ACTA BIOLOGICA SLOVENICA LJUBLJANA 2010 Vol. 53, Št. 2: 61-70 ЛВ Respiration and ingestion rate of different sized Daphnia pulex fed on four algal species Dihanje in prehranjevanje različno velikih osebkov vrste Daphnia pulex s štirimi vrstami alg Tatjana Simčič National Institute of Biology, Večna pot 111, SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia Correspondence: tatjana.simcic@nib.si Abstract: Respiration rate and ingestion rate for four different algal species (Scenedesmus quadricauda, Asterionella formosa, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae and Planktotrix rubescens) of different sized Daphnia pulex were measured in the laboratory. Population of D. pulex grew maximally when it fed S. quadricauda, but the presence of P rubescens and A. flos-aquae caused negative population growth rate. Ingestion rates increased with increasing body size for all investigated algae; the lowest b value was obtained for S. quadricauda and the highest one for P rubescens. The amount of ingested carbon exceeded the required amount for standard metabolism in both small and large sized individuals fed all four algal species. Relatively higher amount of ingested A. flos-aquae and P. rubescens in comparison with A. formosa and S. quadricauda and the results of the growth experiments indicate that the inhibitory effect of filamentous blue-green algae on D. pulex is more due to toxicity, low assimilation efficiency or/and inadequate composition than incapability of ingestion due to mechanical interference with filaments. Key words: ingestion rate, respiration, Daphnia pulex, algae, growth scope Izvleček: V laboratoriju smo pri različno velikih osebkih Daphnia pulex merili dihanje in stopnjo hranjenja s štirimi različnimi vrstami alg (Scenedesmus quadricauda, Asterionella formosa, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae and Planktotrix rubescens). Populacija D. pulex je najbolje uspevala pri hranjenju z algo S. quadricauda, v prisotnosti vrst A. flos-aquae in P. rubescens pa smo opazili negativno rast populacije. Stopnja hranjenja se je povečevala z naraščajočo telesno velikostjo pri vseh vrstah alg; najnižjo vrednost b smo dobili pri hranjenju s S. quadricauda, najvišjo pa s P. rubescens. Količina zaužitega ogljika je presegala porabo za standardni metabo-lizem pri hranjenju z vsemi štirimi vrstami alg. Večje količine zaužitih vrst A. flos-aquae in P. rubescens v primerjavi z vrstama A. formosa in S. quadricauda in rezultati rastnih poskusov kažejo, da je inhibitorni vpliv nitastih modro-zelenih alg na osebke vrste D. pulex bolj posledica strupenosti, nizke asimilacijske učinkovitosti ali/in neustrezne sestave kot pa nezmožnosti zaužitja zaradi težav, ki bi jih povzročala nitasta oblika alg. Ključne besede: stopnja hranjenja, dihanje, Daphnia pulex, alge, obseg rasti Introduction Herbivorous zooplankton is functionally important in aquatic webs. They constitute a link between primary producers and higher trophic levels. A number of studies have investigated the effect of food quality (e.g. Knisley and Geller 1986, Fulton III 1988, Butler et al. 1989, Hawkins and Lampert 1989, Gulati and DeMott 1997, Kilham et al. 1997, Wagner and Kamjunke 2001) and food quantity (e.g. Porter et al. 1982, Urabe and Watanabe 1991) on feeding and/or on growth, survival and reproduction of Daphnia. As eutrophication often results in a proliferation of blue-green algae (Arnold 1971), the blue-green algae had been studied as food for Daphnia in several studies (e.g. Arnold 1971, Gliwicz 1977, Richman and Dodson 1983, Fulton III 1988, Gilbert and Durand 1990, Gliwicz 1990, DeMott 1999, Trabeau et al. 2004). Blue-greens are usually found to be an inadequate food for Daphnia due to mechanical interference of colonies of filaments with food collection, low digestibility or poor nutritive quality. Many genera of blue-greens produce either hepatotoxic or neurotoxic secondary metabolites (Trabeau et al. 2004). In the recent years, food-quality research has increasingly focused on the biochemical nutrient requirements of Daphnia. It has been shown that fatty acid and phosphorous content of food affect the growth and reproduction of Daphnia (Sundbom and Vrede 1997, Park et al. 2002, Ferräo-Filho et al. 2003, Gladyshev et al. 2008, Martin-Creuzburg and Von Elert 2009). Daphnia is filter feeders, having appendages specialized for respiration and food gathering. Food is rejected when the collected amount is greater than it can be ingested, when it is physically unacceptable (i.e., colonies or filaments too large) or if it is chemically unacceptable (see Lampert 1987). The dependence of filtering or ingestion rate (IR) on the body length (L) of Daphnia can be described by power equation of the form IR= a Lb (Lampert 1987). One important factor influencing b is the size of the food. Although large particles can be better handled by large daphnids than by small ones (Lampert 1987), some studies showed that the feeding of larger Daphnia species and larger individuals of single species is more affected by the presence of filaments than the feeding of smaller ones (Hawkins and Lampert 1989, Gilbert and Durand 1990). As filamentous and colonial algae are differently consumed by different body sized Daphnia (Hawkins and Lampert 1989), different ingestion of food particles in juveniles and adults was expected. The effect of food quality on both feeding and respiration of Daphnia were investigated in few studies (Richman and Dod- son 1983, Trabeau et al. 2004) where the effect of different blue-greens on respiration rate of adult stages of Daphnia in the presence of food was measured. However, information about the capability of different sized Daphnia to ingest enough food to meet their carbon demands, required for standard metabolism, is still lacking. Such studies are important to obtain the basic information on growth scope of different sized animals. The aim of the present study was to determine an ingestion rate of different sized individuals of D. pulex that were fed on four different algal species, i.e. Scenedesmus quadricauda, Asterionella formosa, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae and Planktotrix rubescens. Respiration rates were measured in different sized developmental stages in order to estimate carbon demands for standard metabolism. It was hypothesized that ingestion rates of different algal species and respiration rates differ in different sized animals. Growth experiments were carried out to test nutritional value of a single alga and possible toxicity of blue-green algae used in the experiments. Material and methods Cultures Daphnia pulex Leydig originated from a permanent laboratory culture in National Institute of Biology (Ljubljana, Slovenia). Animals were kept in 10 L aquaria and some hundred specimens were there all the time. The water temperature was 24.0 ± 1.5 °C. The animals were fed every second day with suspension of Scenedesmus sp. and yeast. For feeding experiments adult females without eggs were selected, but for growth experiments ovigerous females of similar size were selected. Single animal were transferred using a narrow glass pipette. Algal cultures of Scenedesmus quadricauda, Asterionella formosa, Aphanizomenon flos-aquae and Planktotrix rubescens were obtained from the National Institute of Biology collection (Ljubljana, Slovenia). Algae were cultured in Jaworski medium. Algal cultures were maintained in log growth phase. Algal characteris- Table 1: Morphological characteristics of algae used in experiments. Mean ± SD (n -number measured). Tabela 1: Morfološke značilnosti alg, uporabljenih v poskusih. Povprečje ± SD (n - število meritev). Width of particles Length of particles Max dimension of Dry weight (№> (№> colony (^m) (^g теП -1) Aphanizomenon flos-aquae 3.54 ± 0.73 42.47 ± 25.90 - 5.33 * 10-4 (25) (64) Planktotrix rubescens 4.96 ± 0.53 103.96 ± 52.75 - 1.07 * 10-3 (31) (31) Asterionella formosa 3.98 ± 0.67 46.96 ± 14.4 88.45 ± 25.1 (20) 2.36 * 10-4 (37) (43) Scenedesmus quadricauda 5.17 ± 0.59 8.70 ± 1.1 12.6 ± 3.51 (20) 6.83 * 10-5 (20) (20) tics are given in Table 1. Cells were counted and measured by Soft Imaging System, GmbH, analySIS 3.0, Münster, Germany. Suspension of a single alga was filtered through pre-weighted filter (glass microfibrile filter Whatman GF/C) and dried for 24 h at 60°C. Filters were weighted on 10 ^g electrobalance (Sartorius). Dry weight of single cell or filament was calculated from the concentration and volume of filtered suspension. Population growth experiments Fifteen ovigerous females of similar size (2.20 ± 0.23 mm; average eggs number per female was 2.2) were placed in bottles, each containing 600 mL of synthetic medium (ISO standard) with algal concentration of 1*104 cells (or filaments in the case of blue-green algae) per mL. These animals were collected from the same container, in order to assure that they had similar age and number of eggs. Three replicate bottles for each alga as food were started at the same time to avoid other factors that might affect on experimental conditions. Experimental bottles were kept at 25°C. Before feeding half of water was changed every second day. Relatively constant food level was kept during the experiments. Population growth experiments lasted for 14 days. At the end, animals were killed in formalin solution. Body length was measured from the top of the helmet to the base of the spine using Soft Imaging System, GmbH, analySIS 3.0, Münster, Germany. Population growth rates (r) were estimated as: r = (lnN2-lnNI)/(t2-tI), with N1 and N2 being the population sizes of sampling days t1 and t2. Feeding experiments At the beginning of the experiments, animals were piped into tubes filled with 2 mL suspensions of algae. One animal was placed in each test tube. The initial algal cell concentration was 1 * 104 cells mL-1. Animals were fed for 3 hours. Animals and algae were then killed with formalin solution. In each tube, the ingestion rate (IR) were determined as IR = (c0 - cO * V / t where c is the concentration of algae at the beginning (c0) and the end (c1) of the feeding time (t), and V is volume of suspension (2 mL). Animals were starved for 3 hours before being used in feeding experiments. Respiration rate was estimated by the closed bottle method (Lampert 1984). 150 mL ground glass stoppered bottles were filled with synthetic medium and aerated water from the same, well-mixed, container. Ten bottles received animals (50 similar sized animals were placed in a single bottle), while three bottles served as final con- Table 2: Population growth rates (d-1) for population of Daphnia pulex fed different species of algae (n = 3). Tabela 2: Stopnja rasti populacij (d-1) pri vrsti Daphnia pulex pri hranjenju z različnimi vrstami alg (n = 3). Mean ± SD Aphanizomenon flos aquae Planktotrix rubescens Asterionella formosa Scenedesmus quadricauda -0.481 ± 0.052 -0.040 ± 0.021 0.006 ± 0.001 0.115 ± 0.010 trols. All bottles were kept at 25°C. After 24 h the concentration of dissolved oxygen in the experimental and control bottles was measured by polarographic oxygen electrode (OXI 96, WTW). The difference between the oxygen of each experimental as well as mean oxygen concentration of control bottles was taken as the amount of oxygen consumed by animals. The amount of oxygen consumed was then converted to respiration rate per individum (цЬ O2 /ind/h). Respiratory carbon loss was calculated using the conversion factor 1 mL O2 = 0.5 mg Corg (Lampert 1984). In con- Figure 1: a) Number of individuals and b) percentage of populations for different size classes (mm) of Daphnia pulex fed Planktotrix rubescens (PLANK), Asterionella formosa (ASTER) and Scenedesmus quadricauda (SCEN). Slika 1: a) Število osebkov in b) odstotki populacij po velikostnih razredih (mm) pri vrsti Daphnia pulex, ki se je prehranjevala s Planktotrix rubescens (PLANK), Asterionella formosa (ASTER) in Scenedesmus quadricauda (SCEN). -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 Ln body length Ln body length Figure 2: Relationships between ingestion rates and body length of Daphnia pulex fed Aphanizomenon flos-aquae (APHAN), Planktotrix rubescens (PLANK), Asterionella formosa (ASTER) and Scenedesmus quadri-cauda (SCEN). Slika 2: Razmerje med stopnjo hranjenja in telesno velikostjo osebkov Daphnia pulex pri prehranjevanju s Aphanizomenon flos-aquae (APHAN), Planktotrix rubescens (PLANK), Asterionella formosa (ASTER) in Scenedesmus quadricauda (SCEN). verting respiration to carbon units, a respiratory quotient (RQ) of 1.0 was assumed. Growth scope was calculated as a subtraction of respiratory carbon loss (Cres) from ingested carbon (Cing). Statistical analyses One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) on population growth rates was performed to test differences between different algae. Linear regressions between body length and ingestion rate, and between body length and respiration rate were calculated using Microsoft Excel. Results and discussion Growth experiments Population growth experiments showed that population growth rates differed between food sources (ANOVA, p<0.001). Population of D. pulex grew maximally when it fed S. quadricauda (Table 2). Populations that fed A. formosa had positive growth rates, but the presence of P. rubescens caused negative population growth rate. Structure of populations revealed that all individuals of populations that fed P. rubescens belonged to two the smallest size classes (Figure 1). Populations that fed A. formosa had larger individuals in comparison with P. rubescens as a food source, but the largest animals were observed in diet with S. quadricauda. Feeding on A. flos-aquae resulted in the collapse of populations during six days. These results are in accord with those previous studies where blue-greens are considered as poor-quality food for Daphnia, due to the interference of the filaments with the collection of available food, toxicity, and a low nutritional quality (Arnold 1971, Gliwicz 1977, Richman and Dodson 1983, Fulton III, 1988, Gilbert and Durand 1990, Gliwicz 1990, DeMott 1999, Tra-beau et al. 2004). Arnold (1971) reported that there were differences among the blue-greens in their effects on animals. In the present study A. flos-aquae showed toxicity towards D. pulex, but P. rubescens probably did not provide sufficient nutrition to maintain a population of D. pulex (Table 2). DeMott (1999) reported that D. pulex exhibited stronger inhibition than D. magna, D. pulicaria, and D. galeata, when it fed a mixture of Scenedesmus acutus and Microcystis aeruginosa. Sharp decline in gross growth efficiency showed on growth inhibition as a result of both feeding inhibition and direct toxicity (DeMott 1999). The results of the present study revealed that S. quadricauda was high quality food for D. pulex as the number and body size of animals exceeded those of animals fed P. rubes-cens or A. formosa (Figure 1). High quality of Scenedesmus sp. was also reported by Hawkins and Lampert (1989) and Vijverberg (1989). Size of particles of this species is convenient to be high quality food for all life stages of the crustaceans (Vijverberg 1989). As Planktotrix sp. has the lowest assimilation efficiency among investigated algae and also, Asterionella sp. has lower assimilation efficiency than Scenedesmus sp. (cited in Lampert 1987), dissimilar growth of populations could be probably partly explained by differences in assimilation rates. Feeding experiments Ingestion rate increased with body size for all investigated algae (Figure 2). Increasing of ingestion rates with increasing body length of cladocerans was also observed in DeMott (1982) and Mourelatos and Lacroix (1990). Regression showed that larger individuals consumed significantly more food than smaller ones (p<0.001). The b value ranged from 1.22 for S. quadricauda to 2.35 for P. rubescens. One important factor influencing b is the size of the food. Large particles can be better handled by large daphnids than small ones. On the other hand, small daphnids have finer filters and can retain smaller particles (Lampert 1987). Therefore, low b values which were obtained in the presence of small food particles and high b values for large particles (i.e. P. rubescens) are in accord with expectations. Previous studies showed that ingestion rate depends also on food concentration (DeMott 0.5 0.45 0.4 -■ 0.35 ^ 0.3 " - ■- 0.25 о я "ČL О и _j » и СИ ■=