSUHMHWMH EUDQL 'UXJDVWYDUSDMHVWUDKSUHGMDVQRVWMRLQSUHSURVWRVWMRUHVQLÍQHJDSUHGVSR ]QDQMHP NL QH ]DKWHYD PQRJR]QDOVWYD NL QL ORÍHQR RG ĤLYOMHQMD DPSDN MH OH NRW GHO OHWHJDȡSUHGYHGHQMHPNLMHYHGQRVSUHSOHWHQR]QHYHGHQMHPm=RUH 0RMDUD]SUDYDQHSULQDďDSRGUREQHREUDYQDYHSRVDPH]QLKIUDJPHQWRYLQQH RGJRYDUMDQDVSHFLʳÍQHLQWHUSUHWDWLYQH]DJDWH%ROMNRWWRSULQDďDRSR]RULORRQXMQRVWL ]DYHGDQMDODVWQHʳOR]RIVNHSRWLSRNDWHULVHVSUHKDMDPRLQVNDWHUHVHREUDÍDPRQD]DMN L]YLUQHPX5D]GDOMDSRNDWHULVHJLEOMHPRMHRJURPQD3UHYHOLNDGDELVHODKNRL]RJQLOL YVHP SDVWHP NL QD QDV SUHĤLMR RE SRWL 7XGL QDPȡ WDNR NRW $ULVWRWHOX 1LHW]VFKHMX +HLGHJJHUMXLQďHNRPXȡVHODKNR]JRGLVHMH]JRGLORLQER]JRGLORGDERPRNDWHUHJD RGDUKDLÍQLKPLVOHFHYSRY]HOLSRYUďQRPRUGDFHOR]QDPHQRPSRGSUHWLODVWQRPLVHO$ SUDYMHȡLQYWHPSULVSHYNXVHPWRMDVQR]DULVDOȡGDVHWDNďQHJDSRÍHWMD]DYHGDPRLQ JDREUDYQDYDPRNULWLÍQR/HWDNRERPRY]DÍHWNLKʳOR]RʳMHSUHSR]QDOLNDMYHÍNRW]JROM ]JRGRYLQVNRSRGUREQRVW/HWDNRERPRDUKDLÍQRPLVHOSUHSR]QDOLNRWQHNDMĤLYHJDQH NDMNDUVHMDYOMDWXGLYVRGREQRVWLLQVÍLPHUODKNRHQDNRYUHGQRUD]SUDYOMDPR 101 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 101 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 BIBLIOGRAFIJA &LJOHQHÍNL-DQ 3R]DEOMHQLWHPHQRVRQWRORJLMDLQHVKDWRORJLMDYDUKDLÍQLJUďNLPLVOL /MXEOMDQD.8'/RJRV &XUG3DWULFLD A Presocratics Reader: Second Edition. +DFNHWW3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSD Q\,QGLDQDSROLV &XUG3DWULFLD3UHVRFUDWLF3KLORVRSK\ , v: The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 'RVWRSQRQD KWWSVSODWRVWDQIRUGHGXDUFKLYHVIDOOHQWULHVSUHVRFUDWLFV Fragmenti predsokratikov. ,]GDOD+'LHOVLQ:.UDQ]XU*.RFLMDQÍLÍSUHY' %HQNRģ%RUDN-&LJOHQHÍNL,-)ULGO0+RUYDW*.RFLMDQÍLÍ'0RYULQ%9H]MDN 6:HLVVLQ)=RUH/MXEOMDQD%HOHWULQD *DGDPHU+DQV*HRUJ Izbrani spisi/MXEOMDQD1RYDUHYLMD *UDKDP'DQLHO:+HUDFOLWXVY The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 'RVWRS no na: KWWSVSODWRVWDQIRUGHGXDUFKLYHVIDOOHQWULHVKHUDFOLWXV +HLGHJJHU0DUWLQ Predavanja in sestavki/MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD +HLGHJJHU0DUWLQ Kaj se pravi misliti? /MXEOMDQD=QDQVWYHQD]DORĤED)LOR]RIVNH IDNXOWHWH .RFLMDQÍLÍ*RUD]G3UYLQVNRPLďOMHQMHY Fragmenti predsokratikov, I-XXXII. /MXEOMDQDĎWXGHQWVND]DORĤED .RIPDQ6DUDK 1LHW]VFKHLQWHPDÍQRVW+HUDNOLWD.RSHU+\SHULRQ 0DQVIHOG-DS'R[RJUDSK\RI$QFLHQW3KLORVRSK\Y The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 'RVWRSQRQD KWWSVSODWRVWDQIRUGHGXDUFKLYHVIDOOHQWULHV GR[RJUDSK\DQFLHQW 5HDOH*LRYDQQL=JRGRYLQDDQWLÍQHʳOR]RʳMHY Zvezek 1: od izvorov do Sokrata. /MXEOMDQD6WXGLD+XPDQLWDWLV =RUH)UDQFL /RJRVLQELWYDQWLÍQLʳOR]RʳML/MXEOMDQD=QDQVWYHQRLQSXEOLFLVWLÍQR VUHGLďÍH =RUH)UDQFL ,]]JRGRYLQHDQWLÍQHJUďNHʳOR]RʳMH/MXEOMDQD)LOR]RIVNDIDNXOWHWD =RUH)UDQFL=QDPHQMDQDSRWL+HUDNOLWRYHJDPLďOMHQMDY =DÍHWNLJUďNHJDPLďO-jenja, 141–164/MXEOMDQD.8'/RJRV 102 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 102 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 PARADOKS HEGLOVE FASCINACIJE NAD ANTIGONO Sara Svati Sharan UVOD 3UREOHPUD]PHUMDPHGGXKRPLQQDUDYRPHGGUXJLPYNOMXÍXMHWXGLVDPRXPHY QRVWWHU}QDUDYQRVWmVDPHGLVWLQNFLMHPHGGXKRPLQQDUDYR6DPRXPHYQRVW}QDUDYQH JDm MH QDPUHÍ SRJRVWR NULQND QDGDOMQMH SHUSHWXDFLMH VWHUHRWLSRY VWHUHRWLSL SD VH QH SRMDYOMDMR]JROMYYXOJDUQRVWLYVDNGDQMHJDL]UDĤDQMDDPSDNWXGLYWHRUHWVNHPGLVNXU]X 2]LURPDREHUDYQLVHSUDY]DSUDYGUXJDL]GUXJHQDSDMDWDLPSOLNDFLMHNLVH]DULVXMHMRY PHWDʳ]LNLLPDMRSRVOHGLFHYSUDNVLLQREUDWQR 2VUHGQMDWHPDSULÍXMRÍHJDSULVSHYNDERGLVWLQNFLMDPHGQDUDYRLQGXKRPYWLVWL WRÍNLNRHGHQL]PHGQDMEROMSR]QDQLKSUHGVWDYQLNRYʳOR]RIVNHJDNDQRQDȡ*HRUJ:LO KHOP)ULHGULFK+HJHOȡHQDÍLQDUDYR]ĤHQVNRLQGXKD]PRďNLPģHQVNDMH]YHGHQDQD SDUWLNXODUQRVWWUDGLFLRQDOQHVSROQHYORJH]QRWUDMGUXĤLQVNHVIHUHYQDVSURWMX]PRďNLP NLMHDNWLYHQYGUĤDYLWHU]QDQRVWL'UXĤLQD]DSROQMXMHSROMHSDUWLNXODUQRVWLGUĤDYDSD XQLYHU]DOQRVWLGUXĤLQRSUHÍLERĤML]DNRQGUĤDYRÍORYHďNL]DNRQȡVOHGQMHQDMELUH]XOWL UDORWXGLYNRQʴLNWXPHGĤHQVNRLQPRďNLP2EUDYQDYDODERPSUHGYVHPVSHFLʳÍQLSR ORĤDMĤHQVNHNDNRUMRYVYRMRʳOR]RIVNRPLVHOXPHVWL+HJHO9NRQWHNVWXSRORĤDMDĤHQVN LPDSUL+HJOXSUHFHMLQWULJDQWQRYORJROLN$QWLJRQH9SUDďDWLVHPRUDPR]DNDMVH+HJHO VSORKVNOLFXMHQD$QWLJRQRRESRVNXVXXVWROLÍHYDQMDGLKRWRPLMPRďNRĤHQVNRDNWLYQR SDVLYQRGUĤDYDGUXĤLQDÍHSDVH$QWLJRQD6RIRNORYWUDJLÍQLGUDPVNLOLNWRYUVWQLPSUH GDOÍNDQMHPSUDY]DSUDYL]PLND $QWLJRQDVHSUL+HJOXVLFHUSRMDYLYWUHKGHOLK)HQRPHQRORJLMLGXKD2ULVXʳ OR]RʳMHSUDYLFHLQ3UHGDYDQMLKRHVWHWLNL2EUDYQDYDOLERPR]JROM)HQRPHQRORJLMRGXKD LQ2ULVʳOR]RʳMHSUDYLFHVDMY3UHGDYDQMLKRHVWHWLNL$QWLJRQDVOXĤLYHÍLQRPD]JROM]D UD]ODJRWUDJHGLMHNRWOLWHUDUQHIRUPH9SUHRVWDOLKGYHKGHOLKSD$QWLJRQDNDNRUMRUD ]XPH R]LURPD ĤHOL UD]XPHWL +HJHO YHV ÍDV SUHWHQGLUD RQNUDM 6RIRNORYHJD GUDPVNHJD OLND$QWLJRQD MH REHQHP JODVQLFD VSRUD PHG GYHPD ]DNRQRPD NL VWD RED OHJLWLPQD ÍHSUDYMH]JROMHQOHJDOHQȡLQREHQHPJODVQLFDĤHQVNRVWLNRWWDNHNLQDMELELODYHGQR WHVQRSRYH]DQD]GUXĤLQR1MHQDQDMYLďMDHWLÍQDGROĤQRVWMHQDPUHÍSRNRSEUDWD]DWRGD ODKNRQMHJRYLGXďLRPRJRÍLSUHKRGYSRVPUWQL+DG6WHPNRSRVWDYLVYRMRGUXĤLQRQD SUYRPHVWRSDSUHNUďLREÍHYHOMDYQH]DNRQHYGUĤDYLVDMVH]RSHUVWDYLNUDOMHYLSUHSRYHGL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 103 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 SRNRSD+HJHO$QWLJRQLQRRGORÍLWHYUD]XPHWDNRNRWGDERĤHQVNDNRWWDNDYVDNLÍNR PRUDL]ELUDWLPHGGYHPDRGORÍLWYDPDYHGQRL]EUDODGUXĤLQRÍHWXGLQDUDÍXQGHVWUXN FLMH GUĤDYH ,Q REHQHP ER WXGL L]EUDOD VIHUR ]DVHEQRVWL QDPHVWR MDYQHJD VDM MH VDPD WDNRLQWDNRYSHWD]JROMYSROMH]DVHEQHJD+HJHOVLFHUWRUD]XPHNRW}QDUDYQRGDQRVWmD VHGDMYHPRGDYSROMHMDYQHJDĤHQVNDYWHGDQMHPKLVWRULÍQHPRNYLUXQLQLNROLQLWLLPHOD YVWRSD $QWLJRQR ODKNR VLFHU VNR]L RÍL DNWXDOQHJD ÍDVD UD]XPHPR NRW SDUDGLJPDWVNL SULPHUIHPLQLVWLÍQHJDJHVOD}]DVHEQRMHSROLWLÍQRLQNRWWDNRWXGLMDYQRm$QWLJRQLQR GHMDQMHSRNRSDEUDWDMHELORQDPUHÍ]HORRÍLWQRYVWRSYMDYQRVIHURGHORYDQMDLQGDMH SUDYWRVWRULODĤHQVNDMHNUDOMD.UHRQWDSRYVHPSUHVHQHWLOR6HYHGDSDLGHMDSROLWLÍQRVWL ]DVHEQRVWL NL VH MH SRMDYLOD Y VWROHWMX RPRJRÍD QRYR EUDQMH$QWLJRQH NL SRYVHP SUHVHJD+HJORYHGLKRWRPLMH RAZLIKA 5D]PHUMHHQHJDVXEMHNWDGRGUXJHJDVXEMHNWDVHSUL+HJOXQDKDMD]QRWUDMWUHK UD]OLÍQLK VIHU GUXĤEHQHJD ĤLYOMHQMD GUXĤLQH FLYLOQH GUXĤEH LQ GUĤDYH9VH WUL VIHUH VR REUDYQDYDQHY 2ULVXʳOR]RʳMHSUDYLFH 6SROQDUD]OLNDMHUHOHYDQWQD]DUD]OLNRYDQMHGUXĤ EHQLKUD]PHULMPHGVIHUDPLREMHNWLYQHJDGXKDVDMVWUXNWXUDLQVWLWXFLMY+HJORYHP Orisu WHPHOMLQDVSROQLUD]OLNL6SROQDUD]OLNDLPDSRPHPEQRYORJRWXGLY Fenomenologiji duha. 3RMDYOMDVHNRWUD]OLND]QRWUDMUHVQLÍQHJDGXKDQDYPHVQLVWRSQLÍNLSRWLQDUDYQH ]DYHVWLRGÍXWQHJRWRYRVWLGRDEVROXWQHJD5HVQLÍQLGXKQDWHMYPHVQLVWRSQLÍNLVHNDĤH NRWQDUDYQRQUDYQRREÍHVWYRNLMHGUXĤLQDȡYGUXĤLQLSDQDMELELODQDMEROMHOHPHQWDUQD UD]OLNDPHGPRĤHPLQĤHQRPHGPRďNLPLQĤHQVNR =DNDMSRWUHEXMH+HJHOSUDYVSROQRUD]OLNRGDELRSHULUDO]UD]OLÍQLPLVXEMHNWL ]QRWUDMQMHJRYHJDWHRUHWVNHJDSROMDQDPQLMDVQR$YUQLPRVHQDMSUHMNUD]OLNLNRWWDNL 3UL+HJOXLPDPRȡ]HORJURERUHÍHQRȡGYDSUHFHMQHMDVQDPRPHQWDNRVHSRMDYLUD] PHUMHPHGGYHPDQHHQDNLPDVXEMHNWRPDERM]DSULSR]QDQMHPHGJRVSRGDUMHPLQ KODSFHPWHUYORJRĤHQVNHNLMH]YHGHQDQDSDUWLNXODUQRVWWUDGLFLRQDOQHYORJH]QRWUDM GUXĤLQVNHVIHUHYQDVSURWMX]PRďNLPNLMHDNWLYHQQDY]YHQNLLPD}VXEVWDQFLDOQRĤLYO MHQMHYGUĤDYL]QDQRVWLLQSRGREQHPm+HJHO SAMOZAVEDANJE IN DRUGO +HJORYD Fenomenologija duha VHODKNREHUHNRW]JRGRYLQDGLDOHNWLNHPHGSDU WLNXODUQLP LQ XQLYHU]DOQLP ÍORYHNȡ DPSDN ]JROM NRW PRďNLȡ LďÍH SULSR]QDQMH VYRMH Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 104 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 XPQH XQLYHU]DOQH SODWL 6XEMHNW VH ]DYHGD VDPHJD VHEH NRW UDFLRQDOQR ELWMH ]JROM ÍH SULSR]QDHQDNRYUHGQRVWLQVDPRVWRMQRVWGUXJLKLQÍHMHWRSULSR]QDQMHY]DMHPQRSUL VRWQRWXGL]QMLKRYHVWUDQL9]DMHPQRSULSR]QDQMH]DKWHYDGDREDVXEMHNWDVSUHMPHWD HQDNRYUHGHQLQQHRGYLVHQVWDWXVGUXJHJDVXEMHNWMHVDPR]DYHGHQ]JROMSUHNRGUXJHJD WMNRYLGLVHEHYGUXJHPWDNRNDNRUWDLVWLGUXJLYLGLVHEHYSUYHP}6DPR]DYHGDQMHGR VHĤH]DGRYROMLWHYOHYGUXJHPVDPR]DYHGDQMXm+HJHOVDMWHGDMSRVWDQH}MD] NLMHPLLQPLNLMHMD]m,ELG +HJORYVXEMHNW]DÍQHVYRMRSRWVSR]QDYDQMD]DSUWYVYRMVROLSVLVWLÍQLRERGNHU VHODKNR]DJRWRYR]DYHGD]JROMVDPHJDVHEHRNROLFHSDďHQHSULSR]QDYDNRWVHELHQDNH ĤLYL Y }SUHSULÍDQMX GD MH >]JROM QMHJRYD@ YHGQRVW UHVQLÍQDm .REH +HJORY VXEMHNW VYRMHJD QHSULSR]QDYDQMD QH L]YUďL NRW DEVROXWQR QHJDFLMR RNROLFH LQ GUXJHJD DPSDN ]DQLND ]JROM YHOMDYR QMXQH SR]LFLMH 6DPHJD VHEH SRVWDYOMD QD SUYR PHVWR YVH RVWDORPXMHNRWQH]QDQRPDQMYUHGQRUD]GHOLWHYQDSR]QDQRLQWXMH]DQMYVHEXMHYUHG QRVWQRKLHUDUKLMR+HJHOUDYQR]DWRYQHVHPLVHOQLHNVSHULPHQWNLVOLďLQDLPH NRQʴLNW gospodarja in hlapca. 6DPR]DYHGDQMH MH QDMSRSUHM HQRVWDYQR ]DVHEVWYR VHELHQDNR SUHN L]NOMXÍLWYH . YVHJD GUXJHJD L] VHEH QMHJRYR ELVWYR LQ DEVROXWHQ SUHGPHW PX MH MD] LQ Y WHM QHSRVUHGQRVWL DOL Y WHM ELWL VYRMHJD ]DVHEVWYD MH SRVDPH]QR .DU MH ]DQM GUXJR MH QHELVWYHQ SUHGPHW R]QDÍHQ ] ]QDÍDMHP QHJDWLYXPD $PSDN WR GUXJR MH WXGL QHNR VDPR]DYHGDQMH LQGLYLGXXP QDVWRSL QDVSURWL LQGLYLGXX >@ 5D]PHUMH REHK VDPR]DYHGDQM MH >WRUHM@ GRORÍHQR WDNR GD VH VDPL LQ GUXJR GUXJR SRWUGLWD ] ERMHP QD ĤLYOMHQMH LQ VPUW +HJHO ȡ ÌHELYSRWUMHYDQMXVYRMHVYRERGHUDYQDOLYVLHQDNRELVWDYDĤLYOMHQMDQDNRFNR ȡERMQDĤLYOMHQMHLQVPUWȡQXMQRSRY]URÍLODVPUWYVDMHQHJDL]PHGQDVSURWQLNRYDOLSD FHORREHK3UHĤLYHOLELVHVRRÍLO]QHSUHPRVWOMLYR]DJDWRVDMQHELPRJHOELWLSULSR]QDQ V VWUDQL PUWYHJD LQ VH ]DWRUHM QH EL PRJHO IRUPLUDWL NRW VDPR]DYHGDQMH 0UWYHF MH QDPUHÍ ]JROM QHNDM QH]DYHVWQHJD 6DPR]DYHGDQMX SD MH RKUDQLWHY ĤLYOMHQMD ELVWYHQD VDPR]DYHGDQMH QL PRJRÍH Y PUWYHP VWDQMX DPSDN ]JROM Y ĤLYHP 7R SD VSR]QD ]JROM ]DYHVW WLVWHJD L]PHG QDVSURWQLNRY NL Y ERMX QD ĤLYOMHQMH LQ VPUW QRÍH LWL GR NRQFD LQ VYRMHJDĤLYOMHQMDQHULVNLUD6NUDWNDVSUHMPHSRUD]LQVHSRNRULGUXJHPXSUHGDVYRMR VDPRVWRMQRVWSRVWDQHPXKODSHF=D]DYHVWQMHJRYHJDJRVSRGDUMDSDREVWRMLWDQDL]ELUR ]JROM]PDJDDOLL]JXEDĤLYOMHQMDȡWUHWMHPRĤQRVWLQLQMHJRYD]DYHVWVHQLVSRVREQDVSUH PLQMDWL+ODSÍHYVND]DYHVWPQRJRUDMHSUL]QD]DÍDVQRSRGUHGLWHYȡLQUDYQR]DYROMR VSR]QDQMDQXMQRVWLRKUDQLWYHĤLYOMHQMDYKODSÍHYVNL]DYHVWLOHĤLUHVQLFDL]NDWHUHVHODK NRKUDQLQDGDOMQMHVSR]QDYDQMHYHGQRVWL}5HVQLFDVDPRVWRMQH]DYHVWLMHSRWHPWDNHP KODSÍHYVND]DYHVWm,ELG Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 105 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 $PSDNFHORWHQPLVHOQLHNVSHULPHQWERMD]DSULSR]QDQMHPHGJRVSRGDUMHPLQ KODSFHPMHQHXVSHODUDYQRSULȡSULSR]QDQMX'UXĤEHQDYH]PHGJRVSRGDUMHPLQKODS FHPĤHVWUXNWXUQRQHGRYROMXMHSULSR]QDQMDNDNRERKODSHFSULSR]QDYDOJRVSRGDUMXVD PR]DYHGDQMHÍHMHSDKODSHFELOR]QDÍHQNRWQHNGRNLQLYUHGHQGDELJDNGRSULSR]QDO" 6NUDWNDRY]DMHPQRVWLQHPRUHELWLJRYRUD0RPHQWUD]PHUMDJRVSRGDUMDLQKODSFD WM VDPRVWRMQH LQ QHVDPRVWRMQH ]DYHVWL SUDY]DSUDY VSORK QL QXMHQ HOHPHQW GUXĤEHQH VHVWDYH MH SD VOHGQMR QDMODĤH UD]XPHWL SUDY VNR]HQMȡ YQD]DM 0RPHQW UD]PHUMD JRV SRGDUMDLQKODSFDMHQDPUHÍ]DVQRYDQNRWJHQH]DPLWDRQDVWDQNXLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQRVWL SPOLNA RAZLIKA *UHPRGDOMHÌHVRSRVWDYOMDPRVNXSDMRGORPNHWDNRL] Orisa kot iz Fenomenologije MHVNXSHNLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQRVWLYREOLNLGUXĤLQHSROMHSDUWLNXODUQRVWLGUĤDYDSDXQL YHU]DOQRVWLGUXĤLQRSUHÍLERĤML]DNRQGUĤDYRÍORYHďNL]DNRQȡWRSDUH]XOWLUDYNRQʴLNWX PHGĤHQVNRLQPRďNLPNDNRUVHSRMDYLSUL$QWLJRQLQLJHVWLEUDWRYHJDSRNRSD =GUXĤLWHY PRďNHJDLQĤHQVNHY]DNRQVNHPVWDQXWYRUL}GHMDYQRVUHGLQRFHORWHLQHOHPHQWNLMH UD]GYRMHQYWDGYDHNVWUHPDERĤMHJDLQÍORYHďNHJD]DNRQDUDYQRWDNRQMXQDQHSRVUHGQD ]GUXĤLWHY>@m+HJHO'UXĤLQD}QDY]YHQmIXQNFLRQLUDNRWVDPRVWRMQDRVHED ÍHSUDYRG]QRWUDMVHVWRMLL]YVDMGYHKVYRMR]XQDQMRUHDOQRVWSDLPDYODVWQLQLȡGUX ĤLQRNRWSUDYQRRVHERQDVSURWLGUXJLPRVHEDPSDNRWQMHQDJODYD]DVWRSDPRĤ'UXĤL QDFLYLOQDGUXĤEDLQGUĤDYDȡWULMHPRPHQWLQUDYQRVWLȡREVWDMDMRYQDVSURWMXGRDOLY QDSHWRVWLGUXJGRGUXJHJDYHQGDUVRKNUDWL]GUXĤHQLYWRWDOLWHWLNDWHUHQDMYLďMLL]UD]MH XVWDYDGUĤDYH=DNRQPHGPRďNLPLQĤHQVNRPRĤHPLQĤHQRYVHEXMHGHOLWHYGRPDÍHJD GHODYGUXĤELY]JRMRLQQHJRRWURNRVQRYQRRGJRYRUQRVW]DL]REUD]ERLQXVRGRSULYDWQH ODVWQLQHNRWMRGRORÍDGHGRYDQMH'UXĤLQDNLMR+HJHOREUDYQDYDMHEXUĤRD]QDPHďÍDQ VNDGUXĤLQDMH]JRGRYLQVNDREOLNDNLMHSRYH]DQD]Y]SRQRPLQGXVWULMVNHJDNDSLWDOL] PD7DGUXĤLQDNRHNVLVWLUD]GUXĤEHQLPLQDVOHGNLLQGLYLGXDOL]PDODVWQLQHLQUD]UHGQH GHOLWYHSUDYWDNRSDWXGL]]DKWHYDPL]DVHEQH]DYHVWL 1DMSUHMMHGUXĤLQDVXEVWDQFLDOQDFHORWDNLMLSULSDGDVNUE]DWRSRVHEQRVWUDQ LQGLYLGXDWDNRJOHGHVUHGVWHYLQVSUHWQRVWLGDELVLODKNRSULGRELONDML]REÍHJD SUHPRĤHQMDNRWWXGLJOHGHQMHJRYHVXEVLVWHQFHLQSUHVNUEHYSULPHUXPRUHELWQH QH]PRĤQRVWL&LYLOQDGUXĤEDSDLQGLYLGXDL]WUJDL]WHYH]LQMHQHÍODQHRGWXML GUXJGUXJHPXLQMLKSULSR]QDNRWVDPRVWRMQHRVHEHGDOMH]XQDQMRDQRUJDQVNR QDUDYRLQRÍHWQDWODYNDWHULKMHLPHOSRVDPH]QLNVYRMRVXEVWLVWHQFRFLYLOQD GUXĤED]DPHQMDVVYRMLPLWOHPLLQVDPREVWRMFHORWQHGUXĤLQHSRGYUĤHRGYLVQRVWL RGVHEHQDNOMXÍQRVWL7DNRMHLQGLYLGXXPSRVWDOVLQFLYLOQHGUXĤEHLQNDNRU LPDWD]DKWHYHGRQMHJDWDNRLPDRQSUDYLFHGRQMH+HJHO 6NUDWND HQRWQRVW GUXĤLQH R] QMHQH HNVLVWHQFH NRW QHNH }VSORďQH LQ WUDM QH RVHEHm MH ]JROM ]DÍDVQD QUDYQD UD]SXVWLWHY GUXĤLQH QDVWRSL WDNRM NR RWURFL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 106 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 RGUDVWHMRLQNRVRSUHG]DNRQRPSULSR]QDQL]DRVHEHNLVR]PRĤQHLPHWODVWQLQRLQVH SRURÍLWLȡ }VLQRYL NRW SRJODYDUML QRYLK GUXĤLQ KÍHUNH NRW ĤHQHm }1DUDYQDm HQRWQRVW GUXĤLQHUD]SDGHVVPUWMRGHGRYDQMHPDOLORÍLWYLMRWLVWRNDUMHELORVSUYDSRMPRYDQR NRW]DNRQLWLNRUHODWGUXĤLQHȡWMODVWQLQDȡVHL]NDĤHNRWWLVWRNDUWRHQRWQRVWUD]MH GD'UXĤLQDY]JDMDVYRMHRWURNHQRYVDMVLQRYHWDNRGDVLWLSUL]DGHYDMR]DVYRERGR RVHEQRVWL NR SRVWDQHMR SROQROHWQL LQ ]D WR GD VH MLK SULSR]QD ]D RVHEH WRUHM GUXĤL QD QHQD]DGQMH REVWDMD ]D FLYLOQR GUXĤER GUXĤLQD MH GRMHWD NRW QUDYQL NRUHQ GUĤDYH 3UHSOHWHQRVW PHG GUXĤLQR FLYLOQR GUXĤER LQ GUĤDYR Y]GUĤXMH LQ REHQHP YHV ÍDV UD]UHďXMH SURWLVORYMH PHG XQLYHU]DOQLP LQ SDUWLNXODUQLP PHG REMHNWLYQR GDQRVW MRLQVXEMHNWLYQLPQDJQMHQMHP'UXĤLQDMHSROMHSRVDPLÍQRVWL]DNRQMH}L]YRUQLNRUDN YSURFHVXVNDWHULPVHEVWYRSRVWDQHȣXPHďÍHQRȤ>@]DNRQSRWHPWDNHPSUHGSRVWDYOMD SRMHPVHEVWYDNRWMHXWHOHďHQY6XEMHNWXm6WHLQEHUJHU=DNRQPHGPRĤHPLQ ĤHQRMHWRUHMWLVWLNLUD]UHďXMHSURWLVORYMHPHGLQGLYLGXRPLQGUXĤER7RSDSRÍQHWDNR GDQDUHGL]HORMDVHQUH]PHGSR]LFLMRPRďNHJDLQSR]LFLMRĤHQVNH (QVSROMH]DWRWLVWRGXKRYQRNDUVHUD]GYRMLY]DVHEQRRVHEQRVDPRVWRMQRVW LQ Y Y«GHQMH LQ KRWHQMH VYRERGQH REÍRVWL Y VDPR]DYHGDQMH SRMPRYQH PLVOL LQ KRWHQMH REMHNWLYQHJD NRQÍQHJD VPRWUD ȡ GUXJL VSRO WLVWR GXKRYQR NL VH RKUDQL Y HQRVWL NRW Y«GHQMH LQ KRWHQMH VXEVWDQFLDOQHJD Y IRUPL NRQNUHWQH SRVDPH]QRVWL LQ REÍXWND ȡ SUYL VLOHQ LQ XGHMVWYXMRÍ Y UD]PHUMX QDY]YHQ GUXJL SDVLYHQ LQ VXEMHNWLYHQ 0RĤ LPD ]DWR VYRMH GHMDQVNR VXEVWDQFLDOQR ĤLYOMHQMH Y GUĤDYL ]QDQRVWL LQ SRGREQHP LQ GUXJDÍH Y ERMX LQ GHOX ] ]XQDQMLP VYHWRP LQ V VDPLP VHERM WDNR GD VL OH L] VYRMH UD]GYRMLWYH SULERMXMH VDPRVWRMQR HQRVW V VHERM ȡ NDWHUH PLUQL ]RU LQ ÍXWHÍR VXEMHNWLYQR QUDYQRVW LPD Y GUXĤLQL Y NDWHUL LPD ĤHQD VYRMR VXEVWDQFLDOQR GRORÍLWHY LQ Y WHM SLHWHWL VYRMR QUDYQR QDVWURMHQRVW +HJHO 3DWHU IDPLOLDV PRďNL MH WRUHM V WHP NR XSUDYOMD ] GUXĤLQVNR ODVWQLQR ]QRWUDM FLYLOQHGUXĤEHLQGUĤDYHSRVWDYOMHQQDPHVWRPHGSDUWLNXODUQLPLQXQLYHU]DOQLPQMH JRYDĤHQDSDRVWDMDYH]DQDL]NOMXÍQRQDSROMHSDUWLNXODUQRVWLRQDMHWLVWDWRODĤQLFDLQ VNUEQLFDNDPRUVHSULGHPRďNLVSRÍLWLSRGROJHPGQHYXMDYQHJDXGHMVWYRYDQMD+HJHO ĤHQVNR]DSUHYGUXĤLQRSRWL]VWRSDL]GUXĤLQHSDMLSRSROQRPD]DSUH'DĤHQVNHQLPDMR NDMLVNDWLYVIHULMDYQHJD]DNROLÍLSUHGYVHPYGRGDWNXNL] Orisa: ģHQVNHVRSDÍODKNRRPLNDQHWRGD]DYLďMH]QDQRVWL]DʳOR]RʳMRLQGRORÍHQH SURGXNFLMHXPHWQRVWLNL]DKWHYDMRREÍHQLVRXVWYDUMHQHģHQVNHLPDMRODKNR SUHEOLVNH RNXV OMXENRVW YHQGDU QLPDMR LGHDORY >@ ģHQVNH VH L]REUD]LMR QH YHPR NDNR WDNRUHNRÍ VNR]L DWPRVIHUR SUHGVWDYH EROM VNR]L ĤLYOMHQMH NRW V SULGRELYDQMHP ]QDQM PHGWHP NR PRďNL GRVHĤH VYRM SRORĤDM VDPR V SULGRELWYLMR PLVOL LQ ] PQRJLPL WHKQLÍQLPL QDSRUL +HJHO Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 107 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 SPOL IN ZAKON ZDNRQPHGPRĤHPLQĤHQRQDMELELOQXMHQ]DUD]YRMREMHNWLYQHJDGXKDLQSUH KRGDRGVXEMHNWDKNRQNUHWQLRVHELDPSDNGDELSRVWDOLNRQNUHWQLRVHELELPRUDOLREH RVHELȡPRďNLLQĤHQVNLVXEMHNWPRĤDLQĤHQHȡGRVHÍLYUVWRUHʴHNWLYQHUD]VYHWOLWYHR] Y]DMHPQHJD SRGXKRYOMHQMD }>W@HRULMD VSROD SD EL WR HQRVWDYQR RQHPRJRÍLOD VDM ĤHQ VNHQHELPRJOHQLNROLGRVHÍLWDNHXPQRVWLm6WHLQEHUJHUģHQVNDMHGRORÍH QD]JROMLQVDPRVNR]LVYRMRVHNVXDOQRVWNLMHYIXQNFLMLPRQRJDPQHJD]DNRQD7RUHM VNR]LUHSURGXNWLYQRLQVNUEVWYHQRGHORNLQLPDQHSRVUHGQHJDHNRQRPVNHJDSRPHQD 1MHQDLQGLYLGXDOQRVWVHL]UDĤDL]NOMXÍQRQDSDVLYQLQDÍLQ >@YVHOHMYLQVNR]LVYRERGQRVXEMHNWLYQRVWGUXJHJD.RHQNUDWYVWRSLY]DNRQVNR ]YH]RVÍLPHUMHGRORÍHQRQMHQRFHORWQRĤLYOMHQMHQLNROLYHÍQH]DSXVWLGUXĤLQH =JROM GHNOH ]JXEL VYRMR ÍDVW V ȮSUHGDMR VYRMHJD WHOHVDȯ Y QH]DNRQVNLK VSROQLK UD]PHUMLK =D +HJOD VH ȮGRORÍLWHY GHNOLFH ELVWYHQR VHVWRML ]JROM Y UD]PHUMX ]DNRQDWRUHMVH]DKWHYDGDOMXEH]HQSUHMPHREOLNR]DNRQD/DQGHV ģHQVND MH QHSRSROQ LQGLYLGXXP ]JROM EOHGD VHQFD Y IXQNFLML GUXĤLQH NL }RUJDQL]LUDRVHEQRĤLYOMHQMHVSRPRÍMRLGHRORJLMHOMXEH]QLLQVSROQHGHOLWYHGHODm,ELG 'UXĤLQDWYRULFHORWRSUDY]DWRNHUĤHQVNDQLQLNROLLPHODVYRMHVXEMHNWLYQRVWLDP SDN]JROMQXGLRSRUR]DUD]YRMPRďNHJDVXEMHNWD.DURKUDQMDHQRWQRVW]DNRQDVNXSDM MH ljubezen OMXEH]HQMHY]URNGDVHPRďNLLQĤHQVND]GUXĤLWDY]DNRQVNLVWDQNRWPRĤLQ ĤHQD/MXEH]HQMHWLVWRNDUMX]GUXĤXMHWDNRGDY]DNRQVNL]YH]LR]LURPDNRWGUXĤLQDQLV WDQHRGYLVQLRVHELWHPYHÍÍODQR]LURPDÍODQLFD=DNRQ+HJHOGRORÍLNRW}SUDYQRQUDYQR OMXEH]HQVÍLPHUL]QMHJDL]JLQHPLQOMLYRPXKDVWRLQ]JROMVXEMHNWLYQRm+HJHO GRGDWHNN3ULL]ELUL]D]DNRQJUH]DL]ELURWHJDGDELVLPRĤLQĤHQDGHOLODVYRMRVUH ÍRLQQHVUHÍRY]URNL]D]DNRQSDVR]DPRďNHJDSRVHEQHODVWQRVWLVDPHĤHQVNHWMQD UDYQDOHSRWDPLOLQDďDUP]DĤHQVNRSDSUHPRĤHQMHPRďNHJDQMHJRYVWDQLQSRVHEQRVW ]QDÍDMDSUHGYVHPSULMD]QRVW,ELGN6NUDWNDSUL]DNRQXQHJUH]D]DGRYROMLWHY QDUDYQLKJRQRYNRWMHVSROQRVWSUHGYVHPSDQHJUH]D]DOMXEOMHQRVWOMXEH]HQY]QLNQH L]]DYHGDQMDGDMHSRWUHEQRVNUEHWL]DRWURNHLQVNUEHWL]DUD]YRMGUĤDYH6NUDWNDÍHWXGL +HJHOYHVÍDVWUGLGDVHY]DNRQXL]KDMDL]}VYRERGQHSUHGDMH>RVHEQRVWL@REHKVSRORYm ,ELG PRďNL VSRO VYRMR VYRERGR YHV ÍDV RKUDQMD WDNR NRW SDWHU IDPLOLDV LQ YRGMDGUXĤLQHNRWWXGLYGHORYDQMXYMDYQLVIHULȡPHGWHPNRMHĤHQVNDLPHODVYRERGR ]JROMSUHGSRVWDYOMHQRYVYRMHPGHORYDQMXSDMH]QRWUDM+HJORYHJDWHRUHWVNHJDVLVWHPD QLQLNGDUQLWLLPHOD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 108 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 6LFHUSDMHSR]QHMďL 2ULVʳOR]RʳMHSUDYLFH SUHFHMNRQ]HUYDWLYQHMďLRGEROM]JR GDM QDSLVDQH Fenomenologije duha: v Orisu PRUD GUXĤLQD QXMQR LPHWL PRĤD NRW SDWHU IDPLOLDVPHGWHPNRVHY Fenomenologiji duha JRYRULRĤHQLNRWWLVWLNLMHSUHGVWRMQLFD KLďH+HJHO3UHGYVHPSDMHY Fenomenologiji duha RPHQMHQRHQRUD] PHUMHPHGPRďNLPLQĤHQVNRNLMHPHGVHERMQRYHQGDUOHHQDNRYUHGQRWMVRURMHQVWYR PHGEUDWRPLQVHVWUR(QDNRYUHGQRVWLPHGPRďNLPLQĤHQVNRY Orisu QHPRUHPRLVNDWL ANTIGONA ÌH SRQRYLPR PRďNL ] MDYQLP XGHMVWYRYDQMHP VSDGD Y SROMH GXKD ĤHQVND ] ]DSUWRVWMRYGUXĤLQRYSROMHQDUDYH7RGLKRWRPLMR+HJHOEHUHWDNRVNR]LSUHMRPHQMHQL UD]FHS PHGXQLYHU]DOQRVWMRLQ SDUWLNXODUQRVWMR SROLWLÍQRVWMRLQ VIHUR ]DVHEQRVWL (QR NDUDNWHUL]LUD]DNRQGUĤDYHGUXJRSD]DNRQGUXĤLQHQDUDYHR]ERJRY'DEL+HJHOSR MDVQLOSDUDGLJPDWVNRʳJXURĤHQVNRVWL]QRWUDMGUXĤLQVNHJDĤLYOMHQMDSDȡSRYVHPSUHVH QHWOMLYRȡY]DPH]DY]RUOLN6RIRNORYHWUDJLÍQHMXQDNLQMH$QWLJRQH=QMHQR]JRGERĤHOL SRGNUHSLWLWH]RGDMHĤHQVNDYHGQRSRQDUDYLQDJQMHQDNWHPXGDERVNUEHOD]DVYRMR GUXĤLQRȡWXGLÍHERVWHPGHMDQMHPQDVSURWRYDOD]DNRQRPGUĤDYH $QWLJRQDVHYJUďNLGUDPDWLNLSRMDYLY6RIRNORYLLVWRLPHQVNLWUDJHGLML Antigona SUQďWY6RIRNORYHP Ojdipu v Kolonu SUQďWY$MVKLORYL Sedmerici proti Tebam LQY(YULSLGRYLK )HQLÍDQNDK 6ODSďDN96RIRNORYLWUDJHGLMLMH$QWLJRQD SUHGVWDYOMHQDNRWKÍLNUDOMD2MGLSDLQNUDOMLFH-RNDVWH,PDGYDEUDWD3ROLQHMNDLQ(WHR NODWHUVHVWUR,VPHQR=DWHPNRMH2MGLSRGNULOVYRM]ORÍLQGDMHQHYHGHXELOVYRMHJDRÍH WDLQVHSRURÍLOVVYRMRPDWHUMR-RNDVWRVLMHL]WDNQLORÍLLQRGďHOL]7HE0HGWDYDQMHPRG 7HEGR.RORQDJDMHVSUHPOMDODHGLQDL]PHGQMHJRYLKRWURN$QWLJRQD9YPHVQHPÍDVX MHWHEDQVNLSUHVWRORVWDOSUD]HQ3ROLQHMNMHYRGLOVRYUDĤQRYRMVNRSURWLREODVWLODVWQHJD EUDWDGDELVLSULGRELOSRQMHJRYHPPQHQMXXSUDYLÍHQRPHVWRQDVOHGQLNDNUDOMHVWYD9 ERMXXPUHWDREDEUDWDLQSUHVWROSUHY]DPH.UHRQVWULFPUWYLKEUDWRY2GJRYRUQRVW]D VPUWREHKEUDWRY.UHRQQDSUWL3ROLQHMNX(WHRNODVRSRNRSDOL]YVHPLÍDVWPL3ROLQHMND SD SUHSRYH SRNRSDWL 1MHJRYR WUXSOR QDPHUDYD SXVWLWL UD]JDOMHQR RQHÍDďÍHQR LQ QD PHQMHQR]YHUHP$QWLJRQLQ]ORÍLQMHELOGDMHVYRMHJDEUDWDSRNRSDODNOMXE.UHRQWRYL UD]JODďHQLSUHSRYHGL.UHRQMR]DWRREVRGLQDVPUWLQĤLYR]DNRSOMHYJUREQLFR/DEGDNL GRYVYRMRXVPUWLWHYSUHKLWLVVDPRPRURP1MHQRWUXSORRGNULMH+DMPRQ.UHRQRYVLQ LQ$QWLJRQLQQHVRMHQLPRĤȡRESRJOHGXQDQDWUXSORVHL]ĤDORVWLXELMH6ODSďDN ȡ +HJHO $QWLJRQLQR GHMDQMH R]QDÍL NRW }]DNRQ ÍXWHÍH VXEMHNWLYQH VXEVWDQFLDO QRVWL>@NRW]DNRQVWDULKERJRY>@YHÍQL]DNRQRNDWHUHPQLKÍHQHYHRGNGDMVH MH SRMDYLO LQ Y QDVSURWMX GR RÍLWQHJD ]DNRQD ]DNRQD GUĤDYH >@m +HJHO Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 109 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 7D NRQʴLNW PHG GYHPD UD]OLÍQLPD ]DNRQRPD MH VHYHGD WUDJLÍHQ $QWLJRQD MH SDUDGLJPD ]DNRQD GUXĤLQH ȡ QMHQD QDMYLďMD HWLÍQD GROĤQRVW MH SRNRS EUDWD ]DWR GD QMHJRYL GXďL RPRJRÍL SUHKRG Y +DG WRUHM QH JOHGH QD REÍH YHOMDYQH ]DNRQH Y GUĤD YL NL MLK MH SRVWDYLO NUDOM .UHRQ$QWLJRQD SR +HJOX VWRML ]D ĤHQVNRVW NRW WDNR }ģHQ VNRVWȡ YHÍQD LURQLMD REÍHVWYDȡ VSUHPLQMD ] LQWULJR REÍL VPRWHU YODGH Y QHNL SULYDW QL VPRWHU SUHREUDĤD QMHQR REÍR GHMDYQRVW Y QHNR GHOR WHJD GRORÍQHJD LQGLYLGXD LQ VSUHYUDÍD REÍR ODVWQLQR GUĤDYH Y QHNR SRVHVW LQ NUDV GUXĤLQHm +HJHO $QWLJRQDNRWĤHQVNDWRUHMUHSUH]HQWLUDQHSRVUHGQRVWGUXĤLQVNHJDĤLYOMHQMDLQ SULQFLSSDUWLNXODUQRVWLDREHQHPMHWXGLGXKVXEYHU]LYQHJDLQGLYLGXDOL]PDNLUXďLRE ÍRVW$QWLJRQDVVYRMLPGHMDQMHPUHSURGXFLUDSRPHQVRURGVWYHQLKUD]PHULMLQSRPHQ SRJUHEQHJDULWXDODSRÍDVWLWHYPUWYLKMHSRPHPEQHMďDRGREÍHYHOMDYQLKGUĤDYQLK]D NRQRYSUHSRYHGLSRNRSD 9SUDďDQMH QD NDWHUR SD +HJHO QH RGJRYRUL MH VOHGHÍH NDNR ODKNR ĤHQVND UH SUH]HQWLUDVIHURSDUWLNXODUQRVWLÍHSDQDMVHVWUXNWXUQRQLNROLQHEL]DYHGDODVHEHNRW QHNHJDSRVDPLÍQHJDVXEMHNWD"ÌHĤHQVNDQLVDPRVWRMHQVXEMHNWDPSDNQXGL]JROMRSR URPRďNHPXVXEMHNWX]QRWUDMGUXĤLQVNLKUD]PHULMNDNRWRGDMH$QWLJRQDNLQLĤHQD DPSDNVHVWUDLQNLVHQHERMLVYRMLKGHMDQM]DJRYDUMDWLSUHGNUDOMHYRDYWRULWHWRWHUVHWDNR XGHMVWYRYDWL]QRWUDMMDYQHVIHUHODKNRUD]XPOMHQDNRWSDUDGLJPDĤHQVNRVWL"$QWLJRQD QLQLWLĤHQDQLWLPDWL$QWLJRQDMHVHVWUD5D]PHUMHVHVWUHLQEUDWDMHVLFHUWXGLGUXĤLQVNR UD]PHUMHNDUMHSRDQWDNLMR+HJHOĤHOLVSRURÍLWLNR$QWLJRQRSUHGVWDYOMDNRWLGHDOĤHQ VNRVWLLQLGHDOGUXĤLQHERĤML]DNRQNLYODGDYGUXĤLQLLPDQDPUHÍWULUD]OLÍQDUD]PHUMD ȡPHGPRĤHPLQĤHQRPHGVWDUďLLQRWURNLWHUPHGVRURMHQFLNRWEUDWLLQVHVWUDPL+HJHO $+HJHORÍLWQRQLY]HOYRE]LUGDPRUD$QWLJRQDQDMSUHMYVWRSLWLYVIHURSROL WLÍQRVWLÍHKRÍHVOHGQMLNOMXERYDWLYLPHQXGUXĤLQVNHVIHUH6SUHVWRSRPYSROLWLÍQRVW MH$QWLJRQDĤHL]ďODL]WLĤHQVNHJD}QDUDYQHJDmSRGURÍMDNMHUQLPDVDPRVWRMQHJD]D YHGDQMDLQMHSRVWDODVDPRVWRMQLVXEMHNW6NUDWNDOLN$QWLJRQHQHXVWUH]D+HJORYHPX SRJOHGXQDYORJRĤHQVNHJDVSROD=DNDMVLMHWRUHM+HJHOL]EUDOSUDYWDOLN" PARADOKS ANTIGONE (GHQL]PHGUD]ORJRY]DNDM+HJHOQHELVPHOSUHGVWDYOMDWL$QWLJRQHNRWJODVQL FHGUXĤLQHLQÍDVWLONHVRURGVWYDMHWDGDMHQMHQRFHORWQRVRURGVWYRLQFHVWXR]QR=QDÍDM $QWLJRQLQHJDVRURGVWYDMHGYRXPHQ2MGLSMHȡVLFHUQHYHGHȡXELOVYRMHJDRÍHWDLQVH SRURÍLOVVYRMRPDWHUMRQMHJRYLRWURFLSDVRELOLREHQHPWXGLQMHJRYLEUDWMHLQVHVWUH $QWLJRQLQRÍHMHREHQHPQMHQEUDWVDMVLREDGHOLWDPDWHUY-RNDVWLQMHQDEUDWDSDVWD REHQHPQMHQDQHÍDNDVDMVWDVLQRYDQMHQHJDEUDWDȡRÍHWD2MGLSD.RWXJRWDYOMD-XGLWK %XWOHUMH$QWLJRQD 110 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 110 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 XMHWD Y PUHĤR RGQRVRY NL QH SRUDMDMR QLNDNUďQHJD NRKHUHQWQHJD SRORĤDMD Y VRURGVWYX 6DPD QL VWURJR UHÍHQR ]XQDM VRURGVWYD DOL SUDY]DSUDY LQWHOLJLELOQRVWL 1MHQR VLWXDFLMR MH PRJRÍH UD]XPHWL WRGD OH ] QHNR JUR]R 6RURGVWYR QL OH SUHSURVWR VLWXDFLMD Y NDWHUL MH DPSDN VNXSHN SUDNV NL MLK L]YDMD WXGL VDPD LQ RGQRVRY NL VH SRQRYQR XPHVWLMR Y ÍDVX UDYQR V SUDNVR VYRMHJD SRQDYOMDQMD .R SRNRSOMH EUDWD QH JUH HQRVWDYQR ]D WR GD EL GHORYDOD Y LPHQX VRURGVWYD NDNRU GD EL VRURGVWYR RPRJRÍLOR SULQFLS GHORYDQMDDPSDN]DWRGDMHQMHQRGHORYDQMHGHORVRURGVWYDSHUIRUPDWLYQHJD SRQDYOMDQMD NL REQRYL VRURGVWYR NRW MDYQL ďNDQGDO %XWOHU ȡ 2MGLSMHSRWHPNRMHVSUHYLGHOVYRMHGHMDQMHXERMRÍHWDLQSRURND]PDWHUMR VDPHJDVHEHRVOHSHOLQSUHNOHOVYRMDVLQRYDQMHJRYDVLQRYDVWDYHQDNHPERMX]DREODVW REDSRGOHJODVPUWQLPUDQDP.UHRQMH]DWRGDELODKNRPHVWRRÍLVWLOFHORWQHJDďNDQ GDODR]QDÍLO(WHRNOD]DSULQFLSGREUHJDLQ3ROLQHMND]DSULQFLSVODEHJDNDUMHGREUR MHSRWUHEQRÍDVWLWLNDUMHVODERSDSUHSXVWLWL]YHUHPÌHEL$QWLJRQDSUDYWDNRĤHOHOD SR]DELWLYVH]ORYNDWHUHPMHELODURMHQDELWXGLRQDPRUDOD]DWDMLWLHQHJDL]PHGVYRMLK EUDWRYVHSRURÍLWLV+DMPRQRPPXURGLWLRWURNHLQĤLYHWLĤLYOMHQMHĤHQVNHWMĤLYOMHQMH NL MH QHYLGQR RÍHP MDYQRVWL 7R MH VLFHU VWRULOD Y HQL YHU]LML L]PHG PLWRY$QWLJRQD MH ELODPDWLY+LJLQRYLK Bajkah.RMH.UHRQSUHGDO$QWLJRQRVYRMHPXVLQX+DMPRQXGDEL MRXVPUWLOMRMHL]OMXEH]QL}]DXSDOYYDUVWYRSDVWLUMHPLQVH]ODJDOGDMRMHXELO5RGLOD MHVLQDLQNRMHRGUDVWHOYPRĤDMHSULďHOY7HEHQDďSRUWQHLJUH.HUSDVRLPHOLYVLL] ]PDMVNHJDURGXQDWHOHVXPDWHULQR]QDPHQMHJDMHNUDOM.UHRQSUHSR]QDO+HUNXOJDMH SURVLOQDM+DMPRQXRSURVWLYHQGDU]DPDQWHGDMMH+DMPRQXELOREDVHEHLQVRSURJR $QWLJRQRm+LJLQ6LFHUSDYGUXJLKSULSRYHGLKQL$QWLJRQDQLNROLPDWL $QWLJRQDVVYRMLPGHMDQMHPEUDWRYHJDSRNRSDYYVDNHPSULPHUXYVWRSLYSR OLWLÍQLSURVWRUVWHPSDSUDY]DSUDYSUHWHQGLUDQDPRďNLGUXĤEHQLVSRO9VDPLWUDJHGLML MHQMHQRGHMDQMHYHÍNUDWR]QDÍHQR]DGHMDQMHPRďNHJDVDMVHPRďNHPXODKNRXSUHVDPR GUXJLPRďNL$QWLJRQDQDPUHÍNRWĤHQVND}YRÍHKVYRMHJDSUYHJDJOHGDOLďNHJDREÍLQVWYD DWHQVNLKGUĤDYOMDQRYQLPDQREHQLKSROLWLÍQLKSUDYLFm6ODSďDNģHQVNHYDQWL ÍQL*UÍLMLQLVRLPHOHVWDWXVDGUĤDYOMDQNDPSDNVRELOHSRGREQREUH]SUDYQHNDNRUVXĤQML ,VPHQD]DWR$QWLJRQRRGYUDÍDRGSRNRSDEUDWD]QDVOHGQMLPLEHVHGDPL}3RPLVOLNDN NRQHFQDMXÍDNDÍHQDVLORVHXSUHYDYROMLLQP¶ÍLJRVSRGDUMHY3R]DELWLQHVPHYDGD VYDĤHQLGDQLVYDXVWYDUMHQL]DERM]PRĤPLNHUVOXĤLYDPRÍQHMďLPVYDGROĤQLSRVOXďDWL XND]OHWDLQďHWUďHm6RIRNOHV 9ODGDU .UHRQ PRUD QMHQR QHSRNRUďÍLQR ND]QRYDWL SUDY ]DWR NHU MH $QWLJRQD SUHWHQGLUDODQDPRďNLVSROȡLQVWHPWXGLRJURĤDODYODGDUMHYRPRďNRVW.HU$QWLJRQD QLSRVOXďDODXND]DLQMH]DQHPDUMDODXVWDOMHQRKLHUDUKLMRMH.UHRQWDVWHPSUDY]DSUDY VSUHPHQLODYĤHQVNR2QVDPMHSRVWDOĤHQVND}'HNOHMHĤHSRSUHMND]DORWUPRVWHPGD MHSUHNUďLORPRMXND]DSUYHPXVOHGLOMHGUXJLJUHKNL]QMLPEDKDMHVHPH]DVPHKXMH 6HPNDOLĤHQVNDMD]LQRQDPRĤGDVPHODELEUH]ND]QLYODGDWL"m6RIRNOHV 111 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 111 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 $QWLJRQDQLPRďNLQMHQRGHMDQMHSDMHPRďNR$QWLJRQDÍDVWLVRURGVWYRDYÍDVW MLMHGDQHERQLNROLUHSURGXFLUDODVRURGVWYDNRWPDWL$QWLJRQDSRNRSOMHHQHJDEUDWD QHXNYDUMDSDVHVSRNRSRPGUXJHJDEUDWDLQQHRPHQMDGDMHQMHQRÍHREHQHPWXGL EUDW$QWLJRQDMH]DVYRMDGHMDQMDND]QRYDQDWDNRGDMRĤLYR]D]LGDMRXPUHSDÍDVWQRV VDPRPRURP6NUDWND$QWLJRQDMHSUHSROQDSURWLVORYLM ZAKLJUČEK 6RIRNORYD$QWLJRQDMHL]UD]LWRIHPLQLVWLÍQLOLNQMHQRGHMDQMHEUDWRYHJDSRNR SDMHSROLWLÍQLDNWLQYWHP]YHVWRVOHGLJHVOX}]DVHEQRMHSROLWLÍQRm6WHPNRMH$QWLJRQD ]YHVWDGUXĤLQVNHPXĤLYOMHQMXMHREHQHPSROLWLÍQLVXEMHNWNLVVYRMLPGHORYDQMHPYSOLYD QDMDYQRVIHUR-DYQLVIHULVHSULEOLĤXMHVNR]LSROMHNLMLMHSR]QDQREOL]XLQGRNDWHUHLPD NRWĤHQVNDGRVWRSVNR]LSRJUHEQLNXOW6SUHVWRSRPYSROLWLÍQRVWSDMH$QWLJRQDL]ďODL] WUDGLFLRQDOQHĤHQVNHVSROQHYORJH.UHRQMR]DWRWXGLR]QDÍL]DPRďNHJDNHUMHGUXJDÍH QLWLQHEL]QDOSULSR]QDWLNRWHQDNRYUHGQHGUĤDYOMDQNH $+HJORYREUDQMH6RIRNORYH Antigone MHL]UD]LWRHQR]QDÍQRȡNRPSOHNVQRVWQMH QHJDOLWHUDUQHJDOLNDSRYVHP]YHGHQD]YHVWRERLPSHUDWLYXSRNRSDEUDWD3ROLQHMND.HU MHEUDWQMHQVRURGQLNMH$QWLJRQDÍDVWLONDGUXĤLQH$ÍDďÍHQMHGUXĤLQHMHELOR]DQMRSR OLWLÍQRYSUDďDQMHLQQMHQVDPRPRUYJUREQLFLMHELORVYRERGQRGHMDQMHȡÍDVWLONDGUXĤLQH ELSUHFHMHQRVWDYQHMHELODÍHELVSUHMHODVYRMRXVRGRSXVWLODEUDWRYRWUXSORXMHGDPVH SRURÍLODV+DMPRQRPLQPXURGLODRWURNH1MHQDLQFHVWXR]QDGUXĤLQDMH]D]QDPRYDQD] ]ORÍLQLVDPRPRULXPRULEHJXQVWYRPLQQHVSUHMHPDQMHPVVWUDQLRNROLFHNMHUMH2MGLS WDNR$QWLJRQLQRÍHNRWEUDWLQNRVWD3ROLQHMNLQ(WHRNOHMREHQHPQMHQDQHÍDNDQMHQD SRWHQFLDOQDSULKRGQMDGUXĤLQDV+DMPRQRPELELODSUHFHMEOLĤMHLGHDOXGUXĤLQHYVDMLGH DOXNLJD+HJHOWDNRY 2ULVXʳOR]RʳMHSUDYLFH kot Fenomenologiji duha SRVWDYOMDQDSLH GHVWDO=DNDMVH+HJHOVSORKXNYDUMD]$QWLJRQRQDPMHYHGQRPDQMUD]XPOMLYR3UL]QDWL SDPXPRUDPRGDMHQMHQOLNLQWULJDQWHQLQLQWHUSUHWDWLYQRďLURN6VYRMRSROLWLÍQRVWMR SDďHNDNRDNWXDOHQ 112 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 112 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 BIBLIOGRAFIJA %XWOHU-XGLWK $QWLJRQLQD]DKWHYD6RURGVWYRPHGåLYOMHQMHPLQVPUWMR/MXEOMDQDâWXGHQWVND]DORåED 'RODU0ODGHQ +HJORYDIHQRPHQRORJLMDGXKD/MXEOMDQD$QDOHFWD *DMJDU0DWHMD+HJORYDGLDOHNWLNDPHVWRXåLWNDLQåHQVNHY 'HOWD OHWQLNãW /MXEOMDQD'UXãWYR]DNXOWXURORãNHUD]LVNDYH +HJHO*:)=DNRQVND]YH]DY 3UREOHPL± OHWQLN;;;,9/MXEOMDQD 'UXãWYR]DWHRUHWVNRSVLKRDQDOL]R +HJHO*:) )HQRPHQRORJLMDGXKD/MXEOMDQD$QDOHFWD +HJHO*:) 3UHGDYDQMDRHVWHWLNL. 'UDPVNDSRH]LMD/MXEOMDQD$QDOHFWD +HJHO*:) 2ULV¿OR]R¿MHSUDYLFH/MXEOMDQD.UWLQD +LJLQ %DMNH/MXEOMDQD,QVWLWXWXP6WXGLRUXP+XPDQLWDWLV +XWFKLQJV.LPEHUO\ +HJHODQG)HPLQLVW3KLORVRSK\ 2[IRUG3ROLW\3UHVV -HQVWHUOH'ROHåDO$OHQND 0LWR$QWLJRQLY]DKRGQRLQMXåQRVORYDQVNLKGUDPD-WLNDKVUHGLVWROHWMD/MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD .DLQ3KLOLS-+HJHO$QWLJRQHDQG:RPHQY 2ZORI0LQHUYD YRO. .REH=GUDYNR+HJORYD)HQRPHQRORJLMDGXKDVSRGOHWHODPRMVWURYLQDY 3UREOHPL ±OHWQLN;/, /MXEOMDQD'UXãWYR]DWHRUHWVNRSVLKRDQDOL]R .REH=GUDYNR+HJORYDSUDYLFD2WHRULML¿OR]RIVNHSUDNVHY +HJHO2ULV ¿OR]R¿MHSUDYLFH/MXEOMDQD.UWLQD /DQGHV-RDQ%+HJORYRSRMPRYDQMHGUXåLQHY 3UREOHPL±OHWQLN;;;,9. /MXEOMDQD'UXãWYR]DWHRUHWVNRSVLKRDQDOL]R /RQ]L&DUOD 6SXWLDPRVX+HJHO 0LODQR6FULWWLGL5LYROWD)HPPLQLOH 0LOOV3DWULFLD-+HJHOµV$QWLJRQHY 7KHRZORI0LQHUYD9ROXPH,VVXH. 6ODSãDN6YHWODQD $QWLþQDPLWXUJLMD/MXEOMDQD%HOHWULQD 6ODSãDN6YHWODQD 0LNUDWKHDWULNDDQWURSRORãNLHVHMLRJOHGDOLãþXLQGUDPVNL WHNVWL/MXEOMDQD0HVWQRJOHGDOLãþHOMXEOMDQVNR 6RIRNOHV Antigona/MXEOMDQD'ROHQF 6WHLQEHUJHU3HWHU-+HJHOR]DNRQXLQSROLWLNLY 3UREOHPL±OHWQLN;;;,9. /MXEOMDQD'UXãWYR]DWHRUHWVNRSVLKRDQDOL]R äLåHN6ODYRM Antigona/MXEOMDQD'UXãWYR]DWHRUHWVNRSVLKRDQDOL]R Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 113 27. 10. 2022 11:16:21 WATSUJI IN HEIDEGGER - PROSTORSKOST IN ČASOVNOST KOT OBZORJI KULTURE Tara Peternell UVOD :DWVXMLMHYL QDMEROM ]QDQL GHOL )ĕGR 3RGQHEMH LQ Ningen no gaku to shite no rinrigaku (WLNDNRWUD]LVNDYDRÍORYHNX VWDQHSRVUHGQRXVPHUMHQLYNULWLNRLQGRSROQLWHY WHJD NDU DYWRU YLGL NRW +HLGHJJHUMHYR QH]DGRVWQR UD]XPHYDQMH SURVWRUVNRVWL Y Biti in ÍDVX 1MHJRYSULVSHYHNĤHOLSULND]DWLNDNRMDSRQVNDʳOR]RʳMDQLPRJODVSUHMHWLQDUDY QDQRVWLHYURSVNLKWRNRYNLVRVHWHGDMREUQLOLYVPHUÍLVWHJDLQGLYLGXDOL]PDLQVXEMHN WLYQH SRJRMHQRVWL =GHOR VH PX MH GD MH YVDND GRWHGDQMD RSUHGHOLWHY ÍORYHďWYD LVNDOD VYRMVPLVHO YWHPGDVHYVDNSRVDPLÍHQÍOHQRYHNRWWLVWRNDUMHVDPRVWRMQR1MHJRYD SUYDSULVSHYNDDNDGHPVNHQDUDYHVWDELOLGRNWRUVNDGL]HUWDFLMDR1LHW]VFKHMXLQďWXGLMD .LHUNHJDDUGD YHQGDU MH NDM NPDOX XEUDO GUXJDÍQR VPHU NR MH ELO SROHWL OHWD QD VYRMLL]PHQMDYLY%HUOLQXL]SRVWDYOMHQSUHELUDQMX+HLGHJJHUMD7HGDMQDMELSUYLÍSULÍHO SRJOREOMHQRUD]PLďOMDWLRIHQRPHQXSRGQHEMDNRW IĕGR>㢼ᅵ@QDNDWHUHJDERPYVYRMHP SLVDQMXUHIHULUDOD]XSRUDEREHVHGH miljé:DWVXMLMXVHMH]GHORQHSULPHUQRGDÍDVLJUD WDNRSRPHPEQRYORJRY]JUDGELÍORYHďNHJDREVWRMD8JRWDYOMDOMHGDVHREWHPSR]DEOMD QDUDYQRWROLNRÍHQHďHEROMSRPHPEHQSURVWRUVNLGHOYWHPMHYLGHOL]YRUQHNDWHULK L]PHGYHÍMLKWHĤDYNLEUHPHQLMR %LWLQÍDV OHNDNRQDMELELOÍDVNLQLGRFHODLQYHQDNL PHUL]YH]DQVSURVWRURPÍDVYSROQRSUDYQHPSRPHQX" 2VHPOHWNDVQHMHMHELORNRWGHOHQRG]LYQDWRSUREOHPDWLNRREMDYHGHOHĤQRGHOR )ĕGR NLJDMHDYWRUSULÍHOSLVDWLĤHREYUDÍDQMXQD-DSRQVNR9QMHPREUDYQDYDNXOWXUQH ODVWQRVWLGUĤDYLQSRNUDMLQL]YLGLNDQMLKRYLKSRGQHEQLKLQJHRJUDIVNLKRNROLďÍLQWHUXJR WDYOMDGDYʳOR]RIVNLWUDGLFLMLQLELORQDPHQMHQRGRYROMSR]RUQRVWLRÍLWQHPXGHMVWYXGD QDMELLPHOLGDQLQDUDYQLSRJRMLYNDWHUHMHYUĤHQÍORYHNRJURPQRRSUDYLWL]QRWUDQMLPL VWDQMLÍORYHND3RGYLJVNDWHULPVHSULÍQHVSRSULMHPDWLMHUD]YLWMHWHRULMHRUD]XPHYDQMX ÍORYHďNHHNVLVWHQFHNLELWHPHOMLODQDSURVWRUVNHP7HJDYLGLNRWQHNDMQHSRVUHGQHJDLQ ]YH]DQHJD]QHPHWDʳ]LÍQLPL]NXVWYRPRENURĤXMRÍHJDVYHWDYSURVWRUXȡQHGYRPQRY QDYH]DYLQDGHORVYRMHJDVRGREQLND1LVKLGHNLMHELOWHGDQMLSUHGVWDYQLNN\ýWVNHďROHLQ RGOLNRYDQWHRUHWLNʳOR]RʳMHSURVWRUD +HLGHJJHUVL]DVWDYOMDYSUDďDQMHRWHPNDNRQDMVHÍORYHNYQRYLÍ]YHĤHVSRO QRVWMRELWLNLMLQHXWUXGQRJUR]LQHNDNďHQL]JRQUD]YUHGQRWHQMHNLVHMHSRQMHJRYHP PQHQMXYUďLORYVNORSXPRGHUQHGUXĤEH3RYUďHQRGJRYRUELELOȡSUHNRIHQRPHQDVPUWL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 114 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 LQVLFHUVWHPGDVHWXELWRYHVYRMHVPUWQRVWLLQPLQOMLYRVWL6YRMHVPUWLQHPRUHQLNROL L]NXVLWLL]SUYHURNHDPSDNMHL]NXďQMDVPUWLYHGQRSRVUHGRYDQDYHGQRL]NXVLVDPR VPUW'UXJHJDLQVNR]LWRL]NXďQMRVHRYHGDMHWXGLVDPSUDYWDNRVPUWHQ3ULWHPSR SROQRPDL]SQHVXEMHNWRYRÍDVRYQRELWYVYHWXRGSURVWRUVNHJDLQ]QRWUDMQMHJDSULSLďH YSHWRVWYÍDVWLVWHPXNDUVHSRQXMDNRWSULURÍQR)HQRPHQRORďNDDQDOL]DWXELWLUD]NULYD OH IXQGDPHQWDOQR ELW QDďH HNVLVWHQFH LQ ]JROM UHODWLYQR ELW SUHGPHWRY LQ UHÍL 6 WHP VH+HLGHJJHU]DSOHWHYQHNDNďQRRQWRORďNR]PHGRVDMVPRYUHODFLMLGRGUXJLKDQDďD VNUE]DQMLKMHĤHYHGQR]JROMRGVHYQDďHVNUEL]DVHÌORYHNQDPUHÍYVWRSLY]DYHGDQMH RVYHWXNRVHPXWDSULÍQHSRMDYOMDWLNRWWDNďHQNLMHXSRUDEHQNRWRURGMHPHGWHPNR QMHJRYDYVWDYOMHQRVWYSURVWRULJUDSRPHPEHQGHOYWHM]DVWDYLWYLVDPRYVYRMLQDYH]DYL QDSUHWHNORSULKRGQMHLQ]JRGRYLQVNLÍDV:DWVXMLSDYWHPRNYLUXPHQLGDQDVYHWOH QHPRUHPRJOHGDWL]JROMNRWQHNDMNDUVLQDGDQHYORJRRURGMDDOLQHÍHVDNDUďHQLLQ QDVWDMDWHPYHÍNRWQDĤLYHÍSURVWRUVDMJDYSUYLYUVWLQDPUHÍGRĤLYOMDPRNRWWDNďQHJD =D+HLGHJJHUMDMHYVDNGDQMLVYHWWLVWRNDUVOXĤLXSRUDEQRVWL]DÍORYHďNDELWMDNLVRYHGQR SULPRUDQDNWHPXGDVHSULEOLĤXMHMRNRQÍQHPXPHGWHPNRJD:DWVXMLUD]XPHNRWSUH SOHWHQRVWQHGHOMLYRSRYH]DQRVWGHMDQM3UYLQHYLGLSUHNRVXEMHNWLYQHJDYLGLNDÍORYHďNH JDREVWRMDGUXJLYIHQRPHQXSRGQHEMDLQQMHJRYLSRVHEQRVWLXJOHGDQMHJRYRL]YRUQRVW HEIDEGGER IN PAST INDIVIDUALIZMA 3UHG YVWRSRP Y ]JRGQMR +HLGHJJHUMHYR PLVHO LQ QMHQR NDVQHMďR QDYH]DYR QD MDSRQVNRʳOR]RʳMRJUHL]SRVWDYLWLGDVPRĤHQD]DÍHWNXSRVWDYOMHQLSUHGSRMPRYQR]D JDWR NL VH RGUDĤD Y QHSUHYHGOMLYRVWL YHÍLQH EHVHG V NDWHULPL XSUDYOMDWD REUDYQDYDQD DYWRUMD9MDSRQVNHPMH]LNXQDSULPHUQLQDMWLXVWUH]QHEHVHGH]DELWLQQDYNOMXEYVHP OLQJYLVWLÍQLP QDSRURP GD EL ML SULVNUEHOL SRMHP ďH GDQGDQHV RVWDMD WDNR 7¬UPLQ NL JD]DQMR]DVLOQRNRULVWLMRMHSRVSORďQHPVWULQMDQMX sonzai >Ꮡᅾ@:DWVXMLVHMHYVYR MHPSLVDQMXL]MHPQRUDGXNYDUMDO]HWLPRORJLMRLQSRYH]DYDPLPHGSLVPHQNDPLNDUER UD]YLGQR WXGL Y PRMHP QDGDOMQMHP SLVDQMX =D QDM ER GRYROM GD R]QDQLPR GD sonzai QLNDNRUQLDQDORJHQELWL9NUDMďHPVSLVXLPHQRYDQHP Pomembnost etike kot raziskave o ÍORYHNX]DSLďH}VRQ]DLQHL]KDMDL]VWDYNDȥLVWRMHQDPUHÍXPHYDWLLQELWLȣQHYVHEXMH NRSXOHȥMHȣm:DWVXML9QMHPVHSRGDYKHUPHQHYWLÍQRUD]GHODYRVWUXNWXUH SLVPHQNL]NDWHULKMHSRMHPL]JUDMHQ},]YRUQLSRPHQ son MHVXEMHNWLYQRVDPRRKUDQ MDQMH-HRNOHSDQMHQHÍHVDYQDVSURWMXVSR]DEOMDQMHPLQL]JXEOMDQMHPȡNRWSULPHUȡMH RNOHSDQMHQDRKUDQLWHYVYRMHJDĤLYOMHQMDNRWYQDVSURWMX]L]JXEOMDQMHP9HQGDUSDMHWR NDUVXEMHNWRKUDQMDODKNRSRSUHGPHWHQRWXGLYLGHDODOLLQWHQFLRQDOQLREMHNWm:DWVXML (NVLVWLUDWLMHY son WRUHMYQHNDNďQLQHGRORÍOMLYLQDVSURWXMRÍQRVWLXPLUDQMX SUHGYVHEXMH NYDOLWHWR WUDMDQMD RKUDQMDQMD LQ SULGDQRVW ÍDVRYQH NYDOLWHWHȡ ÍDV MH RV QRYQLJUDGQLNQMHJRYHJDSRPHQD3RGUXJLVWUDQLMH},]YRUQLSRPHQ zai WRGDVXEMHNW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 115 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 REVWDMDQDQHNHPPHVWX7DNR]D zai ELWLYRKUDQMDWLVHYSRUHÍHPRGDMHYQDVSURWMX ]ȥLWLVWUDQȣm:DWVXML'RORÍHQRVWQHNHJDNUDMDMHSRQMHJRYHPPQHQMXGHOR ÍORYHďNHJDELWMD3RMDYGDMHQHNDUHÍQDSRVHEQHPPHVWXUHIHULUD]JROMQDGHMVWYRGDML ÍORYHďNRELWMHGRGHOLWRPHVWR 3R+HLGHJJHUMXELWLQHPRUHPR]DMHWLQHSRVUHGQRVDMQLREMHNWÌHELVHXNYDU MDOL]QMRQDWRYUVWHQQDÍLQELWRSRPHQLORGDELMLGRGHOLOLVWDWXVWHJDNDUELYD.OMXÍQD WHĤDYDMHUDYQRYWHPGDGRQMHQLPDPRQHSRVUHGQHJDGRVWRSD7DNRNRW:DWVXMLVH WXGL+HLGHJJHUYVYRMLʳOR]RʳMLRVUHGRWRÍDQDUD]SUDYRRÍORYHďNLHNVLVWHQFLYHQGDUSUL QMHPQHPRUHPRSULÍDNRYDWLGDERPRRGJRYRUQDYSUDďDQMHRVPLVOXELWLSULGRELOLSUHN GUXJHJDȡ'UXJLVHQDPSULPDUQRSRMDYOMDNRWREMHNW}%LYDMRÍHNDWHUHJDDQDOL]DQDPMH ]DGDQDNRWQDORJDVPRYVHOHMPLVDPLȬELVWYRWXELWLMHYQMHQLHNVLVWHQFLm+HLGHJJHU ÌHVHELWUD]NULYDYÍORYHďNHPREVWRMXLQÍHMHYWXELWLVRURGQDVVHERMELELOR VPRWUQRGDELELODSRYH]DYDNRQNUHWQRUD]ďLUOMLYDQDYVHELYDMRÍHYHQGDUSDWDNRMNR SRVNXVLPJRYRULWLR]GUXĤHQRVWLYVHJDELYDMRÍHJDYQDYH]DYLQDQHNDMNDUQLVHP]JROM MD]VDPDWUÍLPRE]DJDWR7XELWMHELYDMRÍHNLMHYVYRMLELWLYRGQRVXGRELWLNRWWDNHV WHPMHQD]QDÍHQIRUPDOQLSRMHPHNVLVWHQFHVDM}7XELWHNVLVWLUD7XELWMHQDGDOMHELYD MRÍHNLVHPYVHOHMMD]VDP.HNVLVWLUDMRÍLWXELWLVSDGDYVHOHMPRMRVWNRWSRJRMPRĤQRVWL VDPRODVWQRVWLLQQHVDPRODVWQRVWLm+HLGHJJHU ÌORYHďNLREVWRMMHYHGQR]D]QDPRYDQVVYRMRNRQÍQRVWMRLQÍDVRPÍORYHNRYD QDMYLďMD ]PRĤQRVW MH ]PRĤQRVW VPUWL VOHGQMD SD UDGLNDOHQ QHREVWRM VHEVWYD ȡ HNVLVWHQFLDOQDDQDOL]DÍORYHNDVHODKNRYUďLVDPRYRGQRVXGRWH]PRĤQRVWLVDMVDPRQD WDNďHQQHSRVUHGHQQDÍLQODKNRSULGHPRGRUD]NULYDQMDSRPHQDELWL}.RWYUĤHQDELWY VYHWMHWXELWĤHYVHOHM]DXSDQDVYRMLVPUWLm+HLGHJJHU,Q}9VDNDWXELWPRUD XPLUDQMHYVDNRNUDWQRVDPDY]HWLQDVH6PUWMHNROLNRUȣMHȣELVWYHQRVWQRYVHOHMPRMD,Q VLFHUVPUWSRPHQLQHNRSRVHEQRELWQRPRĤQRVWYNDWHULJUHQDUDYQRVW]DELWYVDNRNUDW ODVWQHWXELWL9XPLUDQMXVHNDĤHGDMHVPUWRQWRORďNRNRQVWLWXLUDQDVNR]LYVHOHMPRMRVW LQ HNVLVWHQFRm +HLGHJJHU 9SUDďDQMH MH NDM UHVQLÍQR YHPR LQ VSORK ODKNR SRUHÍHPRRVPUWL9VHNDUL]YHPRRG+HLGHJJHUMDMHGDQDQMRJOHGDNRWQDuniverzalno LQQHRGWXMOMLYRODVWQRVWWXELWLÌHWXGLMRREUDYQDYDNRWPRĤQRVWLPDPRPHQWQXMQRVWLȡ QHL]RJLEQRMHGDERVOHKHUQLL]PHGQDVQDQHNLWRÍNLREVWRMDVRRÍHQ]QMR7DWHPHOMQMH JRYHʳOR]RʳMHY %LWLLQÍDVX QDSRVOHGREYLVLYPHGOLQHUD]MDVQMHQRVWLȡďHYHGQRMHWHUMDQ RGJRYRUQDWRNDNRMHVSORKPRĤQRNRQÍQRELWMH3UL+HLGHJJHUMXYHÍMLSRXGDUHNOHĤLQD ÍDVXDYHQGDUVHʳOR]RIYVHHQRQHNROLNRSRPXGLSULREUDYQDYLSURVWRUDÍHWXGLYYHOLNR EROMVNRSHPUD]SRQX3UDYLGDMHQHNDUHÍYEOLĤLQLÍHMHGRVWRSQD]DRSUDYOMDQMHR]LURPD YUďHQMHQHNDNďQHGHMDYQRVWLLQQDVSURWQRGDOHÍÍHMHRGGDOMHQD1DWHMUDYQLďHYHGQR JRYRULPRRʳ]LÍQL pri LQ od VRWQRVWL3URVWRUVNRVW]QRWUDMVYHWQRSULURÍQHJDQLDQDORJQD SURVWRUVNRVWLʳ]LÍQHJDVYHWDNRWVHQDPNDĤHLQNRWJDGRĤLYOMDPRQHSRVUHGQRWHPYHÍMH VWYDU]DÍUWDQLKRNROLďHYXSRUDEQLKSURVWRURY*UH]DSURVWRUHNLVHGHʳQLUDMRQDQDÍLQ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 116 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 QDNDWHUHJDRPRJRÍDMRUD]SRORĤOMLYRVW]QRWUDMVYHWQRSULURÍQLKHQWLWHWWRUHM]DVSRVRE QRVWYUďHQMDQHNHGHMDYQRVWL6YHWNRWRURGMHMHVYHWXUHMHQQDQDÍLQSUDNWLÍQHGHMDYQRV WLLQWLVWRNDUGHOXMHLQSRVWRSD]QRWUDMQMHJDMHWXELW7DNďHQVYHWY:DWVXMLMHYLKRÍHK QHPRUHGRVOHGQRSRMDVQLWLSURVWRUVNRVWL }6YHWQLQDY]RÍYSURVWRUXODKNRSDJDRGNULMHPROH]QRWUDMVYHWD(NVWDWLÍQD ÍDVRYQRVWWXELWQRVWQHSURVWRUVNRVWLUDYQRQDSUDYLUD]XPOMLYRQHRGYLVQRVWSURVWRUDRG ÍDVDLQQDUREHWXGLQHRGYLVQRVWȯWXELWLRGSURVWRUDNLVHUD]RGHYDY]QDQHPIHQRPHQX GD VDPRUD]ODJR WXELWL LQ SRPHQVNL VHVWRM JRYRULFH VSORK Y YHOLNL PHUL SUHĤHPDMR ȣSURVWRUVNHSUHGVWDYHȤm+HLGHJJHU3URWL]DGQMLPVWUDQHP %LWLLQÍDVD+HL GHJJHUWROPDÍLGDMHSURVWRUSULGREOMHQL]ÍDVRYQRVWLNDUGRNRQÍQRSRWUMXMHGDMHSURV WRUODKNRUD]XPOMHQ]JROMLQHNVNOX]LYQRYUD]PHUMLKÍDVD2EVWRMSRVDPH]QLNDSRVWDYL QDVSURWLSUHGPHWRPSRPHQREVWRMDWXELWLSDSRVWDQHÍDVRYQRVW6YHW]DQMQLʳ]LÍHQ DPSDNUHODFLMVNLSURVWRUYNDWHUHPWXELWVSR]QDYDUHÍLVNDWHULPLYVWRSDYRGQRV.RWR SRÍHQMDDYWRPDWLÍQRVRGHOXMHYWHPVLVWHPXUHODFLMLQVLSULVYDMDVYHW=JRGRYLQVNDYSH WRVWWXELWLMHDSULRULSRJRMQDSRGODJLNDWHUHJDLPDMRODKNR]DQDVNDNUďHQNROLSRPHQ SUHWHNOL GRJRGNL QDVSORK WD ]JRGRYLQVNRVW SULQDďD N ĤLYOMHQMX Y VHGDQMRVWL GHGLďÍLQR SUHWHNORVWLNRWUD]SRORĤOMLYVHWSULORĤQRVWL]DSULKRGQMDGHMDQMD 7XELW SD VH Y VYRMHP YVDNGDQX Y VYRML ID]L QHDYWHQWLÍQRVWL VUHÍXMH WXGL ] GUXJLPLWXELWPL6PLVHOQRMHGDVYHWYNDWHUHPVUHÍXMHPRVWYDULQDVHOXMHMRWXGLGUX JH WXELWL WR +HLGHJJHU SRLPHQXMH ]D VRELW ȡ VSR]QDWL VHEH SRPHQL VRELWL 7R LPSOL FLUD GD VPR QHPXGRPD NR VPR SRVWDYOMHQL Y NRQWHNVW VYHWD ĤH WDNRM XPHďÍHQL WXGL Y NRQWHNVW GUXĤEHQH FHORWHȡ VPR VRFLDOQD ELWMD 7X VH NDĤH ďH HQR L]PHG QDVSURWR YDQM PHG QMLP LQ :DWVXMLMHP WXELW VH PRUD UDYQR L]SHWL L] YVDNGDQD QHDYWHQWLÍQRV WLȡ SUHQHKDWL ] GHMDQMHP SULODJDMDQMD GD EL QDSUDYLOD SRYUDWHN N VHEL L] izgubljenosti Y NDWHUR MH ELOD SDKQMHQDȡ LQ WR VWRUL ďHOH WHGDM NR VH VDPRXUHVQLÍL NRW ELWNVPUWL $YWHQWLÍQRVWWRUHMQDVSURWMHQDďHPXL]JXEOMHQHPXYVDNGDQXSRVWDQHPRĤQD OHVNR]LVWUDKYSULÍDNRYDQMXVPUWL.RQÍQLFLOMVXEMHNWDMHGRVSHWLL]REUD]DYREUD]V seboj YWUHQXWHNVDPRVRRÍHQRVWLLQWRUDYQRWRMHL]NXVWYRNLLQGLYLGXDOL]LUDÍORYHND QDY]YHQ JD SRWHJQH VWUDQ RG GUXĤEHQH YVUNDQRVWL RG SRWRSOMHQRVWL Y GUXĤER QD WDN QDÍLQMHWXELWELWYÍDVXĎHOHWHGDMNRSUHVHĤHPRQHDYWHQWLÍQRVWSUHN]DYHGDQMDVYR MHPLQOMLYRVWLYÍDVXSRVWDQHPRUHVQLÍQLDNWHUML]QRWUDMGUXĤEHQHJDQHSUHQHKRPDVH PRUDPRERULWLGDSRVWDMDPRWRNDUĤHOLPRELWLSULWHPGRJDMDQMXSDNRQFHSW'UXJHJD XĤLYDVNRUDMQLÍQRSR]RUQRVW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 117 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 :DWVXML XYHGH ȥGLDOHNWLÍQLȣ NRQFHSW ningen >ே㛫@ NL JD LQWHUSUHWLUD NRW LQ tencionalno strukturo aidagare>㛫᯶@PHG pri sotnosti ali med od QRVQRVWLLQVOXĤLNRW SRGODJDQMHJRYL Etiki 6WUXNWXUD aidagare QDGJUDMXMH+HLGHJJHUMHYRSLVELWLYVYHWXNRW VRELWLWDNRGDMHVDPDLQWHQFLRQDOQRVWDOLXVPHUMHQRVWRGQRVDSULPDUQRLQQHUHGXNWL ELOQRLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQDȡNRW midva DOLY]DMHPQDUHODFLMDYNDWHULRGNULYDPRVHEHLQGUXJ GUXJHJDYQHNHPGRORÍHQHP miljeju WATSUJIJEVA OBRVNAVA FENOMENA PODNEBJA &LOMWHUD]SUDYHMHGDELUD]MDVQLOIXQNFLMRSRGQHEMDNRWGHMDYQLNDYVWUXNWXUL ÍORYHďNHJDREVWRMD1HXNYDUMDPVHWRUHMVSRJRMHQRVWMRÍORYHďNHJDĤLYOMHQMD NRW WDNHJD V VWUDQL QMHJRYHJD QDUDYQHJD RNROMD 1DUDYQR RNROMH MH SRQDYDGL UD]XPOMHQR NRW REMHNWLYQD UD]ďLULWHY ȮÍORYHďNHJD PLOMHMDȯ NRW NRQNUHWQH SRGODJH $ NR PRWULPR RGQRV PHG WHP LQ ÍORYHďNLP ĤLYOMHQMHP MH VOHGQMH SUL WRYUVWQHP SULVWRSX QDJOR SRSUHGPHWHQR V NRQÍQLP L]LGRP GD VH ]QDMGHPR Y UD]LVNRYDQMX VRURGQRVWL PHG REMHNWRP LQ REMHNWRP NDU L]JXEL SRYH]DYR V VXEMHNWLYQLP REVWRMHP 6OHGQMH MH WR Y NDU XVPHUMDP VYRMR VNUE VDM MH ]D PRMR GUĤR SRJODYLWQR GD VR IHQRPHQL SRGQHEMD REUDYQDYDQL NRW L]UD] VXEMHNWLYQH HNVLVWHQFH LQ QH QDUDYQHJD RNROMD ģH Y ]DÍHWNX EL UDG SULJODVLO VYRM SURWHVW SURWL WHM ]PHďQMDYL :DWVXML ȡ 9 .RQDďHPXREÍXWHQMXSRGQHEMDLQQMHJRYLKYSOLYRYSULGDPRďHGUXĤEHQRRNRO MH QH ]JROM PLďOMHQMD QDUDYQH RNROLFH Y JHRJUDIVNHP VPLVOX VH SULEOLĤDPR WHPX NDU QDPĤHOLVSRURÍLWL:DWVXML7RMHWLVWRNDURPRJRÍDY]DMHPHQUD]YRMHYROXFLMRLQQDSUH GRYDQMHRERMHJD=JRGRYLQDLQQDUDYDVWD]DQMWDNRNRWÍORYHNRYXPLQWHORYQHGHOMLYL SRÍLYDMRÍLYY]DMHPQLRGQRVQRVWLGUXJDGRGUXJH5DYQRNXOWXUDNRWWUHWMHSDMHWLVWR NDUVWRMLQDPHVWXPHGVHERMQHJDPHďDQMDREHKYSOLYRY1DVWDMDODLQIRUPLUDODVHMHVNR]L YHNH]JRGRYLQHLQVHďHQDSUHMRGVHYDYLQYSOLYDQDWUHQXWQRVW6NUDWNDWRNDUVPRQL ]JROMWRNDUPLVOLPRDOLWRNDUL]EHUHPRNRWSRVDPH]QLNLYVYRMHPRVDPOMHQHPL]ERUX YLQGLYLGXDOQRVWLWHPYHÍWXGLSRVOHGLFDSRGQHEQHJDSURVWRUDYNDWHUHJDVPRYUĤHQLLQY NDWHUHPELYDPRLQXPUHPRWHUVPRPXWRUHMSRGYUĤHQLĤHYSULÍHWNXVVYRMLPURMVWYRP .RSRPLVOLPRQDRERMHLQWRY]DMHPQRVWȡQDÍORYHNRYRQDUDYQRLQNXOWXUQR SRGQHEMH Y NDWHUHP VH SRVDPH]QLN ]QDMGHȡ MX ĤH QHSRVUHGQR XJOHGDPR NRW SRSUHG PHWHQD WDNRM WUÍLPR RE JROR Y]DMHPQRVW NL QDVSURWXMH YVDNHPX LQGLYLGXDOL]PX 1D IHQRPHQSRGQHEMDPRUDPRJOHGDWLNRWQDWLVWRNDUMHL]UD]ÍORYHNRYHJDVXEMHNWLYQHJD REVWRMD :DWVXML VH Y WHNVWX )ĕGR ORWL SULND]RYDQMD WH LGHMH SUHN IHQRPHQD KODGQRVWL 7HJDVLY]DPHYREUDYQDYRNRWHQRL]PHGODVWQRVWLSRGQHEMDNLMRRVDPLLQL]SQHL]YHÍMH VOLNH3RQDYDGLYLGLPRVHEHLQKODGNRWQHNDMSRYVHPUD]OLÍQHJDNRWGDMHKODGQHNDMNDU MHORÍHQRRGQDVVDPLKLQSULKDMDRG]XQDM1DQHNLWRÍNLGRMDPHPRGDMHQHNDMPU]OR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 118 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 ďHOHNRWRREÍXWLPRLQVHWHJDRYHPRNRWWDNďQR+ODGQDQDVQHSULWLVNDL]]XQDQMRVWL EROMHELELORUHÍLGDVPR ĤH]XQDMQDKODGQHP1HÍXWLPRJD]JROMLQVDPR]DVHWHPYHÍ JDREÍXWLPRVNXSDMYY]DMHPQRVWL]'UXJLP2EÍXWLPRJDWRUHMQDWUHKUDYQHKYVHEL ]'UXJLPLQYUHODFLMLGRVYHWDGRQDPGDQHJDRNROMD.RWSRVDPH]QLNLVHGRMHPDPR ]QRWUDMWHJD miljeja LQVHUD]NULYDPRVDPLVHELNRWRERMHVRFLDOQDLQKLVWRULÍQDELWMD }.RWÍDVRYQDELWMDELWMDYSHWDYÍDVODKNRREVWDMDPRVDPL]DVHLQSRVHEHMSR GUXJLVWUDQLSDÍHSULSR]QDPRGYRMQLNDUDNWHUÍORYHďNLKELWLMNRWWLVWDNLVRREHQHPY SURVWRUXLQÍDVXLQWDNRSRVDPH]QLNLNRWGUXĤEHQDELWMDWDNRMSRVWDQHMDVQRGDPRUDELWL SURVWRUQHREKRGQRLQ]HORWHVQR]YH]DQVÍDVRPm:DWVXMLÌDVMH]D:DWVXMLMD QHRGWXMOMLYR ]YH]DQ V SURVWRURP NDU ]D VHERM SRYOHÍH WXGL LQGLYLGXDOQH LQ VRFLDOQH DVSHNWHQDVVDPLK7LVWRNDUSRÍLYDYRGYLVQRVWLGRSRGQHEMDSDVWDQDďD]JRGRYLQDLQ NXOWXUD6HEHVHNRWVXEMHNWRYRYHPR]QRWUDMSRGQHEMDȡ]DUDGLSRGQHEMDLQSRJRMHYNL MLKMH]DQDVXVWYDULORVPRSULVSHOLGRWHJDGDREVWDMDPRNRWREVWDMDPRȡLQYWHPVHQD KDMDWDSRVHEQDY]DMHPQRVWYNDWHULY]YH]DQRVWLSRÍLYDWURMLFDSURVWRUDÍDVDLQNXOWXUH ETIČNE PREDPOSTAVKE 6ÍORYHNRPQHPHQLPLQGLYLGXDOQHJDDQWKURSRVKRPRKRPPHLWGWHPYHÍ ÍORYHND RERMH Y WHP LQGLYLGXDOQHP VPLVOX LQ Y]DMHPQR ÍORYHND YSHWHJD Y GUXĤER ]PHV DOL DVRFLDFLMR ÍORYHND 7D GYRMQRVW MH L]YRUQD QDUDYD ÍORYHND :DWVXML ,]WHRULMHNLMRMHSUHGVWDYLOY )ĕGR VHMH:DWVXMLXVPHULOYGLVFLSOLQRHWLNH9 QMHMVL]DJODYQRYSUDďDQMH]DVWDYLNDNRELODKNRXWHPHOMLO]DNRQHGUXĤEHQHJDREVWRMD ÍORYHND ningenÌORYHNMHWLVWLNLKNUDWLUD]SUDYOMDRYSUDďDQMXHWLNHLQMHREHQHPWHM UD]SUDYLSRGYUĤHQ6XEMHNW]DQMSUHGVWDYOMDXWHOHďHQMHYVHSUHĤHWRVWLÍORYHďNLKGHMDQMY VNXSQRVWL6UĤHWLÍQLKSUREOHPRYQHOHĤLY]DYHVWLRVDPOMHQHJDSRVDPH]QLNDDPSDNY PHGRVHEQHP,]UD]NLJDXSRUDEOMD]DHWLNRMH rinri >೔⌮@SUHGVWDYOMDUD]ORJUHGDOL UHODFLMVNLY]RUHFNLVHXGHMDQMDNRWSRQDYOMDMRÍLVHQDÍLQLQWHUDNFLMHGUXJHJDVXEMHNWD] GUXJLPVRXVWYDUMDQMHVVWUDQLOMXGLYSDUWLNXODUQLRGQRVQRVWL-HUHGY]RUFHYVNR]LNDWH UHJDMHY]QLNGUXĤEHQHJDVXEMHNWDďHOHPRĤHQ3UHGRÍHQLVPRWRUHMVSRYH]DQRVWMRVXE MHNWRYYGUXĤELNDWHUH]QDÍDMMHGLQDPLÍQRSUHSOHWDQMHY]RUFDRGQRVQRVWLYQDVWDMDQMX Ningen >ே㛫@ MH YHÍVORMHQ W¬UPLQ 6DPRVWRMHÍ SRPHQL ÍORYHND Y VSORďQHP D QMHJRY ďLUďL SRPHQ L]UDĤD RGQRVȥMD] LQ WLȣ ÌOHQX nin >ே@ L] hito RVHED VH SULGUX ĤXMH gen kot aida >㛫@ NL SRPHQL SURVWRU DOL YPHVQRVW ÌORYHN LPD GYRMQR VWUXNWXUR MH RERMH KNUDWL SRVDPH]QLN LQ GHO GUXĤEHQHJD SURVWRUD .DU ĤHOL :DWVXML SRXGD ULWL MH WR GD MH YVDN SRVDPH]QLN VDP ]DVH LQ Y WHM LQGLYLGXDOQRVWL UD]OLÍHQ RG 'UXJH JD D YHQGDU ďHOH Y ]YH]DQRVWL RERMHJD SROQRSUDYHQ NRW ÍORYHďNR GUXĤEHQR ELWMH 3R VHEQRVW WHJD RGQRVD OHĤL YY]DMHPQL RGORÍLWYL LQ YVDNRNUDWQL YROML SRVDPH]QLNRY NL VR YSHWL Y RGQRVH ȡ N SULYROLWYL Y SRQDYOMDMRÍH VH REQDďDQMH QD QDÍLQ ]GUXĤHYDQMD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 119 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 }'RWRWDOLWHWH ningen sonzai QHPRUHPRGRVSHWL]JROM]XYLGRPYVPUWQRVWY NRQÍQRVW7DWRWDOLWHWDVHQDMSUYRSRURGLYWRWDOLWHWLLQGLYLGXDOQHJDELYDMRÍHJDȡLQ]JROM YWHUSUHNRXGHMVWYRYDQMDYSURFHVXQHVNRQÍQLKQDVSURWRYDQMLQ]GUXĤHYDQMGUXJLKWRWD OLWHW=DWRUHMMHWRWDOLWHWD ningenÍHWXGLYNOMXÍXMHVXEMHNWRYRELWNVPUWLWXGLWDNďQDNL JUHSUHNRQMHm:DWVXMLȡ9VNORSXSRVDPH]QLNDMHWXELW]DYH]DQDNVPUWL DPSDNL]JOHGLďÍDFHORWHGUXĤEHLQKLVWRULÍQRVWLODKNRRSD]XMHPRNDNRVHÍORYHďNLVYHW RKUDQMDNOMXEXPLUDQMXLQGLYLGXXPRY Ningen MHRERMHPRMDVYRMVNRVWLQÍORYHďWYRNL HNVLVWLUDYQMHMMHGLDOHNWLÍQDXQLMDGYRMQHJDNDUDNWHUMDÍORYHND7RÍQRL]UD]ORJDNHUQL L]ROLUDQLKSRVDPH]QLNRYODKNRVSORKSULÍQHPRJRYRULWLRÍORYHNX-D]LQPRM'UXJLNLMX MH+HLGHJJHU]PRĤHQJOHGDWLVDPRNRWGUXJGUXJHPXWXMDVWDWXYVDN]DVHSRVWDYOMHQD YVNXSQRVWNLVHRGYLMDLQSUHSOHWDYGDQHP miljeju VDM}(VHQFDÍORYHNDQHPRUHELWL UD]XPOMHQDEUH]RSD]RYDQMDWHGLDOHNWLÍQHVWUXNWXUHm:DWVXML VLOGA PRAZNINE V IZGRADNJI POJMA DRUŽBENEGA 8]UHWL SRMDYH Y OXÍL SUD]QLQH SRPHQL RVYRERGLWL VH RQWRORďNLK HQWLWHW LQ VSUHJOHGDWL SRGURÍMH WDNďQRVWL ELWL Ȭ SUD]QLQD QL DQWLWH]D ELWL DOL SR]LFL MD PHG QLÍHP LQ ELWMR -H WUDQVFHQGHQFD YVHK VWDOLďÍ 0LOÍLQVNL 9SUHMďQMHPUD]GHONXVHPRPHQLODEHVHGQR]YH]R ningen sonzai WDMHL]JUDMHQD L] QH]DGRVWQHJD L]UD]D ]D ELW LQ ÍORYHND NRW UHODFLMR SRMDVQMHQR Y VNORSX :DWVXMLMHYH Etike 9]ELUXSRVDPLÍQRVWLLQNROHNWLYQRVWLNLMH ningen, SDMHQDGHOXďHQHNDMWUHWMHJD WRMHJLEDQMHNLYRGLNWRWDOLWHWLELYDMRÍHJD3URVWRUDOLSRGODJDNLVLMR:DWVXMLL]EHUH]D XPHVWLWHYWHJDGRJDMDQMDMHEXGLVWLÍQDGRNWULQDRSUD]QLQLNLVHYMDSRQďÍLQL]DSLVXMH s Nĕ>✵@9WUDGLFLML N\ýWVNHďROHMHELODWDREUDYQDYDQDQD]HORVSHFLʳÍHQQDÍLQLQWHUMD SUHYLGQRLQWHPHOMLWRREUDYQDYRNLSUHVHJDRNYLUHWHJDÍODQND }2ERMHSRVDPH]QLNLQFHORWDVWDYQMXQLSROQLUHVQLÍQRVWLȣSUD]QDȣ Nĕ LQWD SUD]QLQDMHDEVROXWQDFHORWD,]WHJDUDGLNDOQHJDYLUDȡWMGROJXMRÍWHPXGDMHSUD]QLQD SUD]QDȡVHUD]YLMHÍORYHďNDHNVLVWHQFDNRWJLEDQMHQHJDFLM1HJDFLMDQHJDFLMHMHUHVQLÍQR JLEDQMHSRYUDÍDQMDYDVHDEVROXWQHFHORWHLQMH]DWRUHMUHVQLÍQRÍORYHďNLRGQRVm'LOZRUWK 1DWDNďHQQDÍLQ'LOZRUWKSRY]HPDWLVWRNDU:DWVXMLR]QDÍL]DȥWRWDOLWHWRÍOR YHNDLQELWLȣ9WHPJLEDQMXVWDSULVRWQDGYDSRJODYLWQDWUHQXWND3UYLMHQHJDFLMDWRWDOLWHWH ningen SUHNNDWHUHY]QLNQHVDPR]DYHGDQMHLQMHWRÍNDQDNDWHULSRVDPH]QLNSULGRELVYRMR LQGLYLGXDOQRVW'UXJLMHQHJDFLMDLQGLYLGXDOQRVWLSUHNNDWHUHVPRSULYHGHQLNVNXSQRVWL WRUHMVDPRUHDOL]DFLMDYNDWHULVPRSULYHGHQLGRVSR]QDQMDGDSULSDGDPRHQRVWLWDHQRVW SDMHSUD]QLQDNLQDMELSRQD]DUMDODSUDYRUHVQLÍQRVWSRVDPH]QLNDDOLNRWELGHMDO1LVKLGD 120 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 120 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 5HVQLÍQRVW MH ELW LQ REHQHP SUD]QLQD MH ELWLQSUD]QLQD REHQHP MH VXEMHNWLYQD LQ REMHNWLYQD QRHWLÍQD LQ QRHPDWLÍQD 5HVQLÍQRVW MH XQLMD VXEMHNWLYQRVWL LQ REMHNWLYQRVWL LQ MH WRUHM VDPRLGHQWLWHWD WLVWHJD NDU VL MH DEVROXWQR QDVSURWXMRÍH$OL EROMH QL WDNR GD EL ORÍHQH VIHUH VXEMHNWLYQRVWL LQREMHNWLYQRVWLSULďOHGR]GUXĤLWYHLQELQDHQNUDWLPHOLUHVQLÍQRVW2SR]LFLMD VXEMHNWLYQRVWLLQREMHNWLYQRVWLPRUDELWLQDVSURWQRPLďOMHQD]QRWUDMGLQDPLÍQR GLDOHNWLÍQH UHVQLÍQRVWL NL MH VDPRGHWHUPLQLUDMRÍD 1LVKLGD ȡ ZAKLJUČEK :DWVXMLMHUD]XPHOSURVWRUVNRJHRJUDIVNHUHODFLMHNRWSRJRMHQHVSRGQHEMHP kot rinri, etiko NL LPD VYRM L]YRU Y PHGRGQRVQRVWL Y SUD]QLQL ,]YLUDMRÍ L] SULQFLSD Nĕ UD]RGHYDYVYRMHPSLVDQMXUD]QROLNHQDÍLQHÍORYHďNHJDELYDQMD3ROHJSUD]QLQHXSUDYOMD VďHHQLPSUDYWDNRSRPHPEQLPSRMPRPNLMH aidagara R]LURPDYH]-HSRYH]DYDNL VSORKSULYHGHGRUD]NULYDQMDQHNHJDSURVWRUDDOLHNVLVWHQFH9WDSURVWRUMHXPHďÍHQR GLDOHNWLÍQRJLEDQMHLQY:DWVXMLMHYLʳOR]RʳML]DVHGDPHVWRDQDORJQR1LVKLGRYLSRVWDYNL ÍLVWHJDL]NXVWYDWRNDUMXGUXĤLSDMHQMXQDQDVSURWXMRÍDVLQDUDYQDQRVWSUHGORÍLWYLMR QDVXEMHNWLQREMHNW3UL:DWVXMLMXDYWHQWLÍQRVWUXNWXURÍORYHďNHJDREVWRMDUD]SR]QDPR ravno v srcu aidagare NLML]DSRGODJRVOXĤL Nĕ]QRWUDMNDWHUHVHSUYDUHDOL]LUDVNR]LSR VWRSHNQHJDFLMHREVWRMDVDPHJD :DWVXMLWRUHMWUGLGDSRVDPH]QLNLREVWDMDMR]JROMYSRJRMHQLRGQRVQRVWLGUXJ GRGUXJHJD7DQHJDWLYQDVWUXNWXUDSULSRPRUHKNRQVWDQWQLWYRUELÍORYHďNLKELWLM6YHW QL ÍDVRYHQ WHPYHÍ UHODFLMVNL 6YHW MH VYHW NDUDNWHUL]LUDQ ] ĤLYR LQ GLQDPLÍQR PHGVH ERMQRVWMR]GUXJLPLYÍDVX in YSURVWRUXQHJUH]DWRNDNREL morali Y]SRVWDYLWLRGQRV GR GUXĤEH WHPYHÍ UD]XPHWL NDNR VPR ĤH SRVWDYOMHQL Y RGQRV ] QMR WHU NDNR RVWDWL Y QMHM(WLÍQRGHMDQMHMH]DQMGHMDQMHNLMHXWHPHOMHQRYSRVDPH]QLNRYL]JRGRYLQVNRVWLQH SULQFLSNLVHPRUHďHOHUHDOL]LUDWL+HLGHJJHUSDUDYQRSUDYLGDMH]DYHGDQMHRVPUWLYLU DYWHQWLÍQRVWLNROLNRULQGLYLGXDOL]LUDWXELW=D:DWVXMLMDMHWRQHSRSROQRLQUDYQRYWHP XJOHGDQDMYHÍMRPDQLIHVWDFLMRQHDYWHQWLÍQRVWL 121 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 121 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 BIBLIOGRAFIJA 'LOZRUWK'DYLG:DWVXML7HWVXUýȡ&XOWXUDO3KHQRPHQRORJLVWDQG (WKLFLDQY Philosophy East and West, Vol. 24, 1. +DZDLL8QLYHUVLW\RI+DZDLȣL3UHVV +HLGHJJHU0DUWLQ %LWLQÍDV/MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD 0LOÍLQVNL0DMD.DMMHbʳOR]RʳMD"b3ULPHU$]LMHY $QWKURSRVOHWQLN/MXEO MDQD6ORYHQVNRʳOR]RIVNRGUXďWYR 1LVKLGD.LWDUýȡ 1LVKLGD.LWDUý=HQVKĕ 7RN\R,ZDQDPL6KRWHQ :DWVXML7HWVXUý Climate and Culture: A Philosophical Study:HVWSRUW*UHHQZR RG3UHVV :DWVXML7HWVXUý7KH6LJQLʳFDQFHRI(WKLFVDVWKH6WXG\RI0DQY Sourcebook for Modern Japanese Philosophy: Selected Documents:HVWSRUW*UHHQZRRG3UHVV :DWVXML7HWVXUýȡ :DWVXML7HWVXUý=HQVKĕ 7RN\R,ZDQDPL6KRWHQ 122 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 122 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 PROBLEM DANOSTI SVETA KOT HORIZONTA V HUSSERLOVI FENOMENOLOGIJI Marko Markič UVOD 9+XVVHUORYLWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLIHQRPHQRORJLMLMHSRMHPVYHWDSULďHOGRVYRMHJD QDMYLďMHJDSUREOHPVNHJDUD]YLWMD1DORJDNLVLMR]DGD+XVVHUOMHLQNRUSRULUDWLWDNRDULV WRWHOVNRXWHPHOMLWHYUD]PHUMDGRVYHWDNRWFHORWHGHMDQVNRVWLNRWWXGLWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQR XWHPHOMLWHYUD]PHUMDGRVYHWDNRWDSULRUQHIRUPHL]NXVWYD=D+XVVHUOD danost sveta kot FHORWHLQSULVWRMQDXWHPHOMLWHYWHGDQRVWLSUYLÍSRVWDQHWDL]UHFHQSUREOHP6SRMPRP VYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWDVH+XVVHUOREHQHPWXGLGYLJQHQDGSRMHPVYHWDNRWY]URÍQHQXM QRVWQHY]DMHPQHSRYH]DQRVWLELYDMRÍHJDNSRMPXY]DMHPQHVRSULSDGQRVWLELYDMRÍHJDY QMHJRYLELWLQHRGYLVQRRGY]URÍQRVWL9WHPGYRMHPMHPRUGDJODYQDYUHGQRVWWUDQVFHQ GHQWDOQRIHQRPHQRORďNH]DVWDYLWYHWHJDSUREOHPD +XVVHUONUL]RHYURSVNH]QDQRVWLNRWWDNHYLGLYL]JXELLGHMHXPQRVWLQDHQLVWUD QLLQGHMDQVNRVWLQDGUXJL&HORWHQ+XVVHUORYSURMHNWYELVWYXOHĤLYRĤLYLWYLDULVWRWHO VNHLGHMHRLQWLPQL]YH]LXPDLQGHMDQVNRVWLGHMDQVNRVWLNRWVPRWUDXPD9VHDQDOL]H NRQVWLWXFLMHVLQWH]HHJDLWQQD]DGQMHVOXĤLMRWHPX2PHQMHQDLGHMDYRGL+XVVHUODWXGL SUL WHPDWL]DFLML VYHWD 1DPHVWR PDWHPDWL]LUDQHJD IRUPDOL]LUDQHJD UDFLRQDOL]LUDQHJD VYHWD*DOLOHMDLQ'HVFDUWHVDUD]VHĤQRVWJHRPHWULMDWHU.DQWDOLQHDUQDY]URÍQRVWQDM ELELOVYHWNRWSUDYDSRVOHGQMDLQYVHREVHĤQDWHPDʳOR]RʳMHVYHWGHMDQVNRVWLGHMDQVNL VYHWȡLQQHQHNDLGHMDVOLNDVYHWD=DWRMHSR+XVVHUOX]QDQRVWYNUL]LRGSRYHGDODVH MHVYRML]DÍHWQLDULVWRWHOVNL]DVWDYLWYLNRWSULVWRMQRVW]DGHMDQVNRVWNDNRUVHĤLYRSULND ]XMH6DPDGDMHLQVLFHUNRWVRUD]PHUQRVWQDUDYLVDPLQHNRWQMHQQDGRPHVWHN'UXJL HOHPHQWSRMPD]QDQRVWLMH]D+XVVHUODHLGHWLNDȡPHWRGDUD]LVNRYDQMDWLSVNLKVSORďQLK ]DNRQLWRVWLLQREOLNSRMDYRY7RGRORÍDWXGLSRMPRYDQMHĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVYHWDVYHWDNRW ELVWYHQHWLSLNHVPLVODGHMDQVNRVWL]DMHWHJDYQMHJRYLFHORVWL ŽIVLJENJSKI SVET KOT HORIZONT +XVVHUORY]UHOLIHQRPHQRORďNLSRMHPVYHWDMHVYHWNRWĤLYOMHQMVNLVYHW6WHP VWDYJUREHPPLďOMHQLHQRWQRVWLQFHORVWVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYDNRWGLQDPLÍQHJDL]NXVWYD FHORVWLPRĤQRVWLLQGHMDQVNRVWLȡNRWL]SROQLWYHNDNRUMHWRIDNWLÍQRSUHGGDQRLQYVHOHM Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 123 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 =ĤLYOMHQMVNLPVYHWRPMHWDNRVH]GLPLďOMHQVYHWNDNRUMHGDQYL]YRUQLHQRW QRVWLVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYDQHNRWQHNVPLVHOQLSRODOLNRUHODWL]NXVWYDNDNRUYHOMD]D IRUPDOQLSRMHPVYHWD =GLVHNRWGDELVH+XVVHUOĤHOHOSRGDWLQDQHNRSUHGNDQWRYVNRWUDQVFHQGHQ WDOQRUDYHQQDUDYHQSUHGVDPR]DYHGDQMHPWRUHMQDVWRSQMRNRQVWLWXFLMHVRRGQRVDVD PR]DYHGDQMDLQVYHWD+XVVHUOVLMHSUDY]DSUDYYVHVNR]LSUL]DGHYDOXWHPHOMLWLWUDQVFHQ GHQWDOQR]QDQRVWNLQHELVORQHOD]JROMQDSRVWXODWLKLQSUDYLOLKWHPYHÍELRGNULYDOD GHOXMRÍRĤLYRNRQVWLWXFLMRNDNRUVHWDGRJDMDYL]NXVWYXȡUDYQRL]WHJDUD]ORJDELELOD WD]QDQRVWIHQRPHQRORďND8WHPHOMLWLMRMHĤHOHOQDWDNďHQQDÍLQGDELSRND]DOGHORYDQ MHWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHVXEMHNWLYLWHWHY]DYHVWQHPVPLVHOQHPĤLYOMHQMXȡRGWRGVHSRUDMD L]YRUYVHSUREOHPDWLÍQHQDSHWRVWLWHʳOR]RʳMH +XVVHUOYSHOMHVYHWNRWKRUL]RQWY Krizi VWHPLEHVHGDPL}>@VYHWQLQDNOMXÍQR HQNUDW DPSDN YHGQR LQ QXMQR SUHGGDQ NRW XQLYHU]DOQR SROMH YVH GHMDQVNH LQ PRĤQH SUDNVHNRWKRUL]RQWģLYHWLMHVWDOQRYVYHWQLJRWRYRVWLĤLYHWLm+XVVHUO*R WRYRWRQHWYRULL]UHFQRL]YRUQHJDL]NXVWYDVDPHJDDPSDNQMHJRYRVWUXNWXURVHSUDYL ĤHWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLVPLVHOVYHWQRVWL7DNRM]DWHPSDVPLVHOKRUL]RQWDELVWYHQRGRORÍL JOHGHQDSUHGPHWQRVW}7DKRUL]RQWMHSRGUXJLVWUDQL]DYHVWHQOHNRWKRUL]RQW]DELYD MRÍHREMHNWHm+XVVHUO 1 1 Na eni strani so stvari enotne v horizontu, a na drugi strani horizontu samemu SULSDGDQHNDHQRWQRVWȡNDNďQD"-HWRVSORKPRJRÍHUD]XPHWLGUXJDÍHNRWELWQRVPL VHOQRHQRWQRVWNRWHQRWQRVWELWQHJDQDÍLQD"7RGDNDNRMHWDHQRWQRVWSRMPRYDQD"$OL MHWRUHVQLÍQRODKNRSRMPRYDQR]JROMNRWHQRWQRVWLLGHDOQHWLSLNHLLVKHPHSUDYLOD LLLLQWHUSUHWDFLMHYVPLVOXVXEMHNWLYQHJDREOLNRYDQMDHQRWQHQDSRWLOQHPUHĤH"ȡVDPR NRWIRUPDOQDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQDFHORWDLQQHNRWQHNVDPRODVWQLVDPRVWRMQLELWQLVPLVHO" +RUL]RQW ODKNR UD]XPHPR NRW SUYHQVWYHQR SUREOHPDWLÍHQ SRMHP 1D HQL VWUDQL MH QDPUHÍ ELVWYHQR GRORÍHQ ] RGSUWRVWMR QHGRNRQÍDQRVWMR }+RUL]RQWD WDNR QH JUH UD]XPHWL NRW PHMH NL ]DSLUD ]DNOMXÍXMH QHNL REVHJ Y FHORWR LQ WR FHORWR WDNR UHNRÍ ]DSHÍDWL DPSDN NRW PHMR NL MH RGSUWD VH RGSLUD QDSRWXMH YHGQR QDSUHM WDNR GD QH GRORÍD NDM YVH VSDGD QRWHU WHPYHÍ OH QDÍLQ NDNR VH Y QMHP SRMDYOMDm +XVVHUO 3ULÍQH VH GR]GHYDWL GD VYHW SRWHPWDNHP QH PRUH ELWL QLNDNUďQD FHORWD NRW WDND 7RGD NROLNRU MH VYHW XQLYHU]DOQL KRUL]RQW PX YHQGDUOH SULSDGD QHND NRQÍQD PHMD QHND VNUDMQRVW 6PLVHO KRUL]RQWD MH WDNR SUREOHPDWLÍHQ REHQHP MH PHMD LQ RGSUWRVW NDU VH SRND]XMH Y QMXQL VRSULSDGQRVWL ȡ MH PHMD NL MH RPRJRÍXMR ÍDWDNďQDNLRGSLUDYVH]QRWUDMQMHWDNRGDYVHEL]DREVHJDNRWRPRJRÍXMRÍLWHPHOM 1 +XVVHUOY]DSLVNLKL]UHFQRR]QDÍLVYHWNRWELYDMRÍHNRW}ELYDMRÍRYVHHQRWQRVWmSRVHELELYDMRÍLK realitet Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 124 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 SVET KOT HORIZONT HORIZONTOV IN CELOTA »KOT CELOTA« =D+XVVHUODMHVYHWELVWYHQRPRĤQRVWVPLVHOQHJDDYVHOHMWXGL]D]QDYQRGD QHJDL]NXVWYD$OLWRUHVWYRULVDPRODVWQLSRMHPVYHWD"+HOGWDNROHSRY]DPH+XVVHUOR YRSRMPRYDQMHVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWD}9VLKRUL]RQWQLQDSRWLOQLVNORSLSDQDSRWXMHMRWXGL GUXJQDGUXJHJDLQWDNRVSDGDMRYXQLYHU]DOQLKRUL]RQWYVHKKRUL]RQWRYVYHWm+HOG 7RGD UDYQR WX VH MDYOMD WHĤDYD GRNOHU MH VYHW ]JROM }KRUL]RQW KRUL]RQWRYm VSDGDYSUDYLVWLUHGNRWKRUL]RQWLL]NXVWYHQHJDSUHGPHWQHJDRNROMD0LVHOGD]LGHMR QHVNRQÍQHJDQDSUHGRYDQMDHYLGHQFDOLUHJUHVDSRJRMHYNRWSUL.DQWXGRVSHPRGRLGHMH VYHWDNRWFHORWHMHSRYVHP]JUHďHQDVDMFHORWDSRJRMHYÍDVRYQHJDL]NXVWYDQLFHORWDY DEVROXWQHP VPLVOX NRW QHSULPHUOMLYD HGLQVWYHQD HQRVW ELWQHJD VPLVOD DPSDN ]JROM FHORWDWDNRSRMPRYDQHJDL]NXVWYHQHJDVYHWD&HORWDVPLVHOQLKLQWHQFMHVDPRHQRWQRVW SRVDPH]QLKWRUHMSUHGPHWQLKELWQRVPLVHOQLKLQWHQFQHSDHQRWQRVWELWLSRVHEL&H ORWDSUHGPHWQHJDELWQHJDVPLVODQLFHORWDELWLNRWWDND 7DNďQRSRMPRYDQMHVORQLQDSUH]UWMXUD]OLNRYDQMDFHORWHNRWFHORWHVPLV OD PRĤQR GDQHJD ELWQHJD VPLVOD Y NRQNUHWQHP ]DYHVWQHP VPLVHOQHP SUHGPHWQHP L]NXVWYXVYHWUD]XPHWL]]QRWUDMVYHWQHJDWRGDQHQXMQRNRWPHWDʳ]LÍQDFHORWD]QR WUDMVYHWQHJD FHORWD SUHGPHWRY VH SUDYL FHORWH Y UHODWLYQHP VPLVOX LQ FHORWH NRW VDPRVWRMQHJDVPLVODVYHWDNRWFHORWQRVWLELWLELWQHFHORWHNRWFHORWH}SRVHELmVHSUDYL FHORWHYDEVROXWQHPVPLVOXNRWDEVROXWQRVWLVDPH7RPLVHOVHGDHNVSOLFLUDWLYPRPHQ WH HGLQVWYHQRVWL FHORYLWRVWL LQ HQRVWL NL WUDQVFHQGLUDMR YVDNUďQR GRORÍHQR IRUPDOQR HGLQVWYHQRVWFHORYLWRVWLQHQRVW7RGDWDVPLVHOFHORWHPRUDYVDMVSUYDRVWDWLďHSRYVHP SUREOHPDWLÍHQ 2 1 'UXJL SRMHP FHORWH NRW VDPRVWRMQHJD DEVROXWQHJD VPLVOD MH WLVWL NL MH HGLQL SULPHUHQ]DSRMPRYDQMHVYHWDYSROQHPUHFLPRPHWDʳ]LÍQHPVPLVOX2GXSRďWHYDQMD WH NOMXÍQH GLIHUHQFH MH RGYLVQD PRĤQRVW SULVWRMQHJD RGQRVD GR VYHWD NRW VDPRODVWQH ELWQRVPLVHOQHFHORWH 3UYL SRMHP FHORWH MH YVHOHM YH]DQ QD SUDY WD VOXÍDMQL L]NXVWYHQR }WDNR LQ WDNRm GDQL SUHGPHWQL VYHW ELYDMRÍHJD GHQLPR ORJLÍHQ Y]URÍHQ OLQHDUQR SURV WRUVNL LQ ÍDVRYHQ LQWHQFLRQDOHQ SUDNWLÍHQ VNUDWND }ĤLYOMHQMVNLm Ȭ QD GROR ÍHQH VPLVHOQRVWQH SUDNVH LQ WDNR QH PRUH GRVHÍL SUDYHJD SROQHJD VPLVOD FH ORWH 'UXJL SRMHP FHORWH MH SRMHP DEVROXWQH HGLQRVWL HQRVWL LQ FHORYLWRVWL ELWL 2 7XQHUD]OLNXMHPVDPo celote kot celote trenutnega]D]QDYQHJDSROMDLQFHORWH}NRWWDNHmDPSDN FHORWRVPLVODYNRQNUHWQHPSUHGPHWQHPL]NXVWYXVSORKLQ}FHORWRNRWWDNRm. Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 125 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 7DSRMHPQLREOLNRYDQ]R]LURPQDQDNOMXÍHQ NRQNUHWHQYVDNRNUDWGRORÍHQ na ÍLQGDQRVWLSUHGPHWRYL]NXVWYDDPSDNLPDQHNVDPRODVWHQVDPRVWRMHQHGLQVWYHQVPL VHO&HORWDMHVDPRODVWQRNRWSUHVHĤQRHGLQDHQDLQFHORYLWDDEVROXWHQLQQHUHODWLYHQ SRMHP 6YHWNRWDEVROXWQDFHORWDMHVDPRVWRMQDLQVDPRODVWQDIRUPDFHORWHȡHQRVWLNL QLFHORWDQHÍHVDGHOQHJDȡLQQLHQRVWQHNHJDPQRďWYDDPSDN vsakršno celoto in enost SRVDPH]QHJDSUDYSUHVHJD7RMHFHORWD}NRWWDNDmR]LURPDSRVHELYUD]OLNLGRFHORWH NRWFHORWHQHNHJDYQDSUHMGRORÍHQHJDSRVDPH]QHJD9VDNDFHORWDSRVDPH]QHJDQDPUHÍ YVHOHMRVWDMDSUDYFHORWDWDNRLQWDNRUD]XPHWHJDLQGRORÍHQHJDSRVDPH]QHJD =DWRODKNRSRGDPRWULDUJXPHQWH 9VDNLFHORWLSRVDPH]QHJDMHODKNR]RSHUVWDYOMHQDQHNDGUXJDÍHSRMPRYDQD FHORWD SRVDPH]QHJD &HORWD SRVDPH]QHJD WRUHM QH PRUH SRPHQLWL FHORWH NL MH Y VYRML IRUPLFHORWQRVWLHGLQVWYHQD3UDYWRSDMHYVHELQDSRMPDVYHWD 7DNRMHYVDNUďQRSRMPR YDQMHVYHWDNRWGRORÍHQHFHORWHSRVDPH]QHJDVDPRHQRL]PHGPRĤQLKSRMPRYDQMVYHWD QHSDSRMHPVYHWDNRWHGLQHJDHQHJDVYHWDR]LURPDHQRVWLHGLQRVWLLQFHORYLWRVWLVYHWD YSUDYHPSRVHEQHPVPLVOX6YHWWDNRUD]SDGHYPQRďWYRWHRUHWVNLKVYHWRYQDPHVWR GDELVHUD]YLODWHRULMDVYHWDNRWHGLQVWYHQHJDXQLIRUPQHJDVPLVODNLQHGRSXďÍDDOWHU QDWLYQLKSRMPRYDQM6YHWNRWFHORWDMHVDPRHQLQ]DWRQHSXVWLGDELVHJDSRMPRYDOR ]GDMNRWFHORWRKRUL]RQWRY]GDMNRWFHORWRSRJRMHY]GDMNRWFHORWRSUDNV]GDMNRWFHORWR QDSRWLO6PLVHOVYHWDNRWFHORWHMHODKNRVDPRHQGRNOHUVHVYHWMHPOMHYSUDYHPVPLVOX LQQHPHWDIRULÍQRȡGRNOHUMHUHVQLÍQRLVNDQLVPLVHOVYHWQHIRUPHHQRVWLLQFHORWQRVWL 6YHWYSUYRWQHPSRPHQXSRMPXMHSUDYQHNRWDNRL]YRUQRHQRVWNLYVDNUďQRPQRJRďHOH RPRJRÍD,]PQRJHJDVDPHJDQDVSURWQRQLNROLQHGRVSHPRGRSUDYHQDÍHOQHHQRVWL DPSDNOHGRHQRVWLNRWDEVWUDNWQHQDNQDGQHIRUPHDOLGRHQRVWLNRWUHJXODWLYQHLGHMH HQRWHQMDPQRďWYD=DWRSRMPDVYHWDQLPRJRÍHWYRULWLL]FHORWQRVWLQHNHJDSUHGPHWQHJD ELWQHJDVPLVODVDMWDYVHOHMSUHGSRVWDYOMDPQRďWYRSUHGPHWQRVWL 9NRQNXUHQÍQLKSRMPLKVYHWDHGLQVWYHQLVDPRODVWQLVPLVHOHQRVWLLQFHORWH VDPHQLNROLQLWLQL]DUHVPHQMHQNHUYVHOHMĤHREVWDQHSULVPLVOXHQRVWLLQFHORWHL]SHO MDQHPL]WHJDL]ÍHVDUMHWDHQRVWHQRVWR]LURPDWDFHORWDFHORWD(QRVWLQFHORWD]DWR QLVWDPHQMHQDNRWQHNDSRVHEQDHGLQVWYHQDVPLVODDPSDNNRWGHULYDWDDOLNRWVSDGDMR ÍDYURGQHNHJDHQRVWLLQFHORWLWXMHJDVPLVOD3UHGSRJRMHPPRĤQRVWLWDNHDOLGUXJDÍQH FHORWH VWRML }SRJRM PRĤQRVWLm FHORWQRVWL VSORK 6WUXNWXUR VPLVHOQHJD L]NXVWYD MH WRUHM WUHEDUD]XPHWLL]VPLVODVYHWDNRWFHORWHQHSDREUDWQR 5D]XPHWLYSUDYHPVPLVOXWRUHMSRPHQLUD]XPHWLVYHWNRWFHORWRQHNRWNRUHODW YQDSUHMGRORÍHQHIRUPHFHORWHVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYDRERMHUD]XPHWLVRL]YRUQRDVDPR VWRMQR)RUPRFHORWHVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYDJUHGRFHODUD]XPHWLďHOHL]UD]XPHWMDVYHWDNRW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 126 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 &HORWD NRW SUHVHĤQD HGLQVWYHQD FHORWD ELWL NRW DEVROXWQD HGLQRVW HQRVW FHORYLWRVWELWLVHQHSXVWLUD]XPHWLSRMPRYDWLXWHPHOMLWLL]NDNUďQHJDNROLGRORÍHQHJD VPLVOD NRW FHORWD QHNHJD GRORÍHQHJD VPLVOD NHU VDPD SR VYRMHP SRMPX NRW DEVROXW QDHGLQVWYHQDFHORWDQLQLÍ GRORÍHQHJD 7RMHPLďOMHQRV}FHORWRNRWWDNRmSRVHELNRW VDPRVWRMQLP VPLVORPȡ DEVROXWQR QH OH UHODWLYQR FHORWR 6 VYHWRP MH WRUHM Y SUDYHP VPLVOXPHQMHQDHQRVWLQFHORYLWRVWELWQHJDVPLVODNRWWDNDLQVDPµSRVHEL,QVLFHUELWL NRWWDNHQHWDNRDOLGUXJDÍHĤHGRORÍHQRSRMPRYDQHJDELWQHJDVPLVOD 6YHWNRWELWQDFHORWDSUHVHJDYVDNUďQRNRQNUHWQRFHORWRELWQHJDVPLVODSRGUX JLVWUDQLSDWXGLQLOHIRUPDQHNHNRQNUHWQHGRORÍHQHFHORWHELWQHJDVPLVODNHUWRSRWHP QLFHORWDELWLNRWWDNHDPSDNFHORWDQDGRORÍHQQDÍLQUD]XPHWHJDELWQHJDVPLVODFHORWD ELWLWDNRDOLGUXJDÍHUD]XPHWHJDELYDMRÍHJDSULÍHPHUUD]XPHWMHELYDMRÍHJDGRORÍDUD ]XPHWMHELWLWDNRVHIRUPDELYDMRÍHJDLPSRQLUDVPLVOXELWLNRWFHORWHVYHWD3ULWHPVH IRUPDFHORWHELYDMRÍHJDL]HQDÍLR]LURPD]DPHQMDVIRUPRFHORWHELWLVDMVHSUHGSRVWDYO MDGDELWQLPDQHNHJDSRVHEQHJDVDPRVWRMQHJDVPLVODDPSDNOHVPLVHONLJDSUHMHPD L]VPLVODELYDMRÍHJD%LWMHYVYRMLDEVROXWQLHGLQVWYHQRVWLVDPRELWQL]GDMSUHGPHWQD ]GDMGHMDQVND]GDMY]URÍQD]GDMLQWHQFLRQDOQD]GDMSUDNWLÍQDELW=DWRFHORWDELWLQH PRUHELWLFHORWDQDQHNGRORÍHQQDÍLQUD]XPHWHJDELWQHJDVPLVODELWYSRMPXFHORWHELWL RVWDMDQHGRORÍHQD 6YHWNRWFHORWDYVPLVOXHGLQVWYHQRHQHELWLQHPRUHELWLFHORWDQD QHNGRORÍHQQDÍLQUD]XPHWHJD]QRWUDMVYHWQHJDELYDMRÍHJD&HORWDSUHGPHWQRVWLSRPHQL IRUPRFHORWQRVWLNLMHGRORÍHQDIRUPDLQVLFHUGRORÍHQDSRIRUPLSUHGPHWQRVWLPHGWHP NRIRUPDELWQHFHORWQRVWLL]YRUQRQHPRUHELWLIRUPDOQRGRORÍHQDVDMQLGRORÍHQD]QH ÍLPGUXJLPRGVHEHDPSDNMHQHNVDPRVWRMQLVPLVHO %LWL]YRUQRQLELWY]URNRYLQWHQFSUHGPHWRYNLQDWRGHOLMRQHNRVNXSQRELWND WHULKKRUL]RQWLNRQVWLWXLUDMRVNXSQLKRUL]RQWHQRWQHJDELWQHJDVPLVOD7DHQRVWELWQHJD VPLVODQDÍHOQRSUHGKDMDELWQHPXVPLVOXSRVDPH]QLKSUHGPHWRYLQSUHGPHWQRVWLVSORK 6PLVHOVYHWDMHWDNRWUHEDUD]XPHWLNRWFHORWQRVWELWLSRVHELQHNRWFHORWQRVW WDNRDOLGUXJDÍHUD]XPHWHJDSUHGPHWQHJDORJLÍQHJDELYDMRÍQHJDELWQHJDVPLVOD%LWQL ELWVDPRQHÍHVDGRORÍHQHJDDPSDNELWYVHJDELYDMRÍHJDNRWWDNHJD]DWRIRUPDFHORWH ELWL QH PRUH ELWL IRUPD WDNR DOL GUXJDÍH UD]XPHWHJD ELYDMRÍHJD ÌLP VSUHJRYRULPR R QHNLGRORÍHQLIRUPLFHORWHVYHWNRWFHORWDQLPLďOMHQNRWQHNVDPRVWRMQLELWQLVPLVHO DPSDNMHL]WHJDSRÍHPHUMHWDIRUPDNRWYVDNRGRORÍHQRGRORÍHQ9VHMHRGYLVQRRG WHJDDOLMHVYHWNRWFHORWDSRMPRYDQNRWQHNVDPRVWRMQLELWQLVPLVHOVDPRVWRMQLVPLVHO ELWQHFHORWQRVWLDOLSDQHNDQDNQDGQDNRQVWUXNFLMD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 127 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 -HVNUDWNDQHNHGLQVWYHQLVPLVHOHQRVWLLQFHORWHUH]HUYLUDQ]DIHQRPHQVYHWD NLVHQHPRUHL]YHVWLL]GUXJLKRELÍDMQLKVPLVORYHQRVWLLQFHORWHNL]DMHPDMRHQRVWLQ FHORWRQHÍHVDYVYHWXÌLPGRORÍLPRVYHWNRWFHORWRQDSRWLOY]DMHPQRQDSRWXMRÍLKKRUL ]RQWRYELVWYHQHWLSLNHMHGURSRPHQVNRVWLDOLSUD]QHQHGRORÍHQHQHPRGLʳFLUDQHPRĤ QRVWLVPRĤHLJQRULUDOLVSUHJOHGDOLWRGDLPDVYHWNRWFHORWDQHNHGLQVWYHQVDPRODVWHQ VPLVHONLVHQHSXVWLREOLNRYDWLSRQHNLKYQDSUHMUD]SRORĤOMLYLKVYHWQLPIHQRPHQRP SULPHUQLKSRMPLKFHORWHLQHQRVWL .DUMHWXNRQWUDLQWXLWLYQRMHWRNDMMHWHGDMVSORKODKNRFHORWDHQRVWÍHQLFH ORWDHQRVWQHÍHVDSRVDPH]QHJDPQRďWYHQHJD".HUWXVHYHGDQHJUHQLWL]DXPVNLVPLVHO HQRVWLQLWL]DQHNQMHQPLVWLÍQLQDGXPVNLVPLVHOUD]XPHWSUDYNRWWDNÍHPXVSORK JRYRULWLRWDNHPVPLVOXHQRVWLLQFHORWH"1LWRWHGDMVDPRQHNRIRUPDOQREUH]YVHELQ VNRUD]OLNRYDQMH".DNRQDMUD]XPHPRVYHWNRWFHORWRÍHQHNRWFHORWQRVWQHNHSR]QDQH IRUPH" 7DNRVHMDYLQDVOHGQMDDSRULMD]GLVHGDPRUDPR]DUD]OLNRYDQMHFHORWHSRVHEL LQFHORWHNRWFHORWHSUHGPHWQHJDVPLVODĤHSUHGKRGQRLPHWLQHNSRMHPFHORWHSRVHEL YHQGDUJDQLPDPRȡMHUDYQRWLVWRNDUMHLVNDQR7RSRPHQLGDVHODKNRQD]QDÍLVDPR QHJDWLYQR3RMHPFHORWHNRWWDNHMHSUDY]DWREUH]WHPHOMDNHUVHJDQHGDXWHPHOMLWLY ÍHPHUNROLNDUVUHÍXMHPR}]QRWUDMmWHFHORWHÌLPELJDWDNRSRMPRYDOLSRVOHGLÍQRQH EL SRMPRYDOL VPLVOD FHORWH VDPH DPSDN VPLVHO FHORYLWRVWL WHK GRORÍHQLK SUHGPHWQLK VPLVORY'UXJRYSUDďDQMHMHDOLMHODKNRFHORWDUD]XPHWDSRVHEL]DVWDYOMHQSDMHWDNR YVDMSUREOHPQDMELELODUD]XPHWDSRVHEL .DMMHSRVOHGLFDWHJDVSUHJOHGDUD]OLNRYDQMD]DSRMPRYDQMHVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWD" 'RNOHUMHVYHWODKNRPLďOMHQNRWKRUL]RQW}YNDWHUHJDVSDGDMRmYVLKRUL]RQWLQLPLďOMHQ VDPRVWRMQRDOLVDPRODVWQRNRWQHNVDPRVWRMQLVPLVHODPSDNVYRMPRPHQWXQLYHU]DO QRVWLFHORWQRVWLSUHMHPDOHL]VWUXNWXUHY]DMHPQHJDQDSRWRYDQMDSUHGPHWQLKRNROQLK KRUL]RQWRY ÌHMHVYHWVDPRXQLYHU]DOQLKRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWRYRNROQHJDL]NXVWYHQHJDVYHWD WHGDMMHWXGLVYHWVDP]JROML]NXVWYHQLVYHWLQQHFHORWDELWLNRWWDND6YHWNRWSRVOHGQML KRUL]RQW LQWHQFLRQDOQLK SUDNV QL VPLVHOQD FHORWD ELWL DPSDN FHORWD WHJD NDU ]DGHYD PRĤQHLQWHQFLRQDOQHSUDNVHȡÍHSUDYYQMLKRYHPLQWHQFLRQDOQHPVLQWHWLÍQHPVRYLVMX ȡMHFHORWDNRWFHORWDNRUHODWRYSRVDPH]QLKVPLVHOQLKSUDNVQHSDFHORWDNRW&HORWDNRW VPLVHOQDFHORWDELWLVSORK+RUL]RQWFHORWHQHPRUHELWLFHORWDSRVDPH]QLKKRUL]RQWRY SRJRMHYVPLVHOQLKUDEDOLVPLVHOQLKSUDNVÍHQDMVHSRMPXMHVDPRODVWQRNRWDEVROXWQD FHORWDNLQLUD]XPOMLYD relativno JOHGHQDQHNDM]QRWUDMFHORWHDPSDNÍHVSORKSRWHP SRVHELNRWHGLQVWYHQRVW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 128 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 3RMHPKRUL]RQWDGDOMHSUHGSRVWDYOMDSRMHP meje 3UREOHPDWLÍQRMHNDNRQDMVH SRMPXMHKRUL]RQWNRWPHMDPRUGDYQHNHPSUDYSRVHEQHPVPLVOXDOLSDĤHNRW]DPH MHQRVWNRQNUHWQHJDL]NXVWYD"6YHWNRWFHORWDELWLQHPRUHELWLSRMPRYDQNRWQHNDPHMD QHÍHVDWDNRGDELELOGRORÍHQ]QHJDFLMRVDMELWNRWHGLQVWYHQDWHJDQHGRSXďÍD9VD RPHMHQRVWYVDNDPHMDMHGRORÍHQRVW]GRORÍHQLP 1 ÌHMHELWQLVPLVHOKRUL]RQWQRVWUXNWXULUDQVHODKNR]GLGDMHWHGDMVYHWNRWFHORWD ELWQHJDVPLVODQXMQRQHNKRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWRYQHSDFHORWDVPLVODELWLNRWWDNH7DNR 2YHUJDDUGVNOHSDGDMHSRMHPVYHWDNRWFHORWHQH]GUXĤOMLYVSRMPRPVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWD VDMELWRSRPHQLORGDKRUL]RQWL]QRWUDMVYHWQHJDSUHGVWDYOMDMRSRJRMPRĤQRVWLVYHWDLQ QHREUDWQR2YHUJDDUG2YHUJDDUGWDNR]DJRYDUMDVPLVHOVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWD PRĤQHJD L]NXVWYD QDPHVWRKRUL]RQWD VWYDUL 7RGD WD UHďLWHY QH ]DGHYD WHĤDYH DPSDN VDPR SUHVWDYL SUREOHP QD GUXJR UDYHQ VDM MH L]NXVWYR VSHW UD]XPHWR NRW SUHGPHWQR L]NXVWYRÍHSUDY2YHUJDDUGWUGLQDMELSRMHPKRUL]RQWDPRĤQRVWLLPHOSRYVHPGUXJDÍHQ ELWQLVPLVHONRWVPLVHOSRVDPH]QHVWYDUL2YHUJDDUG7DWHĤDYDSDQHQDVWRSL ÍHQDVSURWLWDNHPXSRMPRYDQMXVPLVHOVYHWDNRWFHORWHUD]XPHPRNRWGDMHVLFHUVDP KRUL]RQWQRVWUXNWXULUDQLQYWHP]QDÍDMXNRUHOLUDQKRUL]RQWRP]QRWUDMYHWQHJDPHGWHP NRVDPQLKRUL]RQW]QRWUDMVYHWQHJD 5D]XPHYDQMHGDMHVYHWQHNDNďHQXQLYHU]DOQLKRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWRYMHPRJRÍH ]DYUQLWL] YSUDďDQMHP }7RGD ]DNDM MH WDNR GD KRUL]RQWL QDSRWXMHMR GUXJ QD GUXJHJD" 0DU QH SRPHQL WR GD SUHGSRVWDYOMDMR ĤH YQDSUHM QHNR HQRVW ELWQHJD VPLVOD NL QLPD ]QDÍDMDXQLYHU]DOQRVWL]DYVHKRUL]RQWHDPSDNNDWHUHHQRVWȡHGLQRVWHQRWQRVWLQFH ORVWȡQDÍHOQRSUHGKDMDYVDNUďQLWDNLXQLYHU]DOQRVWL"m 7XMHSRWHPVDPRďHHQNRUDNGRVNOHSDNLJDSRWHJQH+HOGGDMHVYHWWHGDMSDÍ PRÍL]HQDÍLWLV }SUYRWQRYPHVQRVWMRNRWLVNDQRRÍLWQRVWQRGLPHQ]LMRm+HOG 6YHWSRVWDQHNDUL]YRUQDHQRWQRVWVPLVODVDPDȡDEVXUGQRSRMPRYDQMHNL]DQLNDVDP VPLVHO}L]YRUQHHQRWQRVWLmVDMQLYHÍHQRWQHJDELWQHJDSROD +XVVHUOVYHWL]UHFQRLPHQXMH}SUHGPHWQLXQLYHU]XPVYHWNRWWDLQWDNRNDNRU MHNRQNUHWQRĤLYOMHQMVNRGDQ>@m+XVVHUO7XVHXMDPHY]DQNR'RNOHUVH Y]WUDMD SUL ĤLYOMHQMVNHP VYHWX RVWDMD SUL SUHGPHWQRVWL LQ QLNROL QH GRVHĤH HGLQVWYHQH FHORWQRVWLELWLVDPHNRWWDNH2LGHMLKRUL]RQWXFHORWHRKRUL]RQWX}VYHWDNRWWDNHJDm +XVVHUONRWMHYLGHWLQHJRYRULQLNMHU 3ULP*:)+HJHO Znanost logike'UXďWYR]DWHRUHWVNRSVLKRDQDOL]R/MXEOMDQDVWUȡ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 129 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 7DLQWHUSUHWDWLYQLSUREOHPELPRUGDODKNRUHďLOL]UD]OLNRYDQMHPLPSOLFLWQHJD GYRMQHJDVPLVODJHQLWLYQHNRQVWUXNFLMH}VYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWDKRUL]RQWRYmLQ}KRUL]RQWD VYHWDm *HQLXVDV WDNR RSR]DUMD QD LPSOLFLWQL LQ SUREOHPDWLÍQL GYRMQL VPLVHO VYHWQHJD KRUL]RQWD} Welthorizont JHQLWLYQDNRQVWUXNFLMDSXďÍDQHRGORÍHQRDOLKRUL]RQWLR]QD ÍXMHMRHGLQVWYHQQDÍLQSULND]RYDQMDVYHWDDOLSDVRVDPRRGYLVQLJOHGHQDVYHWNLRVWDMD WUDQVFHQGHQWHQVYRMHPXKRUL]RQWQHPXSULND]RYDQMXm*HQLXVDVȡ6YHW QLKRUL]RQWWRUHMSRPHQLHGLQVWYHQKRUL]RQW.RWSUDYL}>Ȭ@UD]XPHWLVYHWNRWSUHGGDQL WHPHOMDOLNRWFHORWRSUHGPHWRYSRPHQLRSHULUDWLQDRVQRYLRGORÍLOQRGUXJDÍQHJDSRMPD KRUL]RQWQRVWLm,ELG 7RGDGDELELOVYHWWDNRWUDQVFHQGHQWHQVYRMHPXKRUL]RQWQHPXSULND]RYDQMX LQWRQHQDQDÍLQGDELWDWUDQVFHQGHQWQLRGWHJELOYNOMXÍHQYKRUL]RQWQRVWVDPRDP SDNYFHORWLVH]GLIHQRPHQRORďNRQHY]GUĤQR6YHWMHNYHÍMHPXKRUL]RQWYRGOLNRYDQHP VPLVOXWDNRGDYVLKRUL]RQWLÍHVRVSORKKRUL]RQWLQDSRWXMHMRQDVYHWNRWL]YRUQLSR ÍHOQLKRUL]RQW6LFHUELQDPUHÍLPHOLPQRďWYRKRUL]RQWRYEUH]HQRWQHJDVYHWQRVWQHJD VPLVOD 7RGDÍHVYHWQLKRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWRYDPSDNKRUL]RQWFHORWHNRWFHORWHSRWHP QDVWRSLSUREOHPYNDNďQHPVPLVOXMHSRWHPVSORKKRUL]RQW",QWRYGYRMQHPVPLVOX KRUL]RQWDVYHWDWDNRSRVHEQHJDKRUL]RQWDVYHWDNRWVYHWQHJD]QDÍDMDKRUL]RQWDVSORK 9VHVNR]LSDMHWUHEDUD]OLNRYDWL HQHQRWQLVYHWQLKRUL]RQWNRWXQLYHU]DOQRKRUL]RQWQRIRUPRYVHJDKRUL]RQWQRVWUXN WXULUDQHJDL]NXVWYDNLWHPXSRGHOMXMHQHNRDSULRUQRHQRWQRVW KRUL]RQWVYHWDNRWUHJXODWLYQRLGHMRGHOXMRÍRYL]NXVWYXQHVNRQÍQHPRĤQRVWLL]SRO QLWYHGHMDQVNRVWLVYHWNRWLQYDULDQWQLHLGRVNLXVPHUMDVLQWH]RYVHKPRĤQLKYDULDFLM KRUL]RQWHVYHWQHJDL]NXVWYDNRWQRWUDQMHLQ]XQDQMHKRUL]RQWHELYďRVWQHSULÍXMRÍQH LQSULKRGQRVWQHL]SROQLWYH KRUL]RQWQRVWUXNWXULUDQRVWVYHWQHJDL]NXVWYDL]NXVWYDVYHWDNRW]QDÍDMQDSRWHQRV WLWHQGHQFHNFHORYLWRVWLL]NXVWYDVSORKLQ KRUL]RQWHVYHWDNRWHQRWQHIRUPHL]NXVWYDVHSUDYLKRUL]RQWQRVWUXNWXULUDQVRWVDPH KRUL]RQWQHLGHMHVYHWD 7DNRVH]DVWDYLSUREOHPYNDNďQHPRGQRVXVRWLVPLVOLSRMPLVYHWDNRWKR UL]RQWDÌLPVHWLSRPHQLSRPHďDMRSRVWDQHWDSUREOHPDWLNLVPLVODVYHWDLQPRĤQRVWL RGQRVDGRQMHJDGRFHODQHMDVQL9SUDYHPVPLVOXSUREOHPVYHWDWYRULWDVDPRSRPHQD LQWRGD]JROMNROLNRUVHQDQDďDWDQDRVWDOHSRPHQH9QDMNUDMďLREOLNLVHGDWDSUREOHP IRUPXOLUDWLQDQDÍLQ}9NDNďQHPUD]PHUMXMHKRUL]RQWVYHWDVVYHWQLPKRUL]RQWRP"m Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 130 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 1REHQR RG Y OLWHUDWXUL SUHGODJDQLK UD]XPHYDQM VYHWD NRW KRUL]RQWD R]LURPD UD]UHďLWYH SUREOHPDWLÍQRVWL WHJD SRMPD SD QH XSRďWHYD ]JRUDM HNVSOLFLUDQHJD UD]OLNR YDQMD6YHWNRWKRUL]RQWWDNR QHPRUHELWLQHNRR]DGMH}7RGDÍHMHKRUL]RQWQRVWVYHWDQHRGQRVQDSR WHPMHQHPRUHPRUD]ORĤLWLVVKHPRR]DGMDRVSUHGMD>Ȭ@MHR]DGMHEUH]RVSUHGMDREURÍ EUH]YVDNUďQHJDLQWXLWLYQHJDMHGUDm*HQLXVDV6KHPDR]DGMDRVSUHGMDVSORK QLSULPHUQD]DSRMPRYDQMHKRUL]RQWQRVWLVYHWDDPSDNOH]D]QRWUDMVYHWQRSUHGPHWQRVW 1HPRUHELWLQHNDUHJXODWLYQDLGHMDVSORďQHPRĤQRVWLL]SROQLWYH*HQXLVDV smisel horizonta sveta razume kot VSORďQLVWLOQDNDWHUHJD]DYHVWUD]NULYDVYHWLQVWYDUL *HQLXVDV %LW VYHWD MH WDNR PRJRÍH UD]XPHWL NRW SUHGPRGDOL]LUDQL WHPHOM ELWQLKPRGLʳNDFLMNRW L]YRUQRʳJXURďHQHPRGDOL]LUDQHJDYHUMHWMD,ELG9WHPVPLVOX QDMELELOVYHWKRUL]RQW1DPUHÍWXGL horizonti so privedeni do izpolnitve, do samodanosti *HQLXVDV.DNRUSUDYL+XVVHUO horizont kot horizont pride do } samodanosti m +8$;;;,;5REHUW:DOWRQGRND]XMHGDVRYVLVPLVOLVYHWQHJDKRUL]RQWDL]SHOMDQL L]GYRMQRVWLPRĤQRVWGHMDQVNRVW+RUL]RQWMHQDPUHÍKRUL]RQWHYLGHQFHL]SROQLWYHVYHW NRWXQLYHU]DOQLKRUL]RQWMHXQLYHU]DOQLKRUL]RQWHYLGHQFHKRUL]RQWSRSROQHHYLGHQFHMH HYLGHQWHQSRMHP1,]WHJDL]KRGLďÍDMHSRGDQDWXGLNULWLNDSRSUHGPHWHQHJDUD]XPHWMD VYHWDL]SUHGPHWD:HOWRQȡ +RUL]RQWVYHWDNRWVSORďQLVWLOLQSUHGPRGDOL]LUDQLELWQLVPLVHOELWDNRSRPHQLO QHNDNďQR UHJXODWLYQR LGHMR PRĤQRVWL L]SROQLWYH *HQLXVDVRYR UD]XPHYDQMH KRUL]RQWD VHL]WHÍHYIRUPDOL]HPVYHWNRWKRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWRYMHUD]XPHWNRW}FHORWDWLSLʳNDFLMHm *HQLXVDV6YHW}MHPRJRÍHR]QDÍLWL>@NRWQDMEROMVSORďQRSUD]QR]DYHVWW SNRW]DYHVWRGSUWHPRĤQRVWLUD]XPHWHYQMHQLYVHREVHJDMRÍLVSORďQRVWLm,ELG7R MH RÍLWQR SRYVHP DEVWUDNWHQ LQ QHVDPRODVWHQ SRMHP VYHWD 6YHW NRW UHJXODWLYQD LGHMD L]SROQLWYHELWQHJDVPLVODELYDMRÍHJDMHYH]DQQDIRUPRSRVDPH]QHJDELYDMRÍHJDȡSROHJ WHJDMH]JROMQHND}VOLNDmVKHPDVYHWDLQQHVYHW}SRVHELm *HQLXVDVQDGDOMHIRUPXOLUDSDUDGRNVQRVWVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWDPRĤQRVWLYQDSH WRVWLPHGFHORWQRVWMRLQHQRWQRVWMR}+XVVHUORYSRMHPVYHWQHJDKRUL]RQWDVH]GLSURWLVOR YHQ]DUDGLVYRMHDPELFLMHGDELELOYVHREVHJDMRÍ.RWSUDYDFHORWDQHPRUH]DGUĤDWLVYRMH HQRWQRVWLNRWHQRWHQQHPRUHREVHJDWLWHJDNDUQDMELm*HQLXVDV7DSURWLVORY QRVWQDMELSR-HDQX:DKOXL]YLUDODL]SURWLVORYMDPRĤQRVWLLQFHORWHÌHMHVYHWHQRWHQNRW HQRWQRVWPRĤQRVWLWHGDMQLFHORWDÍHSDMHFHORWDWHGDMQLHQRWHQNRWHQRWQRVWPRĤQRVWL JUHDUJXPHQW7RGDVYHWNRWKRUL]RQWNRWFHORWDPRĤQRVWLMHSUREOHPDWLÍHQSRMHP0RĤ QRVWLVDPLSUREOHPDWLÍQRSULSDGDWDWDNRRGSUWRVWNRW]DPHMHQRVWYQMXQLHQDNRL]YRUQRVWL 3ULP:HOWRQ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 131 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 1HPRUHELWLQHNWHOHRORďNLVPLVHO7DNR*HQLXVDVUD]OLNXMHYWHPHOMXQDVOHGQMD GYD VPLVOD VYHWD NRW KRUL]RQWD XVWUH]QD ]DÍHWQHPX UD]OLNRYDQMX VYHWQRVWL KRUL]RQWD LQ KRUL]RQWDVYHWDVDPHJDVYHWNRWKRUL]RQWRGSUWHPRĤQRVWLVYHWNRWWDPNMHUL]NXVWYDDOL SDNRW}SUHSOHWDQMHKRUL]RQWRY>Ȭ@NRQNUHWQRLQVWDOQRSUHREOLNRYDQMHVPLVODm*HQLXVDV 7RLPHQXMHVYHWNRW}WMDNDPRUmL]NXVWYDNRWQHNDNďHQWHOHRORďNLVPLVHOVYHWD NRWKRUL]RQWD7RGDKRUL]RQWNRWSUHG]DULVDQLVPRWHUSRQRYQRSUHGSRVWDYOMDQHNRGRORÍH QRNRQNUHWQRL]NXVWYHQRGDQRVWL]NDWHUHL]KDMDLQKNDWHULL]NXVWYRWHĤL 1HPRUHELWLKRUL]RQWNRWMHGURPUHĤHSRPHQVNRVWLLQNLJDODKNRUD]XPHPR VDPR }RG ]QRWUDMm 6DPR WDNR QDM EL VH ELOR PRÍ L]RJQLWL SRSUHGPHWHQMX LGHMH VYHWD SR DQDORJLMLVKRUL]RQWQRNRQVWLWXFLMRSUHGPHWRYNLVRODKNRLGHDOQRGDQLYYVHKVYRMLKKRUL ]RQWQLKYLGLNLK:HOWRQ=D:HOWRQDYVDNRUD]XPHWMHKRUL]RQWDVYHWDNRWNRUHODWD VYHW SRSUHGPHWL ,ELG 7RGD SUDY WR SRMPRYDQMH RSUDYL LVWR VDM KRUL]RQW VYHWD UD]XPH SUYHQVWYHQRL]SUHGPHWQRVWLNDNRUMHSDÍVPLVHOQRQDSRWRYDOQRVWUXNWXULUDQD +XVVHUOX MH ]D Y]SRVWDYLWHY ]QDQRVWL R ĤLYOMHQMVNHP VYHWX NOMXÍQR GRVHÍL UDYQR SRMHP danosti FHORWHPRĤQHGHMDQVNRVWL=DWRGDELELODWDNDGDQRVWPRĤQDELPRUDODYVDNL PRĤQRVWLL]SROQLWYHLQYVDNLL]SROQLWYLSULSDGDWLVDPLYVHELQHNDNDPRĤQDFHORWQRVWL] SROQLWYHR]LURPDSRSROQRVWȡGRYUďHQRVWL]SROQLWYHVSORKȡLQSROHJWHJDďHHGLQRVWHQRW QRVWLQLVWRYHWQRVWWHFHORWQRVWLVRL]YRUQHVWRFHORWQRVWMR1DMSUHMYVDPHP]D]QDYQHP L]NXVWYXQDÍHOQRQHPRUHELWLÍHVDWDNHJDȡWRMHYVHOHMRPHMHQDQD]D]QDYQRSROMHNLQH GRSXďÍDQREHQHLGHMHRPRĤQLFHORWQRVWL 1LNROLQHĤLYLPYVYHWXWDNRGDELYVYRMHPL]NXVWYXVYHWDL]KDMDOL]QHNHJDNRQ NUHWQHJD]D]QDYQHJDSROMDDPSDNQDUREHYVDNRNRQNUHWQR]D]QDYQRSROMHODKNRNRWWDNR UD]XPHPOH]QHNHJDSUHGYLGLNDVYHWD6PHUVYHWRVWQHJDKRUL]RQWDMHWRUHM}RGVYHWDSURWL NRQNUHWQHPXmLQQHREUDWQRNDNRUMHYLGHWLGDWRUD]XPHMR+XVVHUOLQWXGLLQWHUSUHWL 1HPRUHELWLKRUL]RQWNRWSDUDGRNVHQSRMHPNRWÍLVWLYLďHN/£V]Oµ7HQJHO\L IRUPXOLUDSDUDGRNVQRVWSRMPDKRUL]RQWLQSUHSR]QDL]YLUWHSDUDGRNVQRVWL1DMSUHMY]SR VWDYLGDKRUL]RQWELVWYHQRGRORÍDVRSULSDGDMRÍDVNULWRVWYGDMDQMXMH]PHUDMQHNDMNDUVH QHGDMHLQVLFHUNRQVWLWXWLYQR9KRUL]RQWXMHWDNRQHNDMYHÍ}9HÍNDNRUVHSUDYPHQLNDĤH 7UDQVFHQGHQFLYVHOHMSULSDGDVNULYDQMH+XVVHUODYUD]XPHYDQMXKRUL]RQWDYRGLWDPRGHO YLďNDm 7HQJHO\L 6YHW NRW KRUL]RQW MDYOMD NRW }YLďHN Y L]NXVWYX VWYDULm ,ELG 6YHWNRWKRUL]RQWMHWHGDMWUDQVFHQGHQWHQJOHGHQDVYHWQRELYDMRÍH6YHWNRWKRUL]RQW ]DGHYDSRWHQFLDOQRHYLGHQFR]DWRVNOHSD7HQJHO\LLQQDYDMD+XVVHUODL] Meditacij, se svet NRWKRUL]RQWPRĤQRVWLNDĤHNRW}LGHMDNLMHNRUHODWLYQDJOHGHQDLGHMRSRSROQHHYLGHQFH L]NXVWYDm ,ELG +RUL]RQW VYHWD NRW YLďHN MH ODKNR OH QHND WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQD VSR]QDYQD LGHMDQHQHNGDQVDPRVWRMHQVPLVHO7RELSRPHQLORGDMHSUL+XVVHUOXQDSRVOHGVYHWWXGL OH LGHMD ÍHSUDY PRUGD WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQR GDQD NL QL ]JROM UHJXODWLYQR SRVWXOLUDQD NHU EL SUHGVWDYOMDODUD]ďLUMHQSRMHPVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYD7DNDLGHMDQLVDPDQHNVDPRVWRMHQVPL VHODPSDNMHNOMXEVYRMLSDUDGRNVQRVWLďHYHGQRYH]DQDQDNRQNUHWQRGRORÍHQRL]NXVWYR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 132 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 PROBLEM KORELACIJE S HORIZONTOM SVETA 1DORJDGDVHVYHWSUHWYRULYĤLYOMHQMVNLIHQRPHQSDQDMELSR7HQJHO\LMXVOXĤLOD WHPXGDVHLGHMDKRUL]RQWDUHGXFLUDQDLGHMRNRUHODWD7HQJHO\L7DUHGXNFLMD QDMELLPHODGDOMQRVHĤQHSRVOHGLFHGDMDODQDMEL SULYLGQHNHJDLGHDOQHJDNRQÍQHJDVWDQMD v katerem bi se vsaka potencialna evidenca pretvorila v aktualno evidenco,ELG7RELVH YHGDXNLQLORPRPHQWYLďNDSUHVHĤNDYSRMPXKRUL]RQWD 3RPQHQMX7HQJHO\LMDELWDNRQDMYHUMHWQHMHPRUDOLL]EUDWLPHGNRUHODFLMR]DYHV WLLQVYHWDLQVYHWQLPKRUL]RQWRPNRWSUHVHĤNRP7RGDQDGUXJLVWUDQLMHKRUL]RQWWHPHO MQRNRUHODFLMVNLSRMHPȡWDNRNRWQLKRUL]RQWDEUH]VXEMHNWLYQRVWLWXGLQLKRUL]RQWDEUH] VYHWDWRGYRMHSDWYRULNRUHODFLMVNRHQRWQRVWIHQRPHQDNRWVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYD9HQGDU SDWRQHSRMDVQMXMHQLWLWHPHOMDQLWLVPLVODWHNRUHODFLMH 6YHWUD]XPHWNRWKRUL]RQW}FHORWHNRWWDNHmLPDODKNRVPLVHOVDPRNROLNRUMH NRWWDNWXGLGDQR]LURPDMHYNRUHODFLML]]DYHVWMRGRNOHURVWDMDPRYPHMDKWUDQVFHQGHQ WDOQHIHQRPHQRORJLMH'DELSRVWDODMDVQDVPLVHOLQPRĤQRVWWDNRUD]XPHWHJDKRUL]RQ WDVYHWDPRUDQDMSUHMSRVWDWLMDVQRDOLMHWDNDGDQRVWVSORKPRĤQDLQNDMQDMELELOVPLVHO WDNHGDQRVWL6DPRL]UD]PHUMDGRVYHWDNRWFHORWHÍHWXGLOHSUREOHPDWLÍQR]DVWDYOMHQH ODKNRSRVWDQHMDVHQVPLVHOVYHWDVDPHJDNRWFHORWH 3UREOHPVHJODVLNDNRMHPRJRÍDGDQRVWKRUL]RQWDNRUHODFLMDVKRUL]RQWRPNRW QHNDNďQLPSUHVHĤNRPWRGDSUHGPHWQRVWLVSORKQHNRQNUHWQHGRORÍHQHSUHGPHWQRV WL"ÌHQDMJRYRULPRRIHQRPHQRORďNLXWHPHOMLWYLSULVWRMQHJDRGQRVDGRVYHWDPRUDWD ELWL QDPUHÍ SULVRWQD RED PRPHQWD +XVVHUO VDP SUREOHP VDPRGDQRVWL KRUL]RQWD NRW WDNHJD]DVWDYLY]DSLVNLK+XVVHUOYSUDďDQMH]DVWDYLWDNROH}.DNRYHP]DVYHWGDMHLQGD MHNRWVYHWHGHQHGLQLVYHW".DNRYHPGDMHWRNDUYVHOHML]NXďDPSRVDPH]QRLQPQR JRWHURQHNDML]XQLYHU]DȣVYHWȤ".DNRYHPYSRVDPH]QHPȣYQDSUHMȤȣDSULRULȤ]DQHNL YHÍ",QNDNďQHYUVWHMHWDYHÍGDSULGRELPWHPHOM]DJRYRURL]NXVWYXVYHWDLQDSULRUQL VYHWQLJRWRYRVWL"m+XVVHUO +XVVHUOGDOMHXJRWDYOMD}>@VYHW>Ȭ@MHELYDMRÍYHGLQRVWL]DNDWHURMHSOXUDO EUH]VPLVOD9VDNSOXUDOLQL]QMHJDSRY]GLJQMHQVLQJXODUSUHGSRVWDYOMDVYHWQLKRUL]RQW >Ȭ@7DGLIHUHQFDELWQLKQDÍLQRYREMHNWDYVYHWXLQVYHWDVDPHJDRÍLWQRSUHGSLVXMHREH PD WHPHOMQR UD]OLÍQH NRUHODWLYQH ]DYHVWQH QDÍLQHm +XVVHUO ȡ .OMXÍQR YSUDďDQMHMHWRUHMWRNDNRMHPRJRÍDNRUHODFLMDVVYHWRPNRWHGLQVWYHQLPKRUL]RQWRP LQ NDM MH QDSRVOHG QMHQ VPLVHO" .DNR VYHWX NRW KRUL]RQWX ELWL SULSDGD HQRVWDYQRVW" ,Q NDNR MH WD NRW WDN QHSUHGPHWHQ ODKNR Y NRUHODFLML ] UD]XPHYDQMHP R] ]DYHVWMR" Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 133 27. 10. 2022 11:16:22 6PLVHO HGLQRVWL VYHWD MH ]D +XVVHUOD enotna, univerzalna veljavnost +XVVHUO 'DOMHR]DREVHJDMRÍLKKRUL]RQWQLKYHOMDYQRVWLKJRYRUL 9]DMHPQRYSOLYDMRÍLKHQDQDGUXJRYIRUPLSRWUMXMRÍLKL]SULÍHYDQMELYDQMD>@ 7RMHODVWQRVLQWHWLÍQHWRWDOLWHWH>@XQLYHU]DOQRGHOXMRÍHĤLYOMHQMHYNDWHUHP QDVWDMD VYHW NRW ]D QDV VWDOQR Y WHNRÍL YVDNRNUDWQRVWL ELYDMRÍ >@ VYHW NRW NRUHODW>@VLQWHWLÍQRSRYH]XMRÍLKVHVWRULWHYGRELYDVYRMELWQLVPLVHOLQVYR MR ELWQR YHOMDYQRVW Y WRWDOLWHWL VYRMLK RQWLÍQLK VWUXNWXU +XVVHUO ĎHGUXJDÍHSUDYLGD}VXEMHNWLYQDVSUHPHPEDGDQRVWQLKQDÍLQRY>@SRYH]XMRÍD VHYSUHWHNDQMXL]YUďXMHHQRWQR]DYHVWHQRVWDYQHȮELWLȯVYHWDm+XVVHUO Tran VFHQGHQWDOQRIHQRPHQRORďNLVPLVHONRUHODFLMHMHL]REOLNRYDQSRIRUPLNRUHODFLMH]DYHVWL LQSUHGPHWQRVWLWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQRIHQRPHQRORďNLSRMHPKRUL]RQWDSDSUHGSRVWDYOMDWD SUHGPHWQLVPLVHONRUHODFLMH=DWRQHPRUHXWHPHOMHYDWLRGQRVDGRKRUL]RQWDVYHWDR]L URPDGDQRVWLVYHWDNRWKRUL]RQWDNROLNRUVHWDSRMPXMHYQDVSURWMXVSUHGPHWQRVWMR %LVWYHQDUD]OLNDIHQRPHQRORďNHJDLQWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHJDSRMPRYDQMDVYHWDQDM ELELODYWHPGDYVOHGQMHPNDMWDNHJDNRWKRUL]RQWVYHWDQLGDQRYL]NXVWYXVYHWDIRUPD WHL]NXďQMHSDMHGDQDOHXPVNRNRWUHJXODWLYQDLGHMD1DVSURWQRSDQDMELELODYIHQR PHQRORďNHPSRMPXVYHWDIRUPDL]NXVWYDVYHWDQHNDNRQDND]DQRGDQDYVDPLL]NXďQML VYHWD =GLVHGDMHUH]XOWDW+XVVHUORYHSUREOHPDWLNHWDGDNRUHODFLMDVKRUL]RQWRPĤL YOMHQMVNHJDVYHWDVSORKQLPRĤQDDPSDNPRUGD]JROMNRUHODFLMDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHJDVD PRVSR]QDQMDVVYHWRPNRWWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLPIHQRPHQRP-HPRUGDWXWUHEDUD]OLNRYDWL PHG ĤLYOMHQMVNLP VYHWRP NRW SUHGGDQLPL }WOHPLm L]NXVWYD LQ ĤLYOMHQMVNLP VYHWRP NRW WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLPKRUL]RQWRP"$OLWRUD]OLNRYDQMHSULSRPRUHNUD]UHďLWYLSDUDGRNVD ĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVYHWDLQVWHPNSRGDMDQMXRGJRYRUDNDNRMHPRJRÍDNRUHODFLMDVVYHWRP"6H SUDYLQHVVYHWRPNRWVWDOQRGHOXMRÍLPXQLYHU]DOQLPKRUL]RQWRPQLWLQHVVYHWRPNRWVPL VHOQRSRGODJRL]NXVWYDDPSDNNRWWHRUHWVNLRGQRVGRVYHWDYREHKVPLVOLKȡWDNRNRWKRUL ]RQWDNDNRUNRWSRGODJHȡNRWL]YLUDMRÍHJDL]VXEMHNWLYQHVYHWRWYRUQHGHMDYQRVWLÍLVWHJD WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHJDMD]D7RQLNRUHODFLMDYSUDYHPVPLVOX7DNRVH]GLGDQDVWRSLDSRULMD *HQLXVDVWDSUREOHPL]UD]LWDNROH}7RGDÍHQLQLWLSUHGPHWHQQLWLWHPDWLÍHQQLWLLQWXLWLYHQQD NDWHUHPWHPHOMXMHWHGDMPRJRÍHWUGLWLGDMHVYHWNRWKRUL]RQWYHQGDUOHGDQ"m*HQLXLVDV(XJHQ)LQN QDMELY Welt und Endlichkeit WDNRVNOHSDOGDVYHWQLGDQSR)LQNRYLKEHVHGDKMHY+XVVHUORYLIHQRPHQRORJLML VYHW}UD]XPHWNRWREURÍNLMHYVHOHMĤH]DGUĤDQYQDSUHMLQNLȥSUD]QRȣRENURĤDSROMHL]NXVWYDm)LQN *HQLXVDVSUHGODJDQDVOHGQMRUHďLWHY}> ... @VYHWNRWKRUL]RQWODKNRSRVWDQHWHPDWLÍHQWDNRGDUD]NULMHPRNDNR WYRULQXMQLSURWLSROSULND]RYDQMXREVWRMHÍLKSUHGPHWRYWDNRGDEUH]QMHJDWRSULND]RYDQMHQHELELORPRJRÍHm *HQLXVDV}>@WUHEDMH]DWUGLWLGDĤLYOMHQMVNLVYHWVDPĤHOHĤLQDL]YRUQHMďHPWHPHOMXL]NXVWYD NDNRUNROLÍXGQRVHWRĤHVOLďLm*HQLXVDV6PLVHOWHJDVWDYNDMHQHMDVHQ,]YRUQDHQRWQRVWKRUL]RQW QRVWLQDMELSRELODXWHPHOMHQDY]JRGRYLQVNRVWLR]LURPDQD]DGQMHIDNWLÍQRVWLJOHM*HQLXVDV&ODHJHV SDUD]OLNXMHKRUL]RQWYRĤMHPLQďLUďHPVPLVOXNRWKRUL]RQWNRQNUHWQHJDĤLYOMHQMVNHJDL]NXVWYDLQNRWIHQRPHQ ʳOR]RIVNHUHʴHNVLMH&ODHJHV Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 134 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 DOLMHVYHWNRWKRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVYHWDYH]DQQDNRQNUHWQREUH]SUHGPHW QRVWLQWDNRQLSULPHUHQ]DSRMHPVYHWDNRWFHORWQRVWLELWLDOLSDMHNRWNRUHODWWUDQVFH GHQWDOQHVXEMHNWLYLWHWHL]SUD]QMHQNRQNUHWQHJDĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVPLVOD +XVVHUOXVHSDUDGRNVQRVYHWNRWFHORWDNRWIHQRPHQSRMDYLVDPRNRLQNROLNRUELWVYHWD NRWYVHELQRJHQHUDOQHWH]H}SRVWDYLYRNOHSDMm3RL]YHGELUHGXNFLMHQHPRUHYHÍQDVWR SLWLNRWIHQRPHQȡYVHELYDMRÍHVHODKNRNDĤHNRWELWQLIHQRPHQWXGLSRL]NORSXL]YU ďHYDQMDWH]HELWLNDNRUVHJDRSD]XMHNRWNRQVWLWXLUDQHJDYGRORÍHQHPELWQHPQDÍLQX VYHWVDPSDEUH]L]YUďHYDQMDWH]HELWLQLPDQLNDNUďQHJDIHQRPHQDOQHJDVPLVOD]DGHYD QDPUHÍELWVDPRNRWWDNRYQMHQLHGLQVWYHQRVWLNLMHQLPRÍWLSL]LUDWLȡVYHWFHORWDELWL QHPRUHSRVWDWLHLGHWVNLGRĤLYOMDM+XVVHUOY]DSLVNLKRĤLYOMHQMVNHPVYHWXL]UHFQRYSHOMH UD]XPHYDQMHVYHWDNRWHLGRVD ÌH SD QD GDQL VYHW SRJOHGDPR NRW QHN JROL PRĤQL VYHW ÍH SURVWR SRPLVOLPR QD IDNW WHJD VYHWD ] QMHJRYR LQYDULDQWQR ȮWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQR HVWHWVNRȯ IRUPR LQ SUHKDMDPR VNR]L YVH SURVWH PRĤQRVWL DOL MK IDQWL]LUDMRÍ ]DULVXMHPR SULGRELPR WDNR HLGRV ȮVYHWȯ NRW LQYDULQDWQR ELVWYR NL SULSDGD YVDNHPX PRĤQHPX VYHWX >@ +XVVHUO +XVVHUOUD]XPHYDQMHVYHWDWHGDMREOLNXMHSRPRGHOXELVWYRJOHGMDPHWRGHNL MHVPLVHOQRXWHPHOMHQDYXPVNHPRGQRVXGRELYDMRÍHJD=D+XVVHUODMHELWYVHOHMGH DOQD ELW L]SROQLWHY XPVNH WH]H QHNHJD ELVWYD 6DPR VSORďQR MH ]DUHV SROQR GDQR =D +XVVHUODMHDEVROXWQRVWYHLGHWVNLXQLYHU]DOQRVWLVDPRYWHPSRPHQXLPD]DQMYHUMHW QR WXGL VYHW ODKNR VPLVHO DEVROXWD =D +XVVHUOD LPD IHQRPHQ QD]DGQMH YVHOHM SRPHQ QHNHJD ]XQDQMHJD RSD]RYDQHJD ] QHNHJD ÍLVWHJD JOHGLďÍD WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQH NRQVWL WXFLMHNLVDPDQLLQQHPRUHELWLIHQRPHQMHSDNRQVWLWXFLMDYVHJDIHQRPHQDOQHJD100 3ULPWXGL&ODHJHV 7DNRVH+XVVHUOYSUDďD}.DNRODKNRSUHGGDQRVWĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVYHWDSRVWDQH]GDMODVWQDLQXQLYHU ]DOQDWHPD"2ÍLWQRVDPRVWRWDOQLPSUHGUXJDÍHQMHPQDUDYQHQDUDYQDQVRVWLSUHGUXJDÍHQMHPYNDWHUHPPLQH ĤLYLPRYHÍNDNRUGRVOHMNRWOMXGMHQDUDYQHJDELYDQMDYVWDOQHPL]YUďHYDQMXYHOMDYQRVWLSUHGGDQHJDVYHWDWHPYHÍ VHYHGQRY]GUĤLPRWHJDL]YUďHYDQMDm7RGDSUDYYWHPVH]JUHďLVPLVHOĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVYHWDVDM}L]YUďHYDQMHWH YHOMDYQRVWLmVSDGDELVWYHQRNĤLYOMHQMVNHPXVYHWX=HSRFKHQDMELʳOR]RIELO}SRYVHPRVYRERMHQQDMPRÍQHMďHLQ QDMXQLYHU]DOQHMďHWHUREWHPQDMVNULWHMďHQRWUDQMHYH]DQRVWLWLVWHRGSUHGGDQRVWLVYHWD=LQYWHMRVYRERMHQRVWL MHGDQRRGNULWMHXQLYHU]DOQHYVHELDEVROXWQRVNOHQMHQHLQDEVROXWQRVDPRVWRMQHNRUHODFLMHVYHWDVDPHJDLQ VYHWQH]DYHVWLm+XVVHUO7XVHSRNDĤHL]YRUQDQDSDNDʳOR]RIMHSRVWDYOMHQ}QDGVYRMRQDUDYQRELW LQQDGQDUDYQLVYHW>Ȭ@NRWʳOR]RIVVYRMHYUVWQRVWLVYRMHLQWHUHVQHXVPHUMHQRVWLVHRGSRYHWHPXGDQDGDOMXMH FHORWQRQDUDYQRL]YUďHYDQMHVYRMHJDVYHWQHJDĤLYOMHQMDWMGDQDWOHKQDY]RÍHJDVYHWDSRVWDYLYSUDďDQMDELWQD YSUDďDQMD>@VYHW>@VHPHGNRQVHNYHQWQRL]SHOMDQRHSRFKHJOHGDÍLVWRNRWNRUHODWVXEMHNWLYQRVWLNLPXGDMH ELWQLVPLVHOLQL]YHOMDYQRVWLNDWHUHRQVSORKȣMHȤm+XVVHUOȡ3UHGQRVWMHSULSLVDQDVXEMHNWLYQRVWL }>@VWRMLPQDGVYHWRPNLMH]GDM]DPHQHSRVWDOIHQRPHQYQHNHPSRYVHPVYRMHYUVWQHPVPLVOXm+XVVHUO 7DNRSULGRELPR}WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLIHQRPHQȣVYHWȤm,ELG7RUHM eo ipso QHYHÍĤLYOMHQMVNLVYHW0RĤ QRQDMELELORGDVH}YVDNÍDV]QRYDYUQHPRYQDUDYQRQDUDYQDQRVWLQYQMHMYSUDďDPRSRĤLYOMHQMVNRVYHWQLK LQYDULDQWQLKVWUXNWXUDKm.DMWDGYRMQRVWPHWRGHSRPHQL]DSRVNXVWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQRIHQRPHQRORďNHXWHPHO MLWYHUD]PHUMDGRVYHWD"6WDOQRSUHPHďÍDQMHL]HQHSHUVSHNWLYHYGUXJRLQVWDOQHSRSUDYNHDQDOL]7XMHNOMXÍHQ L]UD]}YQMHMmQDPUHÍYQDUDYQLQDUDYQDQRVWLLQQHL]QMHVDPH+XVVHUOWXYSHOMHQRYRSRWNUHGXNFLMLYORÍLWYL RG}NDUWH]LMDQVNHSRWLm+XVVHUO7D}VLFHUNRWYHQHPVNRNXĤHYRGLNWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHPXHJXWRGD WHJDVDMPRUDYVDNDSUHGKRGQDHNVSOLNDFLMDPDQMNDWLJOHGDYSULYLOHJLUDQLYVHELQVNLSUD]QLQLYNDWHULVLQH YHPRSRPDJDWLNDMQDMVHVWHPGRELLQVSORKNDNRQDMVHL]WHJDGRELQRYDLQ]DʳOR]RʳMRRGORÍLOQDSRYVHP QRYRYUVWQDWHPHOMQD]QDQRVWm+XVVHUO7X+XVVHUONULWLÍQRSUL]QDSUHVNRNIHQRPHQDVYHWDYNDUWH ]LMDQVNLSRWL}>@YVDNÍORYHNȣQRVLYVHELWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLMD]ȤWRGDQHNRWUHDOQLGHODOLSODVWVYRMHGXďHNDU ELELOQHVPLVHODPSDNNROLNRUMHRQVDPRREMHNWLYDFLMDGRWLÍQHJDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQHJDMD]DNLVHGDSRND]DWL VIHQRPHQRORďNRVDPRRVPLVOLWYLMR>@1DLYQRVWSUYHHSRFKHMH>@LPHOD]DSRVOHGLFRGDMHMD]ʳOR]RʳUDMRÍL ȣHJRȤVWHPNRMHVHEHGRMHONRWIXQJLUDMRÍLMD]NRWMD]SROWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLKDNWRYLQVWRULWHYÍORYHďWYXYNDWH UHPMD]QDMGHPVHEHSULSLVDOLVWRVSUHPHPERYIXQJLUDMRÍRWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQRVXEMHNWLYQRVWNLVHPMRMD]L]YUďLO HGLQRYVHELm+XVVHUO Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 135 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 9WHP]JUHďLVDPRSUREOHPDWLÍQRMHGURIHQRPHQDÍHSUDYJDMHELOVDPWDNR ]DVWDYLOQDSULÍHWNX+XVVHUOVLMHL]UHFQRSUL]DGHYDOSULGRELWLL]YRUHQSRMHPVYHWD3UL WHPSDMH]PHUDMWUHEDLPHWLSUHGRÍPLGDJUHKXVVHUOX]DXPVNLVYHWXPVNRFHORWRGH MDQVNRVWL101 9 WHP ]JUHďL VDPR SUREOHPDWLÍQR MHGUR IHQRPHQD ÍHSUDY JD MH ELO VDP WDNR ]DVWDYLOQDSULÍHWNX+XVVHUOVLMHL]UHFQRSUL]DGHYDOSULGRELWLL]YRUHQSRMHPVYHWD3UL WHPSDMH]PHUDMWUHEDLPHWLSUHGRÍPLGDJUH+XVVHUOX]DXPVNLVYHWXPVNRFHORWR GHMDQVNRVWL102 6YHWVDPSDEUH]L]YUďHYDQMDWH]HELWLQLPDQLNDNUďQHJDIHQRPHQDOQHJDVPLV OD]DGHYDQDPUHÍELWVDPRNRWWDNRYQMHQLHGLQVWYHQRVWLNLMHQLPRÍWLSL]LUDWL6YHW FHORWDELWLQHPRUHSRVWDWLHLGHWVNLGRĤLYOMDM 3UREOHP L]YRUQH HQRWQRVWL KRUL]RQWQRVWL R]LURPD HQRWQRVWL VXEMHNWLYQH KR UL]RQWQRVWLLQVYHWQHKRUL]RQWQRVWLSDMHSUDY]DSUDYWUHEDREUDYQDYDWLNRWWHPSRUDOQL SUREOHPVDMLPDKRUL]RQWELVWYHQRWHPSRUDOQLVPLVHO3UREOHPNRUHODFLMH]DYHVWLLQKR UL]RQWDVYHWDMHSUREOHPNRUHODFLMHÍDVD]DYHVWLLQÍDVRYQRVWLKRUL]RQWD 7RSRPHQLGDVWDGYDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQDMD]DLQGYDVPLVODWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQRVWLR]LURPDGDMHVPLVHOWUDQVFHQ GHQWDOQRVWLJOREOMLRGWLVWHJDNLMHELOSUHGVWDYOMHQY,GHMDK.DQWSDMHXYLGHOGDMH}WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLVXEMHNW >@ODKNRVDPRSRVWXODWLQGDNRQVWLWXFLMDVDPDQLQHNDMNDUELL]YDMDOVXEMHNWNRQVWLWXFLMDLQWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQL MD]VHL]NOMXÍXMHWDUD]HQNROLNRUVXEMHNWLYQRVWL]HQDÍLPRVNRQVWLWXFLMR*OHGHWHQRYHSRWLUHGXNFLMHSUDYL }.RWSULYVHKSULQFLSHOQRQRYRYUVWQLKQDORJDKSULNDWHULKQHPRUHYRGLWLQLWLDQDORJLMDVHWRGRJDMDYGRORÍHQL QHRJLEQLQDLYQRVWL1D]DÍHWNXMHGHMDQMH7RGHODďHQH]DQHVOMLYRQDPHURGRORÍQHMďRLQKNUDWLYHGQRMDVQHMďR QDWLVWLKGHOLKNMHUL]YDMDQMHXVSHYD=DWHPMHSRWUHEQDLQWRMHGUXJRPHWRGLÍQDUHʴHNVLMDNLL]UHFQRRPHMXMH VSORďQLVPLVHOLQGRVHJL]SROQOMLYRVWLWRYUVWQHQDPHUHLQNDUMHYWHPĤHGRVHĤHQRm+XVVHUO7XVOHGL .DQWXNLNDQRQSRVWDYLQDNRQHF Kritike 7RGDWXGLYWHMQRYLSRWLďHGDOMHRVWDMD}VYHWNLMH]DQDVMHSRWDNRELWL LQELWLQDďVYHWÍUSDVYRMELWQLVPLVHOSRYVHPL]QDďHJDLQWHQFLRQDOQHJDĤLYOMHQMDm+XVVHUO7RUHMSD WRQLVDPRODVWHQVYHWQHVYHWNRWSUDYLVDPRODVWQLNRUHODW+XVVHUOVL]DGDMD]DFLOMXQLYHU]DOQRVDPRXPHYQRVW 7XVHRGSLUDMRSUREOHPLWRWDOLWHWHNRWSUREOHPLXQLYHU]DOQHJDXPD1DPUHÍȣ%LVWYHQDWLSLND>@ ĤLYOMHQMVNLVYHW>@NRQVWLWXLUDNRWHQRWQRVWXQLYHU]XPĤLYOMHQMVNRVYHWQLKREMHNWRYȤ+XVVHUO +XVVHUOQDSRVOHGSULVSHGRVNOHSDGDMHQDUDYQRREMHNWLYQRVYHWQRĤLYOMHQMHOHSRVHEHQQDÍLQVWDOQHJDVYHW NRQVWLWXULDMRÍHJDWUDQVFHGHQWDOQHJDĤLYOMHQMD+XVVHUO 9 Husserl 2008. Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 136 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 SKLEP +XVVHUOMH]JROM]DVWDYLOSUREOHPDWLNRKRUL]RQWQHJDVPLVODVYHWDLQQMHJRYHGD QRVWL 3UHGVWDYOMD SD SUDY]DSUDY WRULďÍH +HLGHJJHUMHYHJD SRVNXVD UD]YLWMD ÍDVRYQRVWL SUL NDWHUHP SUREOHPDWLND WHPSRUDOQRVWL NRW KRUL]RQWQH NRQÍQRVWQH VWUXNWXULUDQRVWL VDPHJDELWQHJDVPLVODYQMHJRYLGLIHUHQFL]ELYDMRÍLPNRWEUH]WHPHOMQHJDPRĤQRQH PRĤQHJDQDVWRSLREYSUDďDQMXYNDNďQHPUD]PHUMXMHWDKRUL]RQWRVWVKRUL]RQWQRVW MRVPLVHOQHJDL]NXVWYDWXELWLQKRUL]RQWQRVWMRQDSRWLOQRVWMRVYHWQHJD*ODYQDWRÍND SUREOHPDMHSUDYWRDOLMHQHNRSUHKDMDQMHGLQDPLÍQRUD]PHUMHPHGWHPDGYHPDUDYQH PDVSORKVPLVHOQRDOLSDJUHWXPDU]DKRUL]RQWQRVWYSRYVHPGUXJHPVPLVOXR]LURPD NROLNRLQQDSRGODJLNDWHUHJDWHPHOMDODKNRJRYRULPRRL]YRUQLHQRWQRVWLQHOHHNVWDWLÍ QHKRUL]RQWQRVWLWXELWLLQKRUL]RQWQRVWLELWLDPSDNWXGLKRUL]RQWQHJDL]NXVWYDELYDMR ÍHJDLQKRUL]RQWQHJDL]NXVWYDELWL3RYHGDQRYNDUVHGDVNUDMďDQLREOLNLJUH]DYSUDďDQMH RKRUL]RQWQHPVWDWXVXRQWRORďNHGLIHUHQFHÌHMHVPLVHOQMHVDPHSUREOHPDWLÍHQLPD PRUGDUD]PHUMHPHGREHPDKRUL]RQWQRVWLPDVDPRQHJDWLYHQSUREOHPDWLÍHQVPLVHONL VHVWRMLYWHPGDVHKRUL]RQWQLVPLVHOVYHWQHJDSUHREUQHSUHRNUHQHYVPLVHOKRUL]RQW QRVWLELWLVDPH 7UDQVFHQGHQWDOQD IHQRPHQRORJLMD ]QRYD LQ ]QRYD SRVWDYNR KRUL]RQ WD SRWLVND LQ SUHPHďÍD Y QHVNRQÍQRVW ]DYROMR ]QDQVWYHQHJD LGHDOD WRWDOQH L]SRO QLWYH =DWR ML XPDQMND DEVROXWQRVW VYHWD VYHW SRSUHGPHWLb *ODYQD WH]D WH NUL WLNH VH JODVL GRNOHU MH UD]XPHYDQMH KRUL]RQWQRVWL YH]DQR QD SUHGPHWQRVW QD ELYDMRÍH GRNOHU VH KRUL]RQW UD]XPH NRW KRUL]RQW SUHGPHWQRVWL MH QHPRJRÍH XWH PHOMLWL UD]PHUMH GR VDPRODVWQHJD KRUL]RQWD FHORWH VSORK SD VPLVHO KRUL]RQWQRVWL NRW WDNH FHORWQRVWL NRW WDNH VXEMHNWLYQRVW VWDOQR ]DRVWDMD ]D SUHGPHWQLP KRUL]RQWRP 0HWRGLÍQLSUREOHPNLVHWXMDYLSDMHWDOHÍHLGHMH}VYHWDNRWWDNHJDmQHPR UHPRSULVWQRL]REOLNRYDWLL]KDMDMRÍL]UD]XPHWMDRNROQHJD}VYHWDmRGNRGQHNLQDMELMR ELOL]PRĤQLUD]XPHWLLQSRMPRYDWL"6YHWYVDPRODVWQHPVPLVOXVHWDNRNDĤHNRWQHNDM VPLVHOQHPXUD]XPHWMXNDUQDMEROMRGGDOMHQHJD,]WHGR]GHYQHEUH]XSQRVWLQDORJHSR VWDQHUD]XPOMLYDWHĤQMDWUDGLFLRQDOQHʳOR]RʳMHYNOMXÍQRV+XVVHUORPGDVYHWSRSUHG PHWLLQJDSRMPXMH]JROMNRWSUHGPHWQHJDDOLSDJDSUHWYRULYQHVDPRODVWHQIRUPDOHQ WUDQVFHQGHQWDOQLVSR]QDYQLIHQRPHQ 0RUGDSDWDQH]PRĤQRVW]DMHWMDFHORWHNRWFHORWHL]KDMDMRÍL]ÍHVDUNROL}]QR WUDMVYHWDmQDND]XMHGDVPLVHOFHORWHNRWWDNHWHPHOMLSUDYYWHMQHRVQRYDQRVWLQD ÍHPHUNROL]QRWUDMVYHWQHPGDJDPRUGDWYRULUDYQRWDEUH]WHPHOMQRVWVDPD,]]QR WUDMVYHWQHJDQLPRÍUD]XPHWLVYHWD'DELELOPRJRÍRGQRVGRVYHWDMHWUHEDVHÍLSUHNR VYHWDYQHPRĤQRVWVYHWD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 137 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 +XVVHUOWDNRY]DSLVNLKJRYRULRVYHWXNRWSUD]QHPKRUL]RQWX=QHVNRQÍQRVWMR QHGRORÍHQRVWMRLQSUD]QRVWMR+XVVHUO]DGDQHREEUH]WHPHOMQRVWNRWRVQRYRSRMPRYDQ MDVYHWDNLRPRJRÍLYVDNRSRVDPH]QRGRORÍHQRXWHPHOMHQRLQXWHPHOMHYDOQRL]NXVWYR 3UREOHPMHWHGDMĤHSUL+XVVHUOXVHYHGDWDNROLNRMHQHNDWDNDQHGRORÍHQRVWEUH]WHPHOMQRVW VSORKUHVODKNRQHNKRUL]RQW=DWRVDPQLKDPHGWREUH]WHPHOMQRVWMRNL]DKWHYDSRYVHP GUXJDÍQRREUDWQRSRMPRYQRVWKRUL]RQWDNRWWLVWRNLMRMHPRÍSRY]HWLL]KRUL]RQWDVYHW QHJDLQSRVNXVRPYVHOHM]QRYDSUDYWRDEVROXWQRKRUL]RQWQRVWUD]XPHWLSRDQDORJLMLV VYHWQRKRUL]RQWQRVWMRSRWHQFLDOQRVWLDNWXDOQRVWLLQL]SROQLWYH9HQGDUSDMHODKNRYLGLN WXGLREUDWHQQHVDPRGDVHREDVPLVODKRUL]RQWQRVWLYWHPHOMXUD]OLNXMHWDDPSDNMHPRUGD VYHWQRKRUL]RQWQRVWPRJRÍHSULPHUQRUD]XPHWLOHQDWHPHOMXSUYHDEVROXWQHNLSDVHL] YLGLNDYVDNGDQMHNDĤHSUDYNRWQHKRUL]RQWQRVWPHGWHPNRQMHQDIHQRPHQDOQDYVHELQDY UHVQLFLVNULYDNOMXÍ]DVPLVHOKRUL]RQWRVWLQDVSORKȡDQDOL]DYVDNGDQMHVYHWQHKRUL]RQWQRVWL WDNRODKNRVOXĤLOH]DÍHWQLSUREOHPDWL]DFLML Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 138 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 BIBLIOGRAFIJA &ODHJHV8OULFK=ZHLGHXWJNHLWHQLQ+XVVHUOV/HEHQZHOW%HJUL൵ Y 3HUVSHNWL-YHQWUDQV]HQGHQWDOSKHQRPHQORJLVFKHU)RUVFKXQJ'HQ+DDJ0DUWLQXV1LMKR൵ *HQLXVDV6DXOLXV 7KH2ULJLQVRIWKH+RUL]RQLQ+XVVHUOµV3KHQRPHQRORJ\ 'RUGUHFKW6SULQJHU +HOG.ODXV )HQRPHQRORãNLVSLVL/MXEOMDQD1RYDUHYLMD +XVVHUO(GPXQG 'LH/HEHQVZHOW$XVOHJXQJHQGHU9RUJHJHEHQHQ:HOWXQG LKUHU.RQVWLWXWLRQ7H[WHDXVGHP1DFKODVV±'RUGUHFKW6SULQJHU +XVVHUO(GPXQG ,GHMH]DþLVWRIHQRPHQRORJLMRLQIHQRPHQRORãNR¿OR]R¿MR. /MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD +XVVHUO(GPXQG .UL]DHYURSVNLK]QDQRVWLLQWUDQVFHQGHQWDOQDIHQRPHQRORJL-MD/MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD 2YHUJDDUG6RHUHQ +XVVHUODQG+HLGHJJHURQ%HLQJLQWKH:RUOG/RQGRQ .OXZHUDFDGHPLFSXEOLVKHUV 7HQJHO\/DV]OR+XVVHUORYSRMDPKRUL]RQWDY +RUL]RQWLSRMPDKRUL]RQW+H-PHQHXWLþNHIHQRPHQRORãNHLLQWHUNXOWXUDOQHVWXGLMH 1RYL6DG$NDGHPVNDNQMLJD 7RQNOL$QGULQD 0HGNULWLNRLQNUL]R/MXEOMDQD1RYDUHYLMD :HOWRQ'RQQ 7KH2WKHU+XVVHUO7KH+RULR]RQVRI7UDQVFHQGHQWDO3KHQRPH-QRORJ\%ORRPLQJWRQ,QGLDQD8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 139 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 O TELESU: MED MERLEAU-PONTYJEM IN BOURDIEUJEM Dino Manzoni MERLEAU-PONTYJEVO POJMOVANJE TELESA Telo je zunaj sebe in subjekta. Je edini pravi subjekt. 7RMHKNUDWLHURWLÍQRLQWUDJLÍQRȡQHSDELWL]QRWUDMWHOHVD -HDQ/XF1DQF\LQWHUYMXREMDYOMHQYÍDVRSLVX Delo, 2011 ÌH KRÍHPR UD]XPHWL 0HUOHDX3RQW\HYR SRMPRYDQMH WHOHVQRVWL LQ SHUFHSFLMH PRUDPR Y QMHJRYL ʳOR]RʳML QDMSUHM UD]XPHWL YORJR NRQFHSWD ĤLYOMHQMVNHJD VYHWD 1D ]DÍHWNX PRUDPR RPHQLWL +HLGHJJHUMD LQ QMHJRYR SRMPRYDQMH VYHWD QD NDWHUHJD MH ELVWYHQR YSOLYDO +XVVHUO =D SUYHJD MH ĤLYOMHQMVNL VYHW WHPHOM LQWHQFLRQDOQRVWL VDM MH LQWHQFLRQDOQRVW]DQMELVWYHQLQDÍLQNDNRHNVLVWLUDPRNRWVXEMHNWLYVYHWX6PRWYRUFL VYHWDLQREHQHPVPRYVYHWXVNR]LNDWHUHJDVPRVDPHPXVHELGDQL+HLGHJJHUYGHOX %LWLQÍDVSUDYLGDVWUXNWXURVYHWDWYRULSRPHQVNRVWWDSDMHRVQRYDQDYUD]XPHYDQMX 9HUVWHKHQ.HUVHQHERPRVSXďÍDOLYQMHJRYRʳOR]RʳMRERPRL]SRVWDYLOLVDPR]DQDďR UD]LVNDYRELVWYHQFLWDW}ȬELWYVYHWXMHGXKRYQDODVWQRVWLQȥSURVWRUVNRVWȣÍORYHND MH NDNRYRVW QMHJRYH ĤLYRWQRVWL NL MH KNUDWL YHGQR ȥIXQGLUDQDȣ Y QMHJRYL WHOHVQRVWLm +HLGHJJHU6WUXNWXUDELWLYVYHWXMHQDďHWHPHOMQRXVWURMVWYR=DYHVWLQMD] WDNRQHPRUHWDELWLQHNDM}QRWUDQMHJDmNLSUHGVWDYOMDLQWHUSUHWLUDLQSULSLVXMHSRPHQ ]XQDQMLPVWYDUHPYVYHWXPDUYHÍVPRNRWWXELWYVHOHMQDQHNQDÍLQL]YHQVDPHJDVHEH L]SRVWDYOMHQLODWH[VLVWHQWLDYVYHWXLQLPDPRVYHW=D+HLGHJJHUMDMHWRUHM}VYHWm NRQVWLWLXXP }ÍORYHNDm NRW HNVLVWHQFH 1DďD }SURVWRUVNRVWm MH WDNR GUXJDÍQD NDNRU SURVWRUVNRVW JROLK SUHGPHWRY NL VR QDY]RÍL QSU SURVWRUVNRVW NDPQD PL]H LWQ 7R XJRWRYLWHYERXSRUDELO0HUOHDX3RQW\YHQGDUQHNROLNRGUXJDÍHLQVLFHU]XYHGERSRMPD WHOHVQHVKHPH3ULQMHPVHUD]LVNRYDQMH]DYHVWL]DÍQHVSHUFHSFLMRNLMHHSLVWHPRORďNR SULPDUQD 6YHW UD]XPH NRW GLQDPLÍQR SROMH QDďLK L]NXVWHY }6YHW QL REMHNW NDWHUHJD WYRUQL]DNRQELVLODKNRODVWLODPSDNMHQDUDYQRRNROMHYVHKPRMLKPLVOLLQYVHKPRMLK L]UHFQLK]D]QDYm0HUOHDX3RQW\7DNRVSRGNRSDYDVSRQWDQRVWUXNWXURVYHWD ]D NDWHUHJD MH ELVWYHQR ]XQDQMH UD]PHUMH VXEMHNWREMHNW 3UDY WDNR ]DYUDÍD LGHMR R LQGLYLGXDOQL SULYDWQL QRWUDQMRVWL GR NDWHUH LPD QHSRVUHGHQ GRVWRS ]JROM VXEMHNW NDU SRPHQLGD]DYUDÍDVROLSVL]HPNDUERPRYLGHOLYQDVOHGQMHPSRJODYMX 0HUOHDX3RQW\ SRVNXďD PLVOLWL WHOR NRW IHQRPHQDOQR LQ NRW HNVSUHVLYQR WHOR OHFRUSVH[SUHVLIIÌHL]SRVWDYLPRQDMSUHM+XVVHUORYRUD]OLNRYDQMHWHORQDVWRSDWDNRY YORJLVXEMHNWDNRWYYORJLREMHNWD+XVVHUOUD]OLNXMHPHGĤLYHÍLPWHOHVRP/HLENDNRUJD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 140 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 GRĤLYOMDPRLQSUHNNDWHUHJDVWDQDPGDQDVYHWWHUQDďDODVWQDHNVLVWHQFDLQREMHNWLYQR JOHGDQRPHKDQVNLP}PUWYLPmWHOHVRP.¸USHUNLMHQHNDNďQDRUJDQL]LUDQDVWUXNWXUD VHVWDYOMHQDL]VNXSNDFHOLFRUJDQRYWNLYNRVWLLQWHNRÍLQWHUMHSUHGPHWUD]LVNRYDQMD ʳ]LRORJRYLQVHSUHNULYDVʳ]LRORJLMRĤLYDOL1 =D0HUOHDX3RQW\MDSDQLELVWYHQRVDPRYSUDďDQMHDOLMHWHOROHQDYDGHQREMHNW PHGGUXJLPLREMHNWLLQJDMHPRJRÍHSUHXÍHYDWLVSRPRÍMRQDUDYRVORYQHPHWRGRORJLMH WHU DOL GXďHYQRVW SRVUHGQR DOL QHSRVUHGQR YSOLYD QD WHOR PDUYHÍ GD MH WHOR VUHGVWYR ]D]QDYDQMDVNR]LNDWHUHJDVPRYSHWLYVYHW,]WHJDUD]ORJD0HUOHDX3RQW\XSRUDEOMD SRMHP}WHORVXEMHNWmFRUSVVXMHWVNDWHULPPLVOLWHORNRWĤLYHÍHWHORNLQDPUD]SLUD LQ UD]NULYD VYHW R]LURPD RPRJRÍD ]D]QDYDQMH Y NDWHUHP VH QDP GDMHWD WDNR VYHW NRW VXEMHNW.RWVPRYLGHOLVWDĤH+HLGHJJHULQQMHJRYSUHGKRGQLN+XVVHUOiXJR WDYOMDODGDMH}QRVLOQDSODVWYVHUHDOQRVWLWHOHVQRVWmNLRPRJRÍDL]NXVWYRVYHWD7HOR WDNRYQHNHPR]LUXSRVWDQHFHQWHUVYHWDR]LURPDNDNRUSRGD0HUOHDX3RQW\QDďHWHOR MH}RVVYHWDm0HUOHDX3RQW\=D]QDYQDRGSUWRVWYVYHWNLQDPRPRJRÍDWHOR SDMHYVHOHMSHUVSHNWLYQHJD]QDÍDMD7HOHVQDYSHWRVWMHWRUHMSRJRMPRĤQRVWLUD]NULYDQMD REMHNWRYVYHWDYQMLKRYLODVWQLQHL]ÍUSQRVWLLQGRORÍHQRVWL=D0HUOHDX3RQW\MDQDďD]D ]QDYDYUHVQLFLQLVDPRSDVLYQDPDUYHÍMHDNWLYQDNDNRUMHWUGLOĤH:LOOLDP-DPHVQD WDQDÍLQGDVDPRVHEHUD]YLMDLQERJDWLSUHNXVWYDUMDOQHUHFHSWLYQRVWLVNDWHURRĤLYOMD VYHW2EWHPQDYDMDJHVWDOWLVWD.RIINRNLVOHGQMHRSLďHWDNROH}ÌXWHQMHRSLVXMHL]NXVWYR NLQDPQHGDMH}PUWYLKmNDNRYRVWLDPSDNGHMDYQHNDNRYRVWLȬ2WURNXVH]GLGDVH VYHWOREDVYHÍHVSUHPHQLNRJDWDHQNUDWRSHÍHRGWDNUDWQHSULYODÍLYHÍQMHJRYHURNHLQ SRVWDQHGREHVHGQRRGELMDMRÍDm.RIINDȡ.DVQHMHERPRYLGHOL]DNDMMH ]DWHRULMRWHOHVQHJDGHORYDQMDSRPHPEHQRSLVL]NXVWYDYNDWHUHPVHQDPGDMHMRREMHNWL NRWDNWLYQLR]LURPDNRWGDSRVHGXMHMRVLORNLQDVRGELMDDOLYOHÍHYGHORYDQMH 6NR]L GHORYDQMH VH VXEMHNWL WHOHVD VDPRGHMQR QDUDYQDYDPR SRVWRSQHPX GRORÍDQMX WLVWLK VWYDUL NL VH QDP QDMSUHM NDĤHMR NRW QHMDVQH LQ QHUD]XPOMLYH 1D VWL PXOHL]RNROMDVHQHRG]LYDPROHSDVLYQRDYWRPDWLÍQRWHPYHÍYVHOHMĤHGHOXMHPRNRW XWHOHďHQD Y VYHWX VLWXLUDQD QH ORFLUDQD ELWMD NL VH RG]LYDMR QD SRYVHP NRQNUHWQH 1 'DQHVYRNYLUXELRPHGLFLQVNH]QDQRVWLLQELRWHKQRORJLMHWHORQLYHÍGHWHUPLQLUDQRVVWUDQLNODVLÍQH ELRORJLMH,NLSUHXÍXMHĤLYRQDUDYRNRWWDNRQLWLVVWUDQLNOLQLÍQHʳ]LRORJLMHPDUYHÍMHYVHEROMSRMPRYDQRY RNYLUXPROHNXODUQHELRORJLMHELRNHPLMHLQJHQVNHJDLQĤHQLUVWYD7DNRMHWHORSRVWDOROHVKUDPEDGRORÍHQLK JHQVNLK]DSLVRYLQIRUPDFLMNRGRYNLVHL]UDĤDMRSUHSLVXMHMRWHUWDNRXVPHUMDMR delovanje WHOHVD7RUHMMH FHORRUJDQL]HPOHSURVWRUYNDWHUHPMHVKUDQMHQDJHQHWVNDSRGDWNRYQDEDQNDģLYLRUJDQL]PLVRYWHPR]LUX VLVWHPLYNDWHULKVRUHSURGXNWLELOQHGHGQHLQIRUPDFLMHNRGLUDQHYPROHNXODKYREOLNLQHNDNďQHJDPROHNXODU QHJD}VRIWYHUDm3ULRUJDQL]PLKYWHMSUL]PLXSRUDEOMDPRKHYULVWLÍQLSULQFLSNDNRUGDVRRUJDQL]LUDQLVPRWUQR ÍHWXGLGHOXMHMRSRʳ]LNDOQLK]DNRQLK1DPHQWH]QDQRVWLSDMHVHYHGDVSUHPHPEDRSWLPL]DFLMDLQUHLQĤHQLULQJ PROHNXODUQLKWHUFHOLÍQLKPHKDQL]PRYVNDWHULPLQDMEL]GUDYLOLQHNDWHUHEROH]QL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 141 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 HQNUDWQHLQHGLQVWYHQHSUREOHPHDOLVLWXDFLMH 2 6DUWUHWDNRRSLďHVYRMRXVWYDUMDOQRGH MDYQRVWLQNULWL]LUDWLLGHMR}DYWRPDWVNHJDmSLVDQMD}0RUGDVHPQDYDMHQSLVDWLQLVHP SDQDYDMHQSLVDWLWHKEHVHGYWHP]DSRUHGMX1DVSORďQRUD]ODJDP]QDYDGRQHELVPHOL ]DXSDWLȬVHPYSRVHEQHPVWDQMXÍDNDQMDXVWYDUMDOQHJDÍDNDQMDÍDNDPGDVLEHVH GDȡNLMRSR]QDPYQDSUHMȡVSRVRGLURNRNLSLďHLQÍUWHNLMLKSXďÍD]DVDERGDELVH EHVHGDXUHVQLÍLODm6DUWUH/DKNRELUHNOLGDMHQDYDGDR]LURPDGRQHNHPHUH XVYRMHQDVSUHWQRVWQXMQLSRJRMGHMDYQRVWLNLMH]DUHVL]YLUQDYHQGDUMRREHQHPSUHVHJD ,PSURYL]LUDPRLQXVWYDUMDPRODKNRNRPDMNR]DUHVREYODGDPRQHNRYHďÍLQRGHMDYQRVW ÌHVHRVUHGRWRÍLPRQDWHORODKNRUHÍHPRGDYQHNHPR]LUXVWYDULVDPHSR]LYD MRLQQDJRYDUMDMRWHORGDVHYJLEDQMXQDQMLKQDMEROMRSWLPDOQRQDUDYQDLQVXEMHNW]DGREL QDMEROMďLPRĤHQRSULMHPJULIQSUVSRQWDQR]DY]DPHPR}SUDYRmJOHGLďÍHGLVWDQFR SRORĤDMGDODKNR]DMDPHPRPDNVLPDOQRERJDVWYRGHWDMORYLQMDVQRVWIRUPHWHURSWLPDOQL RSULMHPQDREMHNWH0HUOHDX3RQW\QSURSLďHSULPHUREÍXGRYDQMDVOLNHYPX]HMX6WUXN WXUDWHOHVQRVWLNLVHďLULLQL]UDĤDVNR]LQDďHGHORYDQMHRGUDĤDQDÍLQLQWHQFLRQDOQRVWLV NDWHURVPRYUD]PHUMXVVYHWRPNRWWDNLPȡJHQHUDOQRȡWHUVWYDUPLVYHWDȡVSHFLʳÍQR9 QDVSURWMXV+XVVHUORP]DNDWHUHJDMHLQWHQFLRQDOQRVWVWYDUVXEMHNWD]DYHVWLMH]D0HU OHDX3RQW\MDLQWHQFLRQDOQRVWSUYLQVNRVWYDUWHOHVDVXEMHNWDLQQMHJRYHYSHWRVWLYVYHW }0RMHWHORLPDVYRMVYHWR]LURPDVYRMVYHWUD]XPHQHGDELVHPXELORWUHEDRSLUDWLQDȥSUHG VWDYHȣLQQHGDELVHSRGUHMDORȥVLPEROLÍQLȣDOLȥREMHNWLYLUDMRÍLIXQNFLMLȣm0HUOHDX3RQW\ 3RXGDULWL PRUDPR GD EHVHGD }UD]XPHm QL UD]XPOMHQD ʳJXUDWLYQR DPSDN GREHVHGQR=DYHVWLWDNRQLPRJRÍHIRUPDOQRRSUHGHOLWLQDQDÍLQUHSUH]HQWDFLMHWHPYHÍ MH WD YVHOHM ĤH YNOMXÍHQD Y VWUXNWXUH LQ GHMDYQRVWL ĤLYOMHQMVNHJD VYHWD NRW SURVWRUD NL JDVWUXNWXULUDMRLQWHQFLRQDOQHRULHQWDFLMH NLRSWLPL]LUDMRQDďHYVDNRGQHYQRGHORYDQMH =D 0HUOHDX3RQW\MD MH WHOHVQRVW WLVWD NL RUJDQL]LUD LQ VWUXNWXULUD NRRUGL QDWH Y NDWHULK Y]SRVWDYOMDPR UD]PHUMH V VWYDUPL VYHWD ]DWR XYHGH SRMHP WHOHVQH VKHPHNLMH]DQM}QDÍLQL]UDĤDQMDPRMHJDWHOHVDQDVYHWXm0HUOHDX3RQW\ 2 }9VDNDPHKLQLVWLÍQDWHRULMDWUÍLREGHMVWYRGDMHXÍHQMHVLVWHPDWLÍQRVXEMHNWQH]GUXĤXMHSRVD PH]QLKJLERYVSRVDPH]QLPLVWLPXOLDPSDNMH]GRORÍHQLPLUHďLWYDPLVSRVREHQRGJRYRULWLQDGRORÍHQHREOLNH VLWXDFLMRGSULPHUDGRSULPHUD]ODKNDUD]OLNXMHUD]OLÍQHVLWXDFLMHSULÍHPHUODKNRRGJRYDUMDMRÍHJLEHL]YHGH HQNUDWHQRUJDQGUXJLÍGUXJLVLWXDFLMHLQRGJRYRULSDVRVLYUD]OLÍQLKSULPHULKSRGREQLSUHGYVHPJOHGHQD VNXSQLVPLVHOHOHPHQWRYLQQHWROLNRJOHGHQDQMLKRYRGHOQRLGHQWLWHWRm0HUOHDX3RQW\ =DDYWRUMDVR}LQWHQFLRQDOQHQLWLWLVWHNLVHUD]UDďÍDMRLQVHJDMRYSURVWRUVYHWDWHUQDVSRYH]XMHMR VVWYDUPLXVPHUMDMR]D]QDYRWHUSRVWDYOMDMRSURVWRUVNHNRRUGLQDWHSUHNNDWHULKVHRULHQWLUDPRYRNROMXNLJD QDUHGLMR]DGRPDÍHJDWRSRPHQLGDPXYWLVQHMRSHÍDWGRPDÍHJD7DNRYVHOHMĤHQDQHNDNďHQQDÍLQQDVHOMX MHPRR]VPRQDUDYQDQLQDRNROQLVYHWGDVPRYGHORYDQMXQDMEROMRSWLPDOQL0HUOHDX3RQW\QDYHGHQDVOHGQML SULPHU}0RMHVWDQRYDQMH]DPHQLYUVWDWHVQRSRYH]DQLKSRGREVDMPHREGDMDNRWGRPDÍHRNROMHOHÍHVHPȥV VYRMLPLURNDPLȣDOLVȥVYRMLPLQRJDPLȣďHYHGQRVSRVREHQ]D]QDYDWLJODYQHVPHULLQUD]GDOMHLQÍHVHL]PRMHJD WHOHVDSURWLPRMHPXXVPHUMDPQRďWYRLQWHQFLRQDOQLKQLWLm,ELG },PSOLFLWQRMHWHRULMDWHOHVQHVKHPHWHRULMD]D]QDYHm,ELG Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 142 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 7HOHVQD VKHPD Y VNORSX QDďH ODVWQH ]D]QDYH ODKNR SRVWDQH }REPRÍMH REÍXW OMLYRVWLmLQUD]ďLULREVHJWHUDNWLYQRREPRÍMHQDďHJDÍXWHQMDSULPHUÍXWLOQHSDOLFHLQ NOREXND 7DNRQDPRPRJRÍDGDREMHNWHQDQHNQDÍLQLQWHJULUDPRYODVWQRSURVWRU VNRVW 7RSRPHQLGDSURVWRUQHREVWDMDOHNRWDEVROXWQL1HZWRQVNLSURVWRUYNDWHUHP VHJRGLJLEDQMHLQLQWHUDNFLMDWHOHVSR]DNRQLKNODVLÍQHPHKDQLNHDPSDNYVHOHM]DMHPD WXGLUHODWLYQLSURVWRUYNDWHUHPVXEMHNWY]SRVWDYLODVWQRUD]PHUMHGRREMHNWRY7DNRVR QDPQHNLREMHNWLODKNREROMRGGDOMHQLLQWXMLDOLSDEOL]XLQSR]QDQLR]LURPD}SULURNLm LQVLFHURGYLVQRWHJDNDNRPRÍQRVRVHLQWHJULUDOLR]YNRPSRQLUDOLYWHOHVQRVKHPR 6DPD ]D]QDYQD ]PRĤQRVW MH ]D 0HUOHDX3RQW\MD GLQDPLÍQL SURFHV L]HQDÍHYDQMD WHOH VQHVKHPHÍXWQHPXSUHGPHWX2PRJRÍDLQWHJUDFLMRVWYDULVYHWDYSURVWRUVNRVWODVWQHJD WHOHVD .HU SD MH GHORYDQMH YVHOHM GLQDPLÍQR SD QDP REHQHP RPRJRÍD GD VSRQWDQR ]DJUDELPRVLWXDFLMRLQVHRG]RYHPRYRNYLUXNRRUGLQDWNLMLKSRVWDYOMDWHOHVQDVKHPD QSUYRĤQMDDYWDDOLSOHVYGXHWXNMHUGUXJGUXJHJDYNOMXÍXMHWDYODVWQRWHOHVQRVKHPR LQGRORÍDWDSURVWRUVYRMHJDGHORYDQMD7DNďQDKLSQDLPSURYL]DFLMDMHPRJRÍDOHQDSRG ODJLKDELWXDOQHVWUXNWXUHWHOHVDFRUSVKDELWXHOYNDWHUHPVHVHGLPHQWLUDMRSUHLGHMR}Y PHVRLQNULmGRORÍHQHL]NXďQMHLQVSUHWQRVWLNLVRSRJRMRSWLPDOQHJDGHORYDQMDYVYHWX 6 SRPRÍMR WHOHVQH VKHPH REHQHP ]DMHPDPR }SURVWRUVNRVW VLWXDFLMHm NRW SUDYL 0HU OHDX3RQW\,ELG6LWXDFLMDLQVWYDULYVYHWXVHVXEMHNWXGDMHMRNRWSRGURÍMHPRĤQH JDGHORYDQMDLQGHʳQLUDMRVSHFLʳÍQRVLWXDFLMRNLLPDVYRMHODVWQH]DKWHYHNLSULNOLÍHMR QHN PRGXV RGORÍDQMD LQ RG]LYDQMD /DKNR UHÍHPR GD VLWXDFLMD UD]SUH SROMH YLUWXDOQR PRĤQHJDLQWDNRXVPHUMDQDďHGHORYDQMHQDQDÍLQGDQHNDNRSUHKLWHYDPRVDPLVHEH .HULQWXLWLYQRSULÍDNXMHPRGRORÍHQHVWYDULYVLWXDFLMLNRWSULKDMDMRÍHWRSRPHQLGDMH WXGLYWHOHVQRVKHPRYSLVDQDRGSUWRVWNLYNOMXÍXMHVDPRGHMQRPRGLʳFLUDQMHJOHGHQD GRORÍHQRSROMHPRĤQRVWLLQ]PRĤQRVWDQWLFLSDFLMH7DNRGHORYDQMHYVHOHMĤHLPSOLFLUD ]PRĤQRVWSURMHNFLMHYSULKRGQRVWR]LURPDRGSLUDQMHPRĤQRVWLUD]OLÍQLKQDÍLQRYGHOR YDQMDYHGHQMDNLYYVDNGDQMHPĤLYOMHQMXYYHOLNLPHULSRWHNDL]YHQ]DYHVWQHQDPHUH %HODSDOLFDVNDWHURVLSRPDJDVOHSÍORYHN]DQMQLYHÍREMHNWYVYHWXNDNRUGUXJLREMHNWLWHPYHÍ QMHQDNRQLFDSRVWDQHÍXWLOQRREPRÍMHNLSRYHÍDUD]VHĤQRVWLQUDGLMRWLSD}ÌHVHQDYDGLPRQDNOREXNQDDYWR DOLQDSDOLFRWRSRPHQLGD se vanje namestimo DOLGDMLKYNOMXÍLPRYSURVWRUVNRVWODVWQHJDWHOHVDm0HUOH DX3RQW\ }6XEMHNWYHNMHQDWLSNRYQLFLVRÍUNHWDNRNRWPLYHPRNMHVRQDďLXGLWRSDMHQHNHYUVWHSULXÍHQR ]QDQMHNLQDPQHGDMHSRORĤDMDYREMHNWLYQHPSURVWRUXm0HUOHDX3RQW\6YRMRSRDQWRSUHGVWDYL WXGLQDSULPHUXDYWDSULYRĤQMLNDWHUHJDQDPQLWUHEDHNVSOLFLWQRUD]PLďOMDWLNDMERPRVWRULOLWHNRPYRĤQMHVDM JDXSUDYOMDPRVSRQWDQREUH]WUXGDQSUPHQMDYDPREU]LQH]DYLMDPR]DYLUDPRLQSRVSHďXMHPRLWQ}ÌH]QDP YR]LWLDYWRLQJDXVPHULPYQHNRXOLFRYLGLPGDERP‚ODKNRSULďHOVNR]L‘QHGDELPLELORWUHEDSULPHUMDWLďLULQR XOLFH]YHOLNRVWMRDYWRPRELODLQSUDYWDNRWXGLYVWRSLPYQHNSURVWRUQHGDELYHOLNRVWYUDWSULPHUMDO]YHOLNRVWMR VYRMHJDWHOHVDm$YWRWRUHMVÍDVRPLQWHJULUDPRYQDďR telesno shemo LQGHOXMHNRWSRGDOMďHNWHOHVDSUHN NDWHUHGRORÍDPRODVWQRSURVWRUVNRVWYVYHWXLQ]D]QDYDQMHJOHGHQDGUXJHVWYDUL}SRVWDQHPRHQR]DYWRPm =DVSUHWQRGHORYDQMHLQURNRYDQMHVVWYDUPLQHSRWUHEXMHPRPLVHOQHJDSUHGVWDYOMDQMDVDMLPDPRSUDNWLÍQR XWHOHďHQRYHGQRVW tacit knowledge VHGLPHQWLUDQRR]LURPDVKUDQMHQRYWHOHVXNRWQRVLOFXWHOHVQHVKHPHNL VWUXNWXULUDÍXWLOQRREPRÍMH 3URVWRUYIHQRPHQRORJLMLQLUD]XPOMHQNRWDEVROXWQRXQLYHU]DOQRXQLIRUPQRLQQHVSUHMHPOMLYR SRGURÍMHNRWY1HZWRQRYLNODVLÍQLPHKDQLNLNLMHGDQRQHNHPXUD]UHďHQHPXVXEMHNWXPDUYHÍNRWheterogeni SURVWRUDNDWHUHJDQDVHOMXMHYHGQRĤHVLWXLUDQLQXWHOHďHQVXEMHNW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 143 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 =DYVDNGDQMHVSUHWQRGHORYDQMHLQURNRYDQMHVVWYDUPLQHSRWUHEXMHPRPLVHOQHJDSUHG VWDYOMDQMD2EMHNWDOLRURGMHSRVWDQHVNR]LVSUHWQRGHORYDQMHIHQRPHQRORďNRWUDQVSDU HQWQR NDU SRPHQL GD JD XSRUDEQLN GRĤLYOMD NRW LQWHJUDOQL SRGDOMďHN ODVWQHJD WHOHVD 0LVHOQH]PRĤQRVWLLQSUHGVWDYOMDQMHSDVHQDPDNWLYLUDMROHNRVHQHNRGHORYDQMH]DORPL LQVHSURFHV]DXVWDYLNDNRUSRNDĤHĤH+HLGHJJHUYVYRMLIHQRPHQRORďNLDQDOL]LURNRYDQ MDVVYHWRPYNDWHULORÍLPHG9RUKDQGHQKHLWQDY]RÍQRVWMRLQ=XKDQGHQKHLWSULURÍQRV WMR3HVWURVWLQUD]XPHYDQMHVLWXDFLMHL]KDMDWDL]VDPHVLWXDFLMHLQVLFHUYUD]PHUMXGR WHJDGRNDWHUHPHUHMRVXEMHNWREYODGD7RYHOMDREHQHP]DREMHNWHNLMLKGRMHPDPRY RGYLVQRVWLRGWHJDNDNRGREURVHURNXMHPR]QMLPL.DULNLUDPRÍHKRÍHPRUD]XPHWL NDMMHQSUNODGLYR]DNRYDÍDMHWUHEDSR]QDWLR]LURPDREYODGDWLVDPRREUW'UXJLP]X QDQMLPRSD]RYDOFHPRVWDMDMRPRĤQRVWLXSRUDEHRURGMDLQVWHPQMHJRYSRPHQYYHOLNL PHUL]DNULWL7RUHMMHSRPHQVLWXDFLMHLQREMHNWRYRGYLVHQRGQDďHSR]LFLMHLQNRQWHNVWD Y NDWHULK VH Y]SRVWDYOMD QHNR UD]PHUMH ] QMLPL WHU RG VDPH PRÍL REYODGRYDQMD 7DNR ODKNR+HLGHJJHUMHYRSRMPRYDQMHSULURÍQRVWLȡNRWPRGXVDREMHNWRYNLMHYVHOHMRGYLVHQ GRQHNHJDVNORSDR]LURPDJOREDOQHJDVLVWHPDYNDWHUHPVHYUďLURNRYDQMH]QHNLPRE MHNWRPȡUD]ďLULPRYGUXJRVPHUNRWMRMHXEUDOVDPLQVLFHUVSRXGDUNRPQDVDPHP REMHNWX NL VH Y VYRMLK PRĤQRVWLK GHORYDQMD UD]NULYD VXEMHNWX NL ] QMLP URNXMH 7DNR PRUDPRYURNRYDQMXVVYHWRPYQHNHPR]LUXSUL]QDWLRQWRORďNLSULPDWREMHNWXNLJD ODKNR OH GR QHNH PHUH REYODGDPR V VSR]QDYQLPL PRĤQRVWPL XPD 2EMHNW VH Y VYRMLK ]PRĤQRVWLK UD]NULYD WHOHVQHPX GHORYDQMX LQ URNRYDQMX NL SD QL Y SROQL PHUL ]DYHVW QR 9 WHP VPLVOX ODKNR SULWUGLPR 0HUOHDX3RQW\MX NL Y]WUDMD GD REVWDMD QHND }YHG QRVWmWHOHVDNLY]SRVWDYLSRJRMHUD]NULYDQMDREMHNWRYNRWWDNLKȡNDUVRVDPLQDVHEL NTERSUBJEKTIVNOST SKOZI MEDTELESNOST ,]KRGLďÍH0HUOHDX3RQW\MHYHJDNRQFHSWXDOL]LUDQMDLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQRVWLMH da se NRW OMXGMH YVHOHM ĤH QDMGHPR Y LQWHUVXEMHNWLYQHP VYHWX LQ GD LQWHUDNFLMD PHG VXEMHNWL WHPHOMLQDWHOHVLK7DNRSUDYL 3HWQDMVWPHVHÍQL RWURN RGSUH XVWD ÍH Y LJUL ] ]REPL ]DJUDELP HQHJD RG QMHJRYLK SUVWRY LQ VH GHODP GD JD ERP XJUL]QLO >Ȭ@ 1MHJRYD ODVWQD XVWD LQ ]REMH NDNRU MLK ÍXWL RG ]QRWUDM VR ]DQM ĤH SULSUDYQL ]D JUL]HQMH PHGWHP NR MH PRMD ÍHOMXVW NDNRU MR YLGL RG ]XQDM ]DQM VSRVREQD LVWLK QDNOHSRYȥ8JUL]Į LPD Y QMHJRYLK RÍHK ĤH RG VDPHJD ]DÍHWND LQWHUVXEMHNWLYQL SRPHQ 1MHJRY QDPHQ ]D]QD Y VYRMHP WHOHVX PRMH WHOR ]D]QDYD V VYRMLPVWHPSDYVYRMHPWHOHVX]D]QDYDWXGLPRMHQDPHQH0HUOHDX3RQW\ ģHRGURMVWYDVPRYVWLNXVSRPHPEQLPLGUXJLPLVNDWHULPLVHVSRUD]XPHYDPR QD WHOHVQL UDYQL VDM ďH QLVPR VSRVREQL NRPSOHNVQHMďLK NRJQLWLYQLK RSHUDFLM 3UL WHP QH JUH OH ]D HQRVPHUQR NRPXQLNDFLMR V SRPRÍMR NDWHUH QSU PDWL UD]XPH RWURNRYH SRWUHEHWHPYHÍJUH]DRERMHVWUDQVNR]D]QDYDQMHLQVSR]QDYDQMHWHUXÍHQMHQSUVSH FLʳÍQLK RG]LYRY VNR]L NDWHUH IRUPLUDPR PHGRVHEQH RGQRVH9HQGDU SD WHOHVQRVW NL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 144 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 QDP RPRJRÍD SULPDUQR VRFLDOL]DFLMR QL QHNDM NDU VH NDVQHMH ] UD]YRMHP PLďOMHQMD RGSUDYL PDUYHÍ MH SRJRM YVDNH VRFLDOQH LQWHUDNFLMH LQ VSRUD]XPHYDQMD +HQUL :DOORQ QSU VNR]L UD]LVNRYDQMH NOLQLÍQLK ďWXGLM SDWRORďNLK SULPHURY SRNDĤH GD VR SUL RWUR FLK PRWQMH Y }FHQHVWH]LMLm110 WHVQR SRYH]DQH ] PRWQMDPL v odnosih z drugimi OMXGPL ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYQRVW VDPL UD]XPHPR NRW SURGXNW DIHNWLYQHJD WHOHVD NL QDP RPRJRÍDYĤLYOMDQMHWHURGSUWRVWGRGUXJHJDWHOHVDNLMHSRJRMUHYHU]LELOQRVWLNLMHIXQN FLRQDOQDYQRUPDOQLKVRFLDOQLKLQWHUDNFLMDK3UREOHPQDVWDQHSULNRPXQLFLUDQMXSUHN WHKQRORďNLQDSUDYSULNDWHULKQLSRWUHEQDQHSRVUHGQDWHOHVQDSULVRWQRVW.HUMHWRREVH ĤHQSUREOHPYNDWHUHJDVHQHERPRVSXďÍDOLODKNRL]SRVWDYLPRVDPRGDQSUSVLKRDQD OLWLNL]UD]ORJRPRSR]DUMDMRGDVHPRUDDQDOL]DL]YDMDWLYQHSRVUHGQLWHOHVQLSULVRWQRVWL ȡUD]HQYL]UHGQLKSUHKRGQLKUD]PHUDK 1DďHYVDNGDQMHGHORYDQMHYVRFLDOQHPRNROMX0HUOHDX3RQW\UD]ODJDVSRPRÍMR NRQFHSWDPHGWHOHVQRVWLLQWHUFRUSRU«LW«NLMH]DQMWHPHOMVRFLDOQHNRJQLFLMHLQYĤLYO MDQMD 0HGWHOHVQRVW UD]XPH NRW SUHGUHʴHNVLYQR SUHSOHWDQMH LQ VSRUD]XPHYDQMH WHOHV NMHUWHORGUXJHJDYSOLYDQDQDďHODVWQRWHORQHSRVUHGQREUH]SRVUHGRYDQMDWLPHQWDO QLKUHSUH]HQWDFLMPRGHORYDOLVLPXODFLMQRWUDQMLKVWDQMGUXJLKVXEMHNWRYL]ÍHVDUVOHGL GDMHSRSROQRPDQHSRWUHEQDNDNUďQDNROLNRQFHSWXDOQDDOLRQWRORďNDUHGXNFLMDGUXJLK VXEMHNWRYQDL]ROLUDQHYDVH]DSUWHHQWLWHWH7DQHSRVUHGQRVWVSRUD]XPHYDQMDVHNDĤH YWHPGDLQWHQFHJLEHLQDIHNWHGUXJHJDÍXWLPRYODVWQHPWHOHVX9UD]XPHYDQMHLQ ]D]QDYDQMHGUXJHJDMHWDNRYVHOHMYNOMXÍHQDIHNWL]ÍHVDUL]KDMDGDMHYYVDNLVLPEROQL NRPXQLNDFLMLQDGHOXWXGLWHOHVQDDIHNWLYQRVWNLVHL]UDĤDYSRMDYXYĤLYOMDQMD6OHGQMHQH PRUHPRUD]XPHWLOHNRWNRJQLWLYQRRSHUDFLMRLQWHUSUHWDFLMHWHOHVQLK]QDNRY3UDYWDNR SDVPRYLQWHUDNFLMLYVHOHMREÍXWOMLYLQDVSHFLʳÍQRWHPSRUDOQRVWVNR]LNDWHURGHOXMHGUX JLQSUULWHPGLQDPLNRLQIUHNYHQFRNLVRNRQVWLWXWLYQL]DVDPRNRPXQLNDFLMRLQSRPH QH7XGLYJRYRUQLNRPXQLNDFLMLSRPHQDQHVSRURÍDMROHEHVHGHDPSDNWXGLVORJJRYRUD QDJODVWRQJHVWHLQʳ]LRJQRPLMD=DWRSRJRYRUQRSUDYLPRGD}GUXJHJDÍXWLPRmDOLSD QHNDUVHQDQDďDQDDIHNWNLSRGJUDMXMHUD]XPHYDQMHLQGRORÍDSRPHQQHNHSURSR]LFLM VNHYVHELQH.RWGRND]ODKNRQDYHGHPRRVHEH]PRWQMDPLDYWLVWLÍQHJDVSHNWUDLQRVHEH ]PRWQMDPLVKL]RIUHQHJDVSHNWUDNLLPDMRYHOLNHWH 10 ĤDYHYPHGRVHEQLKRGQRVLKYWHP NDULPHQXMHPRQRUPDOQDVRFLDOQDLQWHUDNFLMDWHUNRPXQLNDFLMD6DPL]DJRYDUMDPRGD MHY]URNQMLKRYLKVLPSWRPRYUDYQRL]JXEDDIHNWLYQHJDWHOHVDNLMHNOMXÍQR]DYVDNRVR FLDOQRLQWHUDNFLMHWHU]DUD]YRMMD]D &HQHVWH]LMDMHVSORďQLREÍXWHNWHOHVQHJDREVWRMDLQQRUPDOQHJDGHORYDQMDRUJDQL]PD Slovenski medicinski slovar 0LUD]XPHPRSRMHPFHQHVWH]LMH]QHNROLNRYHÍMLPSRXGDUNRPQDWHOHVQLKVHQ]DFLMDK R]REÍXWNLKĤLYHJDWHOHVDYNDWHUHMHYNOMXÍHQR]D]QDYDQMHVSHFLʳÍQLKGUDĤOMDMHYQDSRGURÍMXODVWQHJDWHOHVD $IHNWVHQDQDďDQDSUHKRGL]HQHJDGRĤLYOMDMVNHJDVWDQMDR]LURPDVIHUHYGUXJRYVHOHMSDUD]NULYD WHPHOMQR]PRĤQRVWVXEMHNWDGDDʳFLUDLQMHDʳFLUDQVVWUDQLLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQHJDVYHWD 10 0LQNRZVNLLQ7DUJRZODXJRWDYOMDWDGDMHHGHQRGVLPSWRPRYVKL]RIUHQLMHL]JXEDWHPHOMQH VLJXUQRVWLLQVDPRXPHYQRVWLYUHVQLÍQRVWVYHWDWHURGVRWQRVWREÍXWND]DSULSDGQRVWVNXSQHPXLQWHUVXEMHN WLYQHPXVYHWX.RWERPRSRND]DOLVSRGDMELODKNRWHVLPSWRPHSRMDVQLOLUDYQR]L]JXERWHOHVDNRWSRVUHGQLND VYHWDLQVWHPPHGLMDYNOMXÍLWYHYDIHNWLYQRQDELWLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQLSURVWRU Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 145 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 'DOMHODKNRWUGLPRGDPHGWHOHVQRVWYQHNHPR]LUXSUHGKDMDQDďHPX]DYHVW QHPX MD]X R]LURPD MH QMHJRY SRJRM ÌH MH PHGWHOHVQRVW SULPDUQL QDÍLQ ELWL WHOHV WR SRPHQLGDODKNRďHOHQDSRGODJLSULVRWQRVWLLQRGVRWQRVWLGUXJLKWHOHVSULGRELPRQHNR SUHGVWDYRODVWQHWHOHVQRVWLLQVLFHUWDNRGDUD]OLNXMHPRVYRMHODVWQHWHOHVQHREÍXWNH LQ DIHNWH RG GUXJLK 7R UD]OLNRYDQMH SD EL ODKNR ELOR SRJRM URMVWYD MD]D ÌH YNOMXÍLPR /DFDQRYRWHRULMR]UFDOQHJDVWDGLMDPRUDPL]SRVWDYLWL]DQLPLYSRMDYNLJD]DVOHGLPRSUL PDOÍNLKRGďHVWHJDPHVHFDGDOMHLQVLFHUGDPDOÍHNNOMXEďHQHUD]YLWL]PRĤQRVWLKRMH LQSRNRQÍQHGUĤHNRMHSRVWDYOMHQSUHGRJOHGDOR}RWUSQHQDJQMHQQHNROLNRQDSUHMNRW GDELKRWHOʳNVLUDWLQHNLWUHQXWHNSRGREHNLMRYLGLY]UFDOXm/DFDQȡ'R MHQÍNRYRWHORMHQDMSUHMLQWURFHSWLYQRWHORVDMMHYREGREMX]JRGQMHJDRWURďWYDWRHGLQL QDÍLQELWLWHOHVD},GHQWLWHWDmMHQDUDYQLWHOHVDNLMHNRHNVWHQ]LYQRVVYHWRPVDMRWURN ďHQHORÍLPHGODVWQRWHOHVQRVWMRLQWHOHVQRVWMRGUXJLK6OHGQMDJDDʳFLUDQHSRVUHGQR WDNRYSRGURÍMXDIHNWDNRWYHGHQMDIHQRPHQLPLWDFLMH.RVHNDVQHMHQHNMHPHGLQ PHVHFHPPDOÍHNVNR]LRGVHYNLJDIDVFLQLUDLQYNDWHUHJDLQYHVWLUDVYRMOLELGRRYH FHORWQHSRGREHVDPHJDVHEHNLQLOHIUDJPHQWDUHQGHOWHOHVDVHLGHQWLʳFLUDVWRVYR MR SRGRER /DFDQ 7D FHORYLWRVW ]DNOMXÍHQD HQRYLWRVW SD MH LPDJLQDUQD LQ SRY]URÍLQHNDNďQRRGWXMLWHYUD]FHSSULVXEMHNWXNLVYRMHWHORYLGLNRWREMHNWGYRMQLND WHUPHGWHPNDULQWURFHSWLYQRREÍXWLLQ]D]QDYDYSRGURÍMXODVWQHWHOHVQRVWL1HVPH PR SD SR]DELWL QD VLPEROQR RGWXMLWHY NL MR LPDJLQDUQD SULNULYD 2E WHP VH SRVOHGLÍ QR]DYHGDMHWDNRNRWMHYLGHQYRJOHGDOX]DVHNRWSRGREDYLGHQWXGL]DGUXJH3UL WHPLPDNOMXÍQRYORJRSRJOHGSRPHPEQHJDYHOLNHJD'UXJHJDNLSRWUGLDOLOHJLWLPL UDPDOÍNRYRSULSR]QDQMHODVWQHSRGREH11 LQVWHPRPRJRÍLQMHJRYRVDPR]DYHGDQMH 6OHGQMHSDLPSOLFLUDQHNRQHPRÍLQL]JXERDYWRQRPLMHHGLQVWYHQRVWLLQVXYHUHQRVWLWHU RGWXMHQRVW RG ODVWQH ELWL 7DNR PDOÍHN QLPD YHÍ QHSRVUHGQHJD RGQRVD GR ODVWQH ELWL R]LURPD MH ELO WD QHSRVUHGQL RGQRV UHWURDNWLYQR NRQVWUXLUDQ LQ QDP SUHGVWDYOMD IDQ WD]LMR SR L]YRUQL HQRWQRVWL FHORYLWRVWL LQ WUDQVSDUHQWQRVWL SR NDWHUL ERPR KUHSHQHOL GRNRQFDĤLYOMHQMDNRW1DUFLV7RUHMMHYIXQNFLMLGHUHDOL]DFLMHLQUD]VUHGLďÍHQMDQDďH JDPHVWDYVYHWXLQVLFHUVWHPGDVSORKY]SRVWDYLUD]OLNRPHG}]XQDQMRVWMRmREMHN WLYQLP VYHWRP LQ }QRWUDQMRVWMRm VXEMHNWLYQR SHUVSHNWLYR V NDWHUH ]D]QDYDPR VYHW 7RUHM]YLGLNDSVLKRDQDOL]HQDďDODVWQDWHOHVQRVWQLQHNDMNDUQDPMHGDQRQH SRVUHGQRPDUYHÍMHYVHOHMĤHSRVUHGRYDQRVNR]LVLPEROQLUHJLVWHU6LPEROQRYVHOHMĤH ]DUHĤHLQSUHVHNDQDďRODVWQRWHOHVQRVW 11 6XEMHNW]DGRELYSUHSR]QDQMXQDUFLVWLÍQHSRGREHRSRUR]DmeconnaissanceNLMHSRVYRMHPELVWYX QDSDÍQRSUHSR]QDQMHLQQHQHYHGQRVWLJQRUQFD-D]NLVHÍXWLHGLQVWYHQDYWRQRPHQLQQHRGYLVHQMHSUR GXNWQHSUHVWDQHmeconnaissance /DFDQ7DLGHDOL]DFLMDLQL]RODFLMDNLMRL]YDMD]DYHVWMHQHNDNďQR QDSDÍQRSUHSR]QDYDQMHSRJRMHYVWUXNWXUQHNRQVWLWXFLMHODVWQRVWLVWYDULNLVRYH]DQHQDVXEMHNW.RWVXEMHNWL VHQHSRVUHGQRQH]DYHGDPRNDNRVPRGHWHUPLQLUDQLVVWUDQLGUXĤEHNXOWXUHMH]LNDGLVNXU]DLQQH]DYHGQH JD9HQGDUSDMHSRJRMmeconnaissance UDYQRQHNDYHGQRVWRNROLNDWHUHVHRUJDQL]LUDQDSDÍQRSUHSR]QDQMH Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 146 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 ÌHVHYUQHPRQDNRQFHSWSULPDUQHPHGWHOHVQRVWLNLMHNRWVPRUD]YLOL]JR UDMSRJRMREÍXWNDODVWQHWHOHVQRVWLVHODKNRYSUDďDPRNDNRMHPRĤQRGDVRODKNRĤH ]HORPDMKQLRWURFLR]LURPDGRMHQÍNL 12 WDNRREÍXWOMLYLQDREUD]QRPLPLNRNLL]UDĤDQHND ÍXVWYDQSUQDVPHKDOLVWUDK0DOÍHNSULSHWQDMVWLKPHVHFLKďHQLVSRVREHQRSUDYOMD WLNRPSOHNVQLKSURFHVRYLQQDORJNRWMHGHďLIULUDQMHUHNRQVWUXNFLMDWHUSUHGVWDYOMDQMH YHGHQMVNLK ]QDNRY GUXJLK VXEMHNWRY DOL SULPHUMDQMH SR DQDORJLML V VYRMLP ODVWQLP YH GHQMHPR]LURPD]ODVWQRREUD]QRPLPLNRÌHRWURN]DÍQHLGHQWLʳFLUDWLVHEHLQGUXJHJD NRW DQLPLUDQR WHOR MH WR ]DWR NHU WHOR NRW WDNR JOREDOQR LGHQWLʳFLUD WM FHORYLWR WUGL 0HUOHDX3RQW\9HQGDUSD/DFDQRYDWHRULMD]UFDOQHJDVWDGLMDNRWVPRYLGHOLWR]DYUDÍD *OREDOQD LGHQWLʳNDFLMD MH WDNR VDPR QD UDYQL LPDJLQDUQHJD UHJLVWUD LQ NRW WDND ]DYD MDÌHSUDYSRHQLVWUDQLRPRJRÍDLGHQWLʳNDFLMRQDVSRGUXJLVWUDQL]DYVHOHMRGUHĤHRG ODVWQHJDWHOHVD7DNRXÍLQNXMHVLPEROQLUHG.OMXEWHPXSDWRQHPRUHVSRGELMDWLGUXJLK XJRWRYLWHY NL L]KDMDMR L] UD]XPHYDQMD YORJH PHGWHOHVQRVWL Y VRFLDOQLK LQWHUDNFLMDK ÌHVLQWHWL]LUDPRWLVWRNDUSRYH]XMHQDďRWHOHVQRVWLQWHORGUXJHJDMHSULPDUQR QRWUDQMLRGQRVWHOHVQRVWLNLSDJDODKNRPLVOLPRNRWSURGXNWGHORYDQMDWHOHVQHVKHPH 7DQLDNWLYQDVDPRSULURNRYDQMX]REMHNWLPDUYHÍWXGLYLQWHUDNFLML]GUXJLPLVXEMHN WLWHOHVL6KHPDGHOXMHNRWNRUHODFLMDPHG]DYHGDQMHPVYRMHJDODVWQHJDWHOHVDLQ]D] QDYDQMHPGUXJLKVXEMHNWRY'HMDYQRVWGUXJHJDQDJRYDUMDQDďHODVWQRWHORVDMMHYVDNR YHGHQMHGUXJHJDSRWHQFLDOQRQDďHODVWQRYHGHQMH=D]QDYDQMHSRWHNDNRWNRPSOHPHQWD UQDRSHUDFLMDWDNRGDGRĤLYOMDQMHVYRMHJDODVWQHJDWHOHVDLQWHOHVDGUXJHJDWYRULFHORWRLQ NRQVWLWXLUDQHNR}IRUPRmWHOHVQRVWLȡNDUPLVOLPRGDMHNOMXÍHQXYLGQDSRGODJLNDWHUH JDER%RXUGLHXUD]YLOVYRMSRMHPKDELWXVDȡÍHSUDYMHYUHVQLFLWDFHORWDYVHOHMSUHVHND QDLQRKUDQMDUD]OLNRYDQMHPHGWHOHVL7HOHVQDVKHPDMHSRVYRMHPELVWYXGLQDPLÍQDLQ GHOXMHSR]DNRQXQRWUDQMHJDUDYQRYHVMDNRWDYWRRUJDQL]DFLMHWHUUHODWLYQHXVNODMHQRVWL ]GUXJLPLWHOHVLLQWHOHVQLPLVKHPDPL7HOHVQDVKHPDVHWRUHMODKNRUD]ďLULLQREOLNX MH WHU VH SUHQHVH QD GUXJH VXEMHNWH LQ FHOR QD PHKDQVNH VWURMH DOL WHKQLÍQH QDSUDYH QSU YR]LOD DOL NLEHUQHWVNL SURVWRU Y NDWHUHP NUPDULPR V SRPRÍMR LJUDOQLK NRQ]RO 12 9UD]YRMQLSVLKRORJLMLVHXSRUDEOMDR]QDÍED]DUD]YRMQRREGREMHNLWUDMDRGGRPHVHFHY]D GRMHQÍNRYRRGGROHWDSD]DPDOÍNRYRREGREMH .RJQLWLYQL]QDQVWYHQLNLY]DGQMLKGHVHWOHWMLKXJRWDYOMDMRGDMHWUHEDXSRďWHYDWLRVUHGQMHPHVWRWH OHVDY]D]QDYQHPL]NXVWYXVDMĤLYDELWMDQHGHOXMHPRLQVHQHRG]LYDPRYRNROMXQDQDÍLQSURJUDPLUDQLKSUDYLO DOLSDVLYQHJDUHʴHNVQHJDYHGHQMDWHPYHÍQDL]YLUHQQDÍLQLQVLFHUJOHGHQDSDUDPHWUHNLVWUXNWXULUDMRFHORWQR VLWXDFLMRYNDWHULVH]QDMGHPR.HUWHORQL]DSUWREMHNWDPSDNMHSUHNWHOHVQHVKHPHRGSUWRYVYHWVPRWDNR RGSUWLUD]OLÍQLPVYHWRYRPDSDUDWRPLQWHKQRORJLMDPNLMLKODKNRLQWHJULUDPRLQYNRPSRQLUDPRYQDďRODVWQR SURVWRUVNRVW7XGLQDYLGH]QDUHVQLÍQRVWNLMHREOLNDUDÍXQDOQLďNHVLPXODFLMHSULNDWHULVHXGHOHĤHQHFQDKDMD YYLUWXDOQHP'RNROMXODKNRWXGLQDGDOMDYRȡ}WHOHSUHVHQFHm]DKWHYDYNOMXÍLWHYSRGDWNRYQLKURNDYLFGD WDJORYHV'RÍDOÍHODGHREOHNLWGYQDďHIHQRPHQDOQRWHOHVQRSROMHLQLQWHJUDFLMRVÍORYHNRYRSHUFHSFLMR 7DNďQHYUVWHWHKQRORJLMRELODKNRYSULKRGQRVWLďHEROML]SRSROQLOLLQL]EROMďDOLGDELMRODKNREROMXÍLQNRYLWR XSRUDEOMDOLȡQSUYYRMDďNHQDPHQH]DNLUXUďNRXUMHQMH]DXÍHQMHUD]QLKVSUHWQRVWLSULNUPLOMHQMXVWURMHY QDYLJLUDQMXYR]LOLQURERWRYKRORJUDIVNLKVWURMHYR]KRORJUDʳMLLWQ1DYLGH]QDR]YLUWXDOQDUHVQLÍQRVWQH PRUHELWLVDPRXPVNDGHMDYQRVWVDMQDJRYDUMDFHORWQHJDÍORYHNDLQQMHJRYRL]NXVWYRVYHWDSHUFHSFLMRWHU XVWYDUMDOQRGHORYDQMHLQ]QDMGHQMHYSURVWRUXSUHNDNWLYQHJD]D]QDYDQMD)HQRPHQRORďNRUD]LVNRYDQMHQD SRGURÍMXNLQHVWH]LMHR]LURPDNLQHVWHWLNHLQVHQ]RULÍQRPRWRULÍQLKIXQNFLMMHWDNRNOMXÍQR]DQDGDOMQMLUD]YRM QRYLKWHKQRORJLMLQQMLKRYHJDYNOMXÍHYDQMDYÍORYHďNRWHOHVQRVWLQVYHW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 147 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 MAUSSOVE TEHNIKE TELESA IN BOURDIEUJEV HABITUS =DUDGL YSOLYD ]QDQRVWL WHOR VSRQWDQR UD]XPHPR VNR]L SUL]PR QDUDYRVORY QH PHWRGRORJLMH V NDWHUR VR YVL GUXĤEHQL NXOWXUQL SRPHQL RGVWUDQMHQL 7DNR GRELPR VWHULOL]LUDQR LQ DEVWUDKLUDQR JROR WHOR Körper NL GHOXMH SR PHKDQLFLVWLÍQLK ]DNRQLK 2EUDWQR MH ]D %RXUGLHXMD LQ 0DXVVD WHOR MH YVHOHM GUXĤEHQR WHOR QRVLOHF KDELWXVD LQ GUXĤEHQLK NRGRY 0DUFHO 0DXVV MH UD]LVNRYDO QDÍLQH NDNR OMXGMH Y UD]OLÍQLK GUXĤEDK LQNXOWXUDKXSRUDEOMDPRVYRMDWHOHVD9UD]OLÍQLKNXOWXUDKMHRSD]LOVSHFLʳÍQHWHKQLNH WHOHVDQDÍLQGUĤHKUDQMHQMDSLWMDURMHYDQMDY]JRMHGRMHQMDQRďHQMDRWURNWHUQDÍLQ NDNR WL SRVOXďDMR NDM YLGLMR LQ QD NDM PRUDMR ELWL SR]RUQL LSG 2PHQMD WXGL PDQLUH ULWPHLQIRUPHJLEDQMDQDÍLQHGLKDQMDSRÍLYDQMDOHĤHVHGHYSRÍHSXDNWLYQLSRÍLWHN QSUSOHVLWQWHKQLNHVSDQMDUD]OLÍQLSULSRPRÍNLVNXSDM]GUXJLPLVSDQMHVWRMHQSU SUL 0DVDMLK1 WHKQLNH KRMH RSLVXMH QSU NDNR EULWDQVND SHKRWD NRUDND ] GUXJDÍQLP NRUDNRPLQIUHNYHQFRNRUDNDQMDRGIUDQFRVNHWHKQLNHSODYDQMDSRWDSOMDQMDSRORĤDMD URNYPLURYDQMX]DPL]RLQPHGKRMRNLMLKREÍXWLPRNRW}QDUDYQHmWHKQLNHWHNDSOHVD QSUSOHVYSDUWQHUMHYHPQDURÍMXMHL]XPVRGREQHHYURSVNHFLYLOL]DFLMHWHKQLNHLJUDQMD QDJODVELODQDÍLQGUĤDQMDNR]DUFDWHKQLNHQHJHWHOHVDWHKQLNHNDďOMDQMDLQSOMXYDQMD VSROQHWHKQLNHNDMNDUDNWHUL]LUDQRUPDOQDLQSDWRORďNDYHGHQMDNDUMHWHVQRSRYH]DQR] PRUDORLQRELÍDMLWHUSULÍDNRYDQDYHGHQMDYVSHFLʳÍQLKVLWXDFLMDKQSUQHSUHPLÍQRVWU PHQMHNRW]QDNYOMXGQRVWLYYRMVNLYYVDNGDQMHPĤLYOMHQMXSDMHGRMHWRNRWQHVUDPQRVW DOLFHORDJUHVLYQRVW9VDNDNXOWXUDLPDWDNRVYRMVSHFLʳÍHQRGQRVGRWHOHVDNDUSRPHQL GDMHKDELWXDOQDVWUXNWXUDWHOHVDVRFLDOQHQDUDYHLQ]DMHPDSULGREOMHQHVSRVREQRVWLQD YDGHLQ]PRĤQRVWLNLVHUD]OLNXMHMRPHGGUXĤEDPLLQGUXĤEHQLPLUD]UHGLWHUWDNRIRUPLUD R]LURPDQXGLHOHPHQWHQHNLLGHQWLWHWL %RXUGLHXWHKQLNHWHOHVD]DMDPHVNRQFHSWRP habitus 1DQMHJRYUD]YRMNRQFHSWD VWDNOMXÍQRYSOLYDODUDYQR0DXVVLQ0HUOHDX3RQW\+DELWXVMHVRFLDOL]LUDQRVWUXNWXULUD QRWHORNLMHYDVHLQNRUSRULUDORLPDQHQWQHVWUXNWXUHQHNHJDVYHWD%RXUGLHX $YWRUQHUD]ORĤLPHKDQL]PDNLMHRGJRYRUHQ]D}LQNRUSRUDFLMRmUD]YLGQRSDMHGDPHQL GDVHVNR]LWHOHVQRDNWLYQRVWL]UDĤDMRVWUXNWXUHGUXĤEHQLKSUDNVLQVYHWRY+DELWXV]D MHPDVNXSHNSRGHGRYDQLKLQLQWHUQDOL]LUDQLKQDYDGVSUHWQRVWLGUXĤEHQRLQVWLWXLUDQLK GLVSR]LFLMVORJRYYHGHQMJRYRUDQDJQMHQMNLMLKVWUXNWXULUDMRGUXĤEHQLSRJRML3RVDPH] QLNRYDWHOHVQRVWVHWDNRIRUPLUDVNR]LVRFLDOQRLQWHUDNFLMRLQPDWHULDOQHSUDNVHNLREH QHPREOLNXMHMRLQVWUXNWXULUDMRQDďHNRJQLWLYQHVKHPHLQ]QMLPLSHUFHSFLMRNODVLʳNDFL MHREÍXWNHVRGEHQDÍLQHNDWHJRUL]LUDQMDYUHGQRWHQMDSUHIHUHQFHWHQGHQFHLQVWDOLďÍD }7DNRFHORWQRQLORWVNR$IULNRLQGHOUHJLMH5HSXEOLNHÌDGYVHGR7DQJDQMLNHQDVHOMXMHMROMXGMHNLSR ÍLYDMRQDSROMLKNRWďWRUNOMH1HNDWHULPXVSHSRÍLYDWLQDHQLQRJLEUH]SDOLFHGUXJLVHQDVORQLMRQDSDOLFRm0DXVV Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 148 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 6DPSURFHVSULGRELYDQMDQDYDGLQXÍHQMDSRWHNDEUH]]DYHVWQHQDPHUHLQJD GRĤLYOMDPRNRWVDPRXPHYQHJDGRPDÍHJD7DNRVHY]DMHPQRIRUPLUDWDLQVRXÍLQNXMH WDHQDQDGUXJRWDNRQDďDLGHQWLWHWDNRWWHOHVQRVW3RVOHGLÍQRSRVWDQHSUREOHPDWLÍQR NODVLÍQRUD]OLNRYDQMHPHGXPRPGXďHYQRVWMRLQWHOHVRPNLMHWHPHOMLORQDRQWRORďNHP UD]OLNRYDQMXPHGPDWHULDOQRLQGXKRYQRVXEVWDQFR7HORLQXPNDWHUHJDJODYQDIXQN FLMDMHYVSR]QDYQLVSRVREQRVWLVLQLVWDHQRVWDYQRSRSROQRPDORÍHQDLQQDVSURWQDDP SDNVWDVRRGYLVQDLQVHVRNRQVWUXLUDWDWDNRGDQMXQHLQGLYLGXDOQH]PRĤQRVWLYSOLYDMR GUXJDQDGUXJR5HJLVWHUNRJQLFLMHWDNRYSOLYDQDWHOHVQRVWĤHVWHPGDODKNRXVPHUMD QHNRGHORYDQMHNLMRSRGYSOLYRPL]NXďHQMIRUPLUDMRR]LURPDUHIRUPLUDMR3UDYWDNRSD MHVDPRPLďOMHQMHLQVSR]QDYDQMHYQHNLPHULRGYLVQRRGKDELWXDOQHJDWHOHVDR]LURPD KDELWXVDNLXVPHUMDYVDNGDQMHVSRQWDQRGHORYDQMHYVYHWXLQMHSRJRM]DQM ,]WHJDVOHGLGDVLKDELWXVRELÍDMQRGHOLMROMXGMHVSRGREQLPSRUHNORPGUXĤ EHQLPUD]UHGRPUHOLJLMRHWQLÍQRVWMRQDFLRQDOQRVWMRL]REUD]ER1DQMHJRYLSRGODJLVH tako reproducirajo tudi GUXĤEHQHVWUXNWXUHLQUD]PHUMD 6OHGQMHVHOHJLWLPLUDMRVSRPRÍMR UHĤLPRYUHVQLFNLY]SRVWDYOMDMRSROMDUD]ORÍHYDQMDLQVWHPKLHUDUKLMHNLMLKLPDPR]D VDPRXPHYQH+DELWXVLPDQDVLQQHPLQMHJDWUGL%RXUGLHX%RUGLHX1DYDG QRQHGHOXMHQDQLYRMXUHʴHNVLYQHJDPLďOMHQMDPDUYHÍQDQLYRMXWHOHVQHJDGHORYDQM SUDNVQDYDGLQGLVNXU]D1 7UHEDMHRSR]RULWLGDWRQHSRPHQLGDVPRYVHOHMREVRMHQLQD NRQIRUPL]HPDOL]DYHVWQRQH]PRĤQRVWXSRUDSURWLQHNHPXXVWDOMHQHPXUHGXPDUYHÍ SRMDVQMXMHXVWDOMHQHLQQDXÍHQHQDÍLQHVSRQWDQHJDGHORYDQMDWHURG]LYDQMDYVSHFLʳÍQLK VLWXDFLMDK+DELWXV]DMHPDWXGLVWLOHSULMDWHOMVWHYQDÍLQHOMXEH]QLREÍXWHNQXMQRVWLYVL WXDFLMLREÍXWHNRGJRYRUQRVWLLQGROĤQRVWLREÍXWHN]DWRNDMMHYUHGQRHVWHWLÍQLREÍXWHN LQYNRQÍQLID]LWXGLQHNVYHWRYQLQD]RUDOLVWLOĤLYOMHQMD,ELGQSUVWRLFL]HPNLVH XGHMDQMDVNR]LSUDNVHLQVWHPREOLNXMHWXGLWHKQLNHWHOHVD Telesni hexis ȡ NDNRU MH GLVSR]LFLMDP UHNHO $ULVWRWHO ȡ RGJRYDUMD PRWRULÍ QLP LQ NLQHVWHWLÍQLP IXQNFLMDP Y]RUFHP JLERY JHVW LQ GUĤH L]UD]RY LQ PLPLNL RE UD]D QDJQMHQRVWL JODYH QDÍLQX VHGHQMD LQ XSRUDEH SULSRPRÍNRY WRQX JODVX VOR JX JRYRUD QDÍLQX ]DSHOMHYDQMD LWG 7H SULGREOMHQH LQ XVYRMHQH GLVSR]LFLMH VR WDNR LQGLYLGXDOQH NRW GUXĤEHQH R]LURPD VLVWHPDWLÍQR SULGREOMHQH SUHN LPLWDFLMH LQ Y]JR MH LVWL WLS JLEDQMD LQ GUĤH NRW VWDUďL LPDMR QSU WXGL QMLKRYL RWURFL LQ VRURMHQFL 7DNR REVWDMDMR FHORWQL VLVWHPL WHOHVQLK WHKQLN LQ GHORYDQMD NL VR SUHJQHWHQL ] LGHROR ďNLP GUXĤEHQLP SRPHQRP LQ YUHGQRWDPL NL L]KDMDMR L] VSHFLʳÍQHJD RNROMD %RXU GLHX ,ELG SROHJ WHJD RSR]DUMD GD GHMVWYR GD ODKNR NRJQLWLYQH VKHPH SUHKDMD MRL]SUDNVHYSUDNVRQHGDELďOHVNR]LGLVNXU]DOL]DYHVWQRXÍHQMHďHQHSRPHQLGD VH SULGRELYDQMH KDELWXVD JRGL QD QDÍLQ PHKDQLÍQHJD XÍHQMD V SRVNXVL LQ QDSDNDPL 7XNDMVHQDPVDPDYVLOMXMHY]SRUHGQLFDPHGNRQFHSWRPKDELWXVDLQ:LWWJHQVWHLQRYLPSRMPRP } IRUPHĤLYOMHQMDm Lebensform Filozofske raziskave § 7RVLSUDYWDNRGHOLPR]GUXJLPLLQGRORÍD SRPHQEHVHGYQHNHPNRQWHNVWXÍHSUDYMHMH]LNQDUDYQL]QDNDODKNRHQDN Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 149 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 7DNďQRPHWRGRXSRUDEOMDPRUDYQRNRQDPMHQHNDDNWLYQRVWWXMDQRYD9HQ GDUSDPRUDPRRSR]RULWLGDWRQHELELORPRĤQRÍHQHELSRVHGRYDOLXQLYHU]DOQLKORJLÍ QLK]PRĤQRVWLVNOHSDQMDNLQDPRPRJRÍDMRJHQHUDOL]DFLMRLQVSRVREQRVWLDVRFLLUDQMD SRYH]RYDQMD7RUHMREVWDMDQHNDNďQDSRGHGRYDQDYHGQRVWGHORYDQMDNLSUHKDMDL]SUDNVH YSUDNVRQHGDELďODVNR]L]DYHVWQRGLVNXU]LYQRXÍHQMHPDUYHÍJUHVNR]LDYWRPDWLÍ QR VSRQWDQR LPLWDFLMR 7R MH HGHQ RG UD]ORJRY ]DNDM MH NRQFHSW KDELWXVD Y UD]PHUMX ] PDWHULDOQLPL SUDNVDPL LQ IRUPLUDQMHP VSHFLʳÍQHJD VSR]QDYQHJD QDJQMHQMD ďH NDNR UHOHYDQWHQLQSRPHPEHQ 3UHNWDNďQHLPSOLFLWQHSHGDJRJLNHVHSUDYWDNRSUHQDďDMRSUHIHUHQFHWHQGHQFH LQ SUHGGLVSR]LFLMH REÍXWHN ]D UHDJLUDQMH LQ GHORYDQMH Y QHNL VPHUL WHU GLVSR]LFLMH ]D ]D]QDYDQMHYUHGQRWHQMHLQUD]XPHYDQMHVYHWDNLYGREUďQLPHULSRJRMXMHMRRG]LYDQMH LQGHORYDQMHYVSHFLʳÍQLKVLWXDFLMDKLQLQWHUDNFLMDK,QGLYLGXDOQRLQNROHNWLYQRWHOHVQR LQXPQRVRWXNDMQHORÍOMLYRSUHSOHWHQL1DSULPHUWLVWRNDUSUHIHULUDPRLQGRĤLYOMDPR NRWQDďODVWQLRNXVNLL]YLUDL]VDPHJDRUJDQL]PDNDMQDPSULMDLQNDMQHMHWDNRYYHOLNL PHULSULXÍHQR/DKNRSDGRGDPRGDVHQDMYHÍQDXÍLPRRGWLVWLKSRPHPEQLGUXJLKV NDWHULPLVHLGHQWLʳFLUDPRLQWDNRY]SRVWDYLPRPRÍQHMďROLELGLQDOQRYH]LQLQYHVWLFLMR +DELWXVDWRUHMQHPRUHPRHQDÍLWL]HNVSOLFLWQLPLPRUDOQLPLSUDYLOLNRGHNVLDOL NRGLREQDďDQMDNLVRQDPSRVUHGRYDQLSUHNRMH]LNDÍHSUDYVHPHGVHERMQRSRGSLUDMRLQ GRSROQMXMHMR1DQHNQDÍLQSUHVHJDSUDYQLLQPRUDOQLUHGDPSDNJDREHQHPWXGLYNOMX ÍXMH=DGHORYDQMHLQIXQNFLRQLUDQMHGUXĤEHVRWRUHMELVWYHQHJDSRPHQDWDNRHNVSOLFLWQR DUWLNXOLUDQDSUDYQDLQPRUDOQDSUDYLODWHU]DNRQLNRWQDÍLQLGUĤHLQREQDďDQMHNLQLVR IRUPDOL]LUDQLLQHNVSOLFLWQRSRVWDYOMHQLR]LURPDGHʳQLUDQL %RXUGLHXMHYDʳOR]RʳMDGHORYDQMDNLMLSUDYLWXGLGLVSR]LFLRQDOQDWDNR}UD]LVNX MHSRWHQFLDOHYSLVDQHYNRUSXVDJHQVRY1 LQYVWUXNWXURVLWXDFLMYNDWHULKGHOXMHMRR]LUR PDQDWDQÍQHMHYQMLKRYRUD]PHUMHm%RUGLHX3ULWHPMHNOMXÍQRUD]PHUMHPHG REMHNWLYQLPL VWUXNWXUDPL GUXĤEHQHJD SROMD LQ LQNRUSRULUDQLPL VWUXNWXUDPL KDELWXVD 'UXĤEHQDSROMD VRSRGURÍMDGUXĤEHQLKSUDNVYNDWHUHPGHOXMHMRVXEMHNWL6RIXQNFLRQDO QRLQVRFLDOQRGLIHUHQFLUDQDLQLPDMRVYRMDODVWQDSUDYLODLQORJLNRȡORJLNRSUDNVH1DďD ĤLYOMHQMDQDMELWDNRELODSRJRMHQDVSRORĤDMHPYSROMX3ROMDVRQHNDNďQLSURVWRULLJUHLQ LPDMRVYRMRODVWQRDYWRQRPLMRWHUGHWHUPLQLUDMRVWUXNWXURREMHNWLYQLKUD]PHULM,JUHSD VRDUELWUDUQHGUXĤEHQHNRQVWUXNFLMHLQGHOXMHMRYKHWHURJHQHPGUXĤEHQHPSURVWRUX9 QMLKVRXVSHďQLWLVWLNLLPDMRVSHFLʳÍQHNRQʳJXUDFLMHUD]OLÍQLKYUVWNDSLWDODNLQDMEROM RGUDĤDMR]DKWHYHQHNHJDXVWDOMHQHJDGUXĤEHQHJDUHGD7H]DKWHYHVRYVHOHMWDNRDOLGUX JDÍHGLVNULPLQDWRUQHWHUSULYLOHJLUDMRQHNWLSGHORYDQMDLQPLďOMHQMD'UXĤEHQLVYHWSDMH YNRQÍQLID]LVNXSHNUD]OLÍQLKSROMNLGHOXMHMRY]DMHPQRLQVRUD]SRUHMHQDKLHUDUKLÍQR %RXUGLHXVXEMHNWHLPHQXMH agensi VDMVHOMXGMHYHÍLQRPDQH]DYHGDPRREMHNWLYQLKSRJRMHYNLYHOLNR NUDWXVPHUMDMRLQGRORÍDMRQDďQDÍLQĤLYOMHQMD7DNRSUDYL}$NWHUQLFHOVXEMHNWVYRMH praxis. m%RUGLHX Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 150 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 SKLEP =DQDVMHELVWYHQHJDSRPHQDXJRWRYLWHYGDIRUPLUDQMHWHOHVDVRYSDGDVNRJQL WLYQLPVWUXNWXULUDQMHPVYHWDRERMHSDVHJRGLVNR]LPDWHULDOQHSUDNVH.HUVHQDYDGQR QHSRGUHMDPR]DYHVWQRYQHNGUXĤEHQLLQLGHRORďNLUHGDPSDNGHOXMHPRYQHNLVPHUL NL QDP MH EOL]X QDP XJDMD OHĤL MH WUHED Y GUXĤEHQLK LQ SROLWLÍQLK DQDOL]DK ELWL PHG GUXJLPSR]RUHQWXGLQDWDDVSHNWVRFLDOQLKLQWHUDNFLM7DNRMHWUHEDXSRďWHYDWLREHSODWL GUXĤEHQHGLQDPLNHLQVLFHU sistemsko NDUSRPHQLGDGHORYDQMHSRVDPH]QLNRYLQQMLK RYHLQWHUDNFLMHYHGQRSRWHNDMRYGRORÍHQLKVWUXNWXUDOQLKLQVWLWXFLRQDOQLKLQSRGREQLK kontekstih, ter telesno-afektivno NLQHSRVUHGQRXVPHUMDLQGRORÍDVRFLDOQHLQWHUDNFLMH LQVSRUD]XPHYDQMHÌHSUDYQLNMHUQHPRUHPR}YLGHWLmIRUPHWHOHVQRVWLNLGRORÍD QDÍLQ PHGRVHEQLK LQWHUDNFLM LQ RGQRVRY ODKNR SRYVRG YLGHYDPR QMHQH XÍLQNH ,Q Y WHP MH QDďDVWDYDPDWHULDOQRVWKDELWXVDWHOHVQHVKHPHLQIRUPRWHOHVQRVWLMHPRĤQRREÍXWLWL VDMSURL]YDMDXÍLQNHÍHSUDYQLPDQLNDNUďQHQHSRVUHGQHSR]LWLYQHHPSLULÍQHHNVLVWHQFH $IHNWLWHOHVD]DQDVQLVRQHNDNďQLVHNXQGDUQLSURL]YRGXPDQSUNRQHNRVLWX DFLMRDOLGHMDYQRVWDQDOL]LUDPRVSR]QDYDPRY]QLNQHMRREHQHPDIHNWLNLGDMRPLďOMHQMX QHNRYUHGQRVWQRRFHQRGRORÍLWHYDPSDNVRYVHOHMNRQVWLWXWLYQL]DVDPRVSR]QDYDQMH LQPLďOMHQMHWDNRGDJDGRQHNHPHUHXVPHUMDMRLQGRORÍDMR.RWSULPHUODKNRQDYHGHPR ]DOMXEOMHQRVWNLVHMHQHRYHPRWDNRGDQDMSUHMSRPLVOLPRLQXJRWRYLPRGDVPR]DO MXEOMHQLPDUYHÍWDNRGDVHYHGHPRLQRG]LYDPRQDQHNQDÍLQNLJDSRJRMXMHVDPDIHNW .RPDMNDVQHMHLQSRVUHGQRSUHNRVYRMHJDRG]LYDQMDLQYHGHQMDVHQDPUD]NULMHR]LURPD VH RYHPR GD VPR ]DOMXEOMHQL $IHNWL WHOHVD WDNR GR QHNH PHUH XVPHUMDMR GHORYDQMH Y svetu in sam QDÍLQ NDNRGHOXMHPRWHUVRNRWWDNL QHORÍOMLYLRGYUHGQRWHQMDLQVSR]QDYDQMD .RW VPR SRND]DOL V SRPRÍMR 0HUOHDX3RQW\MD MH QDďH WHOR ] GUXJLPL WHOH VL NRHNVWHQ]LYQR LQ SUHSOHWHQR WHOHVD VH WRUHM Y]DMHPQR VRNRQVWLWXLUDMR 'UXJL QDV SUHVHNDLQQLHQRVWDYQRUDGLNDOQRGUXJL0HGQDPLLQGUXJLPL ni niti fuzije niti popolne ORÍHQRVWL VDM VH MD] LQ GUXJL YVHOHM VHNDWD Y]YUDWQR SUHSOHWDWD DʳFLUDWD ÍHSUDY VWD Y WHPHOMQL RQWRORďNL QHVLPHWULML 7DNR VH Y VRFLDOQL LQWHUDNFLML MD] LQ GUXJL VRGRORÍDWD YHQGDUNOMXEWHPXRKUDQMDWDELVWYHQRGLYHUJHQFRLQVLQJXODUQRVW7HOHVQRVWLQÍXWQRVW GUXJHJDQDV]DGHYDWDQHSRVUHGQR9YVDNGDQMHPĤLYOMHQMXYVLSR]QDPRIHQRPHQ}QD OH]OMLYRVWLmSULNDWHUHPJUH]DWRGDVLVNRUDMQHPRUHPRSRPDJDWLGDVHQHQDOH]H PRQHNDWHULKÍXVWHYDOLYHGHQMDGUXJHJD/DKNRL]SRVWDYLPRSULPHUHNRWVR]HKDQMH ]DUGHYDQMHVWUDKMRNDOLSDVPHMDQMHQSUNRVSRQWDQRQDOHWLPRQDQDVPHMDQREUD] ]DÍXWLPRGDPLďLFHRNROLQDďLKXVWQDUHGLMRHQDNREUD]QLL]UD]ÍHWXGLVHGHMDQVNRQH QDVPHKQHPRSUREOHPLREVWDMDMRSULRVHEDK]PRWQMDPLDYWLVWLÍQHJDVSHNWUDNLLPDMR RNUQMHQR VRFLDOQR SHUFHSFLMR NDU EL ODKNR UD]ORĤLOL WDNR GD MLP umanjka ravno ta te-meljna telesna afekcija, NL QDP QXGL SRGODJR QD NDWHUL VH VSRUD]XPHYDPR ] GUXJLPL Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 151 27. 10. 2022 11:16:23 1MLKRYDNRPXQLNDFLMDWHPHOMLQDUDFLRQDOQHP}REMHNWLYQHPPLďOMHQMXmLQSRVWRSQL LQGXNFLML1DYDGQLPOMXGHPSDQLWUHEDHNVSOLFLWQRLQWHUSUHWLUDWLVLPXOLUDWLUHSUH] HQWLUDWLLQXJRWDYOMDWLNDMSRPHQLMRQHNHNUHWQMHPLPLNDJHVWHDNWLEHVHGHÍXVWYD VDMVRQDPYVHOHMĤHGDQLNRWRVPLďOMHQRYHGHQMHNLVHGREHVHGQRďLULVNR]LJLEDQMHLQ NUHWQMHWHOHVD'UXJLVXEMHNWMHWDNR]PHURPĤHYQDVLQPLYQMHPWHUVHYLQWHUDNFLML QDďLREÍXWNLSUHSOHWDMRȡÍXWLPRGUXJHJDLQVLFHUYODVWQHPWHOHVXQDWRSDWXGLGUXJL ÍXWLQDďRG]LYYVYRMHPWHOHVX'HMVWYRMHGDODKNRYQHNHPR]LUXUHÍHPRGDĤLYLPR R]LURPDVHQDVHOLPRYREUD]XDOLREUD]QLKL]UD]LKGUXJHJDLQREHQHPREÍXWLPRGD RQĤLYLYQDďLK0HGRVHEQDNRRUGLQDFLMDNLVHVDPRGHMQRVLQKURQL]LUDVNR]LXWHOHďHQR LQWHUDNFLMRYNDWHULODKNRUHÍHPRGDVHWHOHVQHVKHPH}VSDULMRmMHWDNRSRJRMVRFLDOQH NRPXQLNDFLMHNLVHGRJDMDVNR]LLQWHUDNWLYQRNURĤQRVW 3ULPDUQDPHGWHOHVQRVWMH0HUOHDX3RQW\MHYSRMHPVNDWHULPSRVNXďDPLVOLWLWHOHV QRDIHNWLYQRVSRUD]XPHYDQMHYNDWHUHPRG]LYHY]JLEHLQQDPHUHGUXJHJDÍXWLPRY ODVWQHPXWHOHVXNLVHQHSUHVWDQRIRUPLUDLQUHIRUPLUDVNR]LVRFLDOQHRGQRVH.LQ HVWHWLNDVHQ]DFLMDLQDIHNFLMHWHOHVDUD]NULYDMRLQWHQFHSRPHQJLEDQMDJHVWLNXODFLMH NUHWQMHLQPLPLNHGUXJHJDVNR]LQDďRODVWQRWHOHVQRVW7DNRODKNRQSUHQROHWRVWDU PDOÍHNNLďHQLRVYRMLO]DSOHWHQLKNRJQLWLYQLKRSHUDFLMGRMHPDQDďHJHVWHQSUJUL]HQ MHSUVWDLQVLFHUWDNRGDMLKÍXWLYVYRMHPWHOHVXNRWGDELELORYHGHQMHQMHJRYRSUDY WDNRLPDMRJHVWHYHGQRWXGLDIHNWLYQRNYDOLWHWRLQVLJQLʳNDQFR]DRWURNDVDMMHRGYLVHQ RGSRPHPEQHJDGUXJHJDVNDWHULPVHVSRUD]XPHYD7DNRSULGHMRGRL]UD]D]D]QDYQL HNVSUHVLYQLLQVHQ]RPRWRULÍQLYLGLNLVRFLDOQHJDUD]XPHYDQMD =D QDV MH SRPHPEQR GD MH PHGWHOHVQRVW NL GHOXMH V SRPRÍMR IXQNFLRQDOQLK telesnih shem, avtonomna LUHGXNWLELOQDFHORWDNLLPD svoje lastne vzorce in dinamiko 7R SDSRPHQLGDVPRPLNRWSRVDPH]QLNLQDQHNQDÍLQYLQWHUDNFLMDKSRGUHMHQLDOLGROR ÍHQL]QDGVWDYERQHNHVSHFLʳÍQHRUJDQL]DFLMHWHOHVQLKVKHPR]LURPDIRUPHWHOHVQRVWL NLVRPHGVHERMODKNREROMDOLPDQMXJODďHQH2GQMLKRYHRUJDQL]DFLMHMHWDNRRGYLVQR NDNRVHNRWVXEMHNWLYVRFLDOQLKVLWXDFLMDKRG]LYDPRYHGHPRLQVHVSRUD]XPHYDPR 17 3UDYWDNRSDLPDMRSUREOHPH]YĤLYOMDQMHPRVHEH]PRWQMDPLVKL]RIUHQHJDVSHNWUDNLVYRMHODVWQR WHORREÍXWLMRNRWWXMHR]VHSRÍXWLMRNRWGDVR}YVWURMXmSUDYLMRQSUGDVHMLP]GLGDVHJLEOMHMRNRWURERWL =DUDGL SUHWLUDQHJD DYWRPDWLÍQHJD VDPRQDG]RURYDQMD LQ KLSHUUHʴHNVLYQRVWL WHU QHSUHVWDQHJD VDPR]DYHGDQ MD MLP XPDQMND GLPHQ]LMD VSRQWDQHJD VDPRGHMQHJD GHORYDQMD Y VYHWX LQ VRFLDOQLK LQWHUDNFLMDK 6WHSKHQVHQ LQ 3HUQDV 6XEMHNW VH WDNR Y GHMDYQRVWL QLNROL QH }L]JXELm UD]SXVWL DPSDN MH QHSUHVWDQR SULVRWHQ NRW VYRM ODVWQL YHOLNL 'UXJLȡ NL SD ]DGREL VWDWXV VXEMHNWD 7DNR MH UDGLNDOQR LQ JOREDOQR VSUHPHQMHQD QMLKRYD FH ORWQD VWUXNWXUD VXEMHNWLYQRVWL VDM SULGH GR UD]NURMD NL JD ODKNR LPHQXMHPR IUDJPHQWLUDQD }VXEMHNWLYQRVWm 6DPHJD VHEH GRĤLYOMDMR QD}VQDSVKRWm QDÍLQ NDU EL ODKNR ELOR SRYH]DQR V WHP GD MLP XPDQMND WXGL KRUL]RQW SULKRGQRVWL7HNRPVRFLDOQHLQWHUDNFLMHVHQHPRUHMRXJODVLWLVVYHWRPQLWL VLQKURQL]LUDWL]GUXJLPLRVHEDPL'UXJH GRĤLYOMDMRNRWWXMFHȡFHORODVWQRGUXĤLQR3UDYWDNRSDQHNDNRQHPRUHMRELWLYHÍDʳFLUDQLVVWUDQLGUXJLKRVHE VWYDUL LQ VLWXDFLM NDU LPSOLFLUD GD VH ] GUXJLPL VXEMHNWL QH PRUHMR SRYH]DWL QD WHOHVQRDIHNWLYQL UDYQL LQ QH ÍXWLMR DIHNWLYQR QDELWHJD VRFLDOQHJD R]UDÍMD R]LURPD DWPRVIHUH =DWR REÍXWLMR QHNDNďHQ QHSUHPRVWOMLYL SUHSDG PHG VDPLP VDER LQ VYHWRP WHU GUXJLPL VXEMHNWL NDU UH]XOWLUD Y REÍXWNX SRSROQH L]ROLUDQRVWL RG VYH WD =QDNH LQ JRYRULFR UD]YR]ODYDMR PHWRGLÍQR LQ SRVUHGQR 2EHQHP SD SRURÍDMR GD QL GLIHUHQFLDFLMH R]L URPD ]DNDVQHORVWL PHG UHʴHNWLUDMRÍLP PLďOMHQMHP LQ VLWXDFLMR NL WHÍH 7DNďQD UD]SDGOD VXEMHNWLYQRVW SD REHQHP SDUDGRNVQR ERWUXMH IHQRPHQRP SUL NDWHULK VXEMHNW REÍXWL QHNDNďQR RJURĤDMRÍH }YGLUDQMHm GUX JLK VXEMHNWRY Y QMLKRYR LQWLPQR }QRWUDQMRVWm 9 VRFLDOQLK LQWHUDNFLMDK QSU REÍXWLMR NRW GD GUXJL }YLGLMRm Y QMLKRYR QRWUDQMRVW GD VOLďLMR QMLKRYH PLVOL VYRMH ODVWQH PLVOL SD ODKNR GRĤLYOMDMR NRW WXMH ]DSRYHGL VOXďQH KDOXFLQDFLMHLWG1MLKRYD}UD]SDGODmVXEMHNWLYQRVWQLPDNRQVLVWHQFHLQPHMHNLMRORÍLRGVYHWD7DNRWRYUVWQDSD WRORJLMDNDĤHQDQDUDYRQDďHVXEMHNWLYQRVWLNLVHODKNRY]SRVWDYLVDPR]PHMRLQSUHSDGRPNLQDVORÍXMHRGVYHWD Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 152 27. 10. 2022 11:16:24 )RUPDWHOHVQRVWLLQDʳQLWHWD]QHNRVWUXNWXURWHOHVQRVWLMHWDNRSRJRMHPSDWLMHVLP-patije in antipatije 7DNREROMDOLPDQMQHSRVUHGQRGRMDPHPRQDPHQH]D]QDYHREÍXWNH LQY]JLEHGUXJLKVXEMHNWRYYQDďHPODVWQHPWHOHVXÍHLPDPR]QHNRPĤH razvite odnose LQYH]L2EHQHP YODVWQLKWHOHVLKÍXWLPR in slutimo,120 GDQDPQHNDWHULVORJLLQYHGHQMD GUXJLKVXEMHNWRYQHSDďHMRDOLVHQDPXSLUDMRFHORJQXVLMRSRGUXJLVWUDQLSDVH]GUX JLPL QHQDYDGQR KLWUR SRYHĤHPR VLQKURQL]LUDPR LQ UD]XPHPR SUDYLPR GD }VPR QD LVWLYDORYQLGROĤLQLm7RNDĤHGDYVHOHMSRVHGXMHPRQHNRDʳQLWHWR]QHNRVWUXNWXURIRU PRWHOHVQRVWL7DNRYWHOHVX]DÍXWLPRSROHJHPSDWLMHWXGLVLPSDWLMRDOLDQWLSDWLMRGR GUXJLK/DKNRELUHNOLGD telesne senzacije, vzgibi in afekti1 21 RULHQWLUDMRLQGRORÍDMRQHNR DʳQLWHWRGRGUXJHJDVNR]LQMLKVH formira odnos, razmerje in interakcija YLQWHUVXEMHNWLY QHPVYHWX7DNRWHOHVDQLVRLQGLYLGXDOL]LUDQDDWRPL]LUDQDDPSDNVLGHOLMRPHGWHOHVQL }QLNRJDUďQMLm SURVWRUYNDWHUHPVWHOHVQRVKHPRSRVHJDPRGUXJYGUXJHJDLQKDELWXV YNDWHUHPSRWHNDLQWHUDNFLMD/HWDNRODKNRPHGRVHEQLRGQRVLIRUPLUDMRVSHFLʳÍQHSRG VYHWRYHNLSRJRMXMHMRLQWHUDNFLMRLQL]NOMXÍXMHMRGUXJHNLQLVRQDLVWLYDORYQLGROĤLQL9 SUDNVLMHWRSRJRVWRYLGQRQDUDYQLSULMDWHOMVWHYLQVRGHORYDQMYNDWHULK]XQDQMLRSD]R YDOHFKLWUR]D]QDNDNRXVNODMHQRIXQNFLRQLUDMRGRORÍHQLSDULDOLVNXSLQHQSUVSRUD]X PHYDQMHVDPRSUHNRSRJOHGDUD]XPHYDQMHLURQLÍQHJRYRULFHLQLQWHUQLKďDOVDUND]PD LWG 'UXJL ODKNR WDNR Y QHNHP VPLVOX SRVWDQH SRGDOMďHN QDďHJD WHOHVD 7H PHMH NL VH Y]SRVWDYLMRYVRFLDOQLKLQWHUDNFLMDKMLKREHQHPSRJRMXMHMRLQMLPGRORÍDMRVSHFLʳÍQR LGHQWLWHWR NRQWUDVW 3UDY WDNR SD MH NOMXÍQHJD SRPHQD XJODďHQRVW QD UDYQL KDELWXVD QSU DOL SULKDMDPR L] LVWHJD RNROMD GUXĤEHQHJD UD]UHGD NXOWXUH LSG 7H XJRWRYLWYH VR ODKNR SRPHPEQH ]D DQDOL]R LQ RGSUDYOMDQMH NRPXQLNDFLMVNLK ďXPRY WHU UD]XPHYDQMH SUHGVRGNRYLQSHUVSHNWLYQHQDUDYHJOHGDQMDQDGUXĤEHQHNRQʴLNWHLQDQWDJRQL]PH ÌHJUHPRďHHQNRUDNGDOMHODKNRUHÍHPRGDÍHSUDYYVDNHJDSRVDPH]QLNDGR QHNHPHUHGHWHUPLQLUDKDELWXVSDLPDYVDNRGQDVVYRMRODVWQRRUJDQL]DFLMRQDYHGHQLK GHMDYQLNRYVYRMODVWHQVORJJLEDQMDYHGHQMDLQLQWHUDNFLMH7DNRELODKNRSRVWDYLOLWH]R da se celo naš lastni ]QDÍDMRGUDĤDYIRUPLWHOHVQRVWL WHUJDREHQHPVDPDWHOHVQRVWLQLQ GLYLGXDOQHSUDNVHYQHNLPHULJUDGLMR7DXJRWRYLWHYMHďHNDNRUHOHYDQWQDYGDQDďQMHP ÍDVXYNDWHUHPVR]HORUD]ďLUMHQHNRQWHPSODWLYQHSUDNVHLQSVLKRWHUDSLMHNLXÍLMRGD laKNR]RVUHGRWRÍHQRVWMRQDQDďRQRWUDQMRVWRGNULMHPRVYRMHSUDYRVHEVWYRÌHXSRďWH YDPRUD]PLďOMDQMHNLVPRJDUD]YLMDOL]JRUDMWDNďQRVHEVWYRQHREVWDMD1DďDVXEMHNWLY QRVWQDPUHÍQHREVWDMDQHRGYLVQRRGQDďHJDGHORYDQMDLQPDWHULDOQLKSUDNVYNDWHULK =DEHVHGRVOXWQMDLPDMRYKUYDďNHPMH]LNXWHUPLQ}SUHGRVMHÉDMmNLJDODKNRGREHVHGQRSUHYHGHPR kot SUHGREÍXWHN 7DEHVHGDMH]DQLPLYDVIHQRPHQRORďNHJDYLGLNDVDMSULPHUQRLQVPLVHOQRL]UD]LVDPGRĤLYOMDM 6DPLÍXVWYDLQUD]SRORĤHQMDUD]XPHPRNRWSRMDYHVNXSQHJDPHGRVHEQHJDR]LURPDPHGWHOHVQHJD SURVWRUDYNDWHUHPSRWHNDLQWHUDNFLMD(PRFLMHSRWHPWDNHPQLVRORNDOL]LUDQHYQRWUDQMRVWLL]ROLUDQLKSRVDPH] QLNRYPDUYHÍYPHGSURVWRUXLQWHUVXEMHNWLYQRVWL3UDYWDNRSDMH]DIHNWLYQLPSURVWRURPDWPRVIHURNROHNWLY QLPUD]SRORĤHQMHPNLVLJDGHOLPR]GUXJLPLLQ]DREVHJDWHUQDGGHWHUPLQLUDDNWLYQHGUXĤEHQHRGQRVH9HÍR WHPJOHM0DQ]RQL'LQR)HQRPHQRORJLMDDIHNWLYQRVWLVSRVHEQLPR]LURPQDUD]SRORĤHQMXLQHPRFLMDKY $QWKURSRVOHWQďW Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 153 27. 10. 2022 11:16:24 VHIRUPLUDQHNDWHOHVQRVW2NROMHNRWSURVWRUGHORYDQMDLQVDPQDÍLQLQWHUDNFLMHLPDMR ʳ]LJRQRPLMRNLNDĤHQDQDďRRVHEQRVW]QDÍDM ÌHSRJOHGDPRVWHSHUVSHNWLYHODKNRKLSRWHWL]LUDPRUDYQRREUDWQRLQVLFHUGDVH VSUHPHPED]QDÍDMDR]LURPDRVHEQRVWL]JRGLWDNRGDdelujemo YQHNLVPHUL7DNLQGLUHNWHQ QDÍLQYNDWHUHPPHKDQLÍQRGHOXMHPRWROLNRÍDVDGDYHGHQMHSRVWDQHQDYDGDSRY]URÍL VSUHPHPEH QD KDELWXDOQL VWUXNWXUL WHOHVD 7DNR VH L]RJQHPR QDUFL]PX LQ QHSUHVWDQL VDPRLQVSHNFLMLNLVWUXNWXUQRSUHSUHÍXMHWDUDGLNDOQHMďRVSUHPHPERVXEMHNWDVDMRKUDQ MDWDGRORÍHQRNYLUL]NDWHUHJDGRORÍDPRNDMQDMELSULVHELVSUHPHQLOL.RVDPR delujemo YQHNLVPHULVHÍH]QHNDMÍDVDQDNOMXÍQRLQVDPRGHMQRRYHPRGDVPRVHELVWYHQR VSUHPHQLOL9HQGDUSDMHUHVWXGLREUDWQRLQVLFHUGRNOHUYHUMDPHPRGDVPRWDLQWDD GHOXMHPRGUXJDÍHQSUSRQHNLK]XQDQMLK]DNRQLKLQSUDYLOLKVHÍH]ÍDVVSUHPHQLPRY VPHULGHORYDQMDQHGDELVHWHJDVSORK]DYHGDOL7RMHHGHQRGUD]ORJRY]DNDMVRďHNDNR SRPHPEQDIRUPDOQDLQQHIRUPDOQDSUDYLODREQDďDQMDGUĤDYQLDNWLWHUPRUDOQL]DNRQLY NDWHUHODKNRFHORQHYHUMDPHPRDYHQGDUXVPHUMDMRLQGRORÍDMRQDďHGHORYDQMHYVYHWX .HUďHVDPHPXVHELQLVPRQHSRVUHGQRRÍLYLGQDLQWUDQVSDUHQWQDELWMDVHVD PLPVHELUD]NULYDPRȡLQREHQHP]DNULYDPRȡVNR]LRG]LYHQDVWYDULVYHWD in si nismo GDQLQHSRVUHGQRWDNRGDYHPRNGRVPRYVYRMLSULYDWQLQRWUDQMRVWL $VSHNWLQDVVDPLK VHQDPUD]NULYDMRLQNDĤHMROHVNR]LLQWHUDNFLMR]GUXJLPLYVLWXDFLMDKWHUYRG]LYLKQD VWYDULVYHWDNRWVPRGHPRQVWULUDOLQDSULPHUXOMXEH]QL7DNRXJRWDYOMDPRGDQDWHOH VXNLQDVYSHQMDYVYHWVRFLDOQHYH]LLQUD]QHVLWXDFLMH SXďÍDMRVYRMSHÍDW LQSULGHMR}Y PHVRLQNULm7D}YJUDYLUDQRVWm YVHOHMĤHXÍLQNXMHÍHWXGLVHWHJDQH]DYHGDPRREHQHP SDVRWHOHVDLQLQWHUDNFLMHSODVWLÍQLWHUVHQHSUHVWDQRVSUHPLQMDMRÍHWXGLQLNROLQHPR UHPR]DUHVL]EULVDWLVHGLPHQWRYNLVRJUDGQLNLQHNHIRUPHWHOHVQRVWL.RPDMNRSULSR ]QDPR WR WHOHVQR VHGLPHQWDFLMR NL QLPD QHSRVUHGQH SR]LWLYQH HPSLULÍQH HNVLVWHQFH DPSDNVHPDQLIHVWLUDVNR]LQDYDGHLQPDWHULDOQHSUDNVHMHPRĤQDNULWLNDLQVSUHPHPED REVWRMHÍLKVRFLDOQLKSUDNV /MXGMHSRWHPWDNHPWDNUDWNRJRYRU«GDWRDOLRQRGHORYDQMHWHOHVDL]YLUDL] GXKDNLGDLPDREODVWQDGWHOHVRPQHYHGµNDMJRYRU«LQQHGHODMRGUXJHJD NRWȡQHGDELVHWHPXÍXGLOLȡ]]YHQHÍLPLEHVHGDPLSUL]QDYDMRGDQHSR]QDMR SUDYHJD Y]URND WHPX GHORYDQMX Ȭ 7X QDYDMDP ďH XVWURM ÍORYHďNHJD WHOHVD NL SR XPHWHOQRVWL GDOHÍ SUHVHJD YVH NDU MH XVWYDULOD ÍORYHďND XPHWQRVW Ȭ 6SLQR]D Etika,,,'HO O izvoru in naravi afektov; ,,SUDYLOR Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 154 27. 10. 2022 11:16:24 BIBLIOGRAFIJA %RXUGLHX3LHUUH Outline of a Theory of Practice 8.&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV %RXUGLHX3LHUUH 3UDNWLÍQLUD]ORJLRWHRULMLGHORYDQMD/MXEOMDQD.UWLQD +HLGHJJHU0DUWLQ %LWLQÍDV/MXEOMDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD +XVVHUO(GPXQG ,GHMH]DÍLVWRIHQRPHQRORJLMRLQIHQRPHQRORďNRʳOR]RʳMR/MXEO MDQD6ORYHQVNDPDWLFD .R൵ND.XUW3HUFHSWLRQDQ,QWURGXFWLRQWRWKH*HVWDOW7KHRU\Y Psychological Bulletin 19: 531–585 /DFDQ-DFTXHV6SLVLY Problemi 31(4): 37–45. /DFDQ-DFTXHV Écrits 1HZ㢼ᅵ@NLGHOHĤL ʳHOGRISDUWLFXODULW\ZKHUHDVWKH6WDWH QDEXGLVWLÍQLGRNWULQLRSUD]QLQLLQRG UHSUHVHQWVWKHSULQFLSOHRIXQLYHUVDOLW\ VRWQRVWLVHEVWYD6OHGQMHJDVHRYHPRďHOH ȢWKHʳUVWJRYHUQHGE\WKHGLYLQHODZRI NRWGHODYFHORWLYVHJDȡNRW ningen >ே㛫@ *RGWKHVHFRQGE\KXPDQODZWKHODWWHU YGHMDYQHPRGQRVXGRRNROLFHSUHĤHWH] VXSSRVHGO\VSULQJLQJIURPWKHFRQʴLFW med SURVWRUVNLP:DWVXMLQDSRW]GYRPO EHWZHHQWKHIHPDOHDQGPDOHSULQFLSOHV MHQMDSRQHVHSRMPDVHEVWYDLQ'UXJHJD 7KHXQLRQRIWKHWZRLQDPDULWDODIIDLU NLVHQDSRVOHGL]SHOMHWDY ningen sonzai > IRUPVDQDFWLYHFRUHRIWKHZKROHWKHLQ ே㛫Ꮡᅾ@YSUDYRUHVQLÍQRVWL]SUD]Q VWLWXWLRQRIIDPLO\EHLQJWKDWZKLFKPDUNV MHQHJDNLGRSXďÍDWUHQXWHNRÍLďÍHQH WKHSRLQWRIGHSDUWXUHLQWRDFLYLOVRFLHW\ QHORÍHQRVWLVWLNVHEVWYDLQQHVHEVWYDNL ,WLVUDWKHUVXUSULVLQJWKDW+HJHOGHFLGHV VHQDSRVOHGYVDNVHELVSXVWLWDYSURVWRU IRUWKHWUDJLFFKDUDFWHURI$QWLJRQHWR LQÍDV1DPHQSULÍXMRÍHJDÍODQNDMHGD HSLWRPL]HWKHSDUDGLJPRIWKHIDPLO\ RVYHWOLLQRYUHGQRWLRPHQMHQHSRYH]DYH ODZDQGWKDWZKLFKGHQRWHVIHPLQLQLW\DV VXFK+HUKLJKHVWHWKLFDOGXW\LVWKHEXULDO ./-8Ì1(%(6('(ELWNVPUWLQLQJHQ RIKHUEURWKHUVRWKDWVKHFDQHQDEOHKLV PLOM«HWLNDGUXJHJDSUD]QLQD VRXOȤVSDVVLQJRQLQWR+DGHV:LWKKHU DFWRISRVLWLRQLQJIDPLO\YDOXHVLQWRWKH ABSTRACT IRUHPRVWSODFHRILPSRUWDQFHVKHLQIDFW EUHDNVXQLYHUVDOODZVRIWKH6WDWHEHFDXVH VKHFRQWUDGLFWVWKHNLQJȤVSURKLELWLRQRI ,Q+HLGHJJHUWKHRQWRORJLFDOWDNHVRQ EXULDO:LWKKHUOR\DOW\WRWKHIDPLO\OLIH an ethical magnitude, ignoring the rela $QWLJRQHWKHUHIRUHEHFRPHVDSROLWLFDO WLRQVKLSLQEHWZHHQȣ,ȤDQGȣ7KRXȤIDLOLQJ VXEMHFWVKHVWDQGVIRUWKH6SLULWRIVXE WRDQVZHUZK\WLPHLVSXWIRUWKDVDIXQ YHUVLYHLQGLYLGXDOLVPWHDULQJGRZQWKH GDPHQWDOFRQVWLWXHQWRIVDLGVWUXFWXUH FRQFHSWRIXQLYHUVDOLW\:LWKKHUSDVVDJH ZKHUHDVVSDFHKDGEHHQDEDQGRQHGLQ LQWRWKHSROLWLFDOVKHKDVWDNHQKHUVHOIRXW FRQFHDOPHQWH[LVWHQFHLVDIWHUDOOFRP RIWKHIHPDOHȣQDWXUDOȤVSKHUHLQZKLFK SULVHGE\ERWKDOLNH7KHSKLORVRSKHUVRI VKHSRVVHVVHGQRDZDUHQHVVRIKHURZQ the N\ýWR VFKRRORIWKRXJKWWDNHRQWKH VKHKDVQRZEHFRPHDVLQJXODUVXEMHFW FRQWUDU\VWDQFHDQLQVLJKWRXJKWWREH DFTXLUHGLQWRWKHZRUOGXVLQJGLIIHUHQW .(<:25'6$QWLJRQHWKH6WDWHIDPLO\ PHDQV:DWVXMLSUHVHQWVDKLVWRULFDODQG +HJHOVXEMHFWIHPDOH cultural climate or IĕGR>㢼ᅵ@ ZKLFK Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 168 27. 10. 2022 11:16:30 ZKLFKIRXQGHGRQWKHEXGGKLVWGRFWULQH UD]XPHMR+XVVHUOLQQMHJRYLLQWHUSUHWL3R RIHPSWLQHVVDQGQRVHOI7KHNQRZOHGJH 7HQJHO\LMXELPRUDOLL]EUDWLPHGNRUHODFLMR ZHVHHNRQWKHPDWWHUPD\RQO\EHDW zavesti in sveta ter svetnim horizontom WDLQHGDVSDUWRIWKHZKROH:HUHVLGHLQ NRWSUHVHĤNRPJOHGHQDSUHGPHWQRVW=D WKLVZRUOGDV ningen >ே㛫@ in an active VWDYOMDPSDUDYQRSUREOHPNDNRMHPRJR UHODWLRQVKLSWRZDUGRXUHQYLURQPHQW ÍDNRUHODFLMDVKRUL]RQWRPNRWSUHVHĤNRP ZKLFKLVSHUPHDWHGZLWKWKHLQWHUSHUVRQ REMHNWLYQRVWL"2EDPRPHQWDPRUDWD DO+HJRHVIXUWKHULQKLVZULWLQJSODFLQJ QDPUHÍELWLSULVRWQDÍHQDMJRYRULPRR ERWKȣ,ȤDQGȣ7KRXȤRQWKHSDWKRIGRXEW IHQRPHQRORďNLXWHPHOMLWYLSULVWRMQHJD ZKLFKOHDGVWRWKHGHFLVLYHPRPHQWRI RGQRVDGRVYHWD ningen sonzai >ே㛫Ꮡᅾ@ZKLFKFRQWDLQV WKHWUXHUHDOLW\RIWKDWZKLFKLVHPSW\ ./-8Ì1(%(6('(KRUL]RQWVYHWELW DQGDOORZVIRUDPRPHQWRISXULʳHGXQGL celota, transcendentalno YLGHGQHVVWRPDQLIHVWLWVHOIWKHFUXFLDO HVWDEOLVKPHQWRIFRQWDFWLQEHWZHHQWKH ABSTRACT VHOIDQGQRVHOIWKDWXOWLPDWHO\HQGXS VHSDUDWLQJSDWKVHDFKGHVFHQGLQJLQWR ,QP\FRQWULEXWLRQ,GHDOZLWK+XVVHUOȤV WLPHDQGVSDFHRQWKHLURZQDFFRUG7KH FRQFHSWRIWKHOLIHZRUOGDQGWU\WRDQ SXUSRVHRIWKLVSDSHULVJLYLQJFODULW\DQG DO\]HWKHSUREOHPRIWKHFRQFHSWRIWKH shedding light on the mentioned rela ZRUOGDVKRUL]RQ7KHPHDQLQJRIWKLV WLRQV FRQFHSWLQ+XVVHUOLVHVVHQWLDOO\GHWHU PLQHGE\REMHFWLYLW\2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLW .(<:25'6EHLQJWRZDUGGHDWKQLQ SHUWDLQVWRWKHKRUL]RQLWVHOIDVDFHUWDLQ JHQPLOLHXWKHHWKLFVRIWKHRWKHUHPS NLQGRIXQLW\+RZDUHZHVXSSRVHGWR tiness XQGHUVWDQGWKLVXQLW\",VWKLVDXQLW\RID W\SLFVVFKHPDUXOHRULQWHUSUHWDWLRQ"$V PROBLEM DANOSTI SVETA ORQJDVZRUOGLVXQGHUVWRRGDVDȣKRUL]RQ KOT HORIZONTA V RIKRUL]RQVȤLWEHORQJVWRWKHVDPHRUGHU HUSSERLOVI FENOMENOLOGIJI DVWKHKRUL]RQVRIWKHH[SHULHQWLDOʳHOG 2QHVKRXOGGLVWLQJXLVKKRZHYHUWKH MARKO MARKIČ ZKROHDVDZKROHRISRVVLEO\JLYHQEH LQJVHQVHLQWKHFRQFUHWHFRQVFLRXVH[SH POVZETEK ULHQFHDQGWKHEHLQJZKROHDVVXFKDVDQ LQGHSHQGHQWVHOIIRXQGHGPHDQLQJV7KH 9SULVSHYNXQDMSUHMRULďHP+XVVHUORY GLUHFWLYHQHVVRIWKHZRUOGKRUL]RQLVWKHQ ȣIURPZRUOGWRZDUGVWKHFRQFUHWHȤDQG SRMHPVYHWDNRWĤLYOMHQMVNHJDVYHWD1DWR QRWFRQYHUVHO\DV+XVVHUODQGKLVLQWHU L]SRVWDYLPSUREOHPDWLNRSRMPDVYHWD SUHWHUVVHHPWRXQGHUVWDQG,QWKLVYLHZ NRWKRUL]RQWD6PLVHOKRUL]RQWD+XVVHUO ,IRUPXODWHDSUREOHPRIFRUUHODWLRQZLWK ELVWYHQRGRORÍLJOHGHQDSUHGPHWQRVW3R WKHXQLTXHZRUOGKRUL]RQDVWKDWZKLFK GUXJLVWUDQLSDKRUL]RQWXVDPHPXSUL SUHFLVHO\WUDQVFHQGVREMHFWLYLW\$OWKRXJK SDGDQHNDHQRWQRVW.DNRQDMUD]XPHPR KRUL]RQLVDQHVVHQWLDOO\FRUUHODWLRQDO WRHQRWQRVW"-HWRPDUHQRWQRVWWLSLNH WHUPWKLVGRHVQRWH[SODLQWKHIRXQGDWLRQ VKHPHSUDYLODLQWHUSUHWDFLMH"'RNOHUMH QRUWKHPHDQLQJRIWKLVFRUUHODWLRQ,W VYHW]JROM}KRUL]RQWKRUL]RQWRYmVSDGD DSSHDUVWKDWWKHUHVXOWRIWKLVSUREOHPDWLF SUDYYLVWLUHGNRWKRUL]RQWLL]NXVWYHQHJD LQ+XVVHUOLVWKDWDFRUUHODWLRQZLWKWKH RNROMD3RWUHEQRSDMHUD]OLNRYDQMHFHORWH KRUL]RQRIOLIHZRUOGLVQRWSRVVLEOHDWDOO NRWFHORWHPRĤQRGDQHJDYNRQNUHWQHP H[FHSWSHUKDSVDVDFRUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQ ]DYHVWQHPL]NXVWYXLQFHORWHNRWWDNH WUDQVFHQGHQWDOVHOIXQGHUVWDQGLQJDQG 2GXSRďWHYDQMDWHNOMXÍQHGLIHUHQFHMH WKHZRUOGDVDWUDQVFHQGHQWDOSKHQRPH RGYLVQDPRĤQRVWSULVWRMQHJDRGQRVDGR QRQ VYHWDNRWELWQRVPLVHOQHFHORWH6PHU VYHWQRVWQHJDKRUL]RQWDMHWRUHM}RGVYHWD .(<:25'6KRUL]RQZRUOGEHLQJZKROH KNRQNUHWQHPXmLQQHREUDWQRNDNRUMH transcendental Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 169 27. 10. 2022 11:16:30 O TELESU: IURPDQWLTXLW\WRWKHPRGHUQDJHDQGWKH MED MERLEAU-PONTYJEM FXUUHQWFRQFHSWLRQRIWKHERG\:HZLOO IN BOURDIEUJEM IRFXVRQ0HUOHDX3RQW\ȤVFRQFHSWLRQVRI FRUSRUHDOLW\DQG%RXUGLHXȤVSKLORVRSK\ DINO MANZONI RIDFWLRQ,QKLVWKHRU\0HUOHDX3RQW\ WUDQVIRUPVWKHDQDO\VLVRILQWHUVXEMHFWLYH LQWHUDFWLRQZLWKRWKHUVȢZKLFKDFFRUG POVZETEK LQJWR+XVVHUODUHIRUXVWKHRWKHU6HOYHV ȢLQWRDQDQDO\VLVRIWKHFRQFUHWHLQWHU 3ULÍXMRÍLSULVSHYHNSUHGVWDYOMDDQDOL]R DFWLRQEHWZHHQOLYLQJPDWHULDOVHQWLHQW UD]PHUMDPHGSRMPRYDQMHPPHGWHOHV ERGLHV7KLVLVKRZKHH[SODLQVRXUGDLO\ QRVWL0HUOHDX3RQW\DWHU%RXUGLHXMHYLP IXQFWLRQLQJLQWKHVRFLDOHQYLURQPHQW NRQFHSWRPKDELWXVD3UYLSRVNXďDLQWHU WKURXJKWKHSULPDU\ȣLQWHUFRUSRUHDOLW\Ȥ VXEMHNWLYQRLQWHUDNFLMRPLVOLWLVSRMPRP LQWHUFRUSRU«LW«ZKLFKVHUYHVDVWKH }PHGWHOHVQRVWLm intercorporéité NLMH IRXQGDWLRQIRUVRFLDOLQWHUDFWLRQFRJQL ]DQMWHPHOMVRFLDOQHNRJQLFLMHLQYĤLYO WLRQDQGHPSDWK\6SRQWDQHRXVGHFRGLQJ MDQMD7LVWRNDUSRYH]XMHQDďRWHOHVQRVW RIWKHKDELWXVRIWKH2WKHUDOORZVIRUD LQWHORGUXJHJDMHSULPDUQR notranji VHQVHRIV\PSDWK\RUDQWLSDWK\ZKLFK odnos telesnosti, ki ga lahko mislimo kot JXLGHVRXULQWHUDFWLRQSDWWHUQVDQGFRP SURGXNWGHORYDQMDWHOHVQHVKHPH=D]QD PXQLFDWLRQ+RZHYHUVLQFHZHDUHQRW YDQMHSRWHNDNRWNRPSOHPHQWDUQDRSHUD GLUHFWO\WUDQVSDUHQWEHLQJVWRRXUVHOYHV FLMDWDNRGDGRĤLYOMDQMHVYRMHJDODVWQHJD ZHUHYHDORXUVHOYHVWRRXUVHOYHVLQYDULRXV telesa in telesa drugega tvorita neko VLWXDWLRQVDQGLQLQWHUDFWLRQZLWKRWKHUV NRHNVWHQ]LYQRVWSUHSOHWHQRVW ÍHSUDY ZKLFKFODULʳHVWKHFRQWH[WXDODQGVLWX VWDYWHPHOMQLRQWRORďNLQHVLPHWULML To, DWHGDVSHFWRIRXUEHLQJWKDWZHFDQQRW NDUGRORÍDNRQWUDVWVSHFLʳÍQHLQWHUDN WKLQNDSDUWIURPWKHZRUOG2QO\ZKHQZH FLMHMH}IRUPDmWHOHVQRVWLȡNDUPLVOLPR UHFRJQL]HVRPHIRUPRIFRUSRUDOLW\WKDW GDMHNOMXÍHQXYLGQDSRGODJLNDWHUHJD PDQLIHVWVLWVHOIWKURXJKKDELWVDQGPDWH ER%RXUGLHXUD]YLOVYRMSRMHPKDELWXVD ULDOSUDFWLFHVWKURXJKZKLFKVRFLDOSRZHU ÌHSUDYQLNMHUQHPRUHPR}YLGHWLmIRUPH LQʴXHQFHDQGVWDWXVDUHH[HUFLVHGLWLV WHOHVQRVWLNLGRORÍDQDÍLQ PHGRVHEQLK SRVVLEOHWRFULWLTXHDQGFKDQJHWKHH[LVW LQWHUDNFLMLQRGQRVRYODKNRSRYVRGRSD LQJVRFLDOSUDFWLFHV ĤDPRQMHQHXÍLQNH,QYWHPMHQDďDVWD YDPDWHULDOQRVWKDELWXVDWHOHVQHVKHPH .(<:25'60HUOHDX3RQW\%RXUGLHX LQIRUPRWHOHVQRVWLMHPRĤQRREÍXWLWLVDM LQWHUFRUSRUHDOLW\ERG\KDELWXV SURL]YDMDXÍLQNHÍHSUDYQLPDQLNDNUďQH SR]LWLYQHHPSLULÍQHHNVLVWHQFH)RUPD WHOHVQRVWLLQDʳQLWHWD]QHNRVWUXNWX URWHOHVQRVWLVWDWDNRSRJRMDHPSDWLMH VLPSDWLMHWHUDQWLSDWLMHVNR]LNDWHUHVH IRUPLUDMRUD]PHUMDLQLQWHUDNFLMDY in WHUVXEMHNWLYQHPVYHWX7DNRWHOHVDQLVR LQGLYLGXDOL]LUDQDDWRPL]LUDQDDPSDNVL GHOLMRPHGWHOHVQR }QLNRJDUďQMR]HPOMRm ./-8Ì1(%(6('(0HUOHDX3RQW\%RXU GLHXLQWHUNRUSRUHDOQRVWWHORKDELWXV ABSTRACT 7KHSDSHUSUHVHQWVDQDWWHPSWWRRXWOLQH WKHKLVWRU\RIWKHSKLORVRSK\RIWKHERG\ Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 170 27. 10. 2022 11:16:30 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 171 27. 10. 2022 11:16:31 Filozofski_maraton_1.indd 172 27. 10. 2022 11:16:31