ON LOW FREQUENCY C-U RELATIONSHIP OF THE IONIZED CLUSTER BEAM, ICB, DEPOSITED Ag/n-Si(111) SCHOTKY DIODES Bruno CvikI Faculty of Civil Engineering, University of Maribor, and "J. Stefan" Institute, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia Key words: Schottky junction, Schottky diodes, C-U relationships. Low frequency C-U relationships, capacitance diodes, energy gaps, semiconductors, ICP, Ionized Cluster Beam, Ag/n-Si depositions, acceleration voltages, DIGS, Disorder Induced Gap States, UHV, Ultra-High Vacuum Abstract: The low frequency capacitance- voltage, C-U, relationship has been investigated on the basis of the postulated model of the semiconductor energy bands for samples of ionized cluster beam, ICB, deposited Ag/n-Si(111) Schottky diodes for nonzero Ag ions acceleration voltage. In the derivation the fundamental assumption made is the existence, within the Si energy gap, in addition to usual P shallow levels also Ag deep donor and acceptor impurity energy levels which, however, are assumed to be spatially confined to the narrow region at Ag/Si junction, only. The electrical activation of Ag, within this region homogeneous distributed, impurities Is biased voltage dependent. The Ag impurity levels are extending up to the maximal penetration length L, which is a function of silver ions acceleration voltage Ua. It is argued, that it is only for small values of L and/or small Ag impurity concentrations, that the C-U relation is expected to exhibit the linear relationship, in accordance with the measurements. The observed bias dependence of the semiconductor series resistance, at constant temperature, as well as the strong temperature dependency of the l-U measurements as reported previously are, in terms of the proposed model, explained on the phenomenological grounds. It is argued, that the relationship between the disordered, enriched semiconductor (interface) layer, formed at the metal/semiconductor junction, presumably responsible for the occurrence of the disorder induced gap states (DIGS), and the Fermi level pinning effect, might be most conveniently investigated by carefully controlled and suitably designed ICB experiments in UHV conditions. O nizkofrekvenčni C-U odvisnosti Ag/n-Si(111) Schottky-jevih diod, nanešenih po metodi curka ioniziranih skupkov, CIS Ključne besede: Schottky spoj, Schottky diode, C-U karakteristike, , C-U karakteristike nizkofrekvenčne, diode kapacitivne, reže energijske, polprevodniki, ICB nanašanje s curkom skupkov ioniziranih, Ag/n-Si nanosi, napetosti pospeševalne, DIGS stanja energijska nereda v reži energijski, UHV vakuum ultravisoki Povzetek: Na osnovi modela energijskih pasov v reži polprevodnika za primer po metodi curka ioniziranih skupkov nanešenih Ag/n-SI(111) Schottky-jevih diod za različne vrednosti pospeševalne napetosti Ag ionov, je v limiti nizkih frekvenc raziskana odvisnost kapacitivnosti diod od velikosti zunanje napetosti. Osnovna podmena, ki je bila privzeta v toku izpeljave C-U odvisnosti, zadeva predvideni obstoj omejenega prostorskega področja polprevodnika znotraj katerega se, poleg fosforja, še dodatno nahajajo električno aktivni in nevtralni srebrovi ioni enakomerne koncentracije. Srebrovi atomi se v polprevodniku vedejo kot ali donorji ali akceptorji, njihova električna aktivnost na pripadajočih energijskih nivojih, ki so uvrščeni globoko znotraj energijske reže, pa v splošnem zavisi od zunanje napetosti. Srebrove nečistoče v notranjosti polprevodnika segajo od stika kovina polprevodnik pa vse do največje globine L, ki zavisi od zunanje pospeševalne napetosti, Ua. Na osnovi izvedenih izračunov je pokazano, daje samo v limiti zanemarljivo majhne dolžine L in/ali majhne koncentracije srebra, v splošnem C-U odvistnost lahko linearna, v skladu z opazovanji. Na osnovi postavljenega modela je v delu podana fenomenološka razlaga odvisnosti serijskega upora od zunanje napetosti, kot tudi temperaturna odvistnost električnega toka in napetosti, l-U, na omenjeni način izvedenih Schottky-jevih diod. V članku je podan predlog, da je mogoče medsebojno razmerje med neurejeno, z srebrovimi nečistočami obogateno polprevodniško vmesno plastjo ob stiku kovina polprevodnik ter s tem povezanim pojavom nastanka novih elektronskih energijskih stanj (DIGS) v reži polprevodnika in vpetjem Fermijevega nivoja, prikladno proučevati prav z skrbno nadzorovanimi in ustreznimi, v ultra visokem vakuumu, izvedenimi eksperimenti rasti tankih heteroplasti po metodi curka ioniziranih skupkov. 1. Introduction The essential idea of ICB deposition method is illus- trated on fig. 1. The material to be deposited is con-Formation of thin films of various electric, magnetic, and tained in a closed crucible with a small nozzle on top. even organic substances on the suitably chosen sub- The vapours, while escaping through the nozzle, un-strata is among the otherwell established methods, also dergo adiabatic, supersonic expansion and during this conveniently accomplished by Takagi /1,2/ ionised process some of the atoms may reportedly /2/ aggre-clusterbeam, ICB, vacuum deposition method. gate in clusters of up to afew dozen atoms. Subsequent to their formation, through the nozzle ejecting atoms and atomic clusters are the subject of electron impact ionisation and are, on their path towards the substrate, accelerated in the static electric field, Ua. It has been generally observed that ejecting atoms or clusters are singly positively ionised. substrate r / / / / / —j- IONIZED / clusters accelerating \ electrode \ -j— neutral / clusters electrons for impact ionization I crucible heating = \ / h' ' I source material ing m — neutral clusters M 0-10 kv Fig. 1. Schematic drawing of an ion duster beam, ICB, deposition experiment /1/. recently been made to analyze the experiment in terms of the theory of thermally assisted tunneling of electrons (thermionic field emission current). This theory /5/ expresses the l-U characteristics in term of a parameter Eoo (which is a function of semiconductor doping density) and in certain cases, as evidenced in the literature, could account for the lowering of the effective potential junction barrier as a function of increasing semiconductor (homogeneous) doping. From the reverse part of l-U characteristics of our ICB deposited samples the extracted values of the "effective" Schottky barrier height, <|)b,the ideality factor, n, (defined as n = (q/kT)3V/a(inJ)), and the donor doping density, determined separately for each case oftheAg-f ions acceleration voltages, Ua, failed to correctly predict the measured l-U temperature variation of the ICB deposited Ag/Si structures /4/. The drastic changes as seen in the reverse part of the l-U diagram of ICB deposited Ag/n-Si(111) Schottky junctions, for Ua=0, 300 V and 1 kV, are presented on fig. 2. The details of the deposition and the analyses of the results are thoroughly discussed in ref. /4/. in general, the l-U electrical characteristics of such samples (for Ua nonzero) exhibit, within the small range of the reverse applied voltage U, almost linear l-U dependence before the saturation, fig. 2. The interval of almost linear l-U relationship is a monotonic function of Ua, the acceleration voltage of Ag+ ions, however accompanied by the corresponding increase of the (reverse) saturation current, fig. 2. For large enough acceleration voltages (say for Ua = 6 kV) the diode rectifying characteristics disappear altogether as thought the effective Schottky barrier height has virtually diminished. The metal/semiconductor structure, in the reverse direction, than effec- It is rather a well documented fact /2/, that ICB low temperature thin film growth method produces a very good quality thin layers. The reason is attributed to the still unexplained effects which generally accompany this particular ion assisted method of film growth. In addition, there exist at least two additional important features contributing to the quality thin film growth, namely the fact that there are no extra atomic species involved which could contaminate or be incorporated in the growing process, as well as the observation, that the amount of damage on the substrate due to the impinging particles, depending on the experimental condition, might be very small indeed. The potential barrier height, 2 kV, it may soon become nonlinear. It is a well established fact /7/, that the Si wafer, following the surface preparation, is under normal laboratory atmospheric conditions almost immediately covered by extremely stable (for the period up to one year) dielectric thin film consisting of about 0.7 nm thick native oxide layer on top of which about 0.2 nm thick organic contamination layer is in general also present. Obviously, the extent of the Ag""" enriched n-Si regions is most conveniently expressed in terms of the penetration lengths, L, which is accessible to Ag+ ions (at a given value of Ua) within the n-Si wafer. This distances have been correspondingly calculated (including the 1.2 nm thick oxide layer on the Si surface) and have been found to be L=2.4 nm for Ua=300 V, and L=4.0 nm for Ua=1 kV /8/. As it is well known /3/ the impurity silver atoms incorporated within the Si substrate can act either as donors (Ed (Ag) in Si = 0.370 eV above Ev) or as Fig. 4. Schematic drawing (not to scale) of forward biased ionized cluster beam deposited Ag/n-Si(111) metal/semiconductor junction. The region within the semiconductor, up to the abrupt plane at depth L, contains additional (besides electrically activated shallow phosphorous dopant level denoted as dots) deep lying Ag donor and acceptor impurities, which are assumed to be homogeneously distributed. L denotes the maximum penetration range, of silver ions for the given value of the external acceleration voltage, Ua. Within the region 0,(s + VOds = = q N d.Ag ^^ ßq 1 + b, N d,P ßq l + b. N, ,Ag 1 1 + h pP^^di ßq 1-t-b, (25) N d.Ag N, ■d,P a,Ag C,=q 2 Vl,(V,0 + l2(Vd2) PqVdi and similarly. N d,P C2 = q,hr e. 1 + b.e -|iqVd2 (31) (32) The resultant low frequency capacitance, C, of the ICB deposited Ag/n-Si(111) Schottky diode is than obtained as. — = — + ■ Ci c. (33) The expressions as given by eqs. (31) and (32) are the central result of the present calculations. One notes that they have been derived without an explicit solution of the Poisson equation, eq. (1). For the interpretation of the l-V measurements, this equation has to be, however, solved explicitly. 3. Results and discussion On account of complicated expressions as provided by eqs. (31) and (32), it is not self evident in general, that the C"^ versus externally applied DC voltage U should yield the straight line. Since the electron potential at x=L, i.e. Vl, is itself an implicit function of the applied bias voltage U, the linear relation obviously is expected to be an exception rather than a rule. However, the above derived results can be simply checked in the limit of very low concentrations of silver impurities in Si substrate as compared to phosphorous concentration doping, i.e. Np >> Na.Ag and Nd.Ag, in the lowest approximation (neglecting the Ag impurities in Si substrate), pi(V) = p2(V) = piVj, and one therefore obtains from the eq. (23), Q, = V2^[^Cp(V)dV - ^j;XV)dV and likewise, (34) (35) In this limit the depletion capacitance of a Schottky diode if evaluated at L = 0, i.e. when Vl = Vo, yields Qi = 0, consequently Ci = 0, and the resulting capacitance is given by, CeeCj = qSsN d,P 2V, (36) where Vd = Vo - Vw. This is, however, the exact result /3/ for the depletion capacitance of on ordinary Schottky diode, as expected. Setting now the opposite limit, i.e. L=W, hence Vl=Vw, only the first term in eq. (34) survives, Q2, and consequently C2 = 0, and the resulting capacitance 0 is once again written in terms of the right side of the expression (36), as it should in the presence of only one homogeneously distributed shallow donor in a semiconductor. On account of the discussion Just presented above it is now possible to offer rather an obvious explanation of the experimental observation concerning the low frequency C-U measurements of Schottky diodes deposited for small values of the ionized silver atoms acceleration voltage Ua < 0.6 keV, (say), by the ionized cluster beam, IBC, deposition method. Apparently, as follows from the stopping power calculations, for these small acceleration voltages the penetration range of Ag ions in Si is small, L « 0, Vl = Vo, and consequently Ci = 0. The resulting capacitance, C, is then given by the eq. (36) and since, Vd = Vo - Vw = 4>b - U - ^ (37) where qOb = 0.78 eV, is the Schottky potential barrier height /3/ and q^ is the energy difference between the semiconductor quasi fermi level and the conduction band, Ec, atthe position x > W, the edge of the depletion region (q^ = kTln(Nc/Nd) and Nc is the effective density of states in the conduction band). Consequently, combining eqs. (36) and (37) the usual linear C'^ versus U relationship is obtained, in accordance with the C-U measurements for Ua = 0 and 300 V samples, as indicated on fig. 3., respectively. Some relevant examples of the low frequency C-U relationships, calculated for the various values of the deep level impurity concentrations, taking the potential, Vl, as an independent parameter, are explicitly exhibited on figs. 5-7. Fig. 5. The calculated values of the resulting capacitance, 1/C^, based on the eq. (33) of the text, versus the external applied DC bias, U, is presented for various values of the parameters. The lines shown are calculated for the following values of parameters expressed in terms of the constant cm~^: line a) Vl=0.45 V, Nd,Ag=10 No, Nd,p=1 No, A/a,Ag=40 No; line b) Vl=0.65 V, Nd,Ag=10 No, Ncs,p=1 No, /Va,Ag=40 No; line c) Vl=0.65 V, A/d,Ag=0, Wd,p=) No, A/a,Ag=0. The latter curve represents the usual case of the homogeneously doped metal/Si semiconductor junction. For the discussion of C-U relationship at large values of Ag ions acceleration voltages, one has to adhere to the full numerical analysis, originating from the exact solution of the Poisson equation /13/. Nevertheless, the simplified model, as depicted on fig. 4., of ICB deposited Ag/Si diodes might possibly provide a direction towards understanding of the findings presented in ref. /6/, where an unusual feature was reported. Namely, applying the usual l-V evaluation procedure /14/ on the raw experimental data, it was found, quite contrary to the expectations, that the ideal- ■«f E o U [V] Fig. 6. The calculated values of the resulting capacitance, 1/C^, based on the eq. (33) of the text, versus the external applied DC bias, U, is presented for various values of the parameters. The lines shown are calculated for the following values of parameters, expressed in terms of the constant No= cm-- : line a) Vl=0.45 V, A/d,Ag=0, A/d,p=r No, Na,Ag=0; (the curve represents the usual case of the homogeneously doped metal/Si semiconductor junction); line b) Vi=0.45 V, A/d,Ag='/ No, A/d,P= 1 No, NaAg=40 No; line c) Vl=0.45 V, A/d,Ag= 10 No, A/d,P= 7 No, A/a,Ag= 100 No- o U [V] Fig. 7. The calculated values of the resulting capacitance, 11C^, based on the eq. (33) of the text, versus the external applied DC bias, U, is presented for various values of the parameters. The lines shown are calculated for the following values of parameters, expressed in terms of the constant No=10^ cm'^: line a) Vl=0.45 V, A/d,Ag=0.3 No, /Vd,P=7 No, Na,Ag=90 No; line b) Vl=0.45 V, A/d,Ag=0, A/d,P=7 No, A/a,Ag=90 No; line c) Vl=0.45 V, A/d,Ag=2 No, A/d,P=7 No, iVa,Ag=60 No. Note that the shape of the calculated curves exhibits different cun/atures, depending upon the values of parameters. ity factor, n, as well as the series resistance, Rs, are bias dependent. The results of an alternative, rather involved and more general, analysis /15/ seem to support the above findings. One notes, that the results of ref. /6/, are based upon the assumption, that the n-Si enriched region is characterized by the constant density of electrically activated silver donors throughout the whole interval of bias investigated. Now, according to the model of fig. 4, this assumption is certainly no longer valid; for forward biases, due to the increasing density of activated acceptor silver impurities accompanied by the corresponding density decrease of the Ag+ donors, the net excess space charge within 0 < x < L interval ought to be bias dependent and at ail times smaller than if only shallow donor P impurities would have been present. Consequently, the series resistance ought to be bias dependent all the way up to its given upper limit above which the net space charge ought to remain constant. Similar characteristic feature, but in the reversed order, is expected to exists for the case of an applied reverse bias. This behavior would be expected to appear always, providing the enriched range exceeds certain minimal Lmin and/or certain minimal Ag impurities densities, which are yet to be determined and thoroughly investigated. Strictly speaking, the presented ICB Ag/n-Si structures consequently may not be truly considered to be a typical representative of an ordinary Schottky metal/semiconductor diodes. The measured strong temperature l-U dependency /4/ of the ICB deposited Ag/n-Si(111) Schottky diodes might now be possible, on the basis of the proposed model exhibited on fig. 4., to assign primarily to the effect of the strong temperature dependent activation of the additional Ag donors and acceptors rather than (in conjunction with the variation of P donors activation) to the direct 1/kT variation itself. There exists another very important feature which deserves a comment. Namely, as reported in ref. /4/ and /6/ the effective Schottky barrier height presumably decreases with an increased silver ions acceleration voltage Ua in clear disagreement with the DIGS model prediction of the strong Fermi level pining at the metal/semiconductor interface for all cases of strong disorders of a semiconductor interface region. Consequently, as DIGS model is generally considered to work well in clear cases of interface disorders, and as an ICB deposition method is certainly expected to produce just such an effect, the question how the effective Schottky barrier is related to the true Schottky barrier height is an important question which still requires to be answered. 4. Conclusions The low frequency capacitance- voltage, C-U, relationship of ionized cluster beam, ICB, deposited Ag/n-Si(111) Schottky diodes for nonzero acceleration voltage of the silver ions, has been investigated on the basis of the postulated model of the semiconductor energy bands. In the derivation the fundamental assumptions made is the homogenous, spatially limited distribution, laying within the semiconductor energy gap, of the bias voltage dependent activated deep Ag donor and acceptor innpurities energy levels. These are (in addition to the shallow phosphorous donor level throughout the Si sample) spatially confined within the Si region extending up to the maximal silver ions penetration length L, which is a function of the silver acceleration voltage Ua. It is argued, that it is only for small values of L and/or small Ag impurity concentrations, within the described impurity additionally enriched semiconductor region, that the C-U relation is expected to exhibit the linear relationship, in accordance with the measurements. The previously observed bias dependence of the semiconductor series resistance, at constant temperature, as well as the strong temperature dependency of the previously reported l-U measurements, are being phe-nomenologically explained in terms of the proposed model. The effects of the additional, within the Si energy gap placed impurity levels arising on account of surface atoms, like O, C, N and traces of S, to be in the process of the Ag impact also transferred into the semiconductor, have been neglected. These impurities may contribute to the additional space charge within the Ag enriched n-Si region, but very likely their importance, as traps, ought to be taken into account if one is concerned with C-V frequency dependency. However, their possible effect, as microcluster formations, on the Schottky barrier height formation, in a sense as first proposed by Freeouf and Woodall /16/, is not to be neglected. It is argued, that the relationship of the disordered (due to Ag and surface atoms) enriched semiconductor layer (at small penetration lengths L), on the Fermi level pinning and consequently on the DIGS implications concerning the metal/semiconductor junction, might be most conveniently investigated by carefully controlled and suitably designed ICB experiments in UHV conditions. 5. References /1/ T. Takagi, Vacuum 36, (1986) 27. /2/ W. L. Brown, M.F. Jarrold, R.L.McEachern, M. Sosnowski, G. Takaoka, H. Usui and I. Yamada, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. in Phys. Research, B59, (1991) 182. /3/ S.M, Sze in Physics of Senniconductor Devices, 2nd Edition, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1981), /4/ B. CvikI and T. Mrdjen, Fizika, A4, (1995) 2, 403. /5/ F. A. Padovani and R. Stratton, Solid-State Electron. 9, (1966) 695, see also C. R. Crowell and V. L. Rideout, Solid-State Electron., 12, (1969) 89. The discussion of their results is also presented in the reference /12/. /6/ B. CvikI, Zs. J. Horvath, T. Mrden, 23rd International Conference on Microelectronics, MIEL'95 and 31st Simposium in Devices and Materials, SD'95, Proceedings, p. 391 -396. September 27.-29, 1995, Terme Čatež, Slovenia. 1711. Takahagi, I. Nagai, A. Ishitani, H. Kuroda, Y. Nagasawa, J. Appl. Phys. 64 (1988) 3516. /8/J. F. Ziegler, J. P. Biersack and U. Littmark in The Stopping and Range of Ions in Solids, Pergamon Press, New York, (1985). /9/ H. Hasegawa and Hideo Ohno, J. Vac. Sei. Technol., B 4, (1986) 1130, see also K. Koyanagi, S, Kasai and H, Hasegawa, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 32, (1993) 502. /10/ R. R. Senechal and J. Basinski, J, Appl. Phys., 19, (1968) 3723. /11/ G. I. Roberts and C. R. Crowell, J. Appl. Phys., 41, (1970) 1767. /12/ E.H. Rhoderic and R.H. Williams in Metal-Semiconductor Contacts, 2nd Edition, Clarendon Press, Oxford, (1988). /13/ T. Mrdjen, B. CvikI and D. Korošak, to be published. /14/ S.K, Cheung and N.W. Cheung, Appl. Phys. Lett., 49, (1986) 85. /15/ D. Donoval, M. Barus and M. Zdimal, Solid-State Electronics, 34, (1991) 1365. /16/ J. L. Freeouf, J. Woodall, J. Appl. Phys. Letts, 39, (1981) 727. Acknowledgment The endeavors of Mess. M. Ko'elj, T. Mrden, F. Moškon, E. Krištof and D. Korošak, at the Division of Reactor Physics, in the course of very involved ionized cluster beam experiments and data treatment, as well as to Professor A. Levstek and M. Sc. C. Filipič at the Condensed Matter Physics Division of the "J. Stefan" Institute, for having made the equipment available and for helping us in C-V measurements, are all greatly appreciated. The acknowledgment is also due to M. Sc. R. Jecl, Faculty of Engineering, for numerical evaluations serving as a basis for some of the arguments presented in this presentation. Dr. Bruno CvikI Fakulteta za gradbeništvo, Univerza v Mariboru, Smetanova 17, 2000 Maribor, ali Institut "J. Stefan", Univerza v Ljubljani, Jamova 39,1000 Ljubljana Tel.: +386 (0)61 188 54 50 Fax: (0)61 374-919; Email: bruno.cvikl@ijs.si Prispelo (Arrived): 31.5.1996 Sprejeto (Accepted): 18.6.1996